고대영시 두운과 변어 사이의 상관관계에 관한 고찰
A Study on the Correlation between Alliteration and Variation in Old English Poetry
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
With regard to the art of composition in Beowulf and other Old English poems scholars generally agree that the art of improvisation is firmly grounded upon the poet's control of traditional components. I believe that the composition of Old English Poetry was much influenced by the techniques of oral literature, but I contest the supposition that Old English Poetry was purely based on oral tradition. Instead, I believe that Old English Poetry from the outset bears specific features of written literature as has been proven in Old English poems. One of the common features in oral composition is the use of pleonasm, which is called variation or apposition in Old English scholarship; a word or expression is repeated, not identically, and each repetition adds a new attributes or quality to the concept. His technique is conspicuous in the combination of alliteration and words containing key meanings in the line. As is shown in the lines of Old English poems key words or words containing major meanings of the line alliterate each other. This again proves that the choice and arrangement of words are not constructed in accordance with oral tradition. It is quite certain that the use of alliteration is not coincidental but exquisitely devised by the poet who intends to heighten the focal meanings. This also proves that the poet is very much constrained in the course of choosing a specific word agreeing with alliteration among lots of variations or synonyms. In general Old English poetry follows this pattern of pleonasm but contains more complicated and various patterns than oral style. The delicate combination of features of inwardness and outwardness proves that the poet is well aware of the oral tradition. However, the fact that words match with the application of alliteration shows that the poet's techniques of composition exceed the scope of oral tradition.
Abstract
With regard to the art of composition in Beowulf and other Old English poems scholars generally agree that the art of improvisation is firmly grounded upon the poet's control of traditional components. I believe that the composition of Old English Poetry was much influenced by the techniques of oral literature, but I contest the supposition that Old English Poetry was purely based on oral tradition. Instead, I believe that Old English Poetry from the outset bears specific features of written literature as has been proven in Old English poems. One of the common features in oral composition is the use of pleonasm, which is called variation or apposition in Old English scholarship; a word or expression is repeated, not identically, and each repetition adds a new attributes or quality to the concept. His technique is conspicuous in the combination of alliteration and words containing key meanings in the line. As is shown in the lines of Old English poems key words or words containing major meanings of the line alliterate each other. This again proves that the choice and arrangement of words are not constructed in accordance with oral tradition. It is quite certain that the use of alliteration is not coincidental but exquisitely devised by the poet who intends to heighten the focal meanings. This also proves that the poet is very much constrained in the course of choosing a specific word agreeing with alliteration among lots of variations or synonyms. In general Old English poetry follows this pattern of pleonasm but contains more complicated and various patterns than oral style. The delicate combination of features of inwardness and outwardness proves that the poet is well aware of the oral tradition. However, the fact that words match with the application of alliteration shows that the poet's techniques of composition exceed the scope of oral tradition.
참고문헌 (25)
- Blackburn, F. A, "The Christian Coloring of Beowulf", PMLA, 12, pp.205~225 (1887)
- Bosworth, Joseph, "An Anglo-Saxon Dictionary" (1882), Oxford UP
- Brodeur, Arthur G, "The Art of Beowulf" (1971), U of California P
- Carey, John, "On Christian Doctrine: Complete Prose Works of John Milton" (1973), Yale UP
- Chadwick, H. Munro, "The Heroic Age", pp.22~47 (1912), Cambridge UP
- Isidore of Seville, "Etymologiae" (1911), Oxford UP
- Kendall, Calvin B, "The Metrical Grammar of Beowulf" (1991), Cambridge UP
- Kendall, Calvin B, "Libri ll De arte metrica et De Schematibus et Tropis: The Art of Poetry and Rhetoric" (1975), Liverpool UP
- Klaeber, Fr, "Beowulf and the Fight at Finnsburg" (1950), Heath
- Klaeber, Fr, "Studies in the Textual Interpretation of Beowulf", Modern Philology, 3, pp.235~265 (1905)
- Lord, Albert B, "The Singer of Tales" (1960), Harvard UP
- Magoun, Jr, "Oral-formulaic Character of Anglo-Saxon Narrative Poetry", Speculum, 28, pp.446~467 (1953)
- Miller, Thomas, "The Old English Version of Bede’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People IV. 24", pp.95~, EETS
- Porter, John, "Beowulf" (1993), Anglo Saxon Books
- Robinson, Fred. C, "Beowulf and the Appositive Style" (1987), The U of Tennessee P
- Robinson, Fred. C., "Essays on Style", pp.124~150 (1979), U of California P
- Rousseau, Phillip, "Basil of Caesarea" (1994), U of California P
- Scragg, D. G, "The Battle of Maldon" (1981), Manchester UP
- Shippey, T. A, "Old English Verse" (1978), Hutchinson University Library
- Smith, A. H, "Three Northumbrian Poems" (1933), George Allen & Unwin
- Stenton, F. M, "Anglo-Saxon England" (1947), Oxford UP
- Swanton, M. J, "Crisis and Developent in Germanic Society 700-800" (1982), Kummerle Verlag
- "The New International Version(NIV) Study Bible" (1984), Hodder & Stoughton
- Whitelock, Dorothy, "The Audience of Beowulf" (1951), Clarendon
- Wrenn, C. L, "The Poetry of Caedmon" (1947), Harrap
