본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

난임 환자 미술치료의 체계적 문헌고찰

Systematic Review of Art Therapy for Infertile Patients

최한|도현정|오혜록
한국미술치료학회 (Korean Art Therapy Association)|2021.08|미술치료연구 (Korean Journal of Art Therapy)|제28권 제4호|pp. 965-985|DOI 10.35594/kata.2021.28.4.005

0

조회

0

다운로드

4

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

체계적 문헌고찰Systematic Review미술치료Art therapy난임Infertility난임 환자MINORSInfertile patients
주제분류심리과학

초록

본 연구는 1996년부터 2020년까지 국내외 난임 환자를 대상으로 미술치료 문헌의 체계적 문헌고찰을 시행하였다. 국내외 9개의 학술검색원을 통해 총 4,108편의 관련된 문헌을 검색하고 선정기준에 적합한 3편의 문헌을 분석하였다. 연구의 편향 평가를 위해 문헌은 질 평가 도구 MINORS와 Cochrane Collaboration Risk of Bias(RoBANS) 도구를 이용해 사정하였다. 연구 결과, 미술치료 중재는 난임 여성의 우울감 감소에 유의미하였다. 이외도 부분적으로 집착적 사고 감소와 사회적 교류 욕구 상승의 유의미한 결과를 확인하였다. 한편, 문헌의 질을 평가한 결과 두 도구 모두에서 편향 위험이 높은 문헌으로 평가되었다. 이에 본 연구는 첫째, 난임 환자 미술치료에서 연구대상자 선정, 연구 설계, 연구 결과 보고 및 연구 윤리 측면에서 연구의 방향 및 과제를 제시하였다. 둘째, 미술 치료학에서의 체계적 문헌고찰 연구 방법을 정립하고 기초자료를 마련하는 데 의의가 있다.

Abstract

This study conducted a systematic review of art therapy literature for domestic and foreign infertile patients from 1996 to 2020. A total of 4,108 related documents were searched through 9 academic search centers at domestic and abroad, and 3 documents suitable for the selection criteria were analyzed. To evaluate the bias of the study, the study was assessed using the quality assessment tool MINORS and the Cochrane Collaboration Risk of Bias (RoBANS) tool. In the results of the study, art therapy intervention was significant in reducing depression in infertile women. In part, significant results were confirmed in the reduction of obsessional thinking and the increase in the desire for social exchange. Meanwhile, as a result of evaluating the quality of the literature, both tools were evaluated as having a high risk of bias. first, this suggested the direction and tasks of the study in terms of research subject selection, study design, reporting of research results, and research ethics in art therapy for infertile patients. Second, it was significant in preparing basic data by establishing a thorough systematic literature review research method in art therapy.

참고문헌 (78)

