中国大陆和台湾学者的退溪视角－以张立文与李明辉、林月惠的四七考察为例－
Chinese and Taiwanese Scholars’ Perspectives on Toegye: In the Case of Interpretations on the Four-Seven Debate of Zhang Liwen, Li Minghui and Lin Yuehui
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
随着中韩关系的发展和学术交流的加深, 中国不仅涌现了多位退溪学者, 也诞生了多本退溪学专著、优质的研究课题、计划和退溪论文｡ 本文首先简单介绍两岸的退溪学研究概况和特征,接着以大陆学者张立文和台湾学者李明辉、林月惠对四端七情的考察为例, 比较两岸代表学者在退溪理气论、心性论认识上的异同,并指出产生差异的最根本的原因是对朱学的理解不同｡ 最后, 试图从修养论方面探析退溪理发说的现实意图,为退溪理发说提供一个整合性的视角｡
Abstract
Following the improved relation and academic exchange between China and Korea, there is not only a rise in the number of Toegye scholars, but also an increase of professional books, research tasks and plans, and theoretical papers on Toegye in China. This paper first briefly introduces the general trend and characteristics of Toegye researches in China and Taiwan. And based on three interpretations on the Four-Seven debate made by prominent Chinese and Taiwanese scholars-Zhang Liwen (Chinese), and Li Minghui, Lin Yuehui (Taiwanese)-, the comparison among three scholars’ understanding on Toegye’s Li (理)-Ki (氣) theory and Heart-mind (心)-Nature (性) theory will follow. Then, the analysis showing the fundamental reason they see Toegye differently will be made that it is due to their contrastive understandings on Zhu Xi. Last but not least, I would like to give a consistent interpretation of Toegye’s explanation on the manifestation of li (理发) by focusing on the practical implication presented in his self-cultivation theory.
참고문헌 (33)
- "退溪集", 韩国古典翻译院
- "两先生四七理气往复书", 韩国古典翻译院
- "退溪先生年表月日条录" (2006), 退溪学研究院
- 张立文, "退溪书节要" (1989), 中国人民大学出版社
- 张立文, "朱熹与退溪思想比较研究" (1995), 文津出版社
- 张立文, "李退溪思想研究" (1997), 东方出版社
- 张立文, "李退溪思想世界" (2013), 人民出版社
- 周月琴, "退溪哲学研究" (1997), 杭州出版社
- 李甦平, "韩国儒学史" (2009), 人民出版社
- 王甦, "退溪学论集" (1992), 文史哲出版社
- 李明辉, "四端与七情——关于道德情感的比较哲学探讨" (2008), 华东师范大学出版社
- 林月惠, "异曲同调——朱子学与朝鲜性理学" (2010), 国立台湾大学出版中心
- 尹丝淳, "韩国儒学研究" (1998), 新华出版社
- 安炳周, "退溪李滉的哲学思想" (2000), 国际退溪学会
- 高桥进, "李退溪和主敬哲学" (1991), 延边人民出版社
- 陈来, "朱子哲学研究" (2000), 华东师范大学出版社
- 陈来, "有无之境——王阳明哲学的精神" (2006), 北京大学出版社
- 牟宗三, "心体与性体" (2006), 正中书局
- 丁淳睦, "臺灣〮中國에서의 退溪學硏究", 韓國의 哲學, (19) (1991)
- 정원재, "「論四端七情第三書」의 재구성", 퇴계학보, (142), pp.163~210 (2017), 퇴계학연구원[DOI]
- 文锡胤, "退溪에서 理發과 理動,理到의 意味에 對하여-理의 能動性 問題", 退溪学报, (110) (2001)
- 임월혜, "臺灣李退溪研究的特點", 퇴계학논집, (21), pp.401~426 (2017), 영남퇴계학연구원
- 李明辉, "台湾学界关于韩国儒学的研究述评", 哲学动态, (12) (2009)
- 杨祖汉, "韩儒李退溪与奇高峰“四端七情”之论辩", 华冈文科学报, (26) (2003)
- 杨祖汉, "四端七情之辩与成德之教", 鹅湖学誌, (30) (2003)
- 채가화(蔡家和), "대만 학계의 한국유학 연구동향 및 평가", 퇴계학보, (143), pp.175~260 (2018), 퇴계학연구원[DOI]
- 陳繪宇, "韓國儒學在臺灣的硏究槪況(2010~2018)", 한국철학논집, (60), pp.131~163 (2019), 한국철학사연구회[DOI]
- 朱七星, "20세기 中國에서의 李退溪思想에 대한 연구 개황과 그 발전 추세", 퇴계학보, 112, pp.117~161 (2002), 퇴계학연구원
- 陈来, "退溪心学之再研究", 退溪学报, (70) (1991)
- 陈来, "略论朝鲜李朝儒学李滉与奇大升的性情理气之辩", 北京大学学报, (3) (1985)
- 陈来, "韩国朱子学新论——以李退溪与李栗谷的理发气发说为中心", 厦门大学学报, (1) (2015)
- 陈来, "论儒家的实践智慧", 中国哲学, (8) (2014)
- 손양, "朱熹和李滉对“理发”涵义的理解", 중국학연구, (49), pp.267~279 (2009), 중국학연구회