본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

한국전쟁 당시 미국잡지에 실린 한국 이미지 분석

An Analysis of Korean Images in Popular US Magazines during the Korean War

0

조회

0

다운로드

2

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

The Korean War is a "forgotten war" to Americans. Situated between the World War II, or known as 'the great war,' and the Vietnam War, or known as 'the bad war,' the Korean War lacked any heroic war stories or great achievements, but only the tiresome tug-of-war. Even though a large number of U.S. and U.N soldiers lost their lives in Korea War, it ended in armistice which could hardly be defined as either a victory or a failure. On the other hand, the Korean War was the beginning of the Cold War between the U.S. and the Soviet Union. Although the Korean War was instigated due to the North Korean crossing of the border, it was hardly a war between the North and the South. It was rather a proxy war between the U.S. and the Soviet and China. All three superpowers needed to win the Korean War to prove their ideologies and themselves as the true superpower. However, Korea was an unknown country to American public. The inscription of the Korean War Veterans' Memorial describes Korea as "a country they never knew and a people they never met." Moreover, the Korean War broke out shortly after World War II, so American people were rather reluctant about the idea of engaging in another war. Therefore, U.S. government needed effective propaganda to draw more support from their people and to win the 'ambivalent, yet important war.'The role of the media was a crucial factor in the government's propaganda efforts. The Korean War was a transitional period between World War II and the Vietnam War, and the media's attitude changed greatly during that period. Strong anti-Communist sentiment was prevalent in America and the government enacted several laws to strictly prohibit the media from reporting anything that might be harmful to U.S. On the other hand, the Vietnam War was just the opposite of World War II. After the 'Pentagon Papers Revelation' and the 'Watergate Scandal,' the media became highly skeptical of the government activities. In addition, since the Vietnam War was a guerilla war, there was no set defense line which allowed the reporters to witness firsthand the cruelty of the war. With the increasing number of TV sets in each homes, American public was exposed to the gruesome images of the war. Situated in this transitional period of the changing media attitude, this paper examines the U.S. popular magazines during the period of the Korean War. If the Vietnam War was a 'television war,' the Korean War was a 'magazine war,' and American public was largely influenced by the magazines. After carefully studying the images of Koreans in U.S. magazines, this paper came to following conclusions: Firstly, among the Koreans' images, Korean soldiers were almost absent, and even when they made appearances, they were limited as either off-focused or background. Secondly, Korean men's images were almost absent, and most of the images were those of women or children. Thirdly, the stories of American soldiers who saved suffering Korea orphans or children were repeated. Lastly, U.S. was depicted as the 'good and kind,' while demonizing the Soviet Union and China. Aforementioned results are related to the circumstances of the time. First of all, the absence of men's images is due to the fact that they were taken during the war when most of the young men were drafted into the military. Moreover, since South Korea's defense capability of that time was rather meager because of the long history of Japanese Occupation, South Korean role in the Korean War was limited to assisting position to the U.S. On the other hand, the repeated images of Korean children and orphans saved by U.S. soldiers were the result of the Cold War rhetoric and the U.S.'s need to gain support from its people. By demonizing the Soviet and North Korea as evil forces that hurt small children, U.S. could depict themselves as the good force who cured and rescued them. Moreover, that kind of rhetoric earned sympathy from its people.

