The relationship of non-cognitive factors to academic and clinical performance in graduate rehabilitation science students in the United States: a systematic review
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose: Rehabilitation science programs utilize cognitive and non-cognitive factors to select students who can complete the didacticand clinical portions of the program and pass the licensure exam. Cognitive factors such a prior grade point average and standardizedtest scores are known to be predictive of academic performance, but the relationship of non-cognitive factors and performance is lessclear. The purpose of this systematic review was to explore the relationship of non-cognitive factors to academic and clinical performance in rehabilitation science programs. Methods: A search of 7 databases was conducted using the following eligibility criteria: graduate programs in physical therapy (PT),occupational therapy, speech-language pathology, United States-based programs, measurement of at least 1 non-cognitive factor, measurement of academic and/or clinical performance, and quantitative reporting of results. Articles were screened by title, abstract, andfull text, and data were extracted. Results: After the comprehensive screening, 21 articles were included in the review. Seventy-six percent of studies occurred in PT students. Grit, self-efficacy, emotional intelligence, and stress were the most commonly studied factors. Only self-efficacy, emotional intelligence, and personality traits were examined in clinical and academic contexts. The results were mixed for all non-cognitive factors. Higher grit and self-efficacy tended to be associated with better performance, while stress was generally associated with worse outcomes. Conclusion: No single non-cognitive factor was consistently related to clinical or academic performance in rehabilitation science students. There is insufficient evidence currently to recommend the evaluation of a specific non-cognitive factor for admissions decisions.
Abstract
Purpose: Rehabilitation science programs utilize cognitive and non-cognitive factors to select students who can complete the didacticand clinical portions of the program and pass the licensure exam. Cognitive factors such a prior grade point average and standardizedtest scores are known to be predictive of academic performance, but the relationship of non-cognitive factors and performance is lessclear. The purpose of this systematic review was to explore the relationship of non-cognitive factors to academic and clinical performance in rehabilitation science programs. Methods: A search of 7 databases was conducted using the following eligibility criteria: graduate programs in physical therapy (PT),occupational therapy, speech-language pathology, United States-based programs, measurement of at least 1 non-cognitive factor, measurement of academic and/or clinical performance, and quantitative reporting of results. Articles were screened by title, abstract, andfull text, and data were extracted. Results: After the comprehensive screening, 21 articles were included in the review. Seventy-six percent of studies occurred in PT students. Grit, self-efficacy, emotional intelligence, and stress were the most commonly studied factors. Only self-efficacy, emotional intelligence, and personality traits were examined in clinical and academic contexts. The results were mixed for all non-cognitive factors. Higher grit and self-efficacy tended to be associated with better performance, while stress was generally associated with worse outcomes. Conclusion: No single non-cognitive factor was consistently related to clinical or academic performance in rehabilitation science students. There is insufficient evidence currently to recommend the evaluation of a specific non-cognitive factor for admissions decisions.
참고문헌 (40)
- Nuciforo M, "Variables predictive of admission to US physical therapist education programs", J Phys Ther Educ, 28, pp.112~119 (2014)[DOI]
- Mitch Wolden, "Predicting Success for Student Physical Therapists on the National Physical Therapy Examination (NPTE): Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis", Physical Therapy, pp.73~89 (2019), Oxford University Press (OUP)[DOI]
- Baggs T, "The value of traditional cognitive variables for predicting performance in graduate speech-language pathology programs", J Allied Health, 44, pp.10~16 (2015)
- Coleman-Salgado B, "The relationship of preadmission academic variables to academic performance in a doctor of physical therapy program", J Allied Health, 48, pp.e9~e14 (2019)
- Michelle Richardson, "Psychological correlates of university students' academic performance: A systematic review and meta-analysis.", Psychological Bulletin, 138(2), pp.353~387 (2012), American Psychological Association (APA)[DOI]
- Schneider M, "Variables associated with achievement in higher education: a systematic review of meta-analyses", Psychol Bull, 143, pp.565~600 (2017)[DOI]
- Cook C, "What traits are reflective of positive professional performance in physical therapy program graduates?: a Delphi study", J Allied Health, 47, pp.96~102 (2018)
- Marie A. Chisholm-Burns, "Systematic review of noncognitive factors influence on health professions students’ academic performance", Advances in Health Sciences Education, 26(4), pp.1373~1445 (2021), Springer Science and Business Media LLC[DOI]
- Sommerfeld A, "Recasting non-cognitive factors in college readiness as what they truly are: non-academic factors", J Coll Admiss, 213, pp.18~22 (2011)
- Marlene P. Ballejos, "Increasing the Relative Weight of Noncognitive Admission Criteria Improves Underrepresented Minority Admission Rates to Medical School", Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 27(2), pp.155~162 (2015), Informa UK Limited[DOI]
