본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Tacit Knowledge and the Sociological Turn in Population Studies in Korea in the 1960s and 1970s

김인수
한국학중앙연구원 (The Academy of Korean Studies)|2023|Korea Journal|제63권 제2호|pp. 201-234|DOI 10.25024/kj.2023.63.2.201

1

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

tacit knowledgePopulation Councilfertility surveysYi Hae-yeongKoreanization of social surveyssociological turn in population studies
주제분류한국어와문학

초록

Three fertility surveys were carried out in Korea in the 1960s through funding provided by the Population Council. In this study, I reveal the sociological turn in population studies in Korea that occurred over the 1960s and 1970s by focusing on sociologist Yi Hae-yeong’s 1965 fertility survey and a 1972 scholarly conference hosted by the Korean Sociological Association under the title “Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities.” I analyze the academic foundations of fertility surveys in the 1960s (i.e., ‘coupling to American academia’), internal changes of the actors implementing the surveys in the field (i.e., ‘feedback from the field’), and the discursive challenge to medical doctor-led implementation of fertility surveys initiated by tacit knowledge of survey (i.e., ‘competition for institutional resources’). Thus, I review the attempt at the Koreanization of social surveys in the field of sociology and the sociological turn in population studies, and explore the reason this legacy has been forgotten.

Abstract

Three fertility surveys were carried out in Korea in the 1960s through funding provided by the Population Council. In this study, I reveal the sociological turn in population studies in Korea that occurred over the 1960s and 1970s by focusing on sociologist Yi Hae-yeong’s 1965 fertility survey and a 1972 scholarly conference hosted by the Korean Sociological Association under the title “Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities.” I analyze the academic foundations of fertility surveys in the 1960s (i.e., ‘coupling to American academia’), internal changes of the actors implementing the surveys in the field (i.e., ‘feedback from the field’), and the discursive challenge to medical doctor-led implementation of fertility surveys initiated by tacit knowledge of survey (i.e., ‘competition for institutional resources’). Thus, I review the attempt at the Koreanization of social surveys in the field of sociology and the sociological turn in population studies, and explore the reason this legacy has been forgotten.

참고문헌 (54)

