본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

중등 수학교과서가 다루는 수학사의 비판과 대안

Study on Criticism and Alternative on the History of Mathematics Described in the Secondary School Mathematics Textbooks

1

조회

0

다운로드

6

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

본 논문의 목적은 중등 수학교과서에 기술되어 있는 수학사의 주요 문제점을 알아보고, 그리고 중등 수학교과서에수학문화의 전이가 반영되어야함을 주장하는데 있다. 교과서에서 다루는 수학사는 기축시대와 고대 그리스에서 고대이집트, 고 바빌로니아, 그리고 이슬람 수학을 제외한 유럽으로의 수학문화의 전이가 반영되어 있다. 우리는 이를 알아보고 수학사적 문제의 대안을 제시하였다.

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to discuss some of the most commonly repeated misconceptions on the history of mathematics described in the secondary school mathematics textbooks, and recommend that we should include mathematical transculture in the secondary school mathematics. School mathematical history described in the texts reflects the axial age, and deals with mathematical transculture from the ancient Greek into Europe excluding the ancient Egypt, Old Babylonia, and Islamic mathematics. We discuss about them through out the secondary school textbooks and give some alternatives for the historical problems.

참고문헌 (210)

  1. 고호경, "중학교 수학③" (2012), 교학사
  2. 2009 개정 교육과정에 따른 수학과 교육과정 연구, "교육과학기술부", ~ (2011)
  3. 교육부, "초등수학 5-1" (2015), ㈜천재교육
  4. 김서령, "중학교 수학①" (2012), 천재교육
  5. 김서령, "중학교 수학②" (2012), 천재교육
  6. 김용운, "수학의 흐름" (1975), 배영사
  7. 김용운, "수학의 흐름" (1985), 전파과학사
  8. 김용운, "재미있는 수학여행 3" (1991), 김영사
  9. 김용운, "중국수학사" (1996), 민음사
  10. 김용운, "한국 수학사" (2012), 살림Math
  11. 김원경, "중학교 수학②" (2012), 비상교육
  12. 김원경, "고등학교 수학I" (2014), 비상교육
  13. 김창동, "고등학교 미적분I" (2014), ㈜교학사
  14. 김창동, "고등학교 미적분II" (2014), ㈜교학사
  15. 김창동, "고등학교 기하와 벡터" (2014), ㈜교학사
  16. 김창동, "고등학교 수학II" (2014), ㈜교학사
  17. 류희찬, "중학교 수학①" (2013), 천재교과서
  18. 류희찬, "중학교 수학②" (2013), 천재교과서
  19. 류희찬, "중학교 수학③" (2013), 천재교과서
  20. 류희찬, "고등학교 수학I" (2014), 천재교과서
  21. 류희찬, "고등학교 수학II" (2014), 천재교과서
  22. 류희찬, "고등학교 기초수학" (2014), 천재교과서
  23. 러시아 과학 아카데미 철학연구소, "세계철학사1" (2008), 중원문화
  24. 박종률, "예술(음", 미)과 수학 통합 교수 학습자료 개발, 2013
  25. 박제남, "현대대수학" (2013), 경문사
  26. 박제남, "황금비와 수학교육 담론", 수학교육 논문집, 28(2), pp.281~302 (2014), 한국수학교육학회
  27. 박제남, "초등학교 수학 교과서가 다루는 수학사의 보완 방안 -수학문화의 전이를 중심으로-", 수학교육 논문집, 28(4), pp.493~511 (2014), 한국수학교육학회
  28. 박제남, "4천년 역사의 흔적" (2004), 교우사
  29. 손주영, "이집트역사" (2011), 가람기획
  30. 신준국, "중학교 수학③" (2012), 두배의느낌
  31. 이광연, "고등학교 미적분II" (2014), 지학사
  32. 우정호, "중학교 수학②" (2012), 두산동아
  33. 우정호, "중학교 수학③" (2012), 두산동아
  34. 우정호, "고등학교 기하와 벡터" (2014), 두산동아
  35. 이강섭, "고등학교 수학I" (2014), ㈜미래엔
  36. 이강섭, "고등학교 수학II" (2014), ㈜미래엔
  37. 이종우, "기하학의 역사적 배경과 발달" (1998), 경문사
  38. 이정우, "세계철학사1" (2014), 도서출판 길
  39. 이준열, "중학교 수학③" (2012), 천재교육
  40. 이준열, "고등학교 수학II" (2014), 천재교육
  41. 이준열, "고등학교 기초수학" (2014), 천재교육
  42. 정상권, "중학교 수학①" (2012), ㈜금성출판사
  43. 정상권, "고등학교 미적분II" (2014), ㈜금성출판사
  44. 정수용, "수학교과서 속 수학자들에 대한 비판적 분석: 융합적 협업으로서 다문화교육 관점에서", 교과교육학연구, 18(2), pp.441~470 (2014), 교과교육연구소
  45. 정해남, "예비수학교사를 위한 수학사 활용 방안", 한국수학사학회지, 25(3), pp.141~157 (2012), 한국수학사학회[DOI]
  46. 한경혜, "수학과 교수-학습에서 수학사 활용의 교육적 함의", 한국수학사학회지, 19(4), pp.31~62 (2006), 한국수학사학회
  47. 김영록, "고등학교 미적분II" (2014), (주)좋은책신사고
  48. 황선욱, "고등학교 기하와 벡터" (2014), 좋은책신사고
  49. 황선욱, "고등학교 수학I" (2014), 좋은책 신사고
  50. 허민, "중학교 수학①" (2012), 대교
  51. 허민, "중학교 수학③" (2012), 대교
  52. Aaboe, A., "Episodes from the early history of mathematics" (1998), MAA
