세계문화유산 「영릉」의 영문안내판에 나타난 오류
Errors on the Information Board of Yeongneung, the UNESCO World Heritage Site
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
A cornerstone is located at the entrance of Yeongneung which was recorded on the UNESCO World Heritage List in accordance with the Convention concerning the Protection of World Cultural and Natural Heritage in 2009. As is well-known Yeongneung is one of the 40 royal tombs of the Joseon Dynasty. Like the cornerstone, all the information boards here were renovated after it was designated as a world heritage. There are more than twenty information boards here including the cornerstone. But in this paper we examined only four information boards, namely the cornerstone “Royal Tombs of the Joseon Dynasty”, “Tomb of King Sejong the Great (Yeongneung)”, “Sejongjeon” and “Yepongneung Monument” (the misspelling of Yeongneung is shown at the title of the information board). The errors are examined in four categories, namely vocabulary errors, errors caused by addition, errors caused by omission and unfaithfulness of translation. Many vocabularies are found to be used wrongly, and the translator added too much useless contents and omitted much more necessary contents. Those errors naturally lead to unfaithfulness of the translation. The source texts themselves seem to be very difficult to understand. They inserted a lot of Chinese characters in the source texts and the source texts contain a lot of culture specific items. The distortion of the contents seems to have been caused by the unfaithfulness to the source texts as examined in this study.
Abstract
A cornerstone is located at the entrance of Yeongneung which was recorded on the UNESCO World Heritage List in accordance with the Convention concerning the Protection of World Cultural and Natural Heritage in 2009. As is well-known Yeongneung is one of the 40 royal tombs of the Joseon Dynasty. Like the cornerstone, all the information boards here were renovated after it was designated as a world heritage. There are more than twenty information boards here including the cornerstone. But in this paper we examined only four information boards, namely the cornerstone “Royal Tombs of the Joseon Dynasty”, “Tomb of King Sejong the Great (Yeongneung)”, “Sejongjeon” and “Yepongneung Monument” (the misspelling of Yeongneung is shown at the title of the information board). The errors are examined in four categories, namely vocabulary errors, errors caused by addition, errors caused by omission and unfaithfulness of translation. Many vocabularies are found to be used wrongly, and the translator added too much useless contents and omitted much more necessary contents. Those errors naturally lead to unfaithfulness of the translation. The source texts themselves seem to be very difficult to understand. They inserted a lot of Chinese characters in the source texts and the source texts contain a lot of culture specific items. The distortion of the contents seems to have been caused by the unfaithfulness to the source texts as examined in this study.
참고문헌 (11)
- 남성우, "통번역의 이해와 수행" (2006), 한국문화사
- 박경일, "영어", 번역 어떻게 가르칠까, 번역 전문가 양성을 위한 탈이론적 방법론 서설, pp.번역학연구, 2003[DOI]
- 박순봉, "수안보면 미륵리 안내판의 영어번역 오류 분석", 동화와 번역, (19), pp.119~146 (2010), 동화와번역연구소
- 이근희, "번역의 변환(Shift) 현상에 관한 소고: 정보제공 목적의 텍스트 중심", 번역학연구, 5(2), pp.113~144 (2004), 한국번역학회
- 최희섭, "번역 첫걸음 내딛기" (2007), 도서출판 동인
- 최희섭, "‘경기전’ 경내 영어안내판의 오류 실태 -왕의 안내판을 중심으로", 동화와 번역, (17), pp.355~384 (2009), 동화와번역연구소
- 한국관광공사, "2007 외국어 관광안내표기 용례집" (2007), 한국관광공사
- Aixelá, J., "Culture-specific Items in Translation, in Translation, Power, Subversion", pp.52~78 (1996), Multilingual Matters
- 남원준, "How Students Translate Culture-specific Items: An Analysis of Student Translations & Suggestions for Improvement", 번역학연구, 9(3), pp.151~175 (2008), 한국번역학회
- Nida, E., "The Theory and Practice of Translation" (1982), United Bible Society
- Steiner, G., "After Babel: Aspect of Language and Translation" (1975), Oxford UP
