본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Intersecting Perspectives in Labor History and New Minjung History

장미현
한국학중앙연구원 (The Academy of Korean Studies)|2024.12|Korea Journal|제64권 제4호|pp. 64-86|DOI 10.25024/kj.2024.64.4.64

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

labor historyminjung historyresearch on labor by disabled persons
주제분류한국어와문학

초록

In minjung history, the worker was the protagonist of the anti-imperialistic struggle for national liberation and the leader of revolutionary change in the capitalistic system of South Korea. As such, the proletariat were important subjects in minjung historiography, which sought to overcome the colonial and divisional view of history. Similar to how the intense minjung movement during produced the study of minjung history from the 1980s to the 2000s, the importance of the history of the labor movement has continued to influence and be influenced by the site of labor on the ground and by research into the labor movement. In this article, I first examine the context and major characteristics of research on the South Korean labor movement from the 1980s to early 1990s. Next, I examine how, from the late 1990s, research on labor history expanded as research on minjung history declined. Finally, I explore how the history of the labor movement shifted to a history of labor, as well as the characteristics and limitations of studies of labor history. Finally, I propose accepting the critical inquiries and research achievements of the new minjung history and the field of minority history in order to continue the praxis-oriented nature of research on labor history.

Abstract

In minjung history, the worker was the protagonist of the anti-imperialistic struggle for national liberation and the leader of revolutionary change in the capitalistic system of South Korea. As such, the proletariat were important subjects in minjung historiography, which sought to overcome the colonial and divisional view of history. Similar to how the intense minjung movement during produced the study of minjung history from the 1980s to the 2000s, the importance of the history of the labor movement has continued to influence and be influenced by the site of labor on the ground and by research into the labor movement. In this article, I first examine the context and major characteristics of research on the South Korean labor movement from the 1980s to early 1990s. Next, I examine how, from the late 1990s, research on labor history expanded as research on minjung history declined. Finally, I explore how the history of the labor movement shifted to a history of labor, as well as the characteristics and limitations of studies of labor history. Finally, I propose accepting the critical inquiries and research achievements of the new minjung history and the field of minority history in order to continue the praxis-oriented nature of research on labor history.

참고문헌 (68)