Abstract

The Korean War is a "forgotten war" to Americans. Situated between the World War II, or known as 'the great war,' and the Vietnam War, or known as 'the bad war,' the Korean War lacked any heroic war stories or great achievements, but only the tiresome tug-of-war. Even though a large number of U.S. and U.N soldiers lost their lives in Korea War, it ended in armistice which could hardly be defined as either a victory or a failure. On the other hand, the Korean War was the beginning of the Cold War between the U.S. and the Soviet Union. Although the Korean War was instigated due to the North Korean crossing of the border, it was hardly a war between the North and the South. It was rather a proxy war between the U.S. and the Soviet and China. All three superpowers needed to win the Korean War to prove their ideologies and themselves as the true superpower. However, Korea was an unknown country to American public. The inscription of the Korean War Veterans' Memorial describes Korea as "a country they never knew and a people they never met." Moreover, the Korean War broke out shortly after World War II, so American people were rather reluctant about the idea of engaging in another war. Therefore, U.S. government needed effective propaganda to draw more support from their people and to win the 'ambivalent, yet important war.'The role of the media was a crucial factor in the government's propaganda efforts. The Korean War was a transitional period between World War II and the Vietnam War, and the media's attitude changed greatly during that period. Strong anti-Communist sentiment was prevalent in America and the government enacted several laws to strictly prohibit the media from reporting anything that might be harmful to U.S. On the other hand, the Vietnam War was just the opposite of World War II. After the 'Pentagon Papers Revelation' and the 'Watergate Scandal,' the media became highly skeptical of the government activities. In addition, since the Vietnam War was a guerilla war, there was no set defense line which allowed the reporters to witness firsthand the cruelty of the war. With the increasing number of TV sets in each homes, American public was exposed to the gruesome images of the war. Situated in this transitional period of the changing media attitude, this paper examines the U.S. popular magazines during the period of the Korean War. If the Vietnam War was a 'television war,' the Korean War was a 'magazine war,' and American public was largely influenced by the magazines. After carefully studying the images of Koreans in U.S. magazines, this paper came to following conclusions: Firstly, among the Koreans' images, Korean soldiers were almost absent, and even when they made appearances, they were limited as either off-focused or background. Secondly, Korean men's images were almost absent, and most of the images were those of women or children. Thirdly, the stories of American soldiers who saved suffering Korea orphans or children were repeated. Lastly, U.S. was depicted as the 'good and kind,' while demonizing the Soviet Union and China. Aforementioned results are related to the circumstances of the time. First of all, the absence of men's images is due to the fact that they were taken during the war when most of the young men were drafted into the military. Moreover, since South Korea's defense capability of that time was rather meager because of the long history of Japanese Occupation, South Korean role in the Korean War was limited to assisting position to the U.S. On the other hand, the repeated images of Korean children and orphans saved by U.S. soldiers were the result of the Cold War rhetoric and the U.S.'s need to gain support from its people. By demonizing the Soviet and North Korea as evil forces that hurt small children, U.S. could depict themselves as the good force who cured and rescued them. Moreover, that kind of rhetoric earned sympathy from its people.

참고문헌 (19)

  1. 김상미, "시각이미지로 재현된 한국전쟁 : 한국전쟁기 시각 이미지와 전후세대의 회화작품을 중심으로", 석사, 미술사, pp.2007
  2. 황인성, "텔레비전의 미,이라크 전쟁 보도와 미국식 오리엔탈리즘: KBS 텔레비전 뉴스 사례를 중심으로", 한국언론학보, 48(3), pp.144~167 (2004), 한국언론학회
  3. Berinsky, Adam, "In Time of War: Understanding American Public Opinion from World War II toIraq" (2009), The University of Chicago Press
  4. Cumings, Bruce, "Child of Conflict : the Korean-American Relationship, 1943-1953, In Child of Conflict : the Korean-American Relationship, 1943-1953" (1983), University of Washington Press
  5. Horrell, M., "Reportingthe" Forgotten War ": Military-Press Relations in Korea, 1950-1954", 박사, pp.2002
  6. Kerin, J, "The Korean War and American Memory", 박사, pp.1994
  7. Kim, J, "Press and Military in Korea:An Attitudinal Study", 박사, pp.1995
  8. Kim, M. J, "Coverage of the Korean War by the "New York Times" and "Asahi Simbun": Foreign Policy as the Key Constraint on the War Reporting", 박사, pp.1991
  9. Klein, Christina, "Cold War Orientalism:Asia in the Middlebrow Imagination, 1945-1961" (2003), University of California Press
  10. Koner, M, "Korea’s Children: The Old in Hear", Colliers, 132, pp.24~27 (1953)
  11. Lederer, W. J, "Operation Kid-Life", Ladies’ Home Journal, 69, pp.48~49 (1952)
  12. Michener, J. A, "Way It Is in Korea", Reader’s Digest, 62, pp.15~20 (1953)
  13. Mosier, R. H, "GI and the Kids of Korea", National Geographic, 103, pp.635~664 (1953)
  14. Mosier, R. H., ""New Treatments for Frostbite Save Limbs of Korean Casualties", Life, 30, pp.82~84 (1951)
  15. Steinbeck, John, "Once There Was a War" (1958), Penguin Books
  16. "The Sedition Act of 1918", Pbs.com, 2007. Web. 24 Oct. 2010, ~ (2007)
  17. Rougier, M, "Little Boy Who Wouldn’t Smile", Life, 31, pp.91~94 (1951)
  18. Rusk, H, "Voicefrom Korea : Won’t You Help Us Off Our Knees?", Life, 36, pp.178~182 (1954)
  19. "We Head for Another Perimeter", Life, 30, pp.17~23 (1951)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (8건)