본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

The Donghak Peasant War: From a History of the Minjung Movement to a History of the Minjung and What Follows

배항섭
한국학중앙연구원 (The Academy of Korean Studies)|2024.12|Korea Journal|제64권 제4호|pp. 39-63|DOI 10.25024/kj.2024.64.4.39

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

EurocentrismDonghak Peasant Warrevolutionary movementmodernocentrismsubject of revolutionary changeunilinear development theory
주제분류한국어와문학

초록

This article examines research on the Donghak Peasant War based on the theory of subjects of revolutionary change—which found active application from the 1980s to the mid-to-late 1990s—by focusing on the view of history. Research along these lines defines the minjung, which has properties of being class-coalitional, as the subject of revolutionary change that takes on both national and class contradictions. This contrasts with how the minjung, to include peasant farmers, were understood in Marxist views as requiring guidance by the more advanced classes, or other studies that follow modernization theory. However, research on the Donghak Peasant War based on the theory of subjects of revolutionary change has to date been limited to a binary view of time that divides modern from premodern, and to a binary view of space that separates the interior and exterior of a nation-state. It is difficult to adequately respond to the newly rising tasks born from modern civilization and the acceleration of globalization, to include the climate crisis, environmental problems, inequality, and discrimination, from such a Eurocentric and modernocentric perspective and a unilinear view of historical development.

Abstract

This article examines research on the Donghak Peasant War based on the theory of subjects of revolutionary change—which found active application from the 1980s to the mid-to-late 1990s—by focusing on the view of history. Research along these lines defines the minjung, which has properties of being class-coalitional, as the subject of revolutionary change that takes on both national and class contradictions. This contrasts with how the minjung, to include peasant farmers, were understood in Marxist views as requiring guidance by the more advanced classes, or other studies that follow modernization theory. However, research on the Donghak Peasant War based on the theory of subjects of revolutionary change has to date been limited to a binary view of time that divides modern from premodern, and to a binary view of space that separates the interior and exterior of a nation-state. It is difficult to adequately respond to the newly rising tasks born from modern civilization and the acceleration of globalization, to include the climate crisis, environmental problems, inequality, and discrimination, from such a Eurocentric and modernocentric perspective and a unilinear view of historical development.

참고문헌 (56)