  1. "Hanguk sahoe gwahak jaryowon(Korean Social Science Data Archive, KOSSDA)"[URL]
  2. "Sleepy Hollow"[URL]
  3. Amrith, Sunil S., "Decolonizing International Health : India and Southeast Asia, 1930–65" (2006), Palgrave Macmillan
  4. Bourdieu, Pierre, "Eoneo-wa sangjing gweollyeok (Language and Symbolic Power)" (2014), Nanam
  5. Cho, Eunju, "Gajok-gwa tongchi(Family and Governance)" (2018), Changbi
  6. Choe, Cheong-un, "Jisik gukgaron : Yeongguk, peurangseu, miguk-eseo-ui nodong tonggye baldal-ui jeongchijeok uimi(On the Knowledge State : Political Implications of Labor Statistics Developments in the United Kingdom, France, and the United States)" (2016), Ijo
  7. Toshi shussan-ryoku chōsa kekka hōkoku (daiippō)” (Report on Urban Fertility Survey Results, vol. 1), "Chōsen sōtoku kanbō chōsa-ka (Investigation Division of the Government-General of Korea)", 55~77, pp.Chōsen sōtoku-fu chōsa geppō (Government-General of Korea Monthly Survey Report) 15.8 (1944), 9
  8. Nōson shussan-ryoku chōsa kekka hōkoku (daiippō)” (Report on Rural Fertility Survey Results, vol. 1), "Chōsen sōtoku kanbō chōsa-ka (Investigation Division of the Government-General of Korea)", 45~60, pp.Chōsen sōtoku-fu chōsa geppō (Government-General of Korea Monthly Survey Report) 15.9 (1944)
  9. Connelly, Matthew, "Population Control Is History : New Perspectives on the International Campaign to Limit Population Growth", Comparative Studies in Society and History, 45(1), pp.122~147 (2003)
  10. Daehan gajok gyehoek hyeophoe (Korean Family Planning Association), "Gahyeop 30-nyeonsa (Thirty-year History of the Korean Family Planning Association)" (1991), Daehan gajok gyehoek hyeophoe
  11. Davis, Kingsley, "Social Structure and Fertility : An Analytical Framework in Economic Development and Cultural Change", Economic Development and Cultural Change, 4(3), pp.211~235 (1956)
  12. DiMoia, John P., "(Let’s Have the Proper Number of Children and Raise Them Well!): Family Planning and Nation-Building in South Korea, 1961–1968", East Asian Science, Technology and Society : An International Journal, 2(3), pp.361~379 (2008)
  13. Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977, "Power", pp.1980, Foucault, Michel
  14. Greenhalgh, Susan, "Governing China’s Population : From Leninist to Neoliberal Biopolitics" (2005), Stanford University Press
  15. Hacking, Ian, "Reconstructing Individualism: Autonomy, Individuality, and the Self in Western Thought", pp.222~236 (1986), Stanford University Press
  16. Hanguk ingu hakhoe (Korean Population Studies Association), "Ingu daesajeon (Population Dictionary)", Tonggyecheong (Statistics Korea), ~ (2016)
  17. Hanguk bogeon sahoe yeonguhoe (Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs), "Ingu jeongchaek 30-nyeon (Thirty Years of Population Policies)" (1991), Hanguk bogeon sahoe yeonguhoe
  18. Hanguk gajok gyehoek yeongu hwaltong-ui sahoehakjeok pyeongga (A Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities), "Hanguk sahoe hakhoe (Korean Sociological Association)", Hanguk sahoe hakhoe, ~ (1972)
  19. Hanguk sahoe gwahak-ui tochakhwa: Yeongu bangbeopeul jungsim-euro (Indigenization of Korean Social Science: Focusing on Research Methods), "Hanguk sahoe gwahak yeongu hyeobuihoe and Yuneseuko hanguk wiwonhoe (Korean Social Sciences Research Council and Korean National Commission for UNESCO)", Hanguk sahoe gwahak yeongu hyeobuihoe, ~ (1979)
  20. Hodges, Sarah, "Contraception, Colonialism, and Commerce : Birth Control in South India 1920–1940" (2008), Ashgate
  21. Homei, Aya, "Science, Technology, and Medicine in the Modern Japanese Empire", pp.227~243 (2016), Routledge
  22. Homei, Aya, "Population Control in Cold War Asia : An Introduction", East Asian Science, Technology and Society : An International Journal, 10(4), pp.343~353 (2016)
  23. "The Population Council and Population Control in Postwar East Asia" (2009)[URL]
  24. Hwang, Seongmo, "Hyeondae sahoe gwahak bangbeomnon (Modern Social Science Methodology)", pp.238~249 (1978), Mineumsa
  25. Im, Heuiseop, "Hanguk gajok gyehoek yeongu hwaldong-ui sahoehakjeok pyeongga (A Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities)", pp.89~97 (1972), Hanguk sahoe hakhoe
  26. Kim, Chin-gyun, "Hanguk-ui sahoe hyeonsil-gwa hangmun-ui gwaje (Korea’s Social Reality and Academic Tasks)" (1997), Munhwa gwahaksa
  27. 김인수, "일제하 조선의 농정 입법과 통계에 대한 지식국가론적 해석 : 제국 지식체계의 이식과 변용을 중심으로", 박사, 사회학과, pp.2013
  28. Kim, Insu(In-soo Kim), "Seoul daehakgyo sahoe baljeon yeonguso 50-nyeonsa: 1965–2015 (A Fifty-year History of the Institute for Social Development and Policy Research, Seoul National University)" (2015), Haneul Academy
  29. 김인수, "농석 이해영의 사회학: ‘한국사회조사사’의 측면에서", 한국사회학, 50(4), pp.27~65 (2016), 한국사회학회
  30. 김인수, "냉전과 지식정치 -박진환의 Far m Management Analysis (1966)의 성립사정을 중심으로", 동북아역사논총, (61), pp.409~465 (2018), 동북아역사재단[DOI]
  31. Kim, Insu(In-soo Kim), "Japanese Population Politics as Viewed through Fertility Surveys in the 1940s and 1950s", Seoul Journal of Japanese Studies, 5(1), pp.139~171 (2019)
  32. Ko, Yeongbok, "Hanguk gajok gyehoek yeongu hwaldong-ui sahoehakjeok pyeongga (A Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities)", pp.41~55 (1972), Hanguk sahoe hakhoe
  33. Ku, Hae-geun, "Hyeondae hanguk sahoe seongkyeok nonjaeng: Singminji, gyegeup, ingyeok yulli (Debate over the Character of Korean Society: Colony, Class, and Personal Ethics)", pp.70~100 (2001), Jeontong-gwa hyeondae
  34. Kwon, Ihyeok, "Bogeonhak-gwa na(Public Health Science and I)" (2008), Sinwon munhwasa
  35. Kwon, Tae-hwan, "Sahoe josa-wa Hanguk sahoe (Social Surveys and Korean Society)", Unpublished manuscript, ~ (2006)
  36. Latham, Michael E., "The Right Kind of Revolution: Modernization, Development, and U.S. Foreign Policy from the Cold War to the Present" (2011), Cornell University Press
  37. Latour, Bruno, "Jeolmeun gwahak-ui jeonseon (Science in Action)" (2016), Akanet
  38. Matsuda, Toshihoko, "Shokuminchi teikoku Nihon ni okeru chi to kenryoku (Knowledge and Power in Colonial Empire Japan)", pp.523~566 (2019), Shibunkaku shuppan
  39. Mizushima, Haruo, "Chōsen jūmin no seimei-hyō(Life Table of Korean Residents)" (1938), Chikazawa shoten
  40. Ozaki, Ayanori, "Shussan-ryoku chōsa kekka no gaisetsu"(Outline of Fertility Survey Results)", Jinkō mondai kenkyū (Population Problem Studies), 1(7), pp.1~95 (1940)[DOI]
  41. 배은경, "한국사회 출산조절의 역사적 과정과 젠더 : 1970년대까지의 경험을 중심으로", 박사, 사회학, pp.2004
  42. Pak, Chiyeong, "Jeguk-ui saengmyeongnyeok: Gyeongseong jeguk daehak uihak-bu wisaenghak yebang-ui hakgyosil-ui ingu tonggye yeongu, 1926–1945 (Vitality of Empire: Demographic Studies in the Department of Hygiene and Preventive Medicine of Keijō Imperial University in Colonial Korea and Japanese Imperialism)", PhD, pp.2019
  43. Sawada, Kayo, "Sengo Okinawa no seishoku o meguru poritikusu: Beiguntōchika no shussei-ryoku tenkan to on’na-tachi no kōshō (Reproductive Politics in Postwar Okinawa: Fertility Transition and Women’s Negotiations under US Military Rule)" (2014), Ōtsukishoten
  44. "Daedosi jiyeok-ui sireop kyoyuk-ui hyokwa-e gwanhan yeongu (Survey on the Effects of Vocational Education in Big Cities)" (1967)[URL]
  45. Sin, Yongha, "Hanguk sahoehak-ui baljeon-gwa banghyang (Directions and Development of Korean Sociology)", Sahoe kwahak nonjip(Journal of Social Science), 1, pp.43~59 (1976)
  46. Takeshita, Chikako, "The Global Biopolitics of the IUD : How Science Constructs Contraceptive Users and Woman’s Bodies" (2012), MIT Press
  47. Yang, Chaemo, "Sarang-ui bit man chi ko(Indebted Only to Love)" (2001), Kyurain
  48. Yi, Hae-yeong, "Hanguk gajok gyehoek yeongu hwaltong-ui sahoehakjeok pyeongga (A Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities)", pp.5~15 (1972), Hanguk sahoe hakhoe
  49. Yi, Hae-yeong, "Hanguk sahoe ingu-wa baljeon (je 1-gwon) (Vol. 1 of Population and Development of Korean Society)" (1978), Seoul daehakgyo chulpanbu
  50. Yi, Hyo-jae, "Hanguk gajok gyehoek yeongu hwaldong-ui sahoehakjeok pyeongga (A Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities)", pp.133~145 (1972), Hanguk sahoe hakhoe
  51. Yi, Man-gap, "Sahoe chosa bangbeop-e taehan gureut doen gyeonhae"(A Mistaken View of the Social Survey Method)", Sahoe hakbo(Journal of Sociology), 1, pp.1~8 (1958)
  52. Yi, Man-gap, "Hanguk sahoe gwahak-ui tochakhwa: Yeongu bangbeop-eul jungsim-euro (Indigenization of Korean Social Science: Focusing on Research Methods)", pp.17~27 (1979), Hanguk sahoe gwahak yeongu hyeobuihoe
  53. Yi, Man-gap, "Salm-ui dwiangil-eseo(On the Byways of Life)" (2004), Segye ilbosa
  54. Yi, Man-gap, "Hanguk gajok gyehoek yeongu hwaldong-ui sahoehakjeok pyeongga (Sociological Evaluation of Korean Family Planning Research Activities)", pp.73~87 (1972), Hanguk sahoe hakhoe

