ICSID 협약 제52조의 계약상 포기에 관한 연구
A Study on the Contractual Waiver of Article 52 ICSID Convention
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
이 논문은 ICSID 협약 제52조에 대한 계약상 포기의 제안 사유 , 유효성 및 계약상 포기에 대해, 그동안 ICSID 중재에 참여하고 관련분야를 연구해온 학자들의 다양한 의견을 중심으로실무상 쟁점과 이에 대한 대응방안을 제시하는데 목적이 있다.
Abstract
This article examines whether parties may agree to contractually waive the right to bring annulment proceedings. Alternately it looks at whether certain grounds of annulment may be waived. The ability for parties to resolve this issue contractually by waiving this element of Article 52(1)(b) ICSID offers a potentially powerful solution. For parties to agree beforehand to the circumstances where tribunals have not ‘manifestly exceeded their power’ could allow them to remove the unpredictability of annulment on this foundation. Even in the event that an ad hoc committee is against the validity of waiver, it may be possible for a party to frame this restriction as an interpretative agreement by the parties rather than strictly as waiver of a ground of annulment. Ultimately, the wish to enter into such an agreement would likely only be driven by a few exceptional commercial need or prior negative experience with the remedy of annulment. In that cases, and depending on the nature of the specific concern with annulment, a limited waiver or interpretative agreement on certain Article 52(1) ICSID grounds may certainly be appropriate.
참고문헌 (40)
- 김상찬, "ICSID 중재판정 취소제도", 중재연구, 25(2), pp.71~96 (2015), 한국중재학회[DOI]
- 김용일, "국제투자협정상 공정하고 공평한 대우에 관한 연구", 중재연구, 22(3), pp.187~213 (2012), 한국중재학회[DOI]
- 김용일, "ICSID 중재판정의 재심제도에 관한 연구 - 중재판정의 취소 사례를 중심으로 -", 국제상학, 28(3), pp.207~227 (2013), 한국국제상학회[DOI]
- 박건도, "ICSID 協約上 取消制度의 性格 및 取消事由에 관한 小考:明白한 越權 및 理由 未記載를 中心으로", 법과정책연구, 10(3), pp.1143~1168 (2010), 한국법정책학회[DOI]
- 오원석, "ICSID 중재의 취소제도에 관한 제 고찰", 중재연구, 24(4), pp.3~28 (2014), 한국중재학회[DOI]
- Baizeau, D., "Waiving the Right to Challenge an Arbitral Award Rendered in Switzerland: Caveats and Drafting Considerations for Foreign Parties", International Arbitration Law Review, 8(3), pp.69~ (2005)
- Bjorklund, A., "State Immunity and the Enforcement of Investor-State Arbitral Awards in International Investment Law for the 21st Century" (2009), Oxford University Press
- Blome, M., "Contractual waiver of Article 52 ICSID: a solution to the concerns with annulment?", Arbitration International, 32 (2016)
- Broches, A., "Observations on the Finality of ICSID Awards", ICSID Review–FJIL, 7, pp.196~ (1992)
- Broches, A., "Awards Rendered Pursuant to the ICSID Convention: Binding Force, Finality, Recognition, Enforcement, Execution", ICSID Review–FJIL, 2(2), pp.287~ (1987)
- Campbell, M., "International Investment Arbitration" (2008)
- Crawford, J., "The Exception of Non-performance: Links between the Law of Treaties and the Law of State Responsibility", Austrian Yearbook of International Law, 21, pp.55~ (2000)
- Delaume, G. R., "The Finality of Arbitration Involving States: Recent Developments", Arbitration International, 5, pp.21~ (1989)
- Delaume, G.R., "How to Draft an ICSID Arbitration Clause", ICSID Review–FJIL, 7, pp.169~ (1992)
- Gaillard, E., "Some Notes on the Drafting of ICSID Arbitration Clauses", ICSID Review –FILJ, 3, pp.136~ (1988)
- Gharavi, H., "ICSID: the Elephant in the Room", Global Arbitration Review, 3, pp.10~1 (2015)
- Goldberg, D., "ICSID Caught in Conflict", Commercial Dispute Resolution Magazine, ~ (2013)
- Hodgson, M., "Costs in Investment Treaty Arbitration: The Case for Reform", Transnational Dispute Management, 11, pp.1~ (2014)
- Hunter, M., "Law and Practice of International Commercial Arbitration" (2004)
- ICSID, "Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States, Analysis of Documents Concerning the Origin and the Formulation of the Convention", ~ (1970)
- ICSID, "Background Paper on Annulment for the Administrative Council of ICSID", ICSID Review–FIJL, 27, pp.443~ (2012)
- ICSID, "The ICSID Caseload–Statistics", ~ (2014)
- ICSID, "The ICSID Caseload–Statistics", ~ (2018)
- Jacob, K.S., "Reinvigorating ICSID With a New Mission and With Renewed Respect for Party Autonomy", Virginia Journal of International Law, 33, pp.123~ (1992)
- Khachvani, D., "Exclusion of Right to Challenge the Arbitral Award", Latin American Journal of International Trade Law, 2(1) (2014)
- Lalive, P., "Annulment of ICSID Awards" (2004), Juris Publishing Inc
- Patocchi, P.M., "International Arbitration in Switzerland" (2000), Kluwer Law International
- Paulsson, J., "ICSID’s Achievements and Prospects", ICSID Review–FILJ, 6, pp.380~ (1991)
- Peter, W, "Arbitration and Renegotiation of International Investment Agreements" (1995), Kluwer Law International
- Pieter, S., "THE WORK OF UNCITRAL ON ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION" (2004), Kluwer Law International
- Redfern, A., "ICSID–Losing its Appeal?", Arbitration International, 3, pp.98~ (1987)
- Reisman, W.M., "The Breakdown of the Control Mechanism in ICSID Arbitration", Duke Law Journal, 4, pp.739~ (1989)
- Rigaux, A., "The Vienna Conventions on the Law of Treaties: A Commentary, Vol. II" (2011)
- Schreuer, C., "Annulment Under the ICSID Convention Awards" (2004)
- Schreuer, C., "From ICSID Annulment to Appeal: Half Way Down the Slippery Slope", The Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals, 10, pp.211~ (2011)
- Schreuer, C., "The ICSID Convention: A Commentary" (2009)
- Schwebel, S., "ICCA Congress Miami Opening Ceremony", ~ (2014)
- Stirk, D., "Growing Number of Countries Allowing for Exclusion Agreements with Respect to Annulment Warrants Greater Scrutiny of Arbitration Clauses", Kluwer Arbitration Blog, ~ (2012)
- Van Houte, H., "Article 52 of the Washington Convention: A. Brief Introduction in E. Gaillard and Y. Banifatemi Annulment of ICSID Awards" (2004), Juris Publishing Inc
- Williams, D., "Arbitration and Dispute Resolution", NZ Law Review, 119 (2005)