A Preliminary Study on the Environmental Policy Value
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
A study on the environmental policy value is at its early stage, and previous studies are lacking. This article attempts to sketch out the environmental policy value. Value is defined criteria with the nature of value and covers standards, principles, ethics in previous studies. Based on a hierarchy of value theory of previous researchers, it is classified into intrinsic value and procedural value. This typology can be a catalyst of in-depth understanding on policy mechanisms and choice of the preferred policy goals and policy means. Intrinsic value is strongly related to policy ideology, and it structures a policy goal setting. Procedural value is used in the selection and evaluation of policy instruments. The intrinsic value of environmental policy is composed of sustainable development, technocentrism and ecocentrism. Procedural value is composed of postmanagement and precaution, individualism and integration, efficiency and equity, shared responsibility and polluters liability. This paper contributed to present a bigger picture of the environmental policy value and paving the ground for a more refined theory.
Abstract
A study on the environmental policy value is at its early stage, and previous studies are lacking. This article attempts to sketch out the environmental policy value. Value is defined criteria with the nature of value and covers standards, principles, ethics in previous studies. Based on a hierarchy of value theory of previous researchers, it is classified into intrinsic value and procedural value. This typology can be a catalyst of in-depth understanding on policy mechanisms and choice of the preferred policy goals and policy means. Intrinsic value is strongly related to policy ideology, and it structures a policy goal setting. Procedural value is used in the selection and evaluation of policy instruments. The intrinsic value of environmental policy is composed of sustainable development, technocentrism and ecocentrism. Procedural value is composed of postmanagement and precaution, individualism and integration, efficiency and equity, shared responsibility and polluters liability. This paper contributed to present a bigger picture of the environmental policy value and paving the ground for a more refined theory.
참고문헌 (39)
- Banisar, David, "Moving from Principles to Rights : RIO 2012 and Access to Information, Public Participation, and Justice", Sustainable Development Law & Policy, 12(3), pp.8~15 (2012)
- Bartlett, R. V., "Ethics and Environmental Policy in Democratic Governance : John Rawls, Public Reason and Normative Precommittment", Policy Integrity, 7(3), pp.219~240 (2005)
- Bran, Florina, "Values and Environmental Ethics-Pillars of Changing Human Behavior Toward Sustainable Development", Journal of Knowledge Management, Economics and Information Technology, 1, pp.194~202 (2013)
- Brennan, A., "Globalization, Environmental Policy and Ethics of Place", Ethics, Place and Environment, 9(2), pp.133~148 (2006)
- Fiksel, Joseph, "A System View of Sustainability-The Triple Value Model", Environmental Development, 2, pp.138~141 (2012)
- Gardiner, Stephen M., "A Core Precautionary Principle", The Journal of Political Philosophy, 14(1), pp.33~60 (2006)
- Gamlund, Espen, "Introduction to 'Confronting Environmental Values. Ethics", Policy and Environment, 14(3), pp.307~312 (2011)
- Henning, D. H., "Environmental Policy and Administration" (1974), American Elsevier
- Hillman, M., "The Importance of Environmental Justice in Stream Rehabilitation. Ethics", Place and Environment, 7(1-2), pp.19~43 (2004)
- Hodgkinson, C., "Toward A Philosophy of Administration" (1978), St. Martins Press
- JanousˇKova´, Svatava, "Values and Sustainable Development : Reflection on Selected Czech Policy Documents(1988–2010)", Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 15(3), pp.371~386 (2013)
- Jax, Kurt, "Ecosystem Services and Ethics", Ecological Economics, 93, pp.260~268 (2013)
- Jeong, Seon-Yang, "Environmental Policy" (1999), Bakyoung Company
- Jeong, Hoe-Seong, "Environmental Policy" (2003), Bakyoung Company
- Jørgensen, Sven Erik, "Tool Boxes for an Integrated Ecological and Environmental Management", Ecological Indicators, 21, pp.104~109 (2012)
- Kaplan, A., "The Conduct of Inquiry" (1964), Chandler Publishing Company
- 김창수, "환경정책의 난제와 윤리기준의 적용", 지방정부연구, 10(3), pp.143~164 (2006), 한국지방정부학회
- Kim, Gyu-Jeong, "A Preliminary Study of Policy Value", Chung-Ang Public Administration Review, 1(1), pp.1~19 (1987)
- 김기성, "독일의 지속가능발전 전략과 환경정책통합", 사회과학논집, 41(2), pp.61~81 (2010), 사회과학연구소
- 김영진, "통합적 환경관리제도에 관한 소고", 한양법학, (33), pp.167~186 (2011), 한양법학회
- Korhonen, J., "Environmental Planning vs. System Analysis : Four Prescriptive Principles vs. Four Descriptive Indicators", Journal of Environmental Management, 82, pp.51~59 (2007)
- Layzer, Judith A., "The Environmental Case : Translating Values into Policy" (2012), SAGE
- 이덕연, "환경정의 개념의 외연과 내포 - 헌법해석론 및 환경법적 함의", 환경법연구, 35(2), pp.133~176 (2013), 한국환경법학회
- Lee, Si-Kyung, "Issue and Criteria of Policy Instrument Choice in Environmental Regulation", Korean Public Administration Review, 30(1), pp.113~127 (1996)
- 이시경, "통합환경관리의 시론적 모형", 한국사회와 행정연구, 15(1), pp.313~332 (2004), 서울행정학회
- 이시경, "환경정책의 가치체계 - 목표가치와 수단가치를 중심으로 -", 한국자치행정학보, 28(2), pp.21~43 (2014), 한국자치행정학회
- Lindhout, Petra E., "The Polluter Pays Principle : Guidelines for Cost Recovery and Burden Sharing in the Case Law of the European Court of Justice", Utrecht Law Review, 10(2), pp.46~59 (2014)
- Mickwitz, P., "A Framework for Evaluating Environmental Policy Instruments", Evaluation, 9(4), pp.415~436 (2003)
- Ministry of Environment, "White Paper of Environment" (2014), Ministry of Environment(Korean)
- Minteer, Ben A., "Convergence in Environmental Values : An Empirical and Conceptual Defense", Ethics, Place and Environment, 3(1), pp.47~60 (2000)
- 박병도, "국제환경법상 오염자부담원칙의 우리나라 환경법에의 수용", 환경법연구, 34(1), pp.331~359 (2012), 한국환경법학회[DOI]
- Park, Yong-sung, "Democratization and Sustainable Development", Conference Proceedings Korea Society of Public Administration (2009)
- O'Riordan, T., "Environmentalism" (1981), Pion
- Pepper, D., "Modern Environmentalism : An Introduction" (1996), Library of Congress
- Rein, Martin., "Social Science and Public Policy" (1976), Penguin Books
- 소영진, "정책평가에 있어서 가치의 역할에 관한 소고", 정책분석평가학회보, 19(3), pp.33~66 (2009), 한국정책분석평가학회
- Tisdell, Clem, "The Precautionary Principle Revisited : Its Interpretations and Their Conservation Consequences", The Singapore Economic Review, 55(2), pp.335~352 (2010)
- UN., "The Future We Want (Outcome From the Conference)", Brasil.A, L.1, pp.2012[DOI]
- Wurzel, Judiger K. W., "Environmental Governance in Europe: A Comparative Analysis of New Environmental Policy Instruments" (2013), Edward Elgar