관련 논문AI추천

Revisiting Korean Family Planning (FP): Population and the pre-1962 ContextJohn P. DiMoia한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2022 · 제62권 제3호Socializing Childbirth: Korea's Family Planning Program in the 1960s and 1970s손애리한국사회연구소 · 한국사회2013 · 제14권 제1호Two Attempts to Medicalize Reproduction and Their Implications김남희, 김정아생명의료법연구소 · 생명윤리정책연구2018 · 제11권 제2호선진 기술을 향한 열망과 적정성의 역전: 1960–80년대 한국의 복강경-미니랩 기술 경쟁박승만대한의사학회 · 의사학2022 · 제31권 제1호Revisiting Americanization: Focusing on the Reformation of Public Health in South Korea, 1945–1960박지영한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2022 · 제62권 제3호피임 기술의 재생산: 1960년대 한국 플라스틱 자궁내장치 제조의 국산화정준호, 천경서의학사연구소 · 연세의사학2023 · 제26권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)

[On this topic] DMZ Beyond Inter-Korean Borderlands: Productive Contradiction from the Perspective of Critical DMZ Studies이현경, 현명호pp. 5-15Making of a North Korean Borderland: Northern Gangwon, 1945–1950현명호pp. 16-45The Eclectic Heritage-Scape of a Tense Border in the Paju DMZ, South Korea이현경, Dacia Viejo-Rosepp. 46-93A Place of Memory: The Ruins of the Korean Workers’ Party Headquarters, Cheorwon박은영pp. 94-127Ecological Cooperation beyond the DMZ on the Korean Peninsula: Birds Know No Man-made Borders이우균, 최현아, Bernhard SELIGERpp. 128-150
원문 보기