본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

지속가능발전의 도그마와 트릴레마: Scott Campbell의 지속가능발전목표 갈등모형의 적용

The Dogma and Trilemma of Sustainable Development: Applying the Triangle Model of Conflicting Sustainable Development Goals by Scott Campbell

0

조회

0

다운로드

6

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류행정학

초록

Is it possible to make development sustainable as people believe in? The purpose of this paper is to answer the question and to discuss about the dogma and trilemma of sustainable development goals through applying the Triangle Model of Conflicting Sustainable Development Goals by Scott Campbell. The property conflict is caused by value conflict between economic development and social equity even though policy makers intended to harmonize the disagreement. The resource conflict may be caused by value conflict between economic development and environmental conservation because policy planners stress more on the former rather than the latter. The value conflict between environmental conservation and social equity brings about the development conflict because it is not easy to put emphasis on the minor values altogether. Through case studies I found that these contradictive goals gave rise to severe opportunity loss among the property, resource and development values. So I suggest that policy planners should consider procedural rationality to overcome sustainable development trilemma through reconsidering and re-balancing policy disagreements and reach social consensus.

Abstract

Is it possible to make development sustainable as people believe in? The purpose of this paper is to answer the question and to discuss about the dogma and trilemma of sustainable development goals through applying the Triangle Model of Conflicting Sustainable Development Goals by Scott Campbell. The property conflict is caused by value conflict between economic development and social equity even though policy makers intended to harmonize the disagreement. The resource conflict may be caused by value conflict between economic development and environmental conservation because policy planners stress more on the former rather than the latter. The value conflict between environmental conservation and social equity brings about the development conflict because it is not easy to put emphasis on the minor values altogether. Through case studies I found that these contradictive goals gave rise to severe opportunity loss among the property, resource and development values. So I suggest that policy planners should consider procedural rationality to overcome sustainable development trilemma through reconsidering and re-balancing policy disagreements and reach social consensus.

참고문헌 (62)