  1. Ahn, Byung-ook, "Historical Characteristics of the Peasant War of 1894", Korea Journal, 34(4), pp.101~113 (1994)
  2. An, Byeong-mu, "Hanguk minjungnon (On the Minjung of Korea)" (1984), Hanguk sinhak yeonguso
  3. Bae, Hang Seob, "1984-nyeon donghak nongmin jeonjaeng-e natanan toji gaehyeok gusang: Pyeonggyun bunjak munje-reul jungsim-euro (Programs of Land Reform in the Donghak Peasant War of 1894)", Sachong (Historical Journal), 43, pp.87~140 (1894)
  4. Bae, Hang Seob, "1894-nyeon donghak nongmingun-ui banil hangjaeng-gwa minjokjeok daeyeonhap chujin (Anti-Japanese Resistance of the 1894Donghak Peasant War and Plans of the Great National Alliance)", Gunsa (Military History), 35, pp.99~132 (1997)
  5. Bae, Hang Seob, "1894-nyeon donghak nongmingun-ui jeongchi, gyeongjejeok jihyang-gwa gaehwapa-wa-ui gwangye (Political and Economic Pursuits of the 1894 Donghak Peasant Army and their Relationship with the Enlightenment School)", Dongyanghak (Oriental Studies), 30, pp.307~319 (2000)
  6. Bae, Hang Seob, "Minshū undōshi: Kinsei kara kindai e 5—Sekaishi no naka no minshū undō(Vol. 5 of History of Minjung Movements: From the Early Modern to the Modern Period—Minjung Movements in World History)", pp.112~139 (2000), Aoki shoten
  7. Bae, Hang Seob, "Hyeonhaeng godeung hakgyo geunhyeondaesa gyogwaseo seosuleseo boineun minjungsang (Image of the Minjung Found in the Present High School History Textbook)", Hanguksa yeongu (Journal of Korean History), 122, pp.6~196 (2003)
  8. Bae, Hang Seob, "Haeoe hangukhak pyeongnon (Review of Korean Studies Abroad) 4", pp.35~57 (2006), Iljogak
  9. Bae, Hang Seob, "Geundae-reul sangdaehwa haneun bangbeop: Minjungsa-eseo bara boneun geundae ‘Idan-ui minjungballan’-gwa ‘minjung-gwa yutopia’-reul ilkko (The Relativization of Modernity: An Approach from a Min-jung Perspective)", Yeoksa bipyeong (Critical Review of History), 88, pp.358~380 (2009)
  10. Bae, Hang Seob, "1920–30-nyeondae saeroun ‘donghak nongminjeonjaengsang’-ui hyeongseong (Formation of a New Perception of the Tonghak Peasant War during the 1920s-30s)", Sarim (Historical Journal), 36, pp.179~208 (1920)
  11. Bae, Hang Seob, "19-segi jibae jilseo-ui byeonhwa-wa jeongchi munhwa-ui byeonyong (Changes of the Ruling Order and the Transformation of Political Culture in the 19th Century—Focusing on the Course of the Common People’s Desire for Benevolent Rule )", Hanguksa hakbo (Journal for the Studies of Korean History), 39, pp.109~158 (2010)
  12. Bae, Hang Seob, "Geundae ihaenggi-ui minjung uisik: Geundae-wa ban geundae-ui neomeo—Tojisoyu mit maemaegwanseup-e daehan insik-eul jungsim-euro (People’s Perception of Things during the ‘Period of Transformation into the Modern Era’: Beyond Acknowledging the Conflict between ‘Aspiring for Modernity’ and ‘Opposing Modernity’—Examination of the People’s Perception of Issues, Like Land Ownership Rights and Customs of Transaction)", Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Modern Korean History), 23, pp.57~96 (2010)
  13. Bae, Hang Seob, "Foundations for the Legitimation of the Tonghak Peasant Army and Awareness of a New Political Order", Acta Koreana, 16(2), pp.399~430 (2013)
  14. Bae, Hang Seob, "Dong asia yeongu-ui sigak: Seogu, geundae jungsimjuui bipan-gwa geukbok (East Asian history and Western-centrism", Modernocentrism), 2014, pp.(109), 146~181
  15. Bae, Hang Seob, "Dong asia-neun myeot si inga? (What Time Is It in East Asia?)", pp.10~33 (2015), Neomeo Books
  16. Bae, Hang Seob, "Tal geundaeron-gwa geundae jungsimjuui (Postmodernism and Modernocentrism)", Minjok munhwasa yeongu (Journal of Korean Literary History), 62, pp.9~39 (2016)
  17. Bae, Hang Seob, "How Shall We Study East Asia?" (2017), Jimoondang International
  18. Bae, Hang Seob, "Bangbeop euroseo-ui ‘dong asia-sa’ yeongu-wa saeroun yeoksasang-ui mosaek: Geundae jungsim juui (modernocentrism) bipan-gwa transhistorical-han jeopgeun (Study of East Asian History as a Research Method and the Search for New History: Criticism of Moderno-centrism and a Trans-historical Approach)", Daedong munhwa yeongu (Daedong Journal for Korean Studies), 112, pp.43~82 (2020)
  19. Bae, Hang Seob, "Hanguk geundaesa ihae-ui geullobeol han jeonhwan-gwa singminjuui bipan: Gihu byeondong-gwa yeoksa yeongu-ui saeroun banghyang mosaek (Global Turn in Understanding Korean Modern History and the Critique of Colonialism: Climate Change and New Directions in Historical Research)", Yeoksa bipyeong (Critical Review of History), 145, pp.292~336 (2023)
  20. Bak, Chan-seung, "vol. 3of Hanguk minjokjuuiron (Vol. 3 of Korean Nationalism)", pp.19~75 (1985), Changbi
  21. Bak, Hyeon-chae, "Hanguk minjokjuiron 3:Minjungjeok minjokjuui (Vol. 3 of Korean Nationalism: Minjung Nationalism)" (1985), Changbi
  22. Bantigny, Ludivine, "Une histoire globale des révolutions (A Global History of Revolutions)" (2023), La Découverte
  23. Bentley, Jerry H, "Contact and Exchange in the Ancient World", pp.17~29 (2006), University of Hawai‘i Press
  24. Guldi, Jo, "Yeoksahak seoneon (History Manifesto)" (2018), The History Manifesto
  25. Society for the Research of the History of Minjung in Korea, "Hanguk minjungsa 1 (Vol. 1 of History of the Minjung of Korea)" (1986), Pulbit
  26. Korean History Society, "1894-nyeon nongmin jeonjaeng yeongu 5 (Vol. 5 of A Study of the 1894 Peasant War)" (1894), Yeoksa bipyeongsa
  27. Joining of the Peasantry War in 1894, and the Nature of Their Participation), "Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Modern Korean History)", 2008, 169~198
