An Arbitral case Study on Burden of Proof for Non-Conformityof Goods Under CISG
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The CISG does not stipulate the subject of the burden of proof, and in the arbitral award, the buyer is liable for proof compared to the seller for nonconformity of the product. Without a unified interpretation of the burden of proof of non-contractual goods, confusion of uncertainty may increase if the parties to the sale contract have a dispute due to the trade in goods. It is an important issue to create a unified regulation on this because the courts or arbitration agencies of the Contracting States of the CISG interpret and apply the "seller's obligation to conform to the goods contract" stipulated in this Convention in various ways. In this study, in the case of international Sales of Goods there is a tendency to prefer arbitration through arbitration agencies in the dispute, so the subject of burden of proof is analyzed through arbitration cases applied by CISG as the governing law. Most international commodity trading around the world is regulated by this Convention, but according to the rigid convention regulations, it is analyzed and interpreted through cases where this convention is applied to each country's international arbitration, suggesting the need for a rigid CISG revision.
Abstract
The CISG does not stipulate the subject of the burden of proof, and in the arbitral award, the buyer is liable for proof compared to the seller for nonconformity of the product. Without a unified interpretation of the burden of proof of non-contractual goods, confusion of uncertainty may increase if the parties to the sale contract have a dispute due to the trade in goods. It is an important issue to create a unified regulation on this because the courts or arbitration agencies of the Contracting States of the CISG interpret and apply the "seller's obligation to conform to the goods contract" stipulated in this Convention in various ways. In this study, in the case of international Sales of Goods there is a tendency to prefer arbitration through arbitration agencies in the dispute, so the subject of burden of proof is analyzed through arbitration cases applied by CISG as the governing law. Most international commodity trading around the world is regulated by this Convention, but according to the rigid convention regulations, it is analyzed and interpreted through cases where this convention is applied to each country's international arbitration, suggesting the need for a rigid CISG revision.
참고문헌 (22)
- Choi Heung Seob, "Conformity of Goods and Standsrds Established by Public Law in the CISG", International Trade Law (2006), MOJ
- David G. Owen, "The Graying of Products Liability Law : Paths Taken and Untaken in the New Restatement", Tenn. L. Rev, 61(1205) (1993)
- Elderlein, "“International Sales Law" (1992), N. Y. Ocena
- F.Enderlein, "International Sales Law; United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sales of Goods; Convention on the Limitation Period in the Internaional Sale of Goods", Oceana Publications (1992)
- Harry M. Flechtner, "Funky Mussels, A Stolen Car, and Decrepit Used Shoes:Non-Conforming Goods and Notice thereof under the United Nations Sales Convention(“CISG”)", Boston University International Law Journal, 26 (2008)
- Jong-Won Lee, "A study on the product liability in the pharmaceutical product", Kyungsung University Law Research, 23(1) (2014)
- Kwang-Huyn Suk, "Law of Contracts for the International Sale of Goods" (2010), Pakyongsa Publishing Co
- 위계찬, "독일 손해배상법상 입증책임", 법학연구, 19(1), pp.43~62 (2008), 법학연구소
- Lee Eun Sup, "International Trade Norm and Enviromnetnal Norms", pp.2001
- Ingeborg Schwenzer, "Commentary on the UN Convention on the International Sale of Goods" (2005), Oxford University Press
- Ingeborg Schwenzer, "International Sales Law" (2007), Routledge·Cavendish
- 하강헌, "국제물품매매에서 물품의 일치성에 관한 고찰 -CISG 사례를 중심으로-", 무역학회지, 32(2), pp.399~420 (2007), 한국무역학회
- Michale Joacjim Bomell, "The UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts and CISG-Alternatives of Complementary Instruments?", Uniform Law Review, 26 (1996)
- 한나희, "국제물품매매에서 중재조항 성립의 해석에 관한 고찰", 중재연구, 27(4), pp.91~113 (2017), 한국중재학회[DOI]
- 한나희, "중국 상사중재에서 CISG의 적용에 관한 연구 - CIETAC 중재사례를 중심으로 -", 중재연구, 29(1), pp.53~70 (2019), 한국중재학회
- Rosett, "Critical Reflections on the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods", Ohio State Law Journal, 45 (1984)
- Petra Butler, "Cisg and International Arbitration", Int’l Trade & Bus. L. Rev, 17, pp.322~ (2014)
- R.F. Henschel, "The Conformity of Goods in International Sales" (2005), Thomson, Cad Jura
- 홍성규, "국제물품매매계약에 있어서 하자담보책임에 관한 법리- CISG를 중심으로 -", 중재연구, 24(4), pp.147~175 (2014), 한국중재학회[DOI]
- Won-Suk Oh, "Seller’s Obligation for the Fitmess of Goods in International Sales Contract", Korea Trade Review, 3 (2002)
- 오원석, "국제물품매매거래에서 매도인의 계약적합성물품 인도의무에 관한 비교연구", 무역상무연구, 37, pp.3~33 (2008), 한국무역상무학회
- Yun-Jig Gwag, "General Rules of Civil Law", ~ (1991)