- J. Tetzlaff, "PNS154 THE PRISMA 2020 STATEMENT: DEVELOPMENT OF AND KEY CHANGES IN AN UPDATED GUIDELINE FOR REPORTING SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS AND META-ANALYSES", Value in Health, 23, pp.S312~S313 (2020), Elsevier BV[DOI]
- Veritas Health Innovation, "Covidence systematic review software" (2017), Veritas Health Innovation
- Law M, "Critical review form: quantitative studies" (1998), McMaster University Evidence-based Practice Research Group
- Cohen J, "Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences" (1988), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
- Lewis E, "Emotional intelligence as a predictor for clinical performance in professional physical therapy students", Internet J Allied Health Sci Pract, 8, pp.6~ (2010)[DOI]
- Utsey CJ, "Differences in motivational beliefs and learning strategies of physical therapist students in classroom and clinical settings", pp.2006
- Carp S, "Relationship between Grit Scale Score and academic performance in a doctor of physical therapy program: a case study", J Allied Health, 49, pp.29~35 (2020)
- Rebecca Bliss, "Doctor of Physical Therapy Student Grit as a Predictor of Academic Success: A Pilot Study", Health Professions Education, 6(4), pp.522~528 (2020), Elsevier BV[DOI]
- Bogardus JM, "Mental health disorders in DPT students: identifying needs, support systems, & challenges", pp.2019
- Lynn M. Frank, "Health and Wellness in Entry-level Physical Therapy Students: Are Measures of Stress, Anxiety, and Academic Performance Related?", Cardiopulmonary Physical Therapy Journal, 16(4), pp.5~13 (2005), Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health)[DOI]
- Alexander KM, "Student physical therapists’ competence and self-confidence in basic clinical assessment and musculoskeletal differential diagnosis", J Allied Health, 45, pp.95~100 (2016)
- Guffey JS, "An evaluation of the usefulness of noncognitive variables as predictors of scores on the national physical therapy licensing examination", J Allied Health, 31, pp.78~86 (2002)
- Carolyn Galleher, "Determining Cognitive and Non-Cognitive Predictors of Success on the National Physical Therapy Examination", Internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, pp.7~ (2012), Nova Southeastern University[DOI]
- Vandenberg L, "Exploration of emotional intelligence, DPT curriculum, and student success", pp.2019
- Scott Richardson, "Grit and Academic Performance in Doctor of Physical Therapy Students", Internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, pp.13~ (2020), Nova Southeastern University[DOI]
- Scott Richardson, "Empathy Levels Correlate with Practical Examination Scores in Doctor of Physical Therapy Students", Internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, pp.13~ (2021), Nova Southeastern University[DOI]
- Huhn K, "Exploration of grit and emotional intelligence and success in a doctor of physical therapy program", Internet J Allied Health Sci Pract, 19, pp.10~ (2021)[DOI]
- Peter C. Douris, "The relationship between academic success and sleep, stress and quality of life during the first year of physical therapy school", Journal of American College Health, pp.1~10 (2021), Informa UK Limited[DOI]
- Daniel Flowers, "Make Changes Early! High Stress Levels Predict Lower Academic Performance in First-Year Physical Therapy Students: A Pilot Study", Internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, pp.15~ (2020), Nova Southeastern University[DOI]
- Gordon-Handler L, "The relationship between emotional intelligence and clinical performance in an occupational therapy training program", pp.2010
- Lynne Andonian, "Emotional Intelligence, Self-Efficacy, and Occupational Therapy Students’ Fieldwork Performance", Occupational Therapy In Health Care, 27(3), pp.201~215 (2013), Informa UK Limited[DOI]
- Evelio Velis, "Learning Styles as Predictors of Fieldwork Performance and Adaptability of Graduate Occupational Therapy Students", The American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 69(Supplement_1), pp.6911510139p1~6911510139p1 (2015), AOTA Press[DOI]
- Rubini Pasupathy, "An Investigation of Graduate Speech-Language Pathology Students' SLP Clinical Self-Efficacy", Contemporary Issues in Communication Science and Disorders, 40(Fall), pp.151~159 (2013), American Speech Language Hearing Association[DOI]
- Lydia Richardson, "Predicting Clinical Success in Speech-Language Pathology Graduate Students", Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups, 5(2), pp.479~488 (2020), American Speech Language Hearing Association[DOI]
- Evan Pucillo, "Do Learning and Study Strategies Predict Success in Hybrid-Online Physical and Occupational Therapist Education?", Internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, pp.1~ (2021), Nova Southeastern University[DOI]
- Maureen Conard, "Personality-oriented job analysis to identify non-cognitive factors predictive of performance in a doctor of physical therapy program in the United States", Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions, 15, pp.34~ (2018), Korea Health Personnel Licensing Examination Institute[DOI]
- Crego A, "Stress and academic performance in dental students: the role of coping strategies and examination-related self-efficacy", J Dent Educ, 80, pp.165~172 (2016)
- Kotter T, "Perceived medical school stress of undergraduate medical students predicts academic performance: an observational study", BMC Med Educ, 17, pp.256~ (2017)[DOI]
- Frank Pajares, "Self-Efficacy Beliefs in Academic Settings", Review of Educational Research, 66(4), pp.543~578 (1996), American Educational Research Association (AERA)[DOI]
- Angela L. Duckworth, "Grit: Perseverance and passion for long-term goals.", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 92(6), pp.1087~1101 (2007), American Psychological Association (APA)[DOI]
