본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

The Principle of Confidentiality in Arbitration: A Necessary Crisis

Bernardo M. Cremades|Rodrigo Cortés
한국중재학회 (Korean Association Of Arbitration Studies(Kaas))|2013.09|중재연구 (JOURNAL OF ARBITRATION STUDIES)|제23권 제3호|pp. 25-38|DOI 10.16998/jas.2013.23.3.25

0

조회

0

다운로드

2

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

PublicityArbitrationConfidentialityAwardCommercial ArbitrationInvestments Arbitration
주제분류무역학

초록

Confidentiality has always been considered one of the most important aspects of arbitral proceedings and until recently a principle that could never be ignored. However, under the shadow of the increasing number of arbitral cases in which States are involved, there has recently been a tendency towards publicity, not only in investment protection arbitrations but also in commercial arbitrations. That said, many questions arise: in the event of a conflict between confidentiality and publicity, which should prevail? What role does the arbitrator play in this conflict? Does confidentiality provide more benefits than harm.

Abstract

Confidentiality has always been considered one of the most important aspects of arbitral proceedings and until recently a principle that could never be ignored. However, under the shadow of the increasing number of arbitral cases in which States are involved, there has recently been a tendency towards publicity, not only in investment protection arbitrations but also in commercial arbitrations. That said, many questions arise: in the event of a conflict between confidentiality and publicity, which should prevail? What role does the arbitrator play in this conflict? Does confidentiality provide more benefits than harm.

참고문헌 (39)

  1. Edwards, "Confidentiality in Arbitration, fact or fiction?", International arbitration law review (2001)
  2. Redfern, M. Hunter, "Law and Practice of International Commercial Arbitration" (2004), Sweet & Maxwell
  3. Bernardo M. Cremades, "La participación de los estados en el arbitraje internacional", conferencia dictada en el Congreso Latinoamericano y caribeño de arbitraje comercial internacional (2010)
  4. Christoph Müller, "La confidentialité en arbitrage commercial international: un trompe‐l’oeil? On est souvent satisfait d’être trompé par soi‐même", ASA Bulletin, 23(2) (2005)
  5. Cindy Buys, "The tensions between confidentiality and transparency in international arbitration", American Review of International Arbitration, 14(121) (2003)
  6. "La Privacidad del Arbitraje"[URL]
  7. The Confidentiality of Arbitration: Evolution or Mutation Following ESSO, "BHP v. Plowman", Edouard Bertrand, 1996, Revue de Droit International des affaires, No. 2
  8. Le Principe de Confidentialité de l’Arbitrage Commercial International, "Emanuel Gaillard", en Recueil Dalloz, ~ (1987)
  9. Nuevas Perspectivas sobre la Privacidad y Confidencialidad en el arbitraje Internacional, "Enrique Chávez Bardales", Lima Arbitration, ~, pp.Lima Arbitration no. 3 ‐ 2008 (2009)
  10. Privacidad y confidencialidad en el Arbitraje Comercial Internacional, "Enrique Chávez Bardales", Revista Ibroamericana de Arbitraje, ~
  11. Les Obligations de confidentialité dans l’arbitrage, "Eric Loquin", ~ (2006)
  12. Fernando Cantuarias Salaverry, "Algunos cortos apuntes acerca de la nueva ley de arbitraje peruana", Revista Internacional de Arbitraje, (10) (2009), Bogotá
  13. "Fernando Canturrias Salaverrry y Roque Caivano, La nueva ley de arbitraje peruana, Revista Peruana de arbitraje", ~ (2008)
  14. Francisco González de Cossío, "Arbitraje" (2004), Editorial Porrúa
  15. Hans Bagner, "The Confidentiality Conundrum in International Arbitration", ICC international Court of arbitration bulletin, 12(1) (2001)
  16. Report on confidentiality as a purported obligation of the parties in arbitration, "ICC Commission on international arbitration", ~, pp.document 420 (2009), 20‐009 Rev
  17. Iñigo Iruretagoiena, "Atenuación de los Rasgos de Confidencialidad y Privacidad del Arbitraje de Inversión", Revista de Arbitraje comercial y de Inversiones, 1 (2008)
  18. Jan Paulsson y Nigel Radwing, "The Trouble with Confidentiality", en Arbitration International, 11(3) (1995)
  19. Le secret de délibéré arbitral, "Jean Denis Bredin", Études offertes à Pierre Bellet, ~ (1991)
  20. La confidentialité et le délibéré, "Jean‐Paul Beraudo", Les Arbitres Internationaux, ~ (2005)
  21. Jorge Fábrega, "Arbitraje en el área Iberoamericana", XII Jornadas Iberoamericanas de Derecho Procesal
  22. "El Arbitraje con el Estado"[URL]
  23. "Crisis del Paradigma de la Confidencialidad en el Arbitraje Comercial"[URL]
  24. José Carlos Fernández Rozas, "Trayectoria y Contornos del Mito de la Confidencialidad en el Arbitraje Comercial", Revista de Arbitraje Comercial y de Inversiones, 2(2)
  25. A confidencialidad na arbitragem, "José Emilio Nunes Pinto", ~, pp.Revista de Arbitragem e Mediaçao, No. 6 (2005)
  26. José F. Merino Merchán, "Confidencialidad y Arbitraje", Spain Arbitration Review (2008)
  27. José Rosell, "Confidentiality and arbitration, en Croatian Arbitration Yearbook, Vol. 9" (2002)
  28. "Confidencialidad del Proceso Arbitral?"[URL]
  29. Arbitraje Comercial, "Julio César Rivera", Internacional y Doméstico, ~ (2007)
  30. "Hacia un arbitraje transparente" (2011)[URL]
  31. "Confidencialidad en el Arbitraje"[URL]
  32. International Arbitration. Law and Practice, "Mauro Rubino‐Sanmartano", Kluwer Law International, ~ (2001)
  33. Rodolfo Dávalos, "La Proyectada Corte de Arbitraje de la OHADAC, Revista de Arbitraje comercial y de Inversiones, Vol. 4" (2011)
  34. Roque J. Caivano, "El deber de confidencialidad de los árbitros en el arbitraje comercial desde un enfoque comparativo", Lima Arbitration, (4) (2010)
  35. "Thomas Clay, L’arbitre, Paris", ~ (2001)
  37. United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, "Settlement of Commercial Disputes: Preparation of a Legal standard on Transparency in Treaty‐based Investor‐State Arbitration", ~ (2013)
  38. "Las Ventajas del Arbitraje Internacional: una Perspectiva Ecuatoriana"[URL]
  39. Yves Fortier, "The Occasionally Unwarranted Assumption of Confindentiality", Arbitration International, 15(2) (1999)

