The Proliferation Security Initiative: A Paradigm Shift for Nonproliferation?
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
"The PSI is in substance a form of export control regime activities between and among major allies of the Unites States, which belongs to the typical supply-side approach in terms of the proliferation management. In short, the PSI is not possibly a new paradigm for the proliferation management, contrary to the expectation of some wishful thinking group in field of non- proliferation. In this respect, any effective strategy for nonproliferation must also involve demand-side measures. This paper consists of three sections: the first section looks into the nature of the PSI in terms of political, legal and military dimensions. It begins by assessing the policy change with its center of gravity from 'nonproliferation' to 'counterproliferation.'Based on this assessment, the paper in the second section explores what the PSI can do in the course of conducting nonproliferation efforts and what not by comparing two 'interdiction' cases of the So San and the BBC China. The third and concluding section deals with an alternative suggestions how the future strategy for proliferation management should be pursued policy-wise."
Abstract
"The PSI is in substance a form of export control regime activities between and among major allies of the Unites States, which belongs to the typical supply-side approach in terms of the proliferation management. In short, the PSI is not possibly a new paradigm for the proliferation management, contrary to the expectation of some wishful thinking group in field of non- proliferation. In this respect, any effective strategy for nonproliferation must also involve demand-side measures. This paper consists of three sections: the first section looks into the nature of the PSI in terms of political, legal and military dimensions. It begins by assessing the policy change with its center of gravity from 'nonproliferation' to 'counterproliferation.'Based on this assessment, the paper in the second section explores what the PSI can do in the course of conducting nonproliferation efforts and what not by comparing two 'interdiction' cases of the So San and the BBC China. The third and concluding section deals with an alternative suggestions how the future strategy for proliferation management should be pursued policy-wise."
참고문헌 (26)
- Beck, Michael, "Creating a New Multilateral Export Control Regime", Arms Control Today (2003)
- Davis B. Bobrow, "Hegemonic Management: the U.S in the Asia–Pacific", The Pacific Review, 12(2) (1999)
- Boese, Wade, "Key U.S. Interdiction Initiative Claim Misrepresented", Arms Control Today (2005)
- Coll, Steve, "The Atomic Emporium Abdul Qadeer Khan and Iran’s race to build the bomb", ~ (2006)
- Croddy, Eric, "Weapons of Mass Destruction: An Encyclopedia of Worldwide Policy, Technology, and History" (2005), ABC-CLIO Inc.
- Dosch, Jorn, "Multilateralism and North Korea: Lessons of European Experences,"", paper presented at the Conference on North Korea (2003)
- Ferguson, Charles D., "Counterproliferation and Nonproliferation Backgrounder", Physics &Society, 33(3) (2004)
- Guilfoyle, Douglas, "The Proliferation Security Initiative: Interdicting Vessels in International Waters to Prevent the Spread of Weapons of Mass Destruction?", Melbourne University Law Review, 29(3) (2005)
- Keohane, Robert, "Multilateralism: an Agenda for Research", International Journal, 45(4) (1990)
- Kucia, Christine, "Counterproliferation at Core of New Security Strategy", Arms Control Today, 32 (2002)
- Lambaskis, Steven, "Understanding 'Asymmetric' Threats to the United States", Comparative Strategy, 21(4) (2002)
- Lavoy, Peter R., "US Counterproliferation Cooperation with Allies. in: Avoiding the Abyss: Progress, Shortfalls, and the Way ahead in combating the WMD Threat" (2006), Praeger
- Lee, Seo-Hang, "Key issues of PSI and recent developments", Korea Herald (2009)
- "The Secretary General' s High Level Panel Report"[URL]
- "Counter-prolferation vs. Non-proliferation. in: The Man Who Sold the Bomb"[URL]
- Pugh, Michael, "Combating the arms proliferation problem. Time to embark on an integrated approach", NATO Review, 43(1)
- Ramana, M. V., "India, Pakistan, and the Bomb", Scientific American, 285(6) (2001)
- Ruggie, John Gerald, "Multilateralism: The Anatomy of an Institution", The Theory and Praxis of an International Form (1993)
- Sagan, S. D., "The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: A Debat" (1995), W.W. Norton
- Shanker, Thom, "Threats and responses: arms smuggling; Scud missiles found on ship of North Korea. in: SIPRI Yearbook 2005: Armaments, Disarmament and International Security" (2005), SIPRI
- Snyder, Craig A., "Contemporary Security and Strategy" (1999), Routledge
- "Proliferation Security Initiative Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)"[URL]
- Nonproliferation: Strategy Needed to Strengthen Multilateral Export Control Regimes, "US General Accounting Office", ~, pp.GAO-03-43 (2002)
- Valencia, Mark J., "The Proliferation Security Initiative: A Glass Half-Full", Arms Control Today (2007)
- "PSI Celebrates Fifth Anniversary with Mixed Record"[URL]
- Winner, Andrew C., "The Proliferation Security Initiative: The New Face of Interdiction", Washington Quarterly, 28(2) (2005)