편두통 환자의 한약치료 임상연구에 대한 고찰
Review of Clinical Research on Herbal Medicine Treatment of Migraine
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of herbal medicine treatment for patients with migraine and to suggest research methods for herbal medicine treatment on migraine. Methods: In this study, a search was conducted through several academic sites using a combination of terms ‘편두통’, ‘Migraine', ‘한약’, ‘한약치료’, ‘Herbal medicine’, ‘Herbal medicines’, ‘Herb’, ‘Traditional Chinese Medicine’, and ‘TCM’. Randomized controlled trials using herbal medicine treatments for adult patients with migraine were selected. Results: Ultimately, 46 papers were selected and analyzed. A statistically significant improvement was noted in the treatment group in terms of clinical migraine symptoms and other migraine evaluation tools before and after the herbal medicine treatment. Herbal medicines were administered in decoction, pill, and granule formulations. Many kinds of medicinal herbs, such as 解表藥類, 補益藥類, 淸熱藥類, 活血祛瘀藥類, and 平肝藥類, have been used for migraine. Among them, 川芎, belonging to 活血祛瘀藥類, is mentioned 36 times and is the most frequently used medicine. Herbal medicine was used safely for migraine treatment, without major adverse reactions, and the recurrence rate was significantly lower in the treatment group than in the control group. Conclusions: In conclusion, the herbal medicine treatment for patients with migraine showed a statistically significant improvement in 46 papers. Future studies should utilize standardized and objective evaluation tools, along with appropriate experimental design. The relevant articles should be increased to a significant level to verify the effect of herbal medicine treatments on migraine.
Abstract
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of herbal medicine treatment for patients with migraine and to suggest research methods for herbal medicine treatment on migraine. Methods: In this study, a search was conducted through several academic sites using a combination of terms ‘편두통’, ‘Migraine', ‘한약’, ‘한약치료’, ‘Herbal medicine’, ‘Herbal medicines’, ‘Herb’, ‘Traditional Chinese Medicine’, and ‘TCM’. Randomized controlled trials using herbal medicine treatments for adult patients with migraine were selected. Results: Ultimately, 46 papers were selected and analyzed. A statistically significant improvement was noted in the treatment group in terms of clinical migraine symptoms and other migraine evaluation tools before and after the herbal medicine treatment. Herbal medicines were administered in decoction, pill, and granule formulations. Many kinds of medicinal herbs, such as 解表藥類, 補益藥類, 淸熱藥類, 活血祛瘀藥類, and 平肝藥類, have been used for migraine. Among them, 川芎, belonging to 活血祛瘀藥類, is mentioned 36 times and is the most frequently used medicine. Herbal medicine was used safely for migraine treatment, without major adverse reactions, and the recurrence rate was significantly lower in the treatment group than in the control group. Conclusions: In conclusion, the herbal medicine treatment for patients with migraine showed a statistically significant improvement in 46 papers. Future studies should utilize standardized and objective evaluation tools, along with appropriate experimental design. The relevant articles should be increased to a significant level to verify the effect of herbal medicine treatments on migraine.
참고문헌 (70)
- 김용재, "개원의가 쉽게 다가가는 두통의 진단과 치료 원칙", 대한의사협회지, 53(9), pp.807~814 (2010), 대한의사협회
- The Korean Headache society, "The Headache 2nd edition", pp.42~46 (2017), Koonjapu blisher
- Chin-Sang Chung, "Drug Therapy for Migraine", Journal of the Korean Medical Association, 50(10), pp.917~ (2007), Korean Medical Association (KAMJE)[DOI]
- Association of Korean Medicine Professors for Cardiovascular and Neurological Medicine, "Cardiovascular and Neurological Medicine in Korean Medicine", pp.370~371 (2013), Koonja publisher
- Kim JI, "Literatural Study on the cause of a disease and prescription in migraine", DaeJeon University College of Oriental Medicine symposium, 16(2), pp.171~189 (2000)
- Huang PX, "Neurology special disease Chinese medicine clinical diagnosis and treatment of the second edition", pp.481~488 (2005), People's Health Publishing House
- Lee SS, "Effects of Acupuncture therapy on Cerebral Blood flow in Migraineurs", J Acupunct Res, 18(6), pp.135~140 (2001)
- Lee HE, "Effects of acupuncture in relieving headache: A meta-analysis" (2010)
- Chung DK, "The Effect of Simultaneous Treatment with Acupuncture, Herb Medication and Non-invasive Laser Irradiation of Blood Vessel on Headache", J of Oriental Neuropsychiatry, 12(2), pp.95~102 (2001)