  1. 저출산 대책평가, 국회예산정책처 사업 평가국, 저출산 대책 기획평가, "국회예산정책처", 국회예산정책처, ~ (2016)
  2. 체계적 문헌고찰 및 임상진료지침 매뉴얼 개발, "김수영", 한국보건의료연구원, ~ (2011)
  3. 저출산 대응 재정지원 방안 연구 : 저출산특별회계를 중심으로, "김은정", 한국보건사회연구원, ~ (2020)
  4. 김현진, "30대 불임여성의 미술치료체험연구", 여성건강, 5(1), pp.227~242 (2004)
  5. "불임치료" (2021), 대한생식의학회[URL]
  6. 보건복지부, "2020년 난임부부시술비지원사업지침" (2020), 보건복지부
  8. "질병소분류통계" (2020), 보건의료빅데이터개방시스템[URL]
  9. 신우종, "Editorial: Why Perform Meta-Analysis?", Hanyang Medical Reviews, 35(1), pp.1~2 (2015), 한양대학교 의과대학[DOI]
  10. 안형식, "체계적 고찰 연구의 개요", 대한의사협회지, 57(1), pp.49~59 (2014), 대한의사협회[DOI]
  11. 이가영, "미술치료 매체로서 사진 활용에 관한 체계적 문헌고찰", 미술치료연구, 24(5), pp.1289~1307 (2017), 한국미술치료학회
  12. 이영선, "난임 상담 서비스 체계 구축을 위한 난임 상담 실태 및 요구도 조사", 한국모자보건학회지, 24(1), pp.52~63 (2020), 한국모자보건학회[DOI]
  13. 이혜연, "시험관 아기 시술을 시행하는 난임 여성의 미술치료 체험연구", 한국심리치료학회지, 11(1), pp.21~43 (2019), 한국심리치료학회
  14. 임주현, "집단미술치료가 난임 여성의 스트레스, 불안과 우울 감소에 미치는 영향", 미술치료연구, 22(3), pp.1009~1029 (2015), 한국미술치료학회
  15. 정여주, "심리적 재활에 있어서 미술치료법의이론 및 적응효과", 한국재활심리학회 학술대회자료집, pp.39~51 (1997)
  16. 정여주, "어린왕자 미술치료" (2015), 학지사
  17. 정인숙, "체계적 문헌고찰과 메타분석" (2011), 수문사
  18. "중앙난임․우울상담센터 1주년 기념 심포지엄 보도자료" (2019), 중앙난임․우울증상담센터[URL]
  19. 최한, "미술치료의 신의료기술평가를 위한 제반사항 및 단계별 전략", 미술치료연구, 26(6), pp.1009~1025 (2019), 한국미술치료학회
  20. "2019년 출생 통계" (2019), 통계청[URL]
  21. "2017년도 난임부부 지원사업 결과평가 및 저소득층 지원실태 분석" (2018), 황나미[URL]
  22. "난임 치료 확대 등 난임 지원을 위한 실태 및 제도 개선방안" (2019), 황나미[URL]
  23. Abbing, A., "The Effectiveness of Art Therapy for Anxiety in Adult Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial", Frontiers in Psychology, 10, pp.1203~ (2019)[DOI]
  24. "ICMART World Collaborative Reports for assisted reproductive technology(2016)" (2020)[URL]
  25. Andrus, M., "Exhibition and film about miscarriage, infertility, and stillbirth: Art therapy implications", Art Therapy, 37(4), pp.169~176 (2020)
  26. Baker, F. A., "A systematic review of the efficacy of creative arts therapies in the treatment of adults with PTSD", Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 10(6), pp.643~651 (2018)
  27. Bailey, R. K., "Racial and ethnic differences in depression: current perspectives", Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment, 15, pp.603~609 (2019)
  28. Beard, R. L., "Art therapies and dementia care: A systematic review", Dementia, 11(5), pp.633~656 (2012)
  29. Berman, N. G., "Metaanalysis : neither quick nor easy", BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2(1), pp.1~9 (2002)
  30. Boivin, J., "Emotional distress in infertile women and failure of assisted reproductive technologies: meta-analysis of prospective psychosocial studies", BMJ, pp.342~ (2011)
  31. Bowling, A., "Handbook of health research methods: investigation, measurement and analysis" (2005), McGraw-Hill Education
  32. Cheng, P., "Role of arts therapy in patients with breast and gynecological cancers: A systematic review and meta-Analysis", Journal of Palliative Medicine, 24(3), pp.443~452 (2021)
  33. Colling, J., "Designing Clinical Research", Urologic Nursing, 23(5), pp.357~360 (2003)
  34. Cohen-Yatziv, L., "The effectiveness and contribution of art therapy work with children in 2018-what progress has been made so far? A systematic review", International Journal of Art Therapy, 24(3), pp.100~112 (2019)
  35. Cousineau, T. M., "Psychological impact of infertility Best practice & research", Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 21(2), pp.293~308 (2007)
  36. Domar, A. D., "Impact of group psychological interventions on pregnancy rates in infertile women", Fertility and Sterility, 73(4), pp.805~811 (2000)
  37. Dunphy, K., "Creative arts interventions to address depression in older adults: A systematic review of outcomes, processes, and mechanisms", Frontiers in Psychology, 9, pp.2655~ (2019)[DOI]
  38. Faul, F., "G* Power 3 : A flexible statistical power analysis program for the social, behavioral, and biomedical sciences", Behavior Research Methods, 39(2), pp.175~191 (2007)
  39. Frederiksen, Y., "Efficacy of psychosocial interventions for psychological and pregnancy outcomes in infertile women and men: a systematic review and meta-analysis", BMJ Open, 5(1), pp.e006592~ (2015)[DOI]
  40. Fu, W., "The effect of art therapy in women with gynecologic cancer : A system atic review", Evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2020, pp.1~9 (2020)
  41. Gameiro, S., "ESHRE guideline : routine psychosocial care in infertility and medically assisted reproduction-a guide for fertility staff", Human Reproduction, 30(11), pp.2476~2485 (2015)
  42. Gaitzsch, H., "The effect of mind-body interventions on psychological and pregnancy outcomes in infertile women : A systematic review", Archives of Women's Mental Health, 23(4), pp.479~491 (2020)
  43. Garris, S., "Examining the efficacy of group art therapy for children who have experienced trauma histories: A systematic review", Master, pp.2020
  44. Golshani, F., "The effect of cognitive behavioral therapy on anxiety and depression in Iranian infertile women:A systematic and meta-analytical review", Iranian Journal of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, 14(1), pp.e96715~ (2020)[DOI]
