Indices/Indicators Developed to Evaluate the “Creating Supportive Environments” Mechanism of the Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion: A Setting-Based Review on Healthy Environment Indices/Indicators
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study aimed to identify the indices/indicators used for evaluating the “creating supportive environments” mechanism of the Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion, with a focus on built environments, in different settings. A search for literature with no time limit constraint was performed across Medline (via PubMed), Scopus, and Embase databases. Search terms included “Ottawa Charter,” “health promotion,” “supportive environments,” “built environ-ments,” “index,” and “indicator.” we included the studies conducted on developing, identifying, and/or measuring health promotion indices/indicators associated with “built environments” in different settings. The review articles were excluded. Extracted data included the type of instrument used for measuring the index/indicator, the number of items, participants, settings, the purpose of indices/indicators, and a minimum of two associated examples of the indices domains/indicators. The key definitions and summarized information from studies are presented in tables. In total, 281 studies were included in the review, within which 36 indices/indicators associated with “built environ-ment” were identified. The majority of the studies (77%) were performed in developed countries. Based on their ap-plication in different settings, the indices/indicators were categorized into seven groups: (1) Healthy Cities (n=5), (2) Healthy Municipalities and Communities (n=18), (3) Healthy Markets (n=3), (4) Healthy Villages (n=1), (5) Healthy Workplaces (n=4), (6) Health-Promoting Schools (n=3), and (7) Healthy Hospitals (n=3). Health promotion special-ists, health policymakers, and social health researchers can use this collection of indices/indicators while designing/evaluating interventions to create supportive environments for health in various settings.
Abstract
This study aimed to identify the indices/indicators used for evaluating the “creating supportive environments” mechanism of the Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion, with a focus on built environments, in different settings. A search for literature with no time limit constraint was performed across Medline (via PubMed), Scopus, and Embase databases. Search terms included “Ottawa Charter,” “health promotion,” “supportive environments,” “built environ-ments,” “index,” and “indicator.” we included the studies conducted on developing, identifying, and/or measuring health promotion indices/indicators associated with “built environments” in different settings. The review articles were excluded. Extracted data included the type of instrument used for measuring the index/indicator, the number of items, participants, settings, the purpose of indices/indicators, and a minimum of two associated examples of the indices domains/indicators. The key definitions and summarized information from studies are presented in tables. In total, 281 studies were included in the review, within which 36 indices/indicators associated with “built environ-ment” were identified. The majority of the studies (77%) were performed in developed countries. Based on their ap-plication in different settings, the indices/indicators were categorized into seven groups: (1) Healthy Cities (n=5), (2) Healthy Municipalities and Communities (n=18), (3) Healthy Markets (n=3), (4) Healthy Villages (n=1), (5) Healthy Workplaces (n=4), (6) Health-Promoting Schools (n=3), and (7) Healthy Hospitals (n=3). Health promotion special-ists, health policymakers, and social health researchers can use this collection of indices/indicators while designing/evaluating interventions to create supportive environments for health in various settings.
참고문헌 (57)
- Pie MR, "Nest architecture, activity pattern, worker density and the dynamics of disease transmission in social insects", J Theor Biol, 226, pp.45~51 (2004)
- World Health Organization, "Preventing disease through healthy environments : a global assessment of the burden of disease from environmental risks" (2016), World Health Organization
- Zardini M, "Imperfect health: the medicalization of architecture" (2012), Lars Muller Publishers
- (2021)[URL]
- Poland B, "Securing ‘supportive environments’for health in the face of ecosystem collapse : meeting the triple threat with a sociology of creative transformation", Health Promot Int, 26(Suppl 2), pp.ii202~ii215 (2011)
- World Health Organization, "Healthy settings" (2013), World Health Organization
- Mahase E, "Prevention green paper lacks ambition, say critics", BMJ, 366, pp.l4829~ (2019)
- (1986)[URL]
- Jackson SF, "Integrated health promotion strategies : a contribution to tackling current and future health challenges", Health Promot Int, 21(Suppl 1), pp.75~83 (2006)
- Zinsstag J, "From"one medicine"to"one health"and systemic approaches to health and well-being", Prev Vet Med, 101, pp.148~156 (2011)
- Fry D, "Applying the Ottawa Charter to inform health promotion programme design", Health Promot Int, 32, pp.901~912 (2017)
- Kaur M, "Evaluating the performance of health promotion interventions", Indian J Med Res, 142, pp.109~112 (2015)
- Saadati F, "Indices and indicators developed to evaluate the"strengthening community actions"mechanism of the Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion : a scoping review", Am J Health Promot, 36, pp.881~893 (2022)
- O’Connor-Fleming ML, "A framework for evaluating health promotion programs", Health Promot J Austr, 17, pp.61~66 (2006)
- Ontario Agency for Health Protection and Promotion (Public Health Ontario), "Evaluating health promotion programs:introductory workbook" (2016), Ontario Agency for Health Protection and Promotion (Public Health Ontario)