  1. : The Movement to Build Organizations), "Yeoksa-wa hyeonsil (Quarterly Review of Korean History)", 1989, 98~125
  2. An, Tae-jeong, "Joseon nodong johap jeonguk pyeonguihoe yeongu (A Study on National Council of the Chosun Labor Union)", PhD, pp.2000
  3. Bae, Gyeong-sik, "Nonjaeng-euro bon hanguk sahoe 100-nyeon (A Century of Korean Society Seen Through its Controversies)", pp.346~352 (2000), Yeoksa bipyeongsa
  4. Bae, Youngsoo, "(Teukjip 2: Yeoksa yeongu bangbeomnon-gwa sajeok yumullon) Sahoesa-ui ironjeok hamui: Edeuwodeu Tomseun (E. P. Thomason)-e isseoseo gyegeup-gwa munhwa geurigo yeoksajeok yumullon(Special Feature No. 2: The Methodology of Historical Research and Historical Materialism: The Theoretical Implications of Social History: Class, Culture, and Historical Materialism of E. P. Thompson)", Yeoksa-wa hyeonsil (Quarterly Review of Korean History), 10, pp.123~156 (1993)
  5. Bak, Jeong-mi, "Seongpongnyeok-gwa yeoseong-ui simingwon: Undong sahoe seongpongnyeok ppuri ppopgi 100-in wiwonhoe sarye bunseok (Sexual Violence and Women’s Civil Rights: A Case Study of the 100-Member Committee to Eradicate Sexual Violence Within the Movement Community)", Master, pp.2002
  6. Bak, Mi-a, "Jae-il joseonin yeoseong-gwa amsijang: Haebang jikhu-ui gyeongje hwaldong-eul jungsim-euro (Korean Women in Japan and the Black Market after World War II)", Yeoseong-gwa yeoksa(Women and History), 30, pp.113~144 (2019)
  7. Bak, Seung-ok, "Hanguk nodong undong 20 nyeon-ui gyeolsan-gwa jeonmang (Twenty Years of the Korean Labor Movement: Summary and Outlook)", pp.85~91 (1991), Segye
  8. ), "Yeoksa hakbo (Korean Historical Review)", 2004, 339~361
  9. Bang, Yong-seok, "8-baengman nodongja-wa hamkke (Together With 8Million Workers)", Hyeonsil-gwa jeonmang (Reality and Prospect), 1, pp.13~16 (1984)
  10. Cho, Soon-kyoung, "Saneop-ui jaepyeonseong-gwa yeoseong nodong undong (Industrial Restructuring and Women Workers in the Labor Movement: A Comparative Study of South Korea and Taiwan)", Asia munhwa(Asian Culture), 6, pp.127~154 (1990)
  11. Choe, Gyu-jin, "Hanguk sahoejuui undongsa, mueot-eul eotteoke bol geosinga (History of the Korean Socialist Movement: What It Is and How to View It)", Nyu redikeol ribyu (New Radical Review), 9, pp.414~455 (2001)
  12. Choi, Wooyoung, "1960–1980-nyeondae seoul miyongsa-ui ilsang-gwa jigeop jeongcheseong-ui hyeongseong: Miyongsa Han Jeong-suk-ui gusul saengaesa reul jungsim-euro (Daily Life and Professional Identity of Hairdressers in Seoul, 1960s–1980s: Focusing on the Oral Biography of Hairdresser Han Jung sook)", Seoul-gwa yeoksa (Seoul and History), 115, pp.191~231 (2023)
  13. Dan, Byeong-ho, "Teukbyeol daedam: Gomin-haneun Dan Byeong-ho (Special Interview: Dan Byoeng-ho Is Thinking)", Wolgan sahoe pyeongnon(Monthly Social Review), 91(3), pp.48~67 (1991)
  14. Ginzburg, Carlo, "Misisa: Nae-ga algo inneun myeot gaji geot-deul (Microhistory: Two or Three Things I Know About It)", Yeoksa yeongu (Journal of Historical Studies), 7, pp.223~270 (2000)
  15. Ha, Keum Chul, "Aengbeori jangaein-ui oechim-eun eodiro ganneunga: 1980–1990-nyeondae yeongse jangaein munje-wa jangaein undong-ui daeeung (Where Have the Cries of Disabled Panhandlers Gone: The Problems of Destitute Disabled People in the 1980s–90s and the Responses of the Disability Movement)", Gieok-gwa jeonmang (Memory and Prospect), 42, pp.295~347 (2020)
  16. Han, Bong Seok, "Nuga, nugu-reul eotteoke dasi ilgeul su isseulkka?:Minjungsa-ui hangye-wa jeongcheseong jeongchi (Who, Whom, How Can I Read Again?: Recognizing the Limitations of Minjungsa)", Sarim (Historical Journal), 83, pp.81~107 (2023)
  17. Hanguk minjungsa yeonguhoe, "Hanguk mijungsa 1, 2 (History of the Minjung of Korea, Vols. 1, 2)" (1986), Pulbit
  18. In Anticipation for a Deeper Intellectual History in the Research on Socialism During the Colonial Period : Im Gyeong-seok’s ‘The Origin of Socialism in Korea’; Yi Hyeon-ju’s ‘The Formation of the Socialist Camp in Korea, "Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Modern Korean History)", 2004, 253~272
  19. Hur, Youngran, "1912-nyeon Roi chaepeumeon aendeuryuseu-ui gorae josa wa ‘hanguk-gye gwisin gorae’(Roy Chapman Andrews’ Survey of Gray Whales at the Jangsaengpo Whaling Station in 1912 and the ‘Korean Gray Whale’)", Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Modern Korean History), 27(3), pp.127~1647 (2013)
  20. Im, Gyeong-seok, "Goryeo gongsandang yeongu (A Study of the Korean Communist Party)", PhD, pp.1993
  21. Im, Gyeong-seok, "Hanguk sahoejuui-ui giwon(Origin of Socialism in Korea)" (2003), Yeoksa bipyeongsa
  22. The Participation of Workers and Peasants Farmers in the March First Independence Movement), "Yeoksa bipyeong (Critical Review of History)", 1989, 74~103
  23. Ju, Yun-jeong, "Boiji anneun yeoksa: Hanguk sigak jangaein-deul-ui jeohang gwa yeondae (Invisible History: The Resistance and Solidarity of the Visually Impaired in Korea)" (2020), Deulnyeok
  24. Jun, Myung-Hyuk, "1920-nyeondae gungnae sahoejuui undong yeongu: Seoul pa-reul jungsim-euro (A Study on the Korean Socialist Movement in 1920s:Centered on the ‘Seoul-pa’)", PhD, pp.1998