  45. Hämmerli, K., "The efficacy of psychological interventions for infertile patients : a meta-analysis examining mental health and pregnancy rate", Human Reproduction Update, 15(3), pp.279~295 (2009)
  46. Hinz, L. D., "Expressive therapies continuum:A framework for using art in therapy" (2012), Routledge
  47. Hughes, E. G., "Art therapy as a healing tool for sub-fertile women", Journal of Medical Humanities, 31(1), pp.27~36 (2010)
  48. Hughes, E. G., "A pilot study assessing art therapy as a mental health intervention for subfertile women", Human Reproduction, 26(3), pp.611~615 (2011)
  49. Hulley, S. B, "Designing clinical research" (2007), Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
  51. Jiang, X. H., "Effects of art therapy in cancer care: A systematic review and meta‐analysis", European Journal of Cancer Care, 29(5), pp.e13277~ (2020)[DOI]
  52. Kiani, Z., "Infertility’s hidden and evident dimensions : A concern requiring special attention in Iranian society", Iranian Journal of Public Health, 48(11), pp.2114~2115 (2019)
  53. Kramer, E., "Art as therapy: Collected papers" (2001), Jessica Kingsley Publishers
  54. Kumar, N., "Trends of male factor infertility, an important cause of infertility : A review of literature", Journal of Human Reproductive Sciences, 8(4), pp.191~196 (2015)
  55. Landgarten, H., "Family art psychotherapy: A clinical guide and casebook" (1987), Brunner
  56. Lang, D., "Effects of art therapy for family caregivers of cancer patients : a systematic review protocol", JBI Evidence Synthesis, 12(4), pp.374~394 (2014)
  57. Lemmens, G. M. D., "Coping with infertility : a body-mind group intervention programme for infertile couples", Human Reproduction, 19(8), pp.1917~1923 (2004)
  58. Lindsey, B., "The Psychology of Infertility", International Journal of Childbirth Education, 28(3), pp.41~47 (2013)
  59. Malchiodi, C. A, "미술치료입문" (2012), 학지사
  60. Malchiodi, C. A., "의료미술치료의 실제" (2012), 하나 의학사
  61. Maleki-Saghooni, N., "Effectiveness of infertility counseling on pregnancy rate in infertile patients undergoing assisted reproductive technologies : A systematic review and meta-analysis", International Journal of Reproductive BioMedicine, 15(7), pp.391~402 (2017)
  62. Matthiesen, S., "Stress, distress and outcome of assisted reproductive technology(ART) : A meta-analysis", Human reproduction, 26(10), pp.2763~2776 (2011)
  63. Mousavi, S. A., "Assessment of questionnaires measuring quality of life in infertile couples : a systematic review", Journal of Reproduction and Infertility, 14(3), pp.110~119 (2013)
  64. Murphy, E. M., "Randomized trial of harp therapy during in vitro fertilization–embryo transfer", Journal of Evidence-based Complementary & Alternative Medicine, 19(2), pp.93~98 (2014)
  65. Newman, T. B., "Designing clinical research", pp.171~191 (2001), Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
  66. Newton, C. R., "Psychological assessment and follow-up after in vitro fertilization : assessing the impact of failure", Fertility and Sterility, 54(5), pp.879~886 (1990)
  67. Oxman, A. D., "The science of reviewing research a", Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 703(1), pp.125~134 (1993)
  68. Pasch, L. A., "Psychological distress and in vitro fertilization outcome", Fertility and Sterility, 98(2), pp.459~464 (2012)
  69. Salomon, J. A., "Common values in assessing health outcomes from disease and injury : disability weights measurement study for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010", The Lancet, 380(9859), pp.2129~2143 (2012)
  70. Samadi, H., "The effect of theater therapy on general health of infertile women", Medical Journal of Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, 62, pp.160~168 (2019)
  71. Sarrel, P. M., "Psychotherapeutic intervention for treatment of couples with secondary infertility", Fertility and Sterility, 43(6), pp.897~900 (1985)
  72. Schmidt, L., "Evaluation of a communication and stress management training programme for infertile couples", Patient Education and Counseling, 59(3), pp.252~262 (2005)
  73. Slim, K., "Methodological index for non-randomized studies(minors) : development and validation of a new instrument", ANZ Journal of Surgery, 73(9), pp.712~716 (2003)
  74. Streeter, K., "Art therapy with women with infertility : A mixedmethods multiple case study", Art Therapy, 35(2), pp.60~67 (2018)
  75. Tang, Y., "Art therapy for anxiety, depression, and fatigue in females with breast cancer : A systematic review", Journal of Psychosocial Oncology, 37(1), pp.79~95 (2019)
  76. "세계보건기구(국제질병분류)" (2020)[URL]
  77. Wood, M. J., "What research evidence is there for the use of art therapy in the management of symptoms in adults with cancer? A systematic review", Psycho-Oncology, 20(2), pp.135~145 (2011)
  78. Ying, L., "The effects of psychosocial interventions on the mental health, pregnancy rates, and marital function of infertile couples undergoing in vitro fertilization: A systematic review", Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, 33(6), pp.689~701 (2016)