  53. Aaboe, A, "al-Kashi's iteration method for the determination of sin1°", Scripta Math, 20, pp.24~29 (1954)
  54. Al-Khalili, J., "The house of wisdom : How Arabic science saved ancient knowledge and gave us the Renaissance" (2010), Penguin Books
  55. Anderson, M., "Sherlock Holmes in Babylon" (2004), MAA
  56. Aristoteles, "Politika" (2009), 도서출판 숲
  57. Aristoteles, "Politica(Oxford Classical Text)" (1957), Oxford Univ. Press
  58. Armstrong, K., "축의 시대" (2010), 교양인
  59. Armstrong, K., "The great transformation" (2007), Anchor
  60. Baragar, A., "Constructions using a compass and twice-notched straightedge", Amer. Math. Monthly, 109, pp.151~164 (2002)
  61. Bashmakova, I., "The beginnings and evolution of algebra" (2000), MAA
  62. Beard, C., "The Fibonacci drawing board-design of the great pyramid of Giza", Fibonacci Quarterly, 6, pp.66~68 (1968)
  63. Berggren, J. L., "Episodes in the mathematics of medieval Islam" (1986), Springer
  64. Bernal, M., "블랙 아테나, 제1권" (2011), 소나무
  65. Bernal, M., "Black Athena, Vol. I" (1987), Rutgers Univ. Press
  66. Bernal, M., "블랙 아테나, 제2권" (2012), 소나무
  67. Bernal, M., "Black Athena, Vol. II" (1991), Rutgers Univ. Press
  68. Bernal, M., "Animadversions on the origines of western science", Isis, 83, pp.596~607 (1992)
  69. Bernal, M, "Response to Robert Palter", Hist. Sci, 32, pp.445~468 (1994)
  70. Bold, B., "Famous problems of geometry and how to solve them" (1969), Dover
  71. Bonnard, A., "그리스인 이야기1" (2011), 책과함께
  72. Bonnard, A., "Civilisation Grecque, Vol. 1" (1954), Les Editions de L’aire
  73. Bonnard, A., "그리스인 이야기2" (2011), 책과함께
  74. Bonnard, A., "Civilisation Grecque, Vol. 2" (1957), Les Editions de L’aire
  75. Boyer, B., "A history of mathematics" (1991), John Wiley
  76. Bradly, R., "Euler, D’Alembert and the logarithm function, Leonhard Euler: Life, work and legacy" (2007), Elsevier
  77. Bressoud, D, "Was calculus invented in India?", College Math. J, 33, pp.2~13 (2002)
  78. Broug, E., "Islamic geometric patterns" (2011), Thames & Hudson
  79. Brown, E, "Square roots from 1; 24, 51, 10 to Dan Shanks", College Math. J, 30, pp.82~95 (1999)
  80. Burton, D., "The history of mathematics" (2007), McGraw-Hill
  81. Cajori, F., "History of the exponential and logarithmic concepts", Amer. Math. Monthly, 20(3), pp.5~14 (1913)
  82. Cajori, F., "A history of mathematical notations, Vol. I" (1928), The Open Court Pub. Com
  83. Cajori, F., "A history of mathematics" (1991), AMS
  84. Chace, A., "The Rhind mathematical papyrus" (1979), NCTM
  85. Chang, W., "Trisecting angles in Pythagorean triangles", Amer. Math. Monthly, 121, pp.625~631 (2014)
  86. "Chinese Text Project"[URL]
  87. Clagett, M., "Ancient Egyptian science, A source book Vol. 3: Ancient Egyptian mathematics" (1999), APS
  88. Corbin, H., "이슬람 철학사" (1997), 서광사
  89. Corbin, H., "Histoire de la philosopbie Islamique" (1964), Gallimard
  90. Couprie, D., "How Thales was able to"predict"a solar eclipse without the help of alleged Mesopotamian wisdom", Early Science and medicine, 9(4), pp.321~337 (2004)
  91. Curchin, I., "Hero of Alexandria’s numerical treatment of division in extreme and mean ratio and its implications", Pheonix, 35(2), pp.129~133 (1981)
  92. Dahan-Dalmedico, A., "History of mathematics" (2010), MAA
  93. Derbyshire, J., "Unknown quantity" (2006), Joseph Henry Press
  94. Descartes, R., "The Geometry of René Descartes with a facsimile" (1954), Dover