  25. Jun, Myung-Hyuk, "(Teukjip) Hanguk nodongja gyegeup hyeongseong yeongu (Special Feature: A Study on the Formation of Korean Working Class)", Yeoksa yeongu (Journal of Historical Studies), 11, pp.7~51 (2002)
  26. Kang, In-cheol, "Minjung, sidae-wa yeoksa sok-eseo: Minjung-ui gaenyeomsa, tongsa (Minjung, During the Times and in History: Conceptual History of Minjung, General History)" (2023), Sungkyunkwan University Press
  27. Kang, Man-gil, "Haebang jeonhusa-ui insik 2: Jeongchi, gyeongje, sahoe, munhwajeonk gujo-ui siljeungjeok yeongu (Perception of History Before and After Liberation 2: An Empirical Study of Political, Economic, Social, and Cultural Structures)", pp.11~15 (1985), Hangilsa
  28. Kang, Yi Soo, "1930-nyeondae myeonbangdae gieop yeoseong nodongja-ui sangtae-e daehan yeongu: Nodong gwajeong-gwa nodong tongje-reul jungsim euro (A Study on the Conditions of Female Workers in Cotton Industries in the 1930s: Focusing on the Labor Process and Labor Control)", PhD, pp.1991
  29. Kang, Yi Soo, "Yeoseong-gwa il: Hanguk yeoseong nodong-ui ihae (Women and Work: Understanding the Work of Korean Women)" (2001), Dongnyeok
  30. Kim, Dae-Ryoon, "‘Yeongguk nodong gyegeup-ui hyeongseong’ dashi ilkki(‘The Making of the English Working Class’: Some Reflections)", Yeoksa bipyeong(Critical Review of History), 106, pp.206~228 (2014)
  31. Kim, Daehyun, "1950, 60-nyeondae yuheungeop hyeonjang-gwa yuheung eopso jongeopwon-e daehan nagin (The Bar and Nightclub Industry Circumstances and the Stigma upon the Employees in the Industry during 1950–60s)", Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Modern Korean History), 22(1), pp.47~85 (2018)
  32. Kim, Gwang-un, "3.1-undong 70-junyeon ginyeomteukjip minjok haebang tujaeng-ui Juche-wa seonggyeok-eul saeropge balkinda: Wonsan chongpaeop gwa nodong undong-ui saeroun dangyero-ui ihaeng (Special Issue on the 70th Anniversary of the March 1st Movement Reexamining the Agents and Nature of the National Liberation Struggle: Wonsan General Strike and the Transition to a New Stage in the Labor Movement)", Yeoksa bipyeong (Critical Review of History), 6, pp.138~156 (1989)
  33. Kim, Gyeong-il, "Bukhan hakgye-ui 1920, 30-nyeondae nodong undong yeongu (Research on the Labor Movement of the 1920s and 1930s in North Korean Academia)" (1989), Changbi
  34. Kim, Gyeong-il, "Hanguk geundae nodongsa-wa nodong undong (History of Labor in Modern Korea and the Labor Movement)" (2004), Moonji
  35. Kim, In-geol, "Gwondu jwadam 80-nyeondae minjung sahangnon, mueot-i munje inga (Round Table: Issues in Minjung Historiography of the 1980s)", Yeoksa bipyeong (Critical Review of History), 9, pp.20~56 (1980)
  36. Kim, Jeong-wha, "1960-nyeondae yeoseong nodong: Singmo-wa beoseuannaeyang-eul jungsim-euro (The Woman’s Work in 1960s: Centered on Kitchenmaid and Bus Usher )", Yeoksa yeongu (Journal of Historical Studies), 11, pp.81~107 (2002)
  37. Kim, Ju-hui, "Reidi keuredit: Seong maemae, geumyung-ui eolgul-eul hada (Lady Credit: Prostitution’s Face as Finance)" (2020), Hyunsil munhwa
  38. Kim, Jun, "(Nodongsa teukjip) 1970-nyeondae yeoseong nodongja-ui ilsang saenghwal-gwa uisik: Ireunba mobeom geulloja-reul jungsim-euro (Special Feature on the History of Labor: Everyday Lives and Consciousness of Model Women Workers in 1970s)", Yeoksa yeongu (Journal of Historical Studies), 10, pp.53~99 (1970)
  39. Kim, Kyounghee, "Saneop gujo jojeong-gwa yeoseong goyong buranjeong:Uiryu, sinbal, jeonjaeop-eul jungsim-euro (Industrial Restructuring and Insecurity of Women’s Employment: Looking at the Industries of Textiles, Shoes, and Electronics)", Yeoseong-gwa sahoe (Women and Society), 7, pp.177~203 (1996)
  40. Kim, Kyounghee, "Hanguk yeoseong nodong johap undong-ui chulhyeon: Nodong undong-ui saeroun paereodaim-eul hyanghayeo (The Appearance of Korean Women Trade Unions: Toward the New Paradigm)", Gyeongje-wa sahoe(Economy and Society), 43, pp.133~155 (1999)
  41. Kim, Seong Bo, "Minjung sahak ajikdo yuhyo hanga (Is the History of Minjung Still Valid?)", Yeoksa bipyeong(Critical Review of History), 16, pp.48~55 (1991)
  42. Kim, Serim, "1950-nyeondae gongju yugu jiyeok-ui pinanmin jeongchakchon hyeongseong-gwa jikjoeop (Establishment of Refugee Settlement and Weaving in Gongju Yugu area in the 1950s)", Hangnim (Haklim), 42, pp.47~82 (1950)
  43. Kim, Won, "Minju nojo, nohak yeondae geurigo byeonhyeok: 1980-nyeondae nodong undong-ui yeoksa (Democratic Labor Unions, Labor-Academic Solidarity, and Transformation: A History of the Labor Movement in the 1980s)" (2017), Academy of Korean Studies Press
  44. Lee, Byung-Rye, "Ilje ha jeonsi chejegi nodongja-ui gyeongheom segye (Labor’s Experiential World under the Japanese Imperialist during the Sino Japanese War Period)", Yeoksa yeongu (Journal of Historical Studies), 11, pp.53~79 (2002)
  45. Lee, ImHa, "Hanguk jeonjaeng-i yeoseong saenghwal-e michin yeonghyang:1950-nyeondae jeonjaeng mimangin-ui sam-eul jungsim-euro (Centered on the Lives of the War Widows: The Influence to the Women’s Lives of Korean War)", Yeoksa yeongu (Journal of Historical Studies), 8, pp.9~55 (2000)
