국방무기체계 획득영향요인 상호관계 분석 :함정획득지연 사례 및 요인 분석을 중심으로
A Methodology for Analyzing on the Correlation of Factors Affecting the Acquisition of Military Weapons Systems :Focused on Factor Analysis of Naval Ship Acquisition Delay Cases
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Naval weapons systems of the Republic of Korea are acquired through the Defense Planning Management System. Recently, acquisition of some naval ships have been delayed, and the causes of the delays have been recognized as inappropriate project management at the Execution Phase. However, we argue that the delay problem in naval ships acquisition should be approached, with due regard for the entire Defense Planning Management System. That is, We should try to investigate from Planning Phase to those of Programming, Budgeting and Execution Phases. Therefore, in this study, we investigated the actual cases of the delay in naval acquisition at all phases of the Defense Planning Management System. Based on the investigation, we tried to identify the naval ship Acquisition Delay Factors and find out the Weights of those factors. As the next step, we calculated the Influence Measures on the naval missions, including the Cost of Naval Capability Gap derived from the delays in acquisition of naval ships. As a final step, we calculated the Acquisition Delay Measures based on the interrelationship between the Acquisition Delay Factors and the Influence Measures. Then we evaluated and analyzed what the results stand for. Finally, we made suggestions for future improvement. The improvement suggestions we made for preventing delay in acquisition of naval ships in this study are as follows. First, we need a shift in perception. It is necessary to measure the Acquisition Delay Factors in acquiring naval ships and manage them from the Planning Phase. Second, resolution must be concerted efforts. All relevant agencies, not just a few, should work together to resolve the problems of acquisition delay. Third, analysis must be based on the accumulation of data. This allows the elaborating of naval ship Acquisition Delay Factors and Delay Measures. If this research method is applied to other military weapons systems in the future, we may be able to not just identify the Acquisition Delay Factors in acquisition of other military weapons systems, but also pursue improvement in those cases.
Abstract
Naval weapons systems of the Republic of Korea are acquired through the Defense Planning Management System. Recently, acquisition of some naval ships have been delayed, and the causes of the delays have been recognized as inappropriate project management at the Execution Phase. However, we argue that the delay problem in naval ships acquisition should be approached, with due regard for the entire Defense Planning Management System. That is, We should try to investigate from Planning Phase to those of Programming, Budgeting and Execution Phases. Therefore, in this study, we investigated the actual cases of the delay in naval acquisition at all phases of the Defense Planning Management System. Based on the investigation, we tried to identify the naval ship Acquisition Delay Factors and find out the Weights of those factors. As the next step, we calculated the Influence Measures on the naval missions, including the Cost of Naval Capability Gap derived from the delays in acquisition of naval ships. As a final step, we calculated the Acquisition Delay Measures based on the interrelationship between the Acquisition Delay Factors and the Influence Measures. Then we evaluated and analyzed what the results stand for. Finally, we made suggestions for future improvement. The improvement suggestions we made for preventing delay in acquisition of naval ships in this study are as follows. First, we need a shift in perception. It is necessary to measure the Acquisition Delay Factors in acquiring naval ships and manage them from the Planning Phase. Second, resolution must be concerted efforts. All relevant agencies, not just a few, should work together to resolve the problems of acquisition delay. Third, analysis must be based on the accumulation of data. This allows the elaborating of naval ship Acquisition Delay Factors and Delay Measures. If this research method is applied to other military weapons systems in the future, we may be able to not just identify the Acquisition Delay Factors in acquisition of other military weapons systems, but also pursue improvement in those cases.
참고문헌 (19)
- 조만형, "함정의 품질 제고 방법론 연구", 한국산업경영시스템학회지, 35(1), pp.198~213 (2012), 한국산업경영시스템학회
- A Study on Improving the Acquisition Policy for Naval Ship, "Choi", Hannam University Industry-Academic Collaboration Foundation, ~ (2017)
- Evaluation on Improving Work of National Defense Capabilities for 10 years and Study on Com-prehensive Policy for Defense Acqusition Management System, "Choi, S. B.", Research Report, Korea Institute for Defense Analyses, ~ (2017)
- "Hankook Daily"[URL]
- Hwang, J. -O., "A Study on Improvement of Naval Ship Acquisition Pro-cess", Journal of Military Science and Technology Studies, 11(1), pp.31~39 (2018)
- "Introduction to Defense Acquisition Program", Defense Acquisition Program Administration, ~ (2008)
- A Study on Analyzing the Case of Delivery Delay and Improving the Acquisition Policy for Naval Ships, "Jeon", Security Management Institute, ~ (2018)
- 정용태, "협동교전능력(CEC) 체계구축을 위한 해상작전 적용효과 분석 방법론", 한국산업경영시스템학회지, 42(1), pp.95~105 (2019), 한국산업경영시스템학회[DOI]
- 김재용, "함정사업 시험평가의 효율적 수행방안에 관한 연구", 한국군사과학기술학회지, 19(6), pp.703~711 (2016), 한국군사과학기술학회[DOI]
- 김두억, "함정 획득제도 변경이 품질 및 전력화시기에 미친 영향에 관한 연구", 한국방위산업학회지, 25(1), pp.47~65 (2018), 한국방위산업학회[DOI]
- 김종하, "해군의 함정획득사업 개선방안: 연구개발절차를 중심으로", 한국방위산업학회지, 18(2), pp.161~184 (2011), 한국방위산업학회
- A Study on Improving Process for Minimizing the Acquisition Period of Naval Ship, "Kim, J.-H.", Hannam University Industry-Academic Colla- boration Foundation, ~ (2011)
- A Study on New Relationship Between DAPA and Navy for Ship’s De- sign and Constructing Work, "Kim, J. -T.", Korea Institute for Defense Analyses, ~ (2007)
- Lee, O.-K., "An Empirical Study on the Relationship of Success Factors and Requirements Management Factors in Project for Improvement of Defense Capability", pp.2011
- "Naval Ship Program Management Guide Book", Defense Acquisition Program Administration, 2016~ (2016)
- "Order of Defense Planning Management", Ministry of National Defense, ~ (2017)
- Saaty, T.L., "How to make a decision; The Analytic Hier- archy Process", Interfaces, 24(6), pp.19~43 (1994)
- Shin, J.-H., "A Study on the Improvement of Naval Ship Research and Development Program under Changing Acquisition Environment", pp.2014
- 신상욱, "국방무기체계 연구개발 기반 경제적․기술적 파급효과 : 지상․해상․공중 무기체계를 중심으로", 한국산업경영시스템학회지, 41(4), pp.111~122 (2018), 한국산업경영시스템학회[DOI]