  95. Dunham, W., "Journey through genius" (1991), Penguin Books
  96. Durant, W., "문명이야기, 그리스 문명 2-1" (2011), 민음사
  97. Durant, W., "The story of civilization vol II.: The life of Greece" (1939), Simon & Schuster
  98. Elam, K., "Geometry of design" (2011), Princeton Architectural Press
  99. Engels, H., "Quadrature of the circle in ancient Egypt", Historia Mathematica, 4, pp.137~140 (1977)
  100. Euclid., "The thirteen books of the elements" (1956), Dover
  101. Eves, H., "Great moments in mathematics before 1650" (1983), MAA
  102. Eves, H., "An introduction to the history of mathematics" (1990), The Saunders Series
  103. Fowler, D., "The mathematics of Plato’s academy, A new construction" (2003), Clarendon Press
  104. Friberg, J., "Unexpected links between Egyptian and Babylonian mathematics" (2005), World Scientific
  105. Friberg, J., "A remarkable collection of Babylonian mathematical texts" (2007), Springer
  106. Friberg, J., "Amazing traces of a Babylonian origin in Greek mathematics" (2007), World Scientific
  107. Fritz, K, "The discovery of incommensurability by Hippasus of Metapontum", Annals of Math, 46, pp.242~264 (1945)
  108. Gandz, S., "he origin of the term “algebra”", Amer. Math. Monthly, 33, pp.437~440 (1926)
  109. Gandz, S., "The sources of al-Khowārizmī’s algebra", Osiris, 1, pp.263~277 (1936)
  110. Gandz, S., "The origin and development of the quadratic equations in Babylonian, Greek, and early arabic algebra", Osiris, 3, pp.405~557 (1937)
  111. Gast, K., "Le Corbusier, Paris-Chandigarh" (2000), Birkhauser
  112. Gillings, R., "Mathematics in the time of the pharaohs" (1982), Dover
  113. Gonzalez-Velasco, E., "Journey through mathematics" (2011), Springer
  114. Grabiner, J, "Descartes and problem-solving", Math. Mag, 68, pp.83~97 (1995)
  115. Gutas, D., "그리스 사상과 아랍문명" (2013), 글항아리
  116. 8th-10th Centuries), "Greek thought, Arabic culture: The Graeco-Arabic Translation Movement in Baghdad and Early ʻAbbāsid Society (2nd-4th", pp.1998, Gutas, D.
  117. Hahn, A., "Basic calculus : From Archimedes to Newton to its role in science" (1998), Springer
  118. Hambidge, J., "The elements of dynamic symmetry" (1920), Yale Univ. Press
  119. Hambidge, J., "Dynamic symmetry : The Greek vase" (1920), Yale Univ. Press
  120. Hambidge, J., "The Parthenon and the other Greek temples" (1924), Yale Univ. Press
  121. Heath, T., "Diophantus of Alexandria" (1910), Cambridge Univ. Press
  122. Heath, T., "Mathematics in Aristotle" (1949), Clarendon Press
  123. Heath, T., "A history of Greek mathematics, I : From Thales to Euclid" (1981), Dover
  124. Heath, T., "A history of Greek mathematics, II : From Aristarchus to Diophantus" (1981), Dover
  125. Heath, T, "The work of Archimedes" (2002), Dover
  126. Heath, T., "Aristarchus of Samos : The ancient Copernicus" (2004), Dover
  127. Heidarzadeh, T., "A history of physical theories of comets-From Aristotle to Whipple" (2008), Springer
  128. Herodotos, "역사" (2012), 도서출판 숲
  129. Herodotus, "Herodoti historiae, 2vol(Oxford Classical Text)" (1927), OUP
  130. Ho̷yrup, J., "Lengths, widths, surfaces, A portrait of Old Babylonian algebra and its kin" (2002), Springer
  131. Hughes, H., "Gerard of Cremon’s translation of Al-Khwarizmi’s al-jabr : A critical edition", Mediaeval Studies, 48, pp.211~263 (1986)
