Jurisdiction of the Arbitral Tribunal in the Case of Multiple Contracts
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The foundation of the arbitration jurisdiction is the arbitration agreement entered into by the parties to a contract. Usually, only the signatory parties to a contract and the disputes arising from a contract that includes an arbitration clause or to which the arbitration clause relates are the ones that can be submitted to arbitration. This article discusses some of the arguments for extending the arbitration clause in complex arbitrations, that is, in those cases where there are more than two parties, more than two contracts or more than two parties and contracts. Particularly, this paper addresses multiple contract arbitration when the contracts are related. One of the arguments used by the arbitral tribunal for the extension of jurisdiction is the existence of a link between the contracts. Additional arguments include implied consent, participation in the negotiation and performance of a contract and good faith. The article also discusses some of the typical cases of linked contracts in many civil law countries, such as subcontracts, third party beneficiaries and standard terms of contracts, from which arbitral jurisdictions problems may arise. Finally, special attention is given to Article 14 of the 2008 Peruvian Arbitration Law as the first provision in an arbitration law in Latin America that extends the arbitration agreement to non-signatory parties using for this a mixed approach.
Abstract
The foundation of the arbitration jurisdiction is the arbitration agreement entered into by the parties to a contract. Usually, only the signatory parties to a contract and the disputes arising from a contract that includes an arbitration clause or to which the arbitration clause relates are the ones that can be submitted to arbitration. This article discusses some of the arguments for extending the arbitration clause in complex arbitrations, that is, in those cases where there are more than two parties, more than two contracts or more than two parties and contracts. Particularly, this paper addresses multiple contract arbitration when the contracts are related. One of the arguments used by the arbitral tribunal for the extension of jurisdiction is the existence of a link between the contracts. Additional arguments include implied consent, participation in the negotiation and performance of a contract and good faith. The article also discusses some of the typical cases of linked contracts in many civil law countries, such as subcontracts, third party beneficiaries and standard terms of contracts, from which arbitral jurisdictions problems may arise. Finally, special attention is given to Article 14 of the 2008 Peruvian Arbitration Law as the first provision in an arbitration law in Latin America that extends the arbitration agreement to non-signatory parties using for this a mixed approach.
참고문헌 (35)
- Alan Redfern, "Nigel Blackaby and Constantine Partasides, Redfern and Hunter on International Arbitration" (2009)
- American Law Institute, "Restatement of Contracts Second" (1981), St. Paul
- Alfredo Bullard González, "Carlos Soto Coaguila, Comentarios a la Ley Peruana de Arbitraje, Vol. I" (2011), Instituto Peruano de Arbitraje
- Bernard Teyssie, "Les groupes de contrats", LJDG, (139) (1975)
- Bernard Hanotiau, "Complex Arbitrations, Multiparty, Multicontract, Multi-Issue and Class Actions" (2005), Kluwer Law International
- "Black´s Law Dictionary" (1999), Seventh Ed. St. Paul
- Denis Alland, "Dictionnaire de la Culture" (2003), Juridique
- E. Allan Farnsworth, "Farnsworth on Contracts" (2004)
- Fatma Salah, "Extension of Petroleum Arbitration Agreements", Journal of International Arbitration, 30 (2013), Kluwer Law International
- "FIDIC Contracts Guide", Lausanne, ~ (2000)
- Francesco Messineo, "Encyclopedia del Diritto, Vol. X" (1962), Milan
- Francisco Fernández Urzainqui, "Código Civil" (2011)
- François-Xavier Train, "Les contrats lies devant l'arbitre du commerce international: étude de jurisprudence arbitrale" (2003), LGDJ
- Gary Born, "International Commercial Arbitration, Volume I" (2014), Kluwer Law International
- James Otis Rodner, "Los Contratos Enlazados, El Subcontrato, Academia de Ciencias Políticas y Sociales" (2013)
- Jacques Ghestin, "Cause de l'engagement et validité du contrat" (2006)
- Jean-Luc Aubert, "Notions et rôles de l’offre et l’acceptation dans la formation des contrats" (1970), LGDJ
- Jean Marguerat, "Arbitraje Comercial Internacional en Europa" (2013)
- John McGhee, "Snell’s Equity" (2000)
- Jorge Satistevan, "Extensión del Convenio Arbitral a Partes No-Signatarias: Expresión de la inevitabilidad del arbitraje", Revista Peruana de Arbitraje, 8 (2008)
- José Augusto Quelhas Lima Engrácia Antunes, "Os Grupos de Sociedades" (2002), Almedina
- José Melich-Orsini, "Doctrina General del Contrato" (2014), Academia de Ciencias Políticas y Sociales
- Luis Corsi, "La responsabilidad decenal" (1998)
- Miguel Pasquau Liaño, "La acción directa en el derecho español" (1989)
- Mireille Bacache Gibeili, "La relativité des conventions et les groupes de contrats" (1996), LGDJ
- Pablo Mori Bregante, "Aplicación del Artículo 14 de la Ley Peruana de Arbitraje al Caso de los Grupo de Sociedades . Anuario Latinoamericano de Arbitraje, Aplicación del Convenio Arbitral a Partes No Signatarias", Intervención de Terceros en el Arbitraje, ~ (2012)
- Pedro Romano Martinez, "O Subcontrato" (2006)
- Philip I. Blumberg, "The law of corporate groups, enterprise liability in commercial relationships" (1998), Aspen
- Philippe Fouchard, "Emmanuel Gaillard and Bethold Goldman" (1996), Traité de l’arbitrage commercial international
- Ricardo Enrique La Roche, "Código de Procedimiento Civil - Anotaciones , Vol. I" (1995)
- Roque Caivano, "Arbitraje y estipulación a favor de terceros bajo el derecho peruano", Revista Forseti, (1) (2014)
- Sanne van Dongen, "roups of Contracts: an exploration of the types and the archetype from a Dutch Legal Perspective in Ilse Samoy and Marco Loos" (2012), Linked contracts
- Sigvard Jarvin, "Collection of ICC Arbitral Awards, Volumes I, IV and V" (1994), Kluwer Law and Taxation Publishers
- "UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts 2010", Unidroit, ~ (2010)
- "Yearbook Commercial Arbitration, Volume XXXII", Kluwer Law International BV, ~ (2007)