Anticommons in Public International Law: Consideration of a New Approach for Legal Research
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The theory of the anticommons opens up a new approach for legal research into Public International Law. This article demonstrates that anticommons structures can be readily located in the legal rules and legal institutions of public international law and its many affiliated substantive areas of law, such as in International Environmental Law. It provides an introduction and survey of the existing research into anticommons and sets out a list of the known potential solutions to anticommons structures. As such, it is demonstrated that legal researchers would benefit from a greater familiarity with current research in the field of anticommons theory. This article provides legal researchers with the frameworks necessary to begin research on anticommons in Public International Law. The model knowns as the ‘Tragedy of the Anticommons’ is a symmetrical reflection to the ‘Tragedy of the Commons,’ in that both models work on the extremes of having or not having exclusionary rights over a common resource or completion of a joint endeavor. Both models result in reduced benefits, or welfare, from the underlying resource albeit on different mechanisms. When this common resource or joint endeavor is a legal service, legal right, or legal procedure, one can have a legal anticommons; when the issue is based in complementary or competitive regulatory processes, one can obtain a regulatory anticommons. Evidence is presented that both legal and regulatory anticommons can be found in Public International Law. Given that there are anticommons in the rule sets and legal institutions of Public International Law, policy makers should be able to locate and characterize those anticommons to better identify which problems are thus created and which frustrations in public international law can be avoided or ameliorated.
Abstract
The theory of the anticommons opens up a new approach for legal research into Public International Law. This article demonstrates that anticommons structures can be readily located in the legal rules and legal institutions of public international law and its many affiliated substantive areas of law, such as in International Environmental Law. It provides an introduction and survey of the existing research into anticommons and sets out a list of the known potential solutions to anticommons structures. As such, it is demonstrated that legal researchers would benefit from a greater familiarity with current research in the field of anticommons theory. This article provides legal researchers with the frameworks necessary to begin research on anticommons in Public International Law. The model knowns as the ‘Tragedy of the Anticommons’ is a symmetrical reflection to the ‘Tragedy of the Commons,’ in that both models work on the extremes of having or not having exclusionary rights over a common resource or completion of a joint endeavor. Both models result in reduced benefits, or welfare, from the underlying resource albeit on different mechanisms. When this common resource or joint endeavor is a legal service, legal right, or legal procedure, one can have a legal anticommons; when the issue is based in complementary or competitive regulatory processes, one can obtain a regulatory anticommons. Evidence is presented that both legal and regulatory anticommons can be found in Public International Law. Given that there are anticommons in the rule sets and legal institutions of Public International Law, policy makers should be able to locate and characterize those anticommons to better identify which problems are thus created and which frustrations in public international law can be avoided or ameliorated.
참고문헌 (49)
- Keith Aoki, "Neocolonialism, Anticommons Property, and Biopiracy in the (Not‐so‐Brave) New World Order of International Intellectual Property Protection", Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies, 6, pp.11~58 (1998)
- Kenneth J. Arrow, "Social Choice and Individual Values" (1951), John Wiley
- Enrico Bertacchini, "Never Two without Three: Commons, Anticommons and Simicomons", Review Of Law and Economics, 5(1), pp.163~176 (2009)
- Marena Brinkhurst, "In the Shadow of the Anticommons: The Paradox of Overlapping Exclusion Rights and Open‐Access Resource Degradation in India's Wastelands", Journal of Economic Issues, 44(1), pp.139~162 (2010)
- Giuseppe Bellantuono, "The Regulatory Anticommons of Green Infrastructures", European Journal of Law and Economics, 37(2), pp.325~354 (2014)
- James Buchanan, "Symmetric Tragedies: Commons and Anticommons", Journal of Law and Economics, 43, pp.1~13 (2000)
- Antonin Auguste Cournot, "Recherches sur les Principes Mathematiques de la Theorie des Richesses" (1838), Hachette
- Hanoch Dagan, "The Liberal Commons", The Yale Law Journal, 110(4), pp.549~623 (2001)
- Ben Depoorter, "Putting Humpty Dumpty Back Together: Experimental Evidence of Anticommons Tragedies", Journal Law, Economics & Policy, 3, pp.1~ (2006)
- Sherif El‐Halaly, "The Mathematics of Voting and Apportionment: An Introduction" (2019), Birkhuser Science, Springer Nature Switzerland
- Charles Ellet, Jr, "An Essay on the Laws of Trade in Reference to the Works of Internal Improvement in the United States" (1839), PD Bernard
