질적 평가의 해외 사례 분석과 시사점
An Analysis on the Qualitative Evaluation and Implication
0
조회
0
다운로드
4
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this study is to analyze the cases of qualitative evaluation in the foreign journals such as Evaluation, Evaluation Review, Qualitative Inquiry, and Qualitative Research. Tough these days interests to the qualitative evaluation have increased in Korea, the research results are not accumulated. There are some articles on the qualitative evaluation which used several qualitative methods such as in-depth interview, focus group interview, and participants observation. However there is few article which focused on the contribution for qualitative evaluation. For the implication for Korean research, we reviewed eight foreign cases. Nevertheless also foreign researches are not so many, they suggested some core components for qualitative evaluation. The most thing is the voice of shakeholders in the every policy scene. And it needs more research for evaluating the quality of the qualitative evaluations.
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to analyze the cases of qualitative evaluation in the foreign journals such as Evaluation, Evaluation Review, Qualitative Inquiry, and Qualitative Research. Tough these days interests to the qualitative evaluation have increased in Korea, the research results are not accumulated. There are some articles on the qualitative evaluation which used several qualitative methods such as in-depth interview, focus group interview, and participants observation. However there is few article which focused on the contribution for qualitative evaluation. For the implication for Korean research, we reviewed eight foreign cases. Nevertheless also foreign researches are not so many, they suggested some core components for qualitative evaluation. The most thing is the voice of shakeholders in the every policy scene. And it needs more research for evaluating the quality of the qualitative evaluations.
참고문헌 (45)
- 강근복, "정책분석 및 평가에서의 양적･질적 연구의 혼합", 정책분석평가학회보, 19(4), pp.43~67 (2009), 한국정책분석평가학회
- 권지성, "저소득층 자산형성 프로그램에 대한 질적 평가연구:서울시 희망플러스통장 시범사업을 대상으로", 한국사회복지학, 62(3), pp.193~218 (2010), 한국사회복지학회
- 김정해, "참여정부 규제개혁의 성과평가: 전문가 의견조사를 중심으로", 한국행정학보, 42(2), pp.119~148 (2008), 한국행정학회
- 류영아, "지방행정의 효율성 평가에 관한 연구 : DEA 기법에 의한 기초자치단체 복지서비스 분석", 박사, 행정학, pp.2006
- 박상욱, "개발도상국 국가혁신체제의 평가에 관한 비교연구: 메콩권역 5개국을 중심으로", 한국비교정부학보, 17(1), pp.1~22 (2013), 한국비교정부학회
- 박홍윤, "정책평가론: 실제와 사례" (2012), 도서출판 대영문화사
- 이성우, "후기 실증주의와 질적 연구방법의 정책분석평가연구에의 적용가능성", 정책분석평가학회보, 18(4), pp.15~42 (2008), 한국정책분석평가학회
- 이창무, "경찰 범죄예방 활동의 질적 평가 -지역경찰제를 중심으로-", 한국경찰학회보, 8(1), pp.51~74 (2006), 한국경찰학회
- Anda, Diane de, "A Qualitative Evaluation of a Mentor Program for At-Risk Youth: The Participant's Perspective", Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 18(2), pp.97~117 (2001)
- Blomquist, John, "Impact Evaluation of Social Programs: A Policy Perspective. Social Safety Nets Primer Notes, No. 14" (2003), World Bank
- Adding it up: Improving Analysis & Modelling in the Central Government. A Performance and Innovation Unit Report, "Cabinet Office", HMSO, ~ (2000)
- "Quantitative and Qualitative Evaluation Methods" (2013)[URL]
- Chambers, Robert, "Poverty and Livelihoods: Whose Reality Counts?", Environment and Urbanization, 7(1), pp.173~204 (1995)
- Coffey, Amanda, "Reconceptualizing Social Policy: Sociological Perspectives on Contemporary Social Policy" (2004), Open University Press
- Deng, Ling, "A Qualitative Evaluation on the Role of Cultural Intelligence in Cross-Cultural Leadership Effectiveness", International Journal of Leadership Studies, 3(2), pp.181~197 (2008)
- (Draft) Policy statements on Impact evaluation: September version, "Department for International Development", Department for International Development, ~ (2008)
- Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, "Local Strategic Partnerships: Government Guidance", DETR, ~ (2001)
- National Evaluation of Local Strategic Partnerships: Report on the 2006 Survey of all English LSPs, "Department for Communities and Local Government", Communities and Local Government Publications, ~ (2007)
