CISG and Arbitration Agreements: A Janus-Faced Practice and How to Cope with It
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Arbitration clauses or institutional arbitration rules rarely, if ever, specify the law applicable to the arbitration agreement. A wide range of laws may thus govern this question, such as the law at the place of arbitration, the law where the agreement or the award is enforced or the law of the main contract between the parties. It is also conceivable that international uniform law or soft law may play a role. Tribunals and courts seized with this question must consequently decide which of these various laws shall apply to verify the existence and validity of the arbitration agreement. This paper picks up on this controversially debated conflict of laws issue. At times, this debate is characterized by a strong divide between arbitration and international trade law practitioners. But are the different approaches really leading to diverging results in arbitral practice?
Abstract
Arbitration clauses or institutional arbitration rules rarely, if ever, specify the law applicable to the arbitration agreement. A wide range of laws may thus govern this question, such as the law at the place of arbitration, the law where the agreement or the award is enforced or the law of the main contract between the parties. It is also conceivable that international uniform law or soft law may play a role. Tribunals and courts seized with this question must consequently decide which of these various laws shall apply to verify the existence and validity of the arbitration agreement. This paper picks up on this controversially debated conflict of laws issue. At times, this debate is characterized by a strong divide between arbitration and international trade law practitioners. But are the different approaches really leading to diverging results in arbitral practice?
참고문헌 (54)
- Peter Schlechtriem, "Kommentar zum Einheitlichen UN-Kaufrecht -CISG" (2013), C.H. Beck
- Stefan Kröll, "UN-Convention on the International Sale of Goods (CISG) - Commentary" (2011), C.H. Beck
- Herbert Kronke, "Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards: A Global Commentary on the New York Convention" (2010), Kluwer Law International
- Wolfgang Krüger, "Münchener Kommentar zum BGB, Volume 3" (2012), C.H. Beck
- Bamberger, "Beck`scher Online-Kommentar BGB, Stand: 01.05.2015", pp.2015, Roth
- Franco Ferrari, "Internationales Vertragsrecht" (2011), C.H. Beck
- Karl-Heinz Böckstiegel, "Arbitration in Germany, The Model Law in Practice" (2015), Kluwer Law International
- Reinmar Wolff, "New York Convention - Commentary" (2012), Hart Publishing
- Richard Zöller, "ZPO, Dr" (2014), Otto Schmidt
- Friedrich Stein, "ZPO Kommentar, Volume 10" (2014), Mohr Siebeck
- Alan Redfern, "Redfern and Hunter on International Arbitration" (2009), Kluwer Law International
- Philippe Fouchard, "International Commercial Arbitration" (1999), Kluwer Law International
- Karl Heinz Schwab, "Schiedsgerichtsbarkeit" (2005), Helbing & Lichtenhahn
- Julian Lew, "Comparative International Commercial Arbitration" (2003), Kluwer Law International
- Jeffrey Waincymer, "Procedure and Evidence in International Arbitration" (2012), Kluwer Law International
- Leonardo Graffi, "Conflict of Laws in International Arbitration, sellier" (2011), euopean law publishers
- Frank-Bernd Weigand, "Practitioner´s Handbook on International Arbitration" (2010), Oxford University Press
- Gary Born, "International Commercial Arbitration" (2014), Kluwer Law International
- Gary Born, "International Commercial Arbitration in the United States, Commentary &Materials" (1994), Kluwer Law
- Jean-François Poudret, "Comparative Law of International Arbitration" (2007), Sweet & Maxwell
- Jean-François Poudret, "Droit comparé de l´arbitrage international" (2002), Schulthess
- Michael Bühler, "Handbook of ICC Arbitration" (2014), weet & Maxwell
- Manuel Arroyo, "Arbitration in Switzerland: The Practitioner´s Guide" (2013), Kluwer Law International
- Bernhard Berger, "International and Domestic Arbitration in Switzerland" (2010), Sweet & Maxwell
- Jan Paulsson, "The Idea of Arbitration" (2013), Oxford University Press
