본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

전자게시판 토론 참여자의 토론 능력과 숙의적 토론과의 관계

Relationships between Participants' Argumentative Abilities and Deliberative Discussions in Electronic Bulletin Boards

0

조회

0

다운로드

17

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류신문방송학

초록

본 논문은 전자게시판 토론에 참석한 토론자의 논쟁능력이 그들의 숙의적 토론에 어떤 긍정적인 관계가 있는지를 연구했다. 대구와 서울에 위치한 3개 대학교에서 편이표본 수집방식을 통해 329명의 대학생을 모집한 후 종이 및 온라인 질문지 그리고 후기검증 비-실험연구를 통해 데이터를 수집했고, 상관관계와 회귀분석을 사용하여 가설을 검증했다. 연구결과 토론자의 논쟁능력은 그들의 숙의적 토론과 매우 높은 상관관계를 보였다. 토론과 향후 연구를 위한 제언은 마지막에 소개했다.

Abstract

This study investigates whether participants' argumentative abilities in electronic bulletin board discussions are positively associated with their deliberative discussions. 329 participants were recruited from three universities in either Daegu and Seoul by convenient sampling. Data were collected from paper and pencil and online questionnaires and quasi-experiments. Correlation and regression analyses were used to test hypotheses. The results shows that discussants' argumentative abilities were highly associated with their deliberative discussion. Discussions and suggestions for future research were presented at the end.

참고문헌 (62)

