Pastoral Theological Reflection on Compassion
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study aims to provide a pastoral theological reflection on compassion. In acts of compassion, people often focus on extending compassion toward others, particularly friends, family, or benefactors. While understanding ordinary forms of compassion is relatively straightforward, it becomes more challenging to practice compassion towards individuals or groups that inflict pain and suffering through abuse, oppression or discrimination. When someone attempts to show compassion for those who have consistently caused harm or suffering, their efforts are frequently criticized as potentially jeopardizing the safety of victims and leading to further dander and suffering. Consequently, such acts of compassion are sometimes deemed irrational or pathological. Acknowledging these concerns, this study engages in a pastoral theological reflection on the meaning of compassion in contemporary society. First, it explores the meaning, motivations, and validity of compassion, addressing criticisms from scholars. In addition, the objects of compassion are examined based on Germer's six categories. Second, the practice of compassion for those who cause suffering is discussed at both individual and societal level, drawing on the arguments of practical and pastoral theologians. Ultimately, this study asserts that compassion must be understood as a complicate and complex human experience comprising various dimensions, such as emotion, reason, faith, and duty, rather than merely as an irrational emotion. Furthermore, this study contends that compassion has the potential to dismantle the dualism between self and others, as well as oppressor and oppressed. Practicing compassion for adversaries within families and society can be achieved through an acknowledgment of interconnectedness and relationality.
Abstract
This study aims to provide a pastoral theological reflection on compassion. In acts of compassion, people often focus on extending compassion toward others, particularly friends, family, or benefactors. While understanding ordinary forms of compassion is relatively straightforward, it becomes more challenging to practice compassion towards individuals or groups that inflict pain and suffering through abuse, oppression or discrimination. When someone attempts to show compassion for those who have consistently caused harm or suffering, their efforts are frequently criticized as potentially jeopardizing the safety of victims and leading to further dander and suffering. Consequently, such acts of compassion are sometimes deemed irrational or pathological. Acknowledging these concerns, this study engages in a pastoral theological reflection on the meaning of compassion in contemporary society. First, it explores the meaning, motivations, and validity of compassion, addressing criticisms from scholars. In addition, the objects of compassion are examined based on Germer's six categories. Second, the practice of compassion for those who cause suffering is discussed at both individual and societal level, drawing on the arguments of practical and pastoral theologians. Ultimately, this study asserts that compassion must be understood as a complicate and complex human experience comprising various dimensions, such as emotion, reason, faith, and duty, rather than merely as an irrational emotion. Furthermore, this study contends that compassion has the potential to dismantle the dualism between self and others, as well as oppressor and oppressed. Practicing compassion for adversaries within families and society can be achieved through an acknowledgment of interconnectedness and relationality.
참고문헌 (35)
- Barad, Judith., "The Understanding and Experience of Compassion : Aquinas and the Dalai Lama", Buddhist-Christian Studies, 27, pp.11~29 (2007)
- Bromiley, GeoffreyW, "Theological Dictionary of the NewTestament, VII" (1976), WM. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company
- Browning, Don, "From Culture Wars to Common Ground: Religion and the American Family Debate" (2000), Westminster John Knox Press
- Chung, Hyun Kyung, "Struggle to be the Sun Again : Introducing Asian Women’s Theology" (1991), Orbis Books
- Coleman, Monica A, "Making a Way out of No Way : Womanist Theology" (2008), Fortress Press
- Cone, James H, "Living Stones in the Household of God: The Legacy and Future of Black Theology", pp.3~12 (2004), Fortress Press
- Couture, Pamela D, "Blessed are the Poor? : Women’s Poverty, Family Policy, and Practical Theology" (1991), Abingdon Press
- Couture, Pamela D, "Seeing Children and Seeing God : a Practical Theology of Children and Poverty" (2000), Abingdon Press
- Davies, Oliver, "A Theology of Compassion : Metaphysics of Difference and the Renewal of Tradition" (2001), William B. Eerdmans Publishing
- Davison, James E., "Journey through the Word : Exploring Biblical Themes" (2003), Westminster John Knox Press
- Fabella, Virginia, "With Passion and Compassion : Third World Women Doing Theology" (1986), Orbis Books
- Feldman, Christian, "Compassion : Listening to the Cries of the World" (2005), Rodmell Press
- Germer, Christopher K, "The Mindful Path to Self-Compassion : Freeing Yourself from Destructive Thoughts and Emotions" (2009), The Guilford Press
- Gillman, James, "Faith, Reason, and Compassion : A Philosophy of the Christian Faith" (2007), Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc
- "Race and the Cosmos: An Invitation to Viewthe World Differently" (2002)[URL]
- Joh, Wonhee Anne, "Postcolonial Theologies: Divinity and Empire", pp.149~163 (2004), Chalice Press
- Joh, Wonhee Anne, "Off the Menu: Asian and Asian North American Women’s Religion & Theology", pp.145~162 (2007), Westminster John Knox Press
- Katoppo, Marianne, "Compassionate and Free : An Asian Women's Theology" (1979), World Council of Churches
- Kim, Gyeong, "Pastoral Counseling as a Resource for the Public Mental Health from a Perspective of Pastoral Theology as Public Theology", Theology and Praxis, 36, pp.355~387 (2013)
- Kim, In-Sook, "Suggestions on the Direction of Pastoral Counseling through the Literature Review on Public Theology and Narrative Therapy", Theology and Praxis, 73, pp.561~587 (2021)
- Kim, Jung Ha, "New Spiritual Homes: Religion and Asian Americans", pp.91~106 (1999), University of Hawaii Press
- Kim, Seung-Hwan, "A Study of Public Ministry from the Perspective of Public Theology", Theology and Praxis, 86, pp.913~937 (2023)
- Deuterocanonical Books, "The NRSV Concordance Unabridged including the Apocryphal", pp.1991, Kohlenberger III.
- Neuger, Christie Cozad, "Care of Men" (2007), Abingdon Press
- New King James Version, "The Complete Concordance to the Bible" (1983), Thomas Nelson Publishers
- Paik, Eun-Mi, "Compassionate Educational Ministry for Non-Competitive Society", Theology and Praxis, 58, pp.223~248 (2018)
- Plato, "Republic 607a, Plato the Republic, v. 2" (1935), Heinemann
- Poling, James N., "Men's Work in Preventing Violence against Women" (2002), The Haworth Pastoral Press
- Sharp, Kevin, "Sleuthing the Divine : The Nexus of Science and Spirit" (2000), Fortress
- Terrell, JoAnne Marie, "Power in the Blood? The Cross in the African American Experience" (1998), Orbis Books
- Thomas, Linda E., "Living Stones in the Household of God : The Legacy and Future of Black Theology" (2004), Fortress Press
- Yang, Sung-Jin, "Compassion-Cultivation Education for Human-Becoming in the Post-Human Age : Education for Connecting with the Sacred, Rediscovering Subjective Self, and Participating in the suffering of Others", Theology and Praxis, 88, pp.545~575 (2024)
- Yoo, Sang Hi, "Embracing Complexities : Reflection on Korean Women in Conflictive and Abusive Marital Relationships", Korean Journal of Christian Counseling, 26(3), pp.165~197 (2015)
- "Theology and Praxis", 2021, 407~438
- Young, Robert Young, "Young's Analytical Concordance to the Bible" (1982), Thomas Nelson Publishers