마쓰무라 다케오(松村武雄) 『일본동화집(日本童話集)』의 출전 고찰
A Study on the source of Matsumura Takeo’s Japan fairy tale collection
0
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
田中梅吉は朝鮮総督府学務局に提出した報告書(1917)に基づいて、1924年9 月に『朝鮮童話集』(朝鮮総督府)を刊行した。同年同月に松村武雄はそれまで 出版された東洋・西洋の文献説話と口伝説話を参照し『日本童話集』の中に、 植民地朝鮮の説話を収録している。1924年まで朝鮮に滞在したこともなく、 朝鮮語を駆使できなかった松村が限られた条件の中で、朝鮮説話を収録した 過程を実証することができた。本稿では具体的に松村が収録した27編の朝鮮説話の典拠を具体的に解明することができた。前代の説話集との具体的な対 照分析を通して考察した結果、松村の説話集は高木敏雄の説話集と深い関わ りを持っていることが確認できた。高木と松村は問題意識と関心という側面 で非常に類似している。松村は高木の伝播論に立脚した説話の移動と伝播に 関心を持ち、関連説話を収録したと思われる。実際に、松村は高木の説話集 から1編、高木が取り上げた『慵齋叢話』などの文献説話集から延べ9編を採 用し、高橋亨の『朝鮮の物語集』から7編、三輪環の『伝説の朝鮮』から8編 を採って、文献説話集と口伝説話集から延べ25編を採択したことが確認でき た。松村の説話集の後半部に収録された<26兎の目玉>と<27宝石捜し>はア-レ ン(Allen)の英文説話集から採択したことを実証的に検証できた。1908年に薄 田斬雲の<朝鮮叢話>(『暗黒なる朝鮮』所収)を皮切りに、1910年代·1920年代 に数多くの日本語朝鮮説話集が刊行された。このような状況の中で、松村は 1924年に東洋·西洋の文献を参考にして、日本説話集の中に植民地朝鮮の説話 を収録した。本稿では松村の説話論に対する具体的な検討の一環として、ま ずは松村の説話集の典拠を中心にその影響関係を考察した。松村の説話論と その改作様相に対する考察は今後の課題である。
Abstract
This study, as part of the concrete examination of Matsumura’s narratology, considered the influencing relationship focusing on the original text of Matsumura’s Fairy Tales. In September 1924, Tanaka Umekichi published Chosun Collection of Fairy Tales on the basis of the report of selected documents for Chosun fairy tales that was submitted to the Education Bureau of the Japanese Government-General of Korea. At the same period of time, in Tokyo, Matsumura included the fairy tales of colonial Chosun entitled “ Japanese Fairy Tales” on the basis oral folk tales and literature narratives that were published by then. Matsumura who has never stayed in Chosun and couldn’t speak Korean language until 1924 recorded the Chosun fairy tales within those limits. This study concretely explained the original text of all of 27 Chosun fairy tales included by Matsumura. As a result of specific comparison with previous fairy tales, I verified that Matsumura’s Fairy Tales has many similarities with Takagi Toshio’s Fairy Tales in regard to the critical mind and main concerns. Matsumura, being interested in movement and dissemination of fairy tales based on the Culture Diffusion Theory of Takagi, recorded the Chosun fairy tales and included 9 pieces from literature narratives, including 1 piece from Takagi’s Fairy Tales, 7 pieces from Volume 5 of YongJaeChonghua that was introduced by Takagi, “King’s ears are donkey’s” from SamgukYusa, “Bangi story” of Silla from Youyangjapjo of China. I also identified that Matsumura selected 8 pieces from Miwa Tamaki’s Fairy Tales, 7 pieces from Takahashi Toru’ Fairy Tales, totally 25 pieces. I verified he selected “eyes of rabbit” and “treasure hunt of cat and dog” that was included at the end of the book from English Fairy Tales of Allen. Starting with the <Chosun chongwa> of Usuda Zanun in 1908, a number of Japanese Korean narrative collection in 1910-1920s was published. In such a situation, Matsumura will refer to the literature of the East-West in 1924 , it was recorded colonial Chosunof narrative in Japan narrative collection. First, as part of a specific examination in this study for the narrative theory of Matsumura, it was considered the narrative collection of referenced by Matsumura of narrative collection. Matsumura is create your own fairy tale collections with reference to this that have been published previously. Consideration for the narrative theory and its retelling aspects of Matsumura is the next theme.
참고문헌 (19)
- Enshoff, "Koreanische Erzählungen", Zeitschrift des Vereins für Volkskunde, (22), pp.69~ (1912)
- 송재용, "조선의 설화와 전설-개화기 독일인 아르노스가 기록한 조선의 이야기", pp.29~ (2007), 제이앤씨
- 고대성의 창출과 심성교육 -구비전승(어문학)・교육, 부속도서관 장서분석을 통한 경성제국대학 학지의 연구, "김광식", 서울대 중앙도서관, 379~380 (2014)
- 김광식, "다카기 도시오(高木敏雄)의 조선민간전승 <조선동화집> 고찰", 일본연구, (55), pp.73~95 (2013), 일본연구소
- 김광식, "식민지 시기 일본어 조선설화집 기초적 연구", pp.188~ (2014), 제이앤씨
- 大竹聖美, "1920년대 일본의 아동총서와「조선동화집」", 동화와 번역, 2, pp.15~ (2001)
- 오윤선, "한국설화 영역본(英譯本)의 현황과 특징 일고찰 -<견묘쟁주설화(犬猫爭珠說話)>를 중심으로", 동화와 번역, (21), pp.207~239 (2011), 동화와번역연구소
- 오윤선, "근대초기 한국설화 영역자들의 번역태도 연구-Allen, Griffis, Hulbert, Carpenter를 중심으로-", 동화와 번역, (23), pp.205~231 (2012), 동화와번역연구소[DOI]
- 松村武雄, "日韓類話", 郷土研究, 2(4), pp.35~ (1914)
- 松村武雄, "童話及び児童の研究", pp.114~ (1922), 培風館
- 松村武雄, "日本童話集", pp.798~ (1924), 世界童話大系刊行会
- 金廣植, "帝国日本における「日本」説話集の中の朝鮮と台湾の位置付け", 日本植民地研究, (25), pp.56~57 (2013), 日本植民地研究會
- 金廣植, "1920年代前後における日韓比較説話学の展開―高木敏雄、清水兵三、孫晋泰を中心に", 比較民俗研究, 28, pp.11~13 (2013)
- 松前健, "神話(日本民族学會編『日本民族学の回顧と展望』)", pp.185~ (1966), 日本民族学協會
- 松本信広, "論集 日本文化の起源 第3巻,民族学Ⅰ", pp.9~ (1971), 平凡社
- 次田真幸, "高木敏雄における日本神話研究", 国文学 解釈と鑑賞, 37(1), pp.170~ (1972)
- 오타니 에이이치, "宗教とファシズム", pp.320~ (2010), 水声社
- 向川幹雄, "日本児童文学大事典 2巻", pp.159~ (1993), 大日本図書株式會社
- 中島惠子, "日本昔話事典", pp.293~ (1977), 弘文堂