- (2011)[URL]
- Giannoccaro R, "Measuring citizen satisfaction with aspects of public services from a local authority and determining their importance : a case study", Public Organ Rev, 8, pp.1~15 (2008)
- Lister-Sharp D, "Health promoting schools and health promotion in schools : two systematic reviews", Health Technol Assess, 3, pp.1~207 (1999)
- Watt R, "Oral health promotion evaluation : time for development", Community Dent Oral Epidemiol, 29, pp.161~166 (2001)
- Lindacher V, "Evaluation of empowerment in health promotion interventions : a systematic review", Eval Health Prof, 41, pp.351~392 (2018)
- Papas MA, "The built environment and obesity", Epidemiol Rev, 29, pp.129~143 (2007)
- [URL]
- Grant M, "Urban planning, environment and health: from evidence to policy action", pp.22~97 (2010), WHO Regional Office for Europe
- Pineo H, "Promoting a healthy cities agenda through indicators : development of a global urban environment and health index", Cities Health, 2, pp.27~45 (2018)
- Nakamura K, "Healthy cities & urban policy research", pp.86~113 (2003), Routledge
- Handy SL, "How the built environment affects physical activity : views from urban planning", Am J Prev Med, 23(2 Suppl), pp.64~73 (2002)
- de Leeuw E, "Evaluating WHO Healthy Cities in Europe : issues and perspectives", J Urban Health, 90(Suppl 1), pp.14~22 (2013)
- O’Neill M, "Choosing indicators to evaluate Healthy Cities projects : a political task?", Health Promot Int, 21, pp.145~152 (2006)
- Rice M, "Healthy cities: the theory, policy, and practice of value-based urban planning", pp.151~213 (2017), Springer
- Jansson EV, "Health promotion at local level : a case study of content, organization and development in four Swedish municipalities", BMC Public Health, 10, pp.455~ (2010)
- Rice M, "Lessons learned from the application of a participatory evaluation methodology to healthy municipalities, cities and communities initiatives in selected countries of the Americas", Promot Educ, 14, pp.68~73 (2007)
- Pruss-Ustun A, "Environmental risks and non-communicable diseases", BMJ, 364, pp.l265~ (2019)
- Babey SH, "Designed for disease:the link between local food environments and obesity and diabetes" (2018), UCLA Center for Health Policy Research
- Hilmers A, "Neighborhood disparities in access to healthy foods and their effects on environmental justice", Am J Public Health, 102, pp.1644~1654 (2012)
- Tavares LF, "Development and application of healthiness indicators for commercial establishments that sell foods for immediate consumption", Foods, 10, pp.1434~ (2021)
- Glanz K, "Healthy nutrition environments : concepts and measures", Am J Health Promot, 19, pp.330~333 (2005)
- Nutrition and food systems: a report by the High Level Panel of Experts on Food Security and Nutrition of the Committee on World Food Security, "HLPE Steering Committee", HLPE Steering Committee, ~ (2017)
- Ni Mhurchu C, "Monitoring the availability of healthy and unhealthy foods and non-alcoholic beverages in community and consumer retail food environments globally", Obes Rev, 14(Suppl 1), pp.108~119 (2013)
- Vandevijvere S, "Indicators of the relative availability of healthy versus unhealthy foods in supermarkets : a validation study", Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act, 14, pp.53~ (2017)
- Kelloway EK, "Building healthy workplaces : what we know so far", Can J Behav Sci, 37, pp.223~235 (2005)
- Sparling PB, "Worksite health promotion : principles, resources, and challenges", Prev Chronic Dis, 7, pp.A25~ (2010)
- Johnson K, "Building capacity and sustainable prevention innovations : a sustainability planning model", Eval Program Plan, 27, pp.135~149 (2004)
- Roemer EC, "Reliability and validity of the American Heart Association’s workplace health achievement index", Am J Health Promot, 36, pp.148~154 (2022)
- Lindberg P, "Indicators of healthy work environments : a systematic review", Work, 41(Suppl 1), pp.3032~3038 (2012)
- McGrail MR, "The index of rural access : an innovative integrated approach for measuring primary care access", BMC Health Serv Res, 9, pp.124~ (2009)
- Allahyari MS, "Healthy village cooperative : an approach towards rural development", Sci Res Essays, 5, pp.2867~2874 (2010)
- West G, "The tale of two villages", Glob J Community Psychol Pract, 12, pp.1~12 (2022)
- Penchansky R, "The concept of access : definition and relationship to consumer satisfaction", Med Care, 19, pp.127~140 (1981)
- Kiyu A, "Evaluation of the Healthy Village program in Kapit district, Sarawak, Malaysia", Health Promot Int, 21, pp.13~18 (2006)
- World Health Organization Regional Office for the Eastern Mediterranean, "Evaluation of the healthy village programme in the Syrian Arab Republic" (2007), World Health Organization Regional Office for the Eastern Mediterranean
- Gugglberger L, "Capacity building in and for health promoting schools : results from a qualitative study", Health Policy, 101, pp.37~43 (2011)
- Durlak JA, "Implementation matters : a review of research on the influence of implementation on program outcomes and the factors affecting implementation", Am J Community Psychol, 41, pp.327~350 (2008)
- Lee A, "Effective health promoting school for better health of children and adolescents : indicators for success", BMC Public Health, 19, pp.1088~ (2019)
- Taber DR, "Socioeconomic differences in the association between competitive food laws and the school food environment", J Sch Health, 85, pp.578~586 (2015)
- Mukoma W, "Evaluations of health promoting schools : a review of nine studies", Health Promot Int, 19, pp.357~368 (2004)
- Report on the 11th WHO Workshop of National, "Regional Health Promoting Hospitals Network Coordinators: Dublin, Ireland, 18 May 2005", Regional Office for Europe of the World Health Organization, 2005
- McHugh C, "Health promoting health services : a review of the evidence", Health Promot Int, 25, pp.230~237 (2010)