  1. "읽기의 재발견: 인터넷 토론 공간에서 커뮤니케이션의 효과", 50, pp.65~94 (2006)
  2. "인터넷 정치 토론의 담론적 특성", 51, pp.356~384 (2007)
  3. "숙의 민주주의와 시민성의 의미", 45, pp.162~194 (2000)
  4. "Toward a deliberative model of democratic legitimacy", pp.67~94 (1996), Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
  5. ". Measuring the developmental features of moral discussion. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly", pp.399~410 (1983)
  6. ". Chapter 11. The development of sociomoral discourse. In W. M. Kurtines . Studies in the phenomenology of emotions. Journal of Abnormal Social Psychology", pp.358~363
  7. "Public deliberation: Pluralism, complexity and democracy" (1996), Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
  8. ". Characteristics of arguments and arguing. Journal of the American Forensic Association", pp.129~132 (1977)
  9. "A conceptual definition and theoretical model of public deliberation in small face-to-face groups", 12, pp.398~422 (2002)
  10. ". Argument structures in decision-making groups. Southern Speech Communication Journal"
  11. "Deliberative democracy theory", 6, pp.307~326 (2003)
  12. ". Grounding in communication. In L. B. Resnick Perspectives on socially shared cognition", pp.127~149 (1991)
  13. "The deliberative potential of political discussion", 32, pp.21~62 (2002)
  14. "Public deliberation, discursive participation, and citizen engagement. A review of the empirical literature", 7, pp.315~344 (2004)
  15. "The First Amendment online: Santa Monica’s public electronic network", pp.125~151 (1998), New York, NY: Routledge
  16. "Face-to-face and computer-mediated communities, a comparative analysis", 15, pp.314~248 (1999)
  17. "Bringing deliberation to the democratic dialogue" (1999), Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
  18. "Is face-to-face citizen deliberation a luxury or a necessity?", 17, pp.357~361 (2000)
  19. "Adult civic education through the national issues forums: Developing democratic habits and dispositions through public deliberation", 54, pp.308~328 (2004)
  20. "Civic awakening in the jury room: A test of the connection between jury deliberation and political participation", 64, pp.585~595 (2002)
  21. "Increasing political sophistication through public deliberation", 16, pp.3~23 (1999)
  22. "The electronic discussion combined FtFC-CMC group and the search for political engagement" (1997), University of Southern California
  23. "Democracy and disagreement" (1996), Massachusetts, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
  24. "The theory of communication action. Reason and the rationalization of society", 1984, pp.1 (1981), ~[DOI]
  25. ". The structural transformation of the public sphere An inquiry into a category of bourgeois society" (1989), MIT Press.
  26. "t und Geltung ge zur diskurstheorie des rechts und des demokratischen rechtsstaats. 한상진ㆍ박영도 공역 사실성과 타당성 담론적 법이론과 민주주의적 법치국가 이론", 나남출판.
  27. ". A conceptualization and measure of argumentativeness. Journal of Personality Assessment", pp.72~80 (1986)
  28. "Contexts of uninhibited online behavior: Flaming in social newsgroups on Usenet", 49, pp.1135~1141 (1998)
  29. ". Social psychological aspects of computer-mediated communication. American Psychologist", pp.1123~1134 (1984)
  30. "News, talk, opinion, participation: The part played by conversation in deliberative democracy", 16, pp.361~385 (1999)
  31. "Tocquevile in cyberspace: Using the Internet for citizen associations", 15, pp.213~220 (1999)
  32. ". Construct differentiation and person-centered regulative messages. Journal of Language and Social Psychology", pp.1~27 (1991)
  33. "Understanding deliberation: The effects of discussion networks on participation in a public forum", 26, pp.743~774 (1999)
  34. "Alternative interactional accounts of group argument and influence. Communication Monographs", pp.112~132 (1989)
  35. "Argument in group decision making: Explicating a process model and investigating the argument-outcome link", 65, pp.261~281 (1998)
  36. "Defining and Measuring Deliberative Participation and Potential: A Theoretical Analysis and Operationalization" (2000)
  37. ". Two concepts of argument. Journal of the American Forensic Association", pp.121~128 (1977)
  38. "The public dialogue consortium’s school-wide dialogue process: A communication approach to develop citizenship skills and enhance school climate", 11, pp.105~123 (2001)
  39. "Moral conflict: When social worlds collide" (1997), Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage publications
  40. "Does disagreement contribute to more deliberative opinion?", 19, pp.95~112 (2002)
  41. "Normative and informational influences in online political discussions", 16, pp.47~74 (2006)
  42. "The practice of deliberative democracy: A study of 16 deliberative organizations", 19, pp.359~377 (2002)
  43. ". Group processes in computer-mediated communication. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes", pp.157~187 (1986)
  44. "Media framing and effective public deliberation", 17, pp.363~376 (2000)
  45. "Citizens' juries and deliberative democracy", 48, pp.51~65 (2000)
  46. ". The influence of task type group structure and extraversion on uninhibited speech in computer-mediated communication. Computers in Human Behavior", pp.261~272 (1990)
  47. ". Foundations of dialogical communication. The Quarterly Journal of Speech"
  48. ". Foundations of dialogical communication. The Quarterly Journal of Speech"
  49. "Effects of pictographs and quoting on flaming in electronic mail", 12, pp.225~243 (1996)
  50. "Developing an optimal match within online communities: An exploration of CMC support communities and traditional support", 51, pp.231~251 (2001)
  51. ". Speech acts in argumentative discussions A theoretical model for the analysis of discussions directed towards solving conflicts of opinions. Cinnaminson" (1984)
  52. "Fundamentals of argumentation theory: A handbook of historical backgrounds and contemporary developments" (1996), Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlabum
  53. "University of Alabama Press." (1993)
  54. "Managing disagreement: Rhetorical analysis within a dialectical framework", 37, pp.150~157 (2001)
  55. "The psychology of the Internet" (1999), New York, NY: The Cambridge University Press
  56. "Arguing in Internet chat rooms: Argumentative adaptations to chat room design and some consequences for public deliberation at a distance", 40, pp.23~38 (2003)
  57. "Net-surfers don’t ride alone" Virtual communities as communities" (1999), Philadelphia, PA: Westview
  58. "Does the Internet increase, decrease, or supplement social capital? Social networks, participation, and community commitment", 45, pp.436~455 (2001)
  59. ". Jurgen Habermas and dialectical argumentation. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Speech Communication Association" (1978)
  60. ". Perspectives on argument Dimension of argument Proceedings of the summer conference on argumentation", pp.112~133 (1980)
  61. "Democracy in the digital age" (2000), NY: Routledge
  62. "Jury deliberation: An observation study", 33, pp.547~557 (2000)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (3건)