복지국가에서의 사회정의, 분배정의에 대한 재검토
Social Justice and Distributional Justice in Welfare State: A Re-examination
0
조회
0
다운로드
4
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper attempts to re-examine the relationship between welfare state and social justice, focusing on the implications and limits of ‘distributional justice’. As a result of this review, I would like to argue as follows. First, it is possible to define social justice in welfare state which has universalistic character, although it has relativistic character with the changes of time. Second, the contents of social justice in modern welfare state are not systematic and concrete in comparison with other political ideas, such as constitutional monarchy, liberal democracy, socialism. Third, the definition of social justice in welfare state as distributional justice(for example Rawls) turns a blind eye to the basic structure of capitalist society, although it can have temporary importance from the strategical point of view. It has limits to the theoretical, practical contributions which lead to reduce the gap between classes especially in quality. Forth, if social justice in welfare state aims more freedom and equality without alienation, its ultimate orientation should be over the capitalist relations of production.
Abstract
This paper attempts to re-examine the relationship between welfare state and social justice, focusing on the implications and limits of ‘distributional justice’. As a result of this review, I would like to argue as follows. First, it is possible to define social justice in welfare state which has universalistic character, although it has relativistic character with the changes of time. Second, the contents of social justice in modern welfare state are not systematic and concrete in comparison with other political ideas, such as constitutional monarchy, liberal democracy, socialism. Third, the definition of social justice in welfare state as distributional justice(for example Rawls) turns a blind eye to the basic structure of capitalist society, although it can have temporary importance from the strategical point of view. It has limits to the theoretical, practical contributions which lead to reduce the gap between classes especially in quality. Forth, if social justice in welfare state aims more freedom and equality without alienation, its ultimate orientation should be over the capitalist relations of production.
참고문헌 (34)
- 김기덕, "롤즈의 정의론에 관한 철학적 고찰: 윤리적 측면과 인식론적 측면을 중심으로", 사회복지연구, (26), pp.67~90 (2005), 한국사회복지연구회
- 남현주, "사회정의연구의 두 영역: 규범적 영역과 경험적 영역", 사회보장연구, 23(2), pp.135~159 (2007), 한국사회보장학회
- 로버트 노직, "아나키에서 유토피아로 - 자유주의 국가의 철학적 기초" (2005), 문학과 지성사
- 마이클 샌델, "정의란 무엇인가" (2010), 김영사
- 설헌영, "분배정의와 마르크스주의", 철학, 33, pp.49~77 (1990), 한국철학회
- 시오노 야유이치, "경제와 윤리 - 복지국가의 철학" (2006), 필맥
- 윤도현, "복지국가내의 계급관계", 경제와 사회, 통권 : 20, pp.253~282 (1993), 비판사회학회
- 윤도현, "사회복지사를 위한 철학과 정치사회사상" (2011), 꽃동네대학교출판부
- 윤도현, "계급이여 안녕? -선진자본주의 사회의 계급과 복지국가" (2000), 한울
- 윤성석, "자유, 권리, 사회정의 : 롤즈와 비판가들, In 사회정의와 사회발전", pp.60~88 (2000), 전남대학교 지역개발연구소
- 장동진, "자유주의, In 정치학 이해의 길잡이 -정치사상", pp.206~260 (2008), 법문사
- 정승교, "롤즈와 마르크스의 정의론에 관한 비교분석", 국민윤리연구, (28), pp.169~184 (1989)
- 존 롤즈, "정의론" (2006), 이학사
- 플라톤, "국가론" (2006), 돋을새김
- Cohen. G., "Back to Socialist Basics", New Left Review, 207, pp.3~16 (1994)
- Cohen. G., "If You're an Egalitarian, How Come You're So Rich?" (2000), Harvard University Press
- Daly. J., "Marx and Justice", International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 8(3), pp.351~370 (2000)
- Dolgoff. R., "What does social welfare produce?", International Social Work, 42(3), pp.295~307 (1999)
- Herkommer u. a., "Alltag, Bewusstsein, Klassen. VSA" (1984), Hamburg
- Jürgen. K., "Das Reflexionsdefizit des Wohlfahrtsstaates, In Wohlfahrtsstaatliche Grundbegriffe. Historische und Aktuelle Diskurse", pp.2003, Frankfurt a
- Kersting, W., "Politische Philosophie des Sozialstaats" (2000), Velbrück Wissenschaft
- Kersting. W., "Die Selbstverewigung des egalitaristischen Sozialstaats, In Wohlfahrtsstaatliche Grundbegriffe. Historische und aktuelle Diskurse", pp.105~135 (2003), Campus Verlag
- Kersting. W., "Einleitung, Probleme der politischen Philosophie des Sozialstaats, In Politische Philosophie des Sozialstaats", pp.11~92 (2000), Weilerwist
- Lessenich, S., "Wohlfahrtsstaatliche Grundbegriffe. Historische und aktuelle Diskurse" (2003), Campus Verlag
- MacIntyre. A., "After Virtue. Druckworth" (1981), Marx-Engels-Werke
- Mishra. R., "The Welfare State in Crisis: Social Thought and Social Change" (1984), St. Martin's Press
- Nida-Ruemelin. J., "Die Ethischen Grundlagen des Sozialstaats, In Politische Philosophie des Sozialstaats", pp.333~350 (2000), Velbrück Wissenschaft
- Österle. A., "Evaluating Equity in Social Policy - A Framework for Comparative Analysis", Evaluation, 8(1), pp.46~59 (2002)
- Peter. K., "Soziale Gerechtigkeit, Wirtschaftsordnung und Sozialstaat, In Politische Philosophie des Sozialstaats", pp.120~158 (2000), Velbrück Wissenschaft
- Plant. R., "Political Philosophy and Social Welfare. -Essays on the Normative Basis of Welfare Provision" (1980), Routledge & Kegan Paul
- Roberts. P., "An Introduction to Political Thought - Key Concepts and Thinkers" (2004), New York University Press
- Sandkühler. H. J., "Europäische Enzyklopädie zu Philosophie und Wissenschaften, 4 Bände" (1990), Hamburg
- Schefczyk. M., "Effizienz und Gerechtigkeit - eine Verhältnisbestimmung in sozialpolitischer Absicht, In Politische Philosophie des Sozialstaats", pp.428~466 (2000), Velbrück Wissenschaft
- Zintl. R., "Die Libertäre Sozialstaatskritik bei von Hayek, Buchanan und Nozick, In Politische Philosophie des Sozialstaats", pp.95~119 (2000), Velbrück Wissenschaft