관련 논문AI추천

Confidentiality and the Riddick Principle in International Commercial Arbitration안건형한국중재학회 · 중재연구2021 · 제31권 제3호Due Process, Confidentiality and Impartiality: A Study on Arbitration Principles in the Post-Pandemic Digital Environment미리암 바르톨로치한국중재학회 · 중재연구2024 · 제34권 제3호The Integrity of Finality of International Arbitral Awards: International Commercial and ICSID Arbitration Awards전정원한국중재학회 · 중재연구2018 · 제28권 제2호Scrutiny of Arbitral Awards by Arbitration Institutions in International Arbitration: Focusing on the ICC’s Scrutiny of Award Process전정원법과정책연구원 · 법과정책2017 · 제23권 제2호The Principle of Facticity:Outline for a Theory of Evidence in ArbitrationOctávio Fragata Martins de Barros한국중재학회 · 중재연구2013 · 제23권 제4호ICC's Competitiveness in Investment Treaty ArbitrationAhmet Cemil Yıldırım한국중재학회 · 중재연구2025 · 제35권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

The Word is not Enough – Arbitration, Choice of Forum and Choice of Law Clauses Under the CISGDavid Tebel, Ingeborg Schwenzerpp. 1-23The Use of the UNIDROIT Principles as Neutral Law in ArbitrationHenry Deeb Gabrielpp. 39-59The Legal Characteristics of Consumer Arbitration Clause and Defenses in the U.S. Contract Laws하충룡pp. 61-80Time Limits in Challenging a Tribunal s JurisdictionChan Leng Sun, 한예원pp. 81-99The Development of International Sports Arbitration Bodies and Challenges of Legislative Policy for Reestablishment of Sports Arbitration Agency in Korea연기영pp. 101-126
원문 보기