Modeling the Role of Culture in Policy Transfer: A Dynamic Policy Transfer Model
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Anticorruption policy transfer has been discussed for decades, but the influence of culture in target countries has not received comparable attention sufficient to explain the lack of progress in reducing corruption in those countries. The conceptualization of culture so far has provided only a limited tool for developing a dynamic theory of policy transfer. We propose a bottomup model of dynamic policy transfer that takes into account the cultural context in target countries. We first define culture as a set of values that are consistent with each other but that also conflict. We then develop a dynamic policy transfer model that revises the traditional model by considering the proposed concept of culture. Finally, we discuss the practical implications of the model, emphasizing the importance of knowledge of culture at the local level, where a bottom-up implementation of anticorruption policy takes place. We conclude by suggesting strategies for empirical research and specific implications regarding the Korean policy context.
Abstract
Anticorruption policy transfer has been discussed for decades, but the influence of culture in target countries has not received comparable attention sufficient to explain the lack of progress in reducing corruption in those countries. The conceptualization of culture so far has provided only a limited tool for developing a dynamic theory of policy transfer. We propose a bottomup model of dynamic policy transfer that takes into account the cultural context in target countries. We first define culture as a set of values that are consistent with each other but that also conflict. We then develop a dynamic policy transfer model that revises the traditional model by considering the proposed concept of culture. Finally, we discuss the practical implications of the model, emphasizing the importance of knowledge of culture at the local level, where a bottom-up implementation of anticorruption policy takes place. We conclude by suggesting strategies for empirical research and specific implications regarding the Korean policy context.
참고문헌 (31)
- d, G, "Comparative political systems", Journal of Politics, 18(3), pp.391~409 (1956)
- Almond, G, "The civic culture: Political attitudes and democracy in five nations" (1963), Princeton University Press
- Benson, D, "What have we learned from policy transfer research? Dolowitz and Marsh revisited", Political Studies Review, 9(3), pp.366~378 (2011)
- Berkowitz, D, "The transplant effect", American Journal of Comparative Law, 51(1), pp.163~203 (2003)
- 부형욱, "Korea’s Experience with NPM-Based Reform: Applying the Policy Fashion Concept", Journal of Policy Studies, 25(1), pp.19~33 (2010), 서울대학교행정대학원
- Cameron, K. S, "Diagnosing and changing organizational culture:Based on the competing values framework" (2011), John Wiley
- "Antigraft law stirs up wariness over South Koreans bearing gifts" (2016)[URL]
- Common, R, "The new public management and policy transfer: The role of international institutions", Paper presented at the Public Sector Management for the Next Century Conference (1997), Paper presented at the Public Sector Management for the Next Century Conference, University of Manchester
- Dalton, M. D, "Corruption in cultural context: Contradictions within the Korean tradition", Crime, Law, and Social Change, 43(4-5), pp.237~262 (2005)
- de Graaf, G, "Portraying the nature of corruption using an explorative case study design", Public Administration Review, 68(4), pp.640~653 (2008)
- de Sousa, L, "Anti-corruption agencies: Between empowerment and irrelevance", Crime Law, and Social Change, 53(1), pp.5~22 (2010)
- Diamant, A, "The relevance of comparative politics to the study of comparative administration", Administrative Science Quarterly, 5(1), pp.87~112 (1960)
- Dolowitz, D, "International public policy and management: Policy learning beyond regional, cultural, and political boundaries", pp.25~44 (2004), Marcel Dekker
- Dolowitz, D, "Policy transfer and British social policy" (2000), Open University Press
- Evans, M, "Policy transfer in critical perspective", Policy Studies, 30(3), pp.243~268 (2009)
- Geertz, C, "The interpretation of culture" (1973), Basic Books
- "uth Korea cracks down on bribery of teachers" (2009)[URL]
- Häusermann, S, "International public policy and management:Policy learning beyond regional, cultural, and political boundaries", pp.121~154 (2004), Marcel Dekker
- "Culture: What is culture" (2012)[URL]
- Howlett, M, "The dependent variable problem in the study of policy change: Understanding policy change as a methodological problem", Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, 11(1), pp.33~46 (2009)
- 허태욱, "Analyzing the Configuration of Knowledge Transfer of the Green Island Projects in S. Korea", Journal of Policy Studies, 32(1), pp.1~26 (2017), 서울대학교행정대학원
- Hwang, D, "Confucian culture and whistle-blowing by professional accountants: An exploratory study", Managerial Auditing Journal, 23(5), pp.504~526 (2008)
- Jreisat, J. E, "Politics without process: Administering development in the Arab world" (1997), Lynne Rienner
- Kamrava, M, "Cultural politics in the third world" (1999), UCL Press
- Kim, C, "Public administration in the age of globalization", International Public Management Review, 9(1), pp.39~55 (2008)
- Kingdon, J, "Agendas, alternatives, and public policies" (2011), Pearson
- Korean National Assembly, "Public hearing", National Assembly Document # PAMP1000019005, ~ (2006)
- Lambsdorff, J, "Corruption, Global Security, and World Order", pp.389~415 (2009), Harvard Kennedy School and the Brookings Institution Press
- "Teachers receiving over 30,000 won to be disciplined" (2011)[URL]
- Legrand, T, "Elite, exclusive and elusive : Transgovernmental policy networks and iterative policy transfer in the Anglosphere", Policy Studies, 37(5), pp.440~455 (2016)
- Leiken, R. S, "Controlling the global corruption epidemic", Foreign Policy, 105, pp.55~73 (1996)