본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

신자유주의시대, ‘조선 여성’을 기억하는 한 방식- 새로움과 전형성이 교차하는 <대장금> -

How “Chosŏn Women” are remembered in the Era of Neo-Liberalism: “Daejanggeum” as a cross road between old and new

1

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류학제간연구

초록

This study aims to review the discourses on the global consumption of ‘Daejanggeum,’ a Korean TV series, and explore the neo-liberal ‘needs’ that produces this attractive heroine. During the last 10 years, since the TV series was broadcast on MBC from September 2003 till March 2004, the people of South Korea and other nations have been infatuated with this female expert chef’s success story. Many South Korean scholars have praised this TV series as a case of overcoming the western mainstream popular culture. Some of them even found the possibility for a ‘female alternative narrative’ in the TV series. They argue that the subversive subjectivity of East Asian women can be found in the heroine of the TV series. Has this beautiful, self-cultivated heroine really achieved her own alternative woman’s life in the drama? Can we really find a possibility for a “subaltern subjectivity” through her?In this paper, I explore this question through discourse analysis, comparing ‘Daejanggeum’ story with prototype image of Korean traditional women in the modern society. In the collective memory of modern Korea, a “traditional Chosŏn woman” is basically the symbol of “suppression.” Since the 1970s, several books on ’Ijo YeoIn’ have been published and many ‘historical dramas’ were created. Through these literary and dramatic representations, the public memory of ‘traditional women’ has been invented. Thus invented public memory became the very basis on which the modern gender relationship was constructed. Daejanggeum’s story contains some “new” ideas about traditional women, but it does not go beyond a recursive representation of traditional women in the modern society. The “new ideas” are nothing much more than the factors reflecting the changes in women’s role in the world dominated by “neo-liberalism.” This paper is a critical review of the phenomenon of appropriating the images of traditional Korean women in the context of neo-liberalism. I argue that, despite of the seemingly new and alternative representation of a traditional woman, “Janggeum” does not deviate much from the old “typicality” of “Chosŏn Woman.”

Abstract

This study aims to review the discourses on the global consumption of ‘Daejanggeum,’ a Korean TV series, and explore the neo-liberal ‘needs’ that produces this attractive heroine. During the last 10 years, since the TV series was broadcast on MBC from September 2003 till March 2004, the people of South Korea and other nations have been infatuated with this female expert chef’s success story. Many South Korean scholars have praised this TV series as a case of overcoming the western mainstream popular culture. Some of them even found the possibility for a ‘female alternative narrative’ in the TV series. They argue that the subversive subjectivity of East Asian women can be found in the heroine of the TV series. Has this beautiful, self-cultivated heroine really achieved her own alternative woman’s life in the drama? Can we really find a possibility for a “subaltern subjectivity” through her?In this paper, I explore this question through discourse analysis, comparing ‘Daejanggeum’ story with prototype image of Korean traditional women in the modern society. In the collective memory of modern Korea, a “traditional Chosŏn woman” is basically the symbol of “suppression.” Since the 1970s, several books on ’Ijo YeoIn’ have been published and many ‘historical dramas’ were created. Through these literary and dramatic representations, the public memory of ‘traditional women’ has been invented. Thus invented public memory became the very basis on which the modern gender relationship was constructed. Daejanggeum’s story contains some “new” ideas about traditional women, but it does not go beyond a recursive representation of traditional women in the modern society. The “new ideas” are nothing much more than the factors reflecting the changes in women’s role in the world dominated by “neo-liberalism.” This paper is a critical review of the phenomenon of appropriating the images of traditional Korean women in the context of neo-liberalism. I argue that, despite of the seemingly new and alternative representation of a traditional woman, “Janggeum” does not deviate much from the old “typicality” of “Chosŏn Woman.”

