Conflicting Images and Lost Perspectives: Narratives on the Korean War in American Textbooks
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper delineates the way in which the history of the Korean War is told in the received American history textbooks. In doing this, I compare descriptions of the Korean War in American textbooks with those in Chinese and Korean textbooks. I anticipate a contrast in the ways each textbook perceives the Korean War. At the same time, I focus on the relationship between the content and the most recent academic research on the Korean War, because the two are not always the same. What I find is that the narratives in American textbooks, like in Chinese textbooks, tend to characterize one’s posture as defensive and innocent and identify the other’s ambition as the prime source of disorder and war in Korea. These defender-aggressor mirror images help them to view their own involvement in the Korean War as a morally rational decision. The topic of the U.S.’s failure to appreciate indigenous Korean national needs and alliance with colonial powers is largely ignored. While atrocities in the Vietnam War committed by the U.S. are being taught in the U.S. classroom, those in the Korean War are not mentioned at all. Because textbooks are one of the crucial semiotic codes to construct society, we should allow multiple perspectives to understand historical events and encourage citizens to think about historical events critically. American symbolic code should be sustained and revised according to her value: democracy.
Abstract
This paper delineates the way in which the history of the Korean War is told in the received American history textbooks. In doing this, I compare descriptions of the Korean War in American textbooks with those in Chinese and Korean textbooks. I anticipate a contrast in the ways each textbook perceives the Korean War. At the same time, I focus on the relationship between the content and the most recent academic research on the Korean War, because the two are not always the same. What I find is that the narratives in American textbooks, like in Chinese textbooks, tend to characterize one’s posture as defensive and innocent and identify the other’s ambition as the prime source of disorder and war in Korea. These defender-aggressor mirror images help them to view their own involvement in the Korean War as a morally rational decision. The topic of the U.S.’s failure to appreciate indigenous Korean national needs and alliance with colonial powers is largely ignored. While atrocities in the Vietnam War committed by the U.S. are being taught in the U.S. classroom, those in the Korean War are not mentioned at all. Because textbooks are one of the crucial semiotic codes to construct society, we should allow multiple perspectives to understand historical events and encourage citizens to think about historical events critically. American symbolic code should be sustained and revised according to her value: democracy.
참고문헌 (18)
- Beck, Roger B., "World History: Pattern of Interaction" (2007), McDougal Littell
- Bourdieu, Pierre, "Logic of Practice" (1990), Stanford University Press
- Bulliet, Richard W., "The Earth and Its Peoples: A Global History" (2005), Houghton Mifflin Company
- Cayton, Andrew, "America: Pathways to the Present", pp.2003, Pearson
- Ellis, Elisabeth Gaynor, "World History: Connection to Today", pp.2003, Pearson
- Gilman, Nils, "Mandarins of the Future: Modernization Theory in Cold War America" (2003), Johns Hopkins University Press
- Gittings, John, "US and S. Korea accused of war atrocities: Inquiry uncovers secret of series of attacks by South on North. The Guardian (UK), January 18", ~ (2000)
- Han, Cheolho, "Hanguk geunhyeondaesa (Modern and Contemporary Korean History)" (2007), Daehan kyonkwanseo
- Kim, Hanjong, "Hanguk geunhyeondaesa (Modern and Contemporary Korean History)" (2007), Geumseong Publishing Company
- Kim, Heungsu, "Hanguk geunhyeondaesa (Modern and Contemporary Korean History)" (2002), Chunjae Education
- Kim, Kwangnam, "Hanguk geunhyeondaesa. (Modern and Contemporary Korean History)" (2007), Dusan
- Lakoff, George, "Philosophy in the Flesh" (1999), Basic Books
- Mead, George Herbert, "Mind, Self, and Society" (1934), University of Chicago Press
- Park, Taegyun, "Hanguk jeonjaeng (The Korean War)" (2006), Chaekgwa hamkke
- Renmin jiaoyu chupanshe (People’s Education Press), "Zhongguo jindai xiandaishi (History of Modern and Contemporary China)" (2003), Renmin jiaoyu chupanshe
- Renmin jiaoyu chupanshe (People’s Education Press), "Lishi (History)" (2005), Renmin jiaoyu chupanshe
- Spielvogel, Jackson J., "World History: Modern Times", pp.2008, McGraw-Hill
- Whitehead, Alfred North, "Symbolism: Its Meaning and Effect" (1985), Fordham University Press