  46. Lee, ImHa, "Jeonjaeng mimangin, hanguk hyeondaesa-ui chimmuk-eul kkaeda:Gusul-ro pureo sseun hanguk jeonjaeng-gwa jeonhu sahoe (War Widows Break the Silence of Contemporary Korean History: The Korean War and the Post War Society Through Oral Histories)" (2010), Chaek-gwa hamkke
  47. Lee, Sungho, "1950–60-nyeondae dosi nodongja saenghwal segye-ui jung cheungseong: ‘Incheon ilgi-e natanan gigye gongeop nodongja-ui sarye-reul jungsim-euro (Multi-Layered Character of Urban Workers’Life-World in 1950–60s: Focusing on the Diary of a Machine Industry Worker of Incheon)", Yeoksa-wa segye (History and the World), 52, pp.31~64 (1950)
  48. Lee, Yong-ki, "Minjungsa reul dasi malhanda (Retelling Minjung History)", pp.48~70 (2013), Yeoksa biyeongpsa
  49. Lee, Young Suk, "Yeoksahak gojeon dasi ilkki: Talgyegeup sidae-e tomseun-eul dasi ikda, E. P. Tomseun, ‘Yeongguk nodong gyegeup-ui hyeongseong’ (Re reading E. P. Thompson’s ‘The Making of the English Working Class’ in the Age of De-class)", Seoyang saron (Western History Review), 119, pp.274~302 (2013)
  50. Na, Hyesim, "Dogil-ro gan hanin ganho yeoseong (Korean Nurses Who Went to Germany)" (2012), San-gwa geul
  51. Ota, Osamu, "Ilgi-reul tonghae bon jeontong-gwa geundae, singminji-wa haebang, haebang jikhu eoneu nodongja-ui ilsang saenghwal: Incheon-ui jeongigong yi-ssi-ui ilgi robuteo (A Worker`s Daily Life after the Liberation of Korea: From the Diary of Mr. Yi, An Incheon Electrician)", Minjok munhwa yeongu (Korean Cultural Studies), 57, pp.305~348 (2012)
  52. Pusan National University Hanguk minjok munhwa yeonguso, "Poseop-gwa jeohang-ui rokeolliti (Locality of National Subsumption and Local Resistance)" (2013), Somyong
  53. Seo, Jung-seok, "1970-nyeondae jungban ihu jinbojeok hanguk sahakja-deul ui hanguk geunhyeondaesa yeongu donghyang (Trends of Research on Modern and Contemporary Korean History by Progressive Korean Historians after the Mid-1970s)", Daedong munhwa yeongu (Daedong Journal for Korean Studies), 32, pp.357~409 (1997)
  54. Shin, Hyeon-a, "Junggongeop gajok-ui seosajeok jaehyeon-gwa jiyeokjeok sam-ui yangsik: Jiyeok, nodong, gajok-ui dajung seukeil-gwa jendeo jili-reul jungsim-euro (Narrative Representations of Heavy Industry Families and Regional Forms of Life: Focusing on the Multi-scales of Region, Labor, and Family and Gender Geography)", PhD, pp.2023
  55. So, Hyunsoog, "Maineoriti yeoksa: Minjungsa-ui saeroun hyeoksin inga haeche inga? (Minority History: An Innovation or a Deconstruction of People’s History?)", Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Modern Korean History), 26(2), pp.67~102 (2022)
  56. So, Hyunsoog, "Chimmuk-ui gongdongche: Haebang ihu–1970-nyeondae nongin- ui sam-gwa ‘nong gongdongche’-ui hyeongseong (Silent Community: Life of Deaf People and the Formation of a Deaf Community in South Korea, 1945 to the 1970s)", Hangukhak nonchong (Journal of Korean Studies), 59, pp.359~396 (2023)
  57. Thompson, E. P, "The Making of the English Working Class" (1963), Pantheon Books
  58. Thompson, E. P., "Seoul: Changbi. Originally published as The Making of the English Working Class" (2000), Pantheon Books
  59. Won, Young-Mi, "1980-nyeondae ulsan daegongjang nodongja yeongu:Hyeondae jadongcha-wa hyeondae junggongeop-eul jungsim-euro (A Study on the Workers of Large Factories at Ulsan in the 1980s: Focused on Hyundai Motor Company and Hyundai Heavy Industries)", PhD, pp.2016
  60. of a Korean Telephone Operator during the Total War Regime and the Interiority of the Colonized), "Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Korean Modern History)", 2017, 175~227
  61. Yang, Seung-hun, "Junggongeop gajok-ui yutopia: Saneop dosi geoje, bit-gwa geurimja (Utopia of a Family in Heavy Industries: Light and Shadows of the Industrial City of Geoje)" (2019), Owol-ui bom
  62. Yeoksa munje yeonguso minjungsaban, "Minjungsa-reul dasi malhanda (Retelling Minjung History)" (2013), Yeoksa bipyeongsa
  63. Yeoksahak yeonguso, "Nodongja, jagi yeoksa reul malhada: Hyeonjang-eseo girokhan nodong undong-gwa nodongja gyoyuk ui yeoksa (Workers Speak of Their Own Histories: Records of the Labor Movement from the Scene and the History of Worker Education)" (2005), Seohae Munjip
  64. Yi, Jeong-ok, "Iljeha gongeop nodong-eseo-ui minjok-gwa seong (Nationality and Gender in Industrial Labor under Japanese Colonialism)", PhD, pp.1990
  65. Yi, Ok-ji, "Hanguk yeoseong nodongja undongsa 1 (Vol. 1 of A History of the Women Workers’ Movement in Korea)" (2001), Hanul
  66. Yu, Jeong-suk, "a, yeoseong nodongja (I, a Female Worker). 2 Vols" (2011), Greenbee
  67. Yu, Jeong-suk, "1980 nyeondae, byeonhyeok-ui sigan jeonhwan-ui girok (The 1980s, Record of a Time of Transformation and Transition). 2 Vols" (1980), Bomnal-ui bakssi
  68. Yun, Chung-ro, "Beteunam jeonjaeng-ui hanguk sahoesa ichin jeonjaeng, oraedoen hyeonjae (Korean Social History of the Vietnam War: Forgotten War, Old Present)" (2015), Pureun yeoksa