참고문헌 (30)

  1. 강내희, "신자유주의와 한류― 동아시아에서의 한국 대중문화의 문화횡단과 민주주의", 중국현대문학, (42), pp.273~302 (2007), 한국중국현대문학학회
  2. 곽수경, "중국에서의 대장금현상의 배경과 시사점", 중국연구, 37, pp.197~213 (2006), 중국연구소
  3. 김성수, "글로컬적 관점에서 본 한류에 대한 재평가", 인문콘텐츠, (18), pp.313~335 (2010), 인문콘텐츠학회
  4. 김수정, "동남아에서 한류의 특성과 문화취향의 초국가적 흐름", 방송과 커뮤니케이션, 13(1), pp.5~54 (2012), 문화방송
  5. 김은진, "한국 사극 속 여성성과 담론 분석-대장금을 중심으로-", 여성연구논집, 15, pp.81~114 (2004)
  6. 김태연, "드라마<대장금>에 나타난 영웅서사의 현대적 변용", 어문연구, 53, pp.299~330 (2007), 어문연구학회
  7. 김현미, "한국의 근대성과 여성의 노동권", 한국여성학, 16(1), pp.37~64 (2000)
  8. 박용옥, "한국근대여성사" (1975), 정음사
  9. 박용옥, "이조여성사" (1976), 한국일보사
  10. 백승국, "문화, 미디어로 소통하기", pp.62~67 (2004), 논형
  11. 백원담, "동아시아의 문화 선택" (2005), 한류 펜타그램
  12. 송도영, "서평 : 『“한류”와 아시아의 대중문화』: 조한혜정 외, 서울: 연세대학교 출판부, 2003년", 한국문화인류학, 37(1), pp.286~294 (2004)
  13. 숙명여자대학교 아세아여성연구소, "이조여성연구" (1976), 숙명여자대학교 출판부
  14. 이경하, "내훈" (2011), 한길사
  15. 이석래, "이조의 여인상" (1973), 을유문고
  16. 이영자, "신자유주의 시대의 문화자본주의", 현상과 인식, 36(4), pp.83~110 (2012), 한국인문사회과학회
  17. 이화여자대학교 한국여성사 편찬위원회, "한국여성사" (1972), 이대출판부
  18. 전진성, "역사가 기억을 말하다 : 이론과 실천을 위한 기억의 문화사" (2005), 휴머니스트
  19. 정지영, "조선시대 부녀의 노출과 외출: 규제와 틈새", 여성과 역사, (2), pp.149~181 (2005), 한국여성사학회
  20. 정지영, "임진왜란, 동아시아 삼국전쟁", pp.41~84 (2007), 휴머니스트
  21. 정지영, "1970년대 '이조여인'의 탄생: '조국근대화'와 '민족주체성'의 타자들", 여성학논집, 24(2), pp.41~78 (2007), 한국여성연구원
  22. 조한혜정, "동", 서양 정체성의 해체와 재구성: 글로벌 지각 변동의 징후로 읽는 ‘한류열풍’, 2002, pp.35(1), 3~40[DOI]
  23. 조한혜정, "한류와 아시아의 대중문화" (2003), 연세대학교 출판부
  24. 주창규, "한류의 역사적 성격과 동아시아의 서발터니티에 대한 시론: 신자유주의적 세계화를 역류(逆流)하는 <대장금>의 사례 분석", 한국민족문화, (28), pp.287~324 (2006), 한국민족문화연구소
  25. 하효숙, "역사, 젠더, 그리고 텔레비전 역사드라마: <대장금>을 중심으로", 미디어, 젠더 & 문화, (2), pp.71~117 (2004)
  26. 한소진, "21세기 TV 드라마에 반영된 설화의 세계관 고찰", 문학과 영상, 5(2), pp.269~294 (2004), 문학과영상학회
  27. 미셀푸코, "주체의 해석학(1981-1982, 콜레주 드 프랑스에서의 강의)" (2007), 동문선
  28. Felski, Rita, "The gender of Modernity" (1995), Harvard University Press
  29. Hobsbawm, Eric J., "The Invention of Tradition" (1992), Cambridge Univ. Press
  30. Chatterjee, Partha, "The Nation and Its Fragments -Colonial and Postcolonial Histories" (1993), Princeton University Press

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (26건)