  132. Iamblichus, "On the Pythagorean way of life(Text, Translation, and Notes : J. Dillon and J. Hershbell)" (1991), Scholars Press
  133. Jepson, C., "Making square from Pythagorean triangles", College Math. J, 29(4), pp.284~288 (1998)
  134. Karpinski, L., "Robert of Chester’s Latine translation of the algebra of Al-Khowarizmi" (1915), MacMillan Company
  135. Katz, V, "Ideas of calculus in Islam and India", Math. Mag, 68, pp.163~174 (1995)
  136. Katz, V, "The mathematics of Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, India, and Islam, A source book" (2007), Princeton Univ. Press
  137. Katz, V., "A history of mathematics : An introduction" (2009), Addison-Wesley
  138. Kitto, H., "그리스 문화사" (2004), 탐구당
  139. Kitto, H., "The Greeks" (1951), Penguin Books
  140. Klein, F., "19세기 수학의 발전에 대한 강의" (2012), 나남
  141. Klein, F., "Vorlesungen über die entwicklung der mathematik Im 19" (1926), Springer
  142. Kline, M., "Mathematical thought from ancient to modern times, Vol. 1" (1972), Oxford Univ. Press
  143. Lay-Yong, L., "Circle measurements in ancient China", Historia Mathematica, 13, pp.325~340 (1986)
  144. Livio, M., "The golden ratio" (2002), Broadway Books
  145. Livio, M., "신은 수학자인가?" (2009), 열린과학
  146. Livio, M., "Is god a mathematician?" (2009), Simon & Schuster
  147. Lorch, R., "Greek-Arabic-Latin: The transmission of mathematical texts in the middle ages", Science in Context, 14, pp.313~331 (2001)
  148. Lumpkin, B., "The Egyptians and Pythagorean triples", Historia Mathematica, 7, pp.186~187 (1980)
  149. Lyons, J., "The house of wisdom" (2009), Bloomsbury Press
  150. Mardia, K., "Omar Khayyam, René Descartes and solutions to algebraic equations", International Congress in Commemorating Hakim Omar Khayyam Neyshabouri.(900th Death Anniversary 9) (2009)
  151. Markowsky, G, "Misconceptions about the golden ratio. College Math", College Math. J, 23, pp.1~19 (1992)
  152. Martin, J, "The Helen of geometry", College Math. J, 41, pp.17~28 (2010)
  153. Martin, T., "고대 그리스의 역사" (2011), 가람기획
  154. Martin, T., "Ancient Greece" (1996), Yale Univ. Press
  155. Mendelssohn, K., "The riddle of the pyramids" (1974), Thames and Hudson
  156. Merzbach, U., "A history of mathematics" (2011), Wiley
  157. Miatello, L., "The design of the Snefru pyramids at Dahshur and the Netjerikhet pyramid at Saqqara", PalArch’s Journal Archaeology of Egypt, 2005, pp.1(1), 1~11
  158. Mohanty, S., "Pythagorean Numbers", Fibonacci Quarterly, 28(1), pp.31~42 (1990)
  159. Nahin, P., "The story of  " (1998), Princeton Univ. Press
  160. Neugebauer, O., "The exact sciences in antiquity" (1957), Dover
  161. Newton, I., "The principia" (1999), Univ. of California Press
  162. Ngo, V., "Who cares if      has a solution?", College Math. J, 29(2), pp.141~144 (1998)
  163. Ore, O., "Number theory and its history" (1976), Dover
  164. Osserman, R., "Mathematics of the Gateway Arch", AMS Notices, 57(2), pp.220~229 (2010)
  165. Ostermann, A., "Geometry by its history" (2012), Springer
  166. Panchenko, D., "Thales’s prediction of a solar eclipse", J . for The History of Astronomy, 25, pp.275~288 (1994)
  167. Palter, R, "Black Athena, Afro-centrism, and the history of science. Hist", Hist. Sci, 31, pp.227~287 (1993)
  168. Paton, W. R, "The Greek anthology (BOOKS XIII-XVI)" (1979), Harvard Univ. Press
  169. Phillips, G, "Archimedes the numerical analyst", Amer. Math. Monthly, 88(3), pp.165~169 (1981)