관련 논문AI추천

Reconstructing Korea’s Minjung History: From the Subject of Resistance to a Pluralistic Historiography허영란한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2024 · 제64권 제4호Narratives of Women Workers in South Korea’s Minju Union Movement of the 1970s남화숙한국학중앙연구원 · The Review of Korean Studies2009 · 제12권 제4호[On this topic] The Genealogy of Minjung History and Its New Paths in South Korea허영란한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2024 · 제64권 제4호Disability History and Minjung as Affect소현숙한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2024 · 제64권 제4호The Donghak Peasant War: From a History of the Minjung Movement to a History of the Minjung and What Follows배항섭한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2024 · 제64권 제4호The Significance of the Concept of Minjung and Changes Thereto: With a Focus on the 1920s허수한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2012 · 제52권 제4호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)

[On this topic] The Genealogy of Minjung History and Its New Paths in South Korea허영란pp. 5-14Reconstructing Korea’s Minjung History: From the Subject of Resistance to a Pluralistic Historiography허영란pp. 15-38The Donghak Peasant War: From a History of the Minjung Movement to a History of the Minjung and What Follows배항섭pp. 39-63Disability History and Minjung as Affect소현숙pp. 87-110How South Korea Constructed a Shadow Carceral State through Institutions for People with Mental Disabilities in the 1980s황지성pp. 111-137
원문 보기