- Marian Gabriel, "Education in the Anticommons: Evidence from Romania", Central European Journal of Public Policy, 12(1), pp.32~40 (2018)
- Wulf Gaertner, "A Primer in Social Choice Theory" (2009), Oxford University Press
- Scott Gehlbach, "Formal Models of Domestic Politics" (2013), Cambridge University Press
- Jie GAO, "The Tragedy of the Anticommons in Government Public Management and the Establishment of the System of “Super Ministry” in China", 2008 International Conference on Management Science & Engineering (15th) (2008)
- Antoine‐Auguste Cournot, "Researches into the Mathematical Principles of the Theory of Wealth", ~ (1838)
- Thomas Eichner, "Carbon Leakage, The Green Paradox, and Perfect Future Markets", Int’l Econ. Rev., 52, pp.767~ (2011)
- Charles Ellet Jr, "An Essay on the Laws of Trade in Reference to the Works of Internal Improvement in the United States" (1839)
- Garrett Hardin, "The Tragedy of the Commons", Science, 162, pp.1243~1248 (1968)
- Michael A. Heller, "The Tragedy of the Anticommons: Property in the Transition from Marx to Markets", Harvard Law Review, 111(3), pp.621~688 (1998)
- Michael Heller, "The Tragedy of the Anticommons: A Concise Introduction and Lexicon", Modern Law Review, 76(1), pp.6~25 (2013)
- Michael A. Heller, "Can Patents Deter Innovation? The Anticommons in Biomedical Research", Science, 280(5364), pp.698~701 (1998)
- Michael Hoel, "Global Environmental Problems: The Effects of Unilateral Actions Taken by One Country", J. Envtl. Econ. &Mgmt., 20, pp.55~ (1991)
- Michael Hoel, "The Green Paradox and Greenhouse Gas Reducing Investments", Int’l Rev. Envtl. & Resource Econ., 5, pp.353~ (2011)
- Kyle A. Jacobsen, "From Interstate to Interstellar Commerce:Incorporating the Private Sector into International Aerospace Law", Temple Law Review, 87, pp.159~191 (2015)
- Ronald F. King, "Confusions in the Anticommons", Journal of Politics and Law, 9(7), pp.64~79 (2016)
- Ralf Krömer, "The Form and Function of Duality in Modern Mathematics", Philosophia Scientiæ, 18(3), pp.95~109 (2014)
- Lea Kosnik, "The Anticommons and the Environment", Journal of Environmental Management, 101, pp.206~217 (2012)
- Benjamin David Landry, "A Tragedy of the Anticommons: The Economic Inefficiencies of Space Law", Brooklyn Journal of International Law, 38, pp.523~578 (2013)
- Ivan Major, "A Political Economy Application of the “Tragedy of the Anticommons”: The Greek Government Debt Crisis", International Advanced Economic Research, 20, pp.425~437 (2014)
- Ivan Major, "Anticommons, the Coase Theorem and the Problem of Bundling Inefficiency", International Journal of the Commons, 10(1), pp.244~264 (2016)
- Takao Ohkawa, "The Tragedy of the Anti‐Commons in the Long Run in a Common‐Resource Economy", The Japanese Economic Review, 63(2), pp.171~184 (2012)
- Francesco Parisi, "Entropy in Property", American Journal of Comparative Law, 50, pp.595~632 (2002)
- Francesco Parisi, "Duality in Property:Commons and Anticommons" (2000), University of Würzburg
- Francesco Parisi, "Simultaneous and Sequential Anticommons", European Journal of Law and Economics, 17, pp.175~190 (2004)
- Francesco Parisi, "Duality in Property:Commons and Anticommons", International Review of Law and Economics, 25, pp.578~591 (2005)
- Roy A. Partain, "Coordinating Public and Private Sustainability: Green Energy Policy, International Trade Law, and Economic Mechanisms" (2019), Routledge
- Carol M. Rose, "The Comedy of the Commons: Custom, Commerce, and Inherently Public Property", University of Chicago Law Review, 53(3), pp.711~781 (1986)
- Sabrina Safrin, "Hyperownership in a Time of Biotechnological Promise : The International Conflict to Control the Building Blocks of Life", American Journal of International Law, 98, pp.641~ (2004)
- Nicholas Stern, "Stern Review: The Economics of Climate Change. Vol. 30", pp.3~ (2006), HM Treasury
- An experimental investigation of predictions and symmetries in the tragedies of the Commons and Anticommons, "Steven Stewart", Joint Institute for Energy &Environment, 1~27, pp.Report No. JIEE7 (2002)
- Hans‐Werner Sinn, "Public Policies Against Global Warming: A Supply Side Approach", Int’l Tax & Pub. Fin., 15, pp.377~381 (2008)
- Hans‐Werner Sinn, "The Green Paradox: A Supply‐Side Approach to Global Warming", ~ (2012)
- Hugo Sonnenschein, "The Dual of Duopoly is Complementary Monopoly:or, Two of Cournot’s Theories are One", Journal of Political Economy, 36, pp.316~318 (1968)
- Chia‐Hung Sun, "The Combination of Two Tragedies:Commons and Anticommons Tragedies", Journal of Economics, 122, pp.29~43 (2017)
- Sven Vanneste, "Alain Van Hiel, Francesco Parisi, Ben Depoorter, From “tragedy” to “disaster”: Welfare effects of Commons and Anticommons dilemmas", International Review of Law and Economics, 26, pp.104~122 (2006)
- Alain Van Hiel, "Why Did They Claim Too Much? The Role of Causal Attributions in Explaining Level of Cooperation in Commons and Anticommons Dilemmas", Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 38(1), pp.173~197 (2008)
- Peng Wang, "Tragedy of Commons in Outer Space: The Case of Space Debris 2013‐6" (2013), School of Law, Xi’an Jiaotong University
- J.B. Wiesner, , Scientific American, 211(4), pp.27~ (1964)