  170. Pliny, "Natural history" (1967), Harvard Univ. Press
  171. Platon, "Timaios" (2000), 서광사
  172. Platon., "Platonis Opera, Tomus IV(Oxford Classical Text)" (1902), Oxford Univ. Press
  173. Platon., "Menon" (2009), 이제이북스
  174. Platon, "Platonis Opera, Tomus III(Oxford Classical Text)" (1903), Oxford Univ. Press
  175. Platon, "Phaedrus" (2011), 문예출판사
  176. Platon., "Platonis Opera, Tomus II(Oxford Classical Text)" (1910), Oxford Univ. Press
  177. Platon, "Theaetetos" (2013), 이제이북스
  178. Platon, "Platonis Opera, Tomus I(Oxford Classical Text)" (1995), Oxford Univ. Press
  179. Plutarch., "Parallel lives(플루타르크 영웅전I)" (2014), 동서문화사
  180. Plutarch., "Plutarch’s lives, Vol.1" (1906), Modern Library
  181. Proclus, "The complete works of Plutarch: Essays and miscellanies, Vol. III" (1909), Crowell
  182. Ptolemy, "Almagest" (1998), Princeton Univ. Press
  183. Querejeta, M., "On the eclipse of Thales, cycles and probability", Culture And Cosmos, 15, pp.5~16 (2011)
  184. Rashed, R, "Problems of the transmission of Greek scientific thought into Arabic: Examples from mathematics and optics", His. Sci, 27, pp.199~209 (1989)
  185. Rashed, R., "Classical mathematics from Al-Khwarīzmī to Descartes" (2015), Routledge
  186. Robert, J., "로마에서 중국까지" (2000), 이산
  187. Robert. J., "De Rome à la Chine" (1993), Les Belles Lettres
  188. Robins, G., "The Rhind mathematical papyrus" (1987), Dover
  189. Robson, E., "Neither Sherlock Holmes nor Babylon : A reassessment of Plimpton 322", Historia Mathematica, 28, pp.167~206 (2001)
  190. Robson, E., "Words and pictures: New light on Plimpton 322", Amer. Math. Monthly, 109, pp.105~120 (2002)
  191. Robson, E., "Mathematics in ancient Iraq" (2008), Princeton Univ. Press
  192. Rosen, F, "The algebra of Mohammed ben Musa" (1923), ULAN Press
  193. Rossi, C., "Architecture and mathematics in ancient Egypt" (2003), Cambridge Univ. Press
  194. Sontag, S., "해석에 반대한다" (2013), 이후
  195. Sontag, S., "Against interpretation" (1965), FSG
  196. Stephenson, F., "Thales’s prediction of a solar eclipse", J. for the History of Astronomy, 28, pp.279~282 (1997)
  197. Stillwell, J., "Mathematics and history" (2010), Springer
  198. Struik, D, "A source book in mathematics, 1200-1800" (1986), Princeton Univ. Press
  199. Suzuki, J., "A history of mathematics" (2002), Prentice Hall
  200. Suzuki, J., "Mathematics in historical context" (2009), MAA
  201. Thomas, I, "Greek mathematics II" (1993), Harvard Univ. Press
  202. Thomas, I, "Greek mathematics I" (2006), Harvard Univ. Press
  203. Trachtenber, M., "Architecture: From prehistory to post-modernism" (2002), Prentice Hall
  204. Van Brummelen, G., "The mathematics of the heavens and the earth : The early history of trigonometry" (2009), Princeton Univ. Press
  205. Van De Mieroop, M., "A history of ancient Egypt" (2011), Wiley-Blackwell
  206. van der Waerden, B. L., "A history of algebra" (1985), Springer
  207. Varadarajan, V., "Algebra in ancient and modern times" (1998), AMS
  208. Veljan, D, "The 2500-year-old Pythagorean theorem", Math. Mag, 73(4), pp.259~272 (2000)
  209. Wells, D., "The penguin dictionary of curious and interesting numbers" (1997), Penguin Books
  210. Whitman, E., "Some historical notes on the cycloid", Amer. Math. Monthly, 50(5), pp.309~315 (1943)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (4건)