- James Carter, "International Commercial Arbitration in New York" (2012), Oxford University Press
- David St. John Sutton, "Russell on Arbitration" (2007), Sweet &Maxwell
- Christoph Reithmann, "Internationales Vertragsrecht" (2010), Otto Schmidt
- Christophe Seraglini, "Droit de l’arbitrage interne et international" (2013), Montchrestien
- Loukas Mistelis, "CISG Methodology, sellier", pp.375~ (2009), european law publishers
- Ingeborg Schwenzer, "The CISG - A Story of Worldwide Success", CISG Part II Conference, pp.119~ (2009)
- V. V. Veeder, "Summary of Discussion in The First Working Group", Improving the Efficiency of Arbitration Agreements and Awards: 40 Years of Application of the New York Convention, ICCA Congress Series, 9, pp.43~ (1999), Kluwer Law International
- Ingeborg Schwenzer, "The Word is not Enough – Arbitration, Choice of Forum and Choice of Law Clauses Under the CISG", 중재연구, 23(3), pp.1~23 (2013), 한국중재학회
- Jennifer Gorskie, "US Courts and the Anti-Arbitration Injunction", Arbitration International, 28, pp.295~ (2012)
- Julian Lew, "The Law Applicable to the Form and Substance of the Arbitration Clause", Improving the Efficiency of Arbitration Agreements and Awards: 40 Years of Application of the New York Convention, ICCA Congress Series, 9, pp.113~ (1999), Kluwer Law International
- Michael Stürner, "Das Schiedsvereinbarungsstatut bei vertraglichen Streitigkeiten", Praxis des International Privat- und Verfahrensrechts, 473~ (2014)
- Dominique Hascher, "European Convention on International Commercial Arbitration 1961, Commentary", pp.504~ (2011), Yearbook Commercial Arbitration
- Pilar Perales Viscasillas, "CISG & Arbitration", pp.63~ (2011), Spain Arbitration Review
- Pierre Karrer, "The Law Applicable to the Arbitration Agreement", Singapore Academy of Law Journal, 26, pp.849~ (2014)
- Rolf Schütze, "Kollisionsrechtliche Probleme der Schiedsvereinbarung, insbesondere der Erstreckung ihrer Bindungswirkung auf Dritte", SchiedsVZ, pp.274~ (2014)
- Keechang Kim, "Arbitration Agreement under Korean Law", Korea University Law Review, 3, pp.83~ (2008)
- Alexander Grimm, "Applicability of the Rome I and II Regulations to International Arbitration", SchiedsVZ, pp.189~ (2012)
- François-Xavier Train, "L'affaire Dallah ou de la difficulté pour le juge anglais d'appliquer le droit français, note sous Paris, Pôle 1 – Ch. 1, 17 février 2011 et Cour suprême du Royaume-Uni, 3 novembre 2010", Revue de l'Arbitrage, pp.377~ (2012)
- Urs Peter Gruber, "The Convention on the International Sale of Goods (CISG) in Arbitration", International Business Law Journal, pp.15~ (2009)
- Ugo Draetta, "La Convention des Nations Unies de 1980 sur les Contrats de Vente Internationale de Marchandises et l´Arbitrage", International Business Law Journal, pp.193~ (2012)
- Hans van Houtte, "La convention de Vienne dans la pratique arbitrale de la Chambre de commerce international", ICC International Court of Arbitration Bulletin, 11(2), pp.22~ (2000)
- Alexis Mourre, "Application of the Vienna International Sales Convention in Arbitration", ICC International Court of Arbitration Bulletin, 17(1), pp.43~ (2006)
- Georgios C. Petrochilos, "Arbitration Conflict of Law Rules and the 1980 International Sales Convention", Revue Hellenique de Droit International, 52, pp.191~ (1999)
- Jeffrey Waincymer, "Sharing International Commercial Law across National Boundaries: Festschrift for Albert Kritzer on the Occasion of his Eightieth Birthday, Wildy", pp.582~ (2008), Simmonds & Hill Publishing
- Nils Schmidt-Ahrendts, "CISG and Arbitration", Belgrade Law Review, 59, pp.211~ (2011)
- Robert Koch, "Sharing International Commercial Law acrossNational Boundaries, FS Albert Kritzer" (2008)
- Janet Walker, "Agreeing to Disagree: Can We just Have Words? CISG Article 11 and the Model Law Writing Requirements", Journal of Law and Commerce, 25, pp.153~ (2005)
- Stefan Kröll, "Selected Problems Concerning the CISG's Scope of Application", Journal of Law and Commerce, 25, pp.39~ (2005)
- Wolfgang Kühn, "Current Issues on the Application of the New York Convention A German Perspective", Journal of International Arbitration, 25, pp.743~ (2008)