  28. Hong, Dong Hyun, "1894-nyeon donghak nongmingun-ui hyangchon sahoe nae hwaldong-gwa mujang bonggi-e daehan jeongdangseong nolli: Gyeongsang-do yecheon jiyeok sarye-reul jungsim-euro (Logic for the Legitimacy of the Donghak Peasant Army’s Activities and Armed Uprisings in Rural Communities in 1894: The Case of Yecheon, Gyeongsang-do)", Yeoksa munje yeongu (Critical Studies on Modern Korean History), 18(2), pp.311~338 (2014)
  29. Hur, Soo, "Gyojo sinwon undonggi donghak gyodan-gwa jeongbu gan-ui damnon tujaeng: Yugyojeok cheukmyeon-eul jungsim-euro (Discursive Struggle Between the Religious Body of Donghak and the Government during the Period of the Movement Vindicating the Innocence of the Founder of Donghak: A Consideration on Its Confucian Aspects)", Hanguk geunhyeondaesa yeongu (Journal of Korean Modern and Contemporary History), 66, pp.7~40 (2013)
  30. Jeon, Seok-dam, "Joseon gyeongjesa(Economic History of Joseon)" (1949), Bakmun
  31. Jeong, Chang-ryeol, "Hanguk munhwasa sinnon (A Cultural History of Korea)", pp.629~646 (1975), Chung-Ang University Press
  32. Jeong, Chang-ryeol, "Baekseong uisik, pyeongmin uisik, minjung uisik (Consciousness of the General Populace, Commoners, and Minjung)", Hyeonsang-gwa insik (Korean Journal of Humanities and the Social Sciences), 19, pp.106~126 (1981)
  33. Jeong, Chang-ryeol, "Hangukhak yeongu immun (Introduction to Korean Studies Research)", pp.379~396 (1981), Jisik saneup
  34. Jeong, Chang-ryeol, "19-segi hanguk jeontong sahoe-ui byeonmo-wa minjung uisik (Changes in 19th-Century Korean Traditional Society and Minjung Consciousness)", pp.265~296 (1982), Goryeodae minjok munhwa yeonguso (Research Institute of Korean Studies, Korea University)
  35. Jeong, Chang-ryeol, "vol. 1 of Hanguk minjokjuuiron (Vol. 1 of Korean Nationalism)", pp.15~94 (1982), Changbi
  36. Jeong, Chang-ryeol, "Hanguksa yeongu immun je 2 pan (Introduction to Korean History Research. 2nd ed)", pp.433~447 (1987), Jisik saneupsa
  37. Jeong, Chang-ryeol, "Gabo nongmin jeonjaeng yeongu: Jeon Bong-jun-ui sasang-gwahaengdong-eul jungsim-euro (Studies on the Gabo Peasant War of 1894:Focusing on the Thought and Activities of Jeon Bong-jun)", PhD, pp.1991
  38. Jo, Gyeong-dal, "Kōgo nōmin sensō no shidō shia: Jeong Bong-jun no kenkyu 甲午農民戰爭の指導者: 全琫準の硏究 (A Study of Jeon Bong-jun, Leader of the Gabo Peasant War)", Chōsen shisō (Studies in Korean History), 7, pp.41~84 (1983)
  39. Kang, In-cheol, "Minjung, jeohang-haneun juche: Minjung-ui gaenyeomsa, iron (Minjung, the Resisting Subject: Conceptual History of Minjung, Theory)" (2023), Sungkyunkwan University Press
  40. Kim, Yong-seop, "Jeon Bong-jun gongcho ui bunseok: Donghaknan-ui seonggyeok ilban (Analysis of Interrogations of Jeon Bong-jun: A Glimpse of the Nature of the Donghak Peasant War)", Sahak yeongu(Review of Korean History), 2, pp.1~49 (1958)
  41. Kim, Yong-seop, "Hanguk jabonjuui seonggyeok nonjaeng (Arguments About the Characteristics of Capitalism in Korea)", pp.154~178 (1988), Daewangsa
  42. Ko, Seok-gyu, "Donghak nongmin hyeongmyeong-gwa sahoe byeondong (Donghak Peasant Revolution and Social Change)", pp.11~35 (1993), Hanul
  43. Ko, Seok-gyu, "vol. 3of Hanguk yeoksa immun: Geundae, hyeondae pyeon (Vol. 3 of Introduction to Korean History: Modern and Contemporary Period)", pp.197~219 (1996), Pulbit
  44. Kye, Bong-u, "Donghakdang pokdong (Riot by the Donghak Party)", Hangukhak yeongu (Korean Studies), 5, pp.11~155 (1993)
  45. Lee, Kyung Won, "Gyojo sinwon undonggi Donghak jidobu-ui yugyojeok cheukmyoen-e daehan gochal (A Consideration of the Confucian Aspects of the Donghak Leadership during the Period of the Movement to Vindicate the Innocence of the Founder)", Yeoksa yeongu (Journal of History), 19, pp.7~56 (2010)
  46. Lee, Young-ho, "The Socioeconomic Background and the Growth of the New Social Forces of the 1894 Peasant War", Korea Journal, 34(4), pp.90~100 (1994)
  47. Lew, Young Ick, "The Conservative Character of the 1894 Tonghak Peasant Uprising: A Reappraisal with Emphasis on Chŏn Pong-jun’s Background and Motivation", Journal of Korean Studies, 7(1), pp.149~180 (1990)
  48. Oh, Youngseob, "1940-nyeondae huban yumul saga-deul-ui donghaknongmin undong-ui insik: Sowi nongmin jeonjaengseol-ui wonhyeong-eul chajaseo (Characteristics of Recognition of the Donghak Peasant Movement by Marxist Historians in the Late 1940s: Searching for the Origins of the So-called Peasant War Theory)", Donghak hakbo (Korea Journal of Donghak Studies), 10, pp.229~287 (1940)
  49. Ri, Seigen, "Chōsen shakaishi dokuhon (Korean Social History Reader)" (1936), Hakuyōsha
  50. Suh, Young-hee, "Tracing the Course of the Peasant War of 1894", Korea Journal, 34(4), pp.17~30 (1994)
  51. Tomba, Massimiliano, "Insurgent Universality: An Alternative Legacy of Modernity" (2019), Oxford University Press
  52. Tomba, Massimiliano, "Insurgent Universality: An Alternative Legacy of Modernity", Historical Materialism, 30(4), pp.62~70 (2022)
  53. Vovelle, Michel, "Peurangseu hyeongmyeong-gwa hanguk (French Revolution and Korea)" (1991), Ilwol Books
  54. Yasumaru, Yoshio, "‘Hōhō’ toshite no shisōshi (Intellectual History as Methodology)" (1996), Azekura Shobō
  55. Yeoksa munje yeonguso minjung saban, "Minjung gyeongheom-gwa maineoriti:Dong asia minjungsa-ui saeroun mosaek (Experiences of the Minjung, and Minorities: New Pursuits in the History of the Minjung in East Asia)" (2017), Kyungin
  56. Yeoksahak yeonguso, "Nongmin jeonjang 100-nyeon-uiinsik-gwa jaengjeom (A Hundred Years Since the Peasant War: Perceptions and Issues)" (1994), Georeum