관련 논문AI추천

집단미술치료가 난임 여성의 스트레스, 불안과 우울 감소에 미치는 영향김태완, 임주현한국미술치료학회 · 미술치료연구2015 · 제22권 제3호국내외 마음챙김 기반 미술치료에 관한 체계적 문헌고찰모소현, 박인혜, 좌유선(사)한국예술치료학회 · 한국예술치료학회지2021 · 제21권 제2호외상 후 스트레스 장애(PTSD)에 대한 국내외 미술치료 연구의 체계적 문헌고찰김재훈, 신난설한국미술치료학회 · 미술치료연구2025 · 제32권 제5호다문화 아동․청소년 미술치료 연구의 체계적 문헌고찰최한, 이호정한국미술치료학회 · 미술치료연구2022 · 제29권 제3호여성 우울 관련 집단미술치료의 효과에 대한 체계적 분석과 메타분석이근매, 황문숙사)한국아동발달지원연구소 · 임상미술심리연구2022 · 제12권 제3호시험관 아기 시술을 시행하는 난임 여성의 미술치료 체험연구이혜연, 장연집한국심리치료학회 · 한국심리치료학회지2019 · 제11권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (6건)

암 환자 대상 미술치료 연구동향 분석모소현, 정여주pp. 883-904유아의 사회성을 위한 ETC를 활용한 집단미술치료 사례연구최은아, 전순영pp. 905-926유아의 색채선호 경향과 색채선호에 따른 정서지능, 창의성의 차이 연구이수진, 박정희pp. 927-945아동의 공격성 예측 도구로서의 손검사기정희pp. 947-964미술치료사의 반응작업을 활용한 농인(聾人) 성인여성의 미술치료경험에 대한 내러티브 탐구김갑숙, 백숙희pp. 987-1014
원문 보기