  1. 강하니, "전 세계인이 함께 만들고 지켜야 할 새로운 개발목표: SDGs", ODA Watch, (92) (2014)
  2. 고재경, "전문가 100人의 진단, Rio+20과 한국의 지속가능발전 과제", 이슈 & 이슈, (51) (2012), 경기개발연구원
  3. 김명자, "원자력 트릴레마 : 여론, 커뮤니케이션, 해법의 모색" (2013), 까치글방
  4. 김성수, "물기본권에 관한 연구", 환경법연구, 34(1), pp.231~258 (2012), 한국환경법학회[DOI]
  5. 김수정, "보육서비스의 트릴레마 구조와 한국 보육정책의 선택: 민간의존과 비용중심의 정책", 경제와 사회, (105), pp.64~93 (2015), 비판사회학회[DOI]
  6. 김영평, "불확실성과 정책의 정당성" (1995), 고려대학교 출판부
  7. 김종원, "물과 인권", pp.502~540 (2012), 도서출판 피어나
  8. 김창수, "4대강 살리기 사업의 지속가능성 평가", 지방정부연구, 17(1), pp.319~342 (2013), 한국지방정부학회
  9. 김창수, "한국 관료제의 트릴레마 해부", 정부학연구, 20(1), pp.35~73 (2014), 정부학연구소[DOI]
  10. 김창수, "공공갈등의 제도적 프레임 분석: 기장해수담수화사업 사례를 중심으로", 한국사회와 행정연구, 27(3), pp.147~176 (2016), 서울행정학회
  11. 김창수, "부산광역시 원자력 트릴레마 대응", 행정논총, 54(4), pp.265~290 (2016), 한국행정연구소
  12. 김창수, "낙동강수계 물이용부담금제도의 지속가능성 분석", 지방정부연구, 21(3), pp.409~428 (2017), 한국지방정부학회[DOI]
  13. 원전지역공동체의 위상변화와 공동체 구성원들의 삶: 경험적 태도 분석과 비교연구, "김창수", 미래사회에너지정책연구원, ~ (2018)
  14. 지역의 원전운영 안전 감시기능 강화, "김창수", 에너지경제구원, ~ (2018)
  15. 김태은, "제도변화와 대체요인으로서 딜레마 대응에 관한 연구: 신・재생에너지 발전차액지원제도를 중심으로", 한국행정학보, 43(4), pp.179~208 (2009), 한국행정학회
  16. 음식물류폐기물 관리정책 개선방안 및 해외 우수관리정책 비교 연구, "박미옥", (사)한국행정학회, ~ (2015)
  17. 박재창, "한국의 환경지속성 : 평가와 과제" (2004), 대영문화사
  18. 소영진, "딜레마 이론, 그 의미와 과제: 이론적 정합성을 위한 시론", 한국행정논집, 27(1), pp.23~46 (2015), 한국정부학회
  19. 심형구, "고압송전선로 건설갈등의 프레임 분석: 기장군과 밀양시 주민인식조사를 중심으로", 한국행정논집, 26(2), pp.241~264 (2014), 한국정부학회
  20. 염명배, "저성장시대, 재정 트릴레마 극복을 위한 새로운 재정정책 패러다임의 모색", 재정학연구, 9(1), pp.45~85 (2016), 한국재정학회
  21. 오수길, "지속가능발전목표와 지방정부의 목표체계 전환 : 경상남도를 중심으로", 한국지방정부학회 2018년 하계학술대회 발표논문 (2018)
  22. 윤견수, "한국 행정학의 한국화론: 보편성과 특수성의 조화", pp.284~309 (2013), 법문사
  23. 윤순진, "이명박 정부 1년과 녹색의 변질", 창비주간논평(2009. 3. 4), ~ (2009)
  24. 이승호, "물-에너지-식량 연계성 : 개념과 정책적 함의", 춘천물포럼, pp.501~526 (2017)
  25. 이종범, "불확실성, 모호성과 딜레마 상황하에서 절차적 합리성의 탐색", 행정논총, 43(4), pp.1~27 (2005), 한국행정연구소
  26. 정영근, "물 거버넌스와 지속가능발전 연계 연구. 정부3.0시대의 물 거버넌스", pp.15~54 (2014), 도서출판 피어나
  27. 지속가능발전목표(SDGs) 세부대응전략 수립을 위한 연구, "조을생", 한국환경정책, 평가연구원, ~ (2014)
  28. 최동진, "물값 갈등과 물관리 체계, 물은 누구의 것인가?", 서울환경운동연합 주최 토론회 (2012)
  29. 지속가능한 유역 통합물관리체계 구축방안 연구, "최흥석", K-water, ~ (2018)
  30. K-water, "해수담수화시설 수탁운영 현황", ~ (2014)
  31. 홍준형, "환경법특강" (2013), 박영사
  32. 환경백서, "환경부", ~ (2016)
  33. Campbell, S., "Green cities, growing cities, just cities? Urban planning and the contradictions of sustainable development", Journal of the American Planning Association, 62(3), pp.296~312 (1996)
  34. Connelly, Steve, "Mapping Sustainable Development as a Contested Concept", Local Environment, 12(3), pp.259~278 (2007)
  35. Dančák, Břetislav, "The Czech Republic's Energy Policy in a Wider European Space", The Forum for Future Energy in Busan-Ulsan-Gyeongnam, 22 (2018)
  36. Dodds, Flex, "Negotiating The Sustainable Development Goals: A Transformational Agenda for an Insecure World" (2017), Routlege
  37. Frantál, Bohumil, "Close or renew? Factors affecting local community support for rebuilding nuclear power plants in the Czech Republic", Energy Policy, 104, pp.134~143 (2017)
  38. Graves, James Robinson, "The Trilemma" (1881), Sagwan Press
  39. 허태욱, "Towards Reflexive Governance for Sustainable Development", Journal of Policy Studies, 25(3), pp.1~22 (2010), 서울대학교행정대학원
  40. Local Governments’ Response to Agenda 21: Summary Report of Local Agenda 21 Survey with Regional Focus, "ICLEI", ~ (2002)
  41. Iverson, T., "Equity, Employment, and Budgetary Restraint: The Trilemma of the Service Economy", World Politics, 50(4), pp.507~546 (1998)
  42. Kerk, Geurt van de, "A comprehensive index for a sustainable society: The SSI – the Sustainable Society Index", Journal of Ecological Economics, 66(2-3), pp.228~242 (2008)
  43. Langhelle, Oluf, "Why Ecological Modernization and Sustainable Development Should not be Conflated", Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 2, pp.303~322 (2000)
  44. McCauley, Darren, "Energy Justice: Re-balancing the Trilemma of Security, Poverty and Climate Change" (2018), Palgrave Macmillan
  45. Towards Green Growth: Monitoring Progress-OECD Indicators, "OECD", OECD, ~ (2011)
  46. Paehlke, Robert C., "Environmental Values and Public Policy, in Environmental Policy In The 1990s: Toward A New Agenda" (1994), A Division of Congressional Quarterly Inc.
  47. Empirical Tests and Policy Analysis of Environmental Degradation at Different Stages of Economic Development, "Panayotou, T.", Technology and Employment Programme, International Labour Office, ~, pp.Working Paper WP238 (1993)
  48. Panayotou, T., "Demystifying the environmental Kuznets curve: turning a black box into a policy tool", Environment and Development Economics, 2, pp.465~484 (1997)
  49. Rydin, Yvonne, "Governing for Sustainable Urban Development" (2010), Earthscan
  50. Sachs, Jefferey D., "지속가능한 발전의 시대" (2015), 21세기 북스
  51. Stern, D. I., "The Environmental Kuznets Curve, International Society for Ecological Economics and Internet Encyclopaedia of Ecological Economics" (2003)
  52. Stern, D. I., "Economic growth and environmental degradation : the environmental Kuznets curve and sustainable development", World Development, 24, pp.1151~1160 (1996)
  53. Sustainable Development Solution Network(SDSN)., "An Action Agenda for Sustainable Development" (2013), SDSN
  54. Drinking Water Equity, "UNICEF", ~ (2011)
  55. United Nations Sustainable Development Knowledge Platform, "TST Issues Brief: Water and Sanitation" (2013)
  56. Vig, Norman J., "Environmental Policy: New Directions for the Twenty-First Century" (2010), CQ Press
  57. WCED, "Our Common Future" (1987), Oxford University Press
  58. WWI 2015 지구환경보고서: 지속가능성의 숨은 위협들, "Worldwatch Institute", 환경재단 도요새, ~ (2015)
  59. The Environmental Kuznets Curve, "Yandle, Bruce", PERC, ~, pp.PERC Research Study 02-1 (2002)
  60. Yin, Robert K., "Case Study Research: Design and Methods" (1994), Sage Publications

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (13건)