- Fer, Seval, "Qualitative Evaluation of Emotional Intelligence In-Service Program for Secondary School Teachers", The Qualitative Report, 9(4), pp.562~588 (2004)
- Quantitative and Qualitative Methods in Impact Evaluation and Measuring Results, "Garbarino, Sabine", Governance and Social Development Resource Centre, ~ (2009)
- Intensive Qualitative Research: Challenges, Best Uses, and Opportunities, "Gardenhire, Alissa", ~ (2003)
- Government Social Research Unit, "The Magenta Book: Guidance Notes for Policy Evaluation and Analysis" (2003), HM Treasury
- Evaluation of HIV Prevention Programs Using Qualitative Methods, "Gilliam, Aisha", Center for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion Division of Adolescent and School Health, ~ (1992)
- Guba, Egon G., "The Countenances of Fourth-Generation Evaluation: Description, Judgement and Negotiation, In The Politics of Program Evaluation", pp.202~234 (1987), Sage Publications
- Prototype Employment Zones: A Qualitative and Contextual Evaluation, "Haughton, Graham", The Department for Education and Employment, ~, pp.Research Report No. 232 (2000)
- Hentschel, Jesko, "Contextuality and Data Collection Methods: A Framework and Application to Health Service Utilisation", Journal of Development Studies, 35(4), pp.64~94 (1999)
- Qualitative Evaluation and Changing Social Policy, "House, Ernest R.", ~ (2003)
- Kelly, Marisa, "Policy Analysis in the Post-Positivist Era: Engaging Stakeholders in Evaluating the Economic Development Districts Program", Public Administration Review, 53(2), pp.135~142 (1993)
- Kelsey, Kathleen D, "A Qualitative Evaluation of Customer Service Provided by an Agricultural Center of Excellence", Journal of Southern Agricultural Education Research, 51(1), pp.201~214 (2001)
- Kythreotis, Andrew, "Local Strategic Partnerships: a Panacea for Voluntary Interest Groups to Promote Local Environmental Sustainability?", The UK Context. Sustainable Development, 18, pp.187~193 (2010)
- Learning for Action(LFA) Group, "Evaluation for Orgnizational Learning: Basic Concepts and Practical Tools. LFA Evaluation Handbook", ~ (2010)
- Lucas, Karen, "Putting the 'E' into LSPs: Representing the Environment within Local Strategic Partnerships(LSPs) in the UK", Local Environment, 10(5), pp.461~475 (2005)
- MacFarlane, Anne, "The E-health Implementation Toolkit: Qualitative Evaluation across four European Countries", Implementation Science, 6, pp.1~12 (2011)
- McLeod, John, "Qualitative Research in Counselling and Psychotherapy" (2001), Sage Publications
- Midmore, Peter, "Qualitative evaluation of European Rural Development Policy: Evidence from Comparative Case Studies", 12th Congress of the European Association of Agricultural Economists-EAAE 2008 (2008)
- Porter, Sam, "Stakeholders and Perspectivism in Qualitative Policy Evaluation: A Realist Reflection", Public Administration, 87(2), pp.259~273 (2009)
- Prout, Hayley, "A Qualitative Evaluation of Implementing a Randomized Controlled Trial in General Practice", Family Practice, 20(6), pp.675~676 (2003)
- Prowse, Martin, "Aid Effectiveness: the Role of Qualitative Research in Impact Evaluation" (2007), Overseas Development Institute
- Seiffert, Murray W., "Evaluation as Policy Development: Using Qualitative Research as a Political Tool", Sociological Sites, 2000, 1~12
- Shaw, Ian, "Qualitative Research and Outcomes in Health, Social Work and Education", Qualitative Research, 3(1), pp.57~77 (2003)
- Daniel T., "Qualitative Evaluation of the Project P.A.T.H.S.: Findings Based on Focus Groups", Int Disabli Hum Dev, 9(4), pp.307~313 (2010)
- Quality in Qualitative Evaluation: A Framework for assessing research evidence, "Spencer, Liz", Government Chief Social Researcher's Office, London: Cabinet Office, ~ (2003)
- Stoker, Gerry, "Transforming local governance: From Thatcherism to New Labour" (2004), Palgrave Macmillan
- The 2010 User-Friendly Handbook for Project Evaluation, "Westat, Joy Frechtling", Division of Research and Learning in Formal and Informal Settings of National Science Foundation, ~ (2010)
- Zukoski, Ann, "Participatory Evaluation: What is it? Why Do it? What are the Challenges?", Policy & Practice, 5, pp.1~6 (2002)