관련 논문AI추천

Reconstructing Korea’s Minjung History: From the Subject of Resistance to a Pluralistic Historiography허영란한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2024 · 제64권 제4호Intersecting Perspectives in Labor History and New Minjung History장미현한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2024 · 제64권 제4호Foundations for the Legitimation of the Tonghak Peasant Army and Awareness of a New Political Order배항섭한국학연구원 · Acta Koreana2013 · 제16권 제2호근대전환기 사회운동사 연구의 현황과 제언 - 동학농민전쟁과 의병운동을 중심으로 -김헌주역사연구소 · 史叢(사총)2022 · 제107호1920-30년대 새로운 ‘동학농민전쟁상’의 형성배항섭수선사학회 · 사림2010 · 제36호‘새로운 민중사’의 등장과 새로운 동학농민전쟁史 서술에 대한 모색홍동현남도문화연구소 · 남도문화연구2014 · 제27호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)

[On this topic] The Genealogy of Minjung History and Its New Paths in South Korea허영란pp. 5-14Reconstructing Korea’s Minjung History: From the Subject of Resistance to a Pluralistic Historiography허영란pp. 15-38Intersecting Perspectives in Labor History and New Minjung History장미현pp. 64-86Disability History and Minjung as Affect소현숙pp. 87-110How South Korea Constructed a Shadow Carceral State through Institutions for People with Mental Disabilities in the 1980s황지성pp. 111-137
원문 보기