Evaluation of subgrid scale models in turbulent large eddy simulations of pumpjet propulsor
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
To assess the effectiveness of subgrid scale (SGS) models on the prediction results of unsteady loads and turbulent fluctuation of pumpjet propulsors equipped with both front and rear stators, a pumpjet propulsor computational model with attached parts at the model scale is developed using a fully structured mesh, and large eddy simulations are conducted. The computational results of the different SGS models are compared based on five aspects: open water characteristics, turbulence parameters, incoming turbulence spectrum, vortex structure, and fluctuating pressure. Their results are also compared with the experimental values, and the correlation between the internal flow characteristics of the pumpjet propulsor and the turbulent fluctuation is analyzed. According to the results, as regards the prediction of the open water performance of the pumpjet propulsor containing both front and rear stators, the overall trend obtained by the three subgrid models is similar, and the error between the values predicted by the SL model and the experimental ones is the smallest. At the same mesh level, the turbulent fluctuating scale obtained by the SL model is larger than that obtained by the WALE and DSL models, and the turbulent time scale obtained by the DSL model has the smallest fluctuation in the circumferential direction. Among the three SGS models, the turbulent fluctuating scale of the SL model is larger than those of the WALE and DSL models. The SL model exhibits the largest energy dissipation among the three SGS models, followed by the DSL model, while that of the WALE model is the smallest. In the WALE model, the leakage vortex at the top of the blade is the longest, followed by the DSL model, while it is the shortest in the SL model. In the WALE and DSL models, the fluctuating load fluctuates more in the transition region from the middle section to the trailing edge of the blade.
Abstract
To assess the effectiveness of subgrid scale (SGS) models on the prediction results of unsteady loads and turbulent fluctuation of pumpjet propulsors equipped with both front and rear stators, a pumpjet propulsor computational model with attached parts at the model scale is developed using a fully structured mesh, and large eddy simulations are conducted. The computational results of the different SGS models are compared based on five aspects: open water characteristics, turbulence parameters, incoming turbulence spectrum, vortex structure, and fluctuating pressure. Their results are also compared with the experimental values, and the correlation between the internal flow characteristics of the pumpjet propulsor and the turbulent fluctuation is analyzed. According to the results, as regards the prediction of the open water performance of the pumpjet propulsor containing both front and rear stators, the overall trend obtained by the three subgrid models is similar, and the error between the values predicted by the SL model and the experimental ones is the smallest. At the same mesh level, the turbulent fluctuating scale obtained by the SL model is larger than that obtained by the WALE and DSL models, and the turbulent time scale obtained by the DSL model has the smallest fluctuation in the circumferential direction. Among the three SGS models, the turbulent fluctuating scale of the SL model is larger than those of the WALE and DSL models. The SL model exhibits the largest energy dissipation among the three SGS models, followed by the DSL model, while that of the WALE model is the smallest. In the WALE model, the leakage vortex at the top of the blade is the longest, followed by the DSL model, while it is the shortest in the SL model. In the WALE and DSL models, the fluctuating load fluctuates more in the transition region from the middle section to the trailing edge of the blade.
참고문헌 (41)
- Abbas, N., "CFD prediction of unsteady forces on marine propellers caused by the wake nonuniformity and nonstationarity", Ocean Eng, 104, pp.659~672 (2015)
- Bai, T., "Numerical Simulation of Submarine Self-Propulsion Based on Different Turbulent Simulation Models", International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering, 58776 (2019), American Society of Mechanical Eng
- Cheng, H. Y., "Large eddy simulation of the tip-leakage cavitating flow with an insight on how cavitation influences vorticity and turbulence", Appl. Math. Model, 77, pp.788~809 (2020)
- Ducros, F., "Wall-adapting local eddy-viscosity models for simulations in complex geometries", Num. Method Fluid Dyn