- 방창호, "한방치료로 호전된 만성 두통 환자 치험 1례", 동의생리병리학회지, 24(6), pp.1105~1110 (2010), 한의병리학회
- 최은지, "긴장성두통에 대한 한약치료: 체계적 문헌고찰 및 메타분석", 동의신경정신과학회지, 26(4), pp.383~405 (2015), 대한한방신경정신과학회
- Won JH, "A Case Report on Chronic Tension-type Headache Improved by Korean Medicine with Chuna Manual Therapy", The Journal of Korea CHUNA Manual Medicine for Spine & Nerves, 8(2), pp.105~111 (2013)
- Seng ZF, "Clinical Study of Xiaotong Decoction on Migraine (The Type Of Coagulated Cold and Blood Stasis)" (2015)
- Han F, "Clinical Evaluation of Qinggan Jieyu Decoction in Treating Combination of Migraine Syndrome" (2015)
- He J, "The clinical efficacy and safety observation of Xifengtongluo herbal soup to the migraine of GanFeng with stasis syndrome" (2012)
- Jiang TT, "Clinical research of modified Toutong Xin No.l in treatment of Chronic Migraine" (2015)
- Wang MB, "加减川芎茶调散 to regulate the effects of CGRP and ET-1 on patients with frequent migraine (wind and cold disturbance)" (2016)
- Pan YH, "Clinical observation of Traditional Chinese Medicine(Treatment of phlegm and blood stasis) in treating Migraine" (2012)
- Liang B, "The clinical research of He jie zhi tong Decoction in treating migraine of Stagnation of liver and deficiency spleen" (2015)
- Dong HH, "Clinical observation of the Huatan Quyu recipe on treating 52 cases migraine of Tanzhuo Yuxue type", Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 5(11), pp.20~21 (2013)
- Xin LN, "The Clinical Research about Toutongfang Treatment of Migraine(qi deficiency and blood stasis type)" (2016)
- Liang JF, "The Curative Effect observation of Decoction of Xiong zhi shi gao and Decoction of Tao hong si wu on Migraine, A Report of 42 cases", SHANXIJ of TCM, 24(7), pp.19~20 (2008)
- Li J, "Clinical Observation on Promoting Blood Circulation to Remove Meridian Obstruction Remedy in the Treatment of Migraine" (2009)
- Wang AY, "Flavored SangMa when therapy in liver and kidney Yin deficiency of liver Yang syndrome migraine in clinical research Decoction" (2013)
- Liu TT, "Clinical Research on Treating Migraine of Internal Disturbance of Phlegm-Heat with Tou-tongan Decoction" (2009)
- Chen W, "Effect of Tianning Decoction in Treating 32 Cases with Migraine", Chinese Journal of Experimental Traditional medical Formulae, 21(17), pp.173~176 (2015)
- Fu GY, "Clinical reseach on treating migraine with the Qufeng Huoxue decoction", Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 7(11), pp.101~102 (2015)
- Wang JH, "Forty Cases of Migraine Treated with Gastrodia and Uncaria Decoction", Henan Traditional Chinese Medicine, 36(10), pp.1746~1747 (2016)
- Chen M, "Clinical Observation on Xiehuo Zhitong Decoction in Treatment of Migraine with Liver-fire Ascending Syndrome", Shanghai Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 13(12), pp.1375~1377 (2015)
- Li LJ, "Therapeutic effects of Xiongzhi Decoction on migraine and its effects on EEG and BAEP", Journal of Changchun University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 30(6), pp.1084~1086 (2014)
- Zhang JP, "Effect on Ma Xiong Shu Tong Fang on Migraine and Its Influence on Serum Levels of 5-HT, NF-kB and Inflamatory Cytokines", Journal of Kunming Medical University, 38(8), pp.40~43 (2017)
- Luo WP, "Clinical study on preventing and treating migraine by the Qufeng Huoxue recipe", Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 6(2), pp.23~25 (2014)
- Han F, "Clinical research of Qinggan Jieyu Formula to improve migraine patients with the syndrome of liver depression transforming into heat", China Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Pharmacy, 31(5), pp.1850~1853 (2016)
- Mo XF, "Clinical Study on Treatment for Migraine with Hyperactivity of Liver Wind with Blood Stasis by Calming the Internal Wind and Resolving Blood Stasis", Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 31(4), pp.862~865 (2013)
- Hu SF, "Clinical Study of Rougan Yupian Drink on Preventing and Treating Ganyu Xuexu Type Migrine", Journal of Hunan Univ of CM, 36(12), pp.45~48 (2016)
- Song RS, "Treating 43 cases of migraine with the Tianma Gouteng decoction", Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 9(19), pp.113~114 (2017)
- Zeng XD, "Effective observation on treating 40 cases of migraine with the Shufeng Tongluo prescription", Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 8(35), pp.75~76 (2016)
- You HL, "Observation on the Clinical Effect of Santong Decoction in Treating Migraine", Guangming Journal of Chinese Medicine, 32(3), pp.309~311 (2017)
- Yuan B, "Clinical observation on treating 86 cases of migraine by the Pinggan Huatan Huoxue recipe", Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 4(16), pp.95~96 (2012)
- Guo SF, "62 Cases of Migraine Treated with Jieyu Zhitong Decoction", Liaoning Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 40(10), pp.2078~2079 (2013)
- Wang MB, "Clinical Observation of Modified Chuanxiong Chatiao Powder in the Prevention and Treatment of Migraine", Guangming Journal of Chinese Medicine, 30(10), pp.2111~2113 (2015)
- Liu NQ, "Tianma Gouteng Drinks Treating Migraine 68 cases of Liver Yang hyperactivity Pattern", Journal of Practical Traditional Chinese Internal Medicine, 25(10), pp.77~ (2011)
- Che GX, "The Analysis of 58 Examples on Healing Migraine by using Tianma Gouteng Drink Addition or Subtraction", Journal of Practical Traditional Chinese Internal Medicine, 26(5), pp.77~78 (2012)
- Guo YK, "Sanpian Decoction on the Treatment of Migraine for 30 Cases", Chinese Medicine Modern Distance Education of China, 13(7), pp.30~31 (2015)
- Seng ZF, "Clinical Study of Xiaotong Decoction on Migraine(The Type of Coagulated Cold and Blood Stasis)" (2015)
- Ma JD, "The Observe the clinical effect of a Modified decoction of Bupleuri, Cinnamomi and Zingiberis treating on migraine(syndrome of stagnation of liver-QI with spleen deficiency)" (2011)
- Fu CH, "Therapeutic effect of Chuanxiong Dingtong Decoction on migraine liver phlegm syndrome" (2013)
- Guo YK, "Clinical observation of Jiawei sanpian Decoction in treatment of migraine(wind-phlem stasis type)" (2015)
- Zhao BH, "Clinical Study of Dingxuantongtong Decoction in Treating No aura migraine and Yin Blood Deficiency Windy smuggling" (2013)
- Guo FC, "Study on Mechanism of Jiawei Chuanxiongchatiao Pulvis in treatment of migraine" (2015)
- Han F, "Clinical Evaluation of Qinggan Jieyu Decoction in Treating Combination of Migraine Syndrome" (2015)
- Li DW, "Clinical observation of Xuefu Zhuyu Decoction in the treatment of migraine" (2015)
- Zhang BR, "Since the quasi smooth liver nourishing blood soup in the treatment of migraine essence of liver Yang syndrome clinical observation" (2016)
- Cao K, "Zhengtian Capsule versus flunarizine in patients with migraine: a multi-center, double-blind, double-dummy, randomized controlled, non-inferior clinical trial", Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 16(1), pp.356~ (2016)[DOI]
- Fu C, "Efficacy of Chuanxiong Ding Tong Herbal Formula Granule in the Treatment and Prophylactic of Migraine Patients: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Multicenter, Placebo-Controlled Trial", Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (2012)
- Cui NN, "Clinical Research on the Effect of JIU QI Nian Tong in treating Blood type migraine" (2009)
- Zhang P, "Positive day pill blood stasis migraine clinical study" (2013)
- Mei QL, "Clinical Reseach of Zheng Tian Wan in migraine headache (wind stasis syndrome)" (2010)
- Weldring T, "Patient-Reported Outcomes (PROs) and Patient-Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs)", Health Serv Insights, 6, pp.61~68 (2013)
- 이은현, "성인간호학회지에 나타난 측정도구 사용의 문제점", 성인간호학회지, 24(5), pp.439~440 (2012), 한국성인간호학회
- Katz J, "The McGill pain Questionnaire: Development, psychometric properties, and usefulness of the long-form, short-form, and short-form-2;Handbook of pain assessment, 3rd edition", pp.45~66 (2011), Guilford Press
- Smyth C, "The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI). Try this: Best Practice in Nursing Care to Older Adults", pp.36~39 (2012)
- Buysse DJ, "The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index: a new instrument for psychiatric practice and research", Psychiatry research, 28(2), pp.193~213 (1989)[DOI]
- Zung WWK, "A self-rating depression scale", Archives of General Psychiatry, 12(1), pp.63~70 (1965)[DOI]
- Zung WWK, "A rating instrument for anxiety disorders", Psychosomatics, 12(6), pp.371~379 (1971)[DOI]
- Zhu CQ, "Effect of new zhengtian pill on expression of whole blood platelet membrane adhesion molecules in patients of migraine", Chinese J of Intergrated Traditional and Western Med, 21(11), pp.822~824 (2001)
- Wang YH, "Effect and mechanism of senkyunolide I as an anti-migraine compound from Ligusticum chuanxiong", J Pharm Pharmacol, 63(2), pp.261~266 (2011)[DOI]
- Oriental pathology textbook compilation committee, "Oriental pathology", pp.335;383~385 (2011), Hanuimunhwasa
- Shin MK, "Clinical Traditional Herbalogy", pp.163;258;326;348;531;370~371;630 (2010), YeongLim's Publisher
- Park YC, "Effects of Ligusticum Chuanxiang on blood circulation and oxidative stress", J of Society of Preventive Korean Medicine, 6(2), pp.86~89 (2002)
