The Effect of Present Activity Verbs on Processing Structural Ambiguity in Japanese Garden-Path Sentences
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper addresses the semantics of the present form (known as the -ru form) of activity verbs in Japanese and examines the effect of these verbs in contrast to that of the inflected form (the -ta form). Garden-path sentences involving an ambiguity between a simple sentential reading and a relative clause reading generally show a preference for the former reading; when the preferred reading proves to be inconsistent with the correct reading of the sentence, the ensuing processing difficulty is known as the ‘garden-path effect.’ Interestingly, it has been observed that the effect is reduced in sentences that contain activity verbs in the present -ru form in the adnominal clause. One major problem that arises in the interpretation of the -ru form in subordinate clauses is that it is temporally ambiguous, and may be interpreted as belonging to the matrix clause instead. To date, no uniform analysis has been developed to characterize the semantic nature of the -ru form in subordinate clauses. This study will develop a semantics of the -ru form. The data revealed some interesting findings suggesting some logical characteristics of the -ru form. The results help to clarify how the semantic nature of the -ru form exerts an effect on the processing of garden-path sentences, and to show that, contrary to what had been assumed in the absence of semantic research into the embedding verb, the activity verbs ending in the -ru form extend the worlds against which a given proposition is evaluated, which has the effect of reducing the GP effect.
Abstract
This paper addresses the semantics of the present form (known as the -ru form) of activity verbs in Japanese and examines the effect of these verbs in contrast to that of the inflected form (the -ta form). Garden-path sentences involving an ambiguity between a simple sentential reading and a relative clause reading generally show a preference for the former reading; when the preferred reading proves to be inconsistent with the correct reading of the sentence, the ensuing processing difficulty is known as the ‘garden-path effect.’ Interestingly, it has been observed that the effect is reduced in sentences that contain activity verbs in the present -ru form in the adnominal clause. One major problem that arises in the interpretation of the -ru form in subordinate clauses is that it is temporally ambiguous, and may be interpreted as belonging to the matrix clause instead. To date, no uniform analysis has been developed to characterize the semantic nature of the -ru form in subordinate clauses. This study will develop a semantics of the -ru form. The data revealed some interesting findings suggesting some logical characteristics of the -ru form. The results help to clarify how the semantic nature of the -ru form exerts an effect on the processing of garden-path sentences, and to show that, contrary to what had been assumed in the absence of semantic research into the embedding verb, the activity verbs ending in the -ru form extend the worlds against which a given proposition is evaluated, which has the effect of reducing the GP effect.
참고문헌 (17)
- Bader, M., "Reanalysis in Sentence Processing" (1998), Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Fodor, J. D., "Learning to parse?", Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 27, pp.285~319 (1998)
- Hirose, Y., "Recycling prosodic boundaries", Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 32, pp.162~195 (2003)
- Inoue, M., "Garden Path-Gnshoo-ni motozuku Nihongo-bun-rikai-katei-no Zisshooteki Kenkyu", Ph.D., pp.2000
- Inoue, M., "Meishi-ku no taipu-ga nihongo-bun-rikai-no garden-path-kokani oyobosu eikyo", Proceedings of the 72nd Annual Meetings of the Japanese Society of Psychology, pp.983~ (2008)
- Inoue, M, "The effect of distinctiveness of proper nouns on processing structural ambiguity in comprehending Japanese sentences", Bulletin of Mukogawa Women’s University Humanities and Social Science, 60, pp.71~79 (2012)
- Kageyama, T., "Doosi Imiron – Gengo to Ninti no Setten" (1996), Kuroshio Publishers
- Karttunen, L., "Presuppositions of compound sentences", Linguistic Inquiry, 4, pp.169~193 (1973)
- Kinsui, S., "Nihongo no Meisi-Shuushoku-Hyoogen", pp.29~65 (1994), Kuroshio Publishers
- Levin, B., "Two structure for compositionally derived events", pp.199~223 (1998), Cornell University
- Lewis, D., "Attitudes de dicto and de se", Philosophical Review, 88, pp.513~543 (1979)
- Mazuka, R., "Japanese sentence processing" (1995), Lawrence Erlbaum
- Ogihara, T., "Tense, Attitudes, and Scope" (1996), Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Ohtani, A., "Quantification and the garden-path effect reduction: the case of universally quantified subject", PACLIC, 25, pp.41~50 (2011)
- Saito, M., "Some asymmetries in Japanese and their theoretical implications", Ph.D., pp.1985
- Stalnaker, R. C., "Context and Content" (1999), Oxford University Press
- Yamamori, Y., "The effect of present activity verbs on processing structural ambiguity in Japanese garden-path sentences", Proceedings of the EuroAsianPacific Joint Conference on Cognitive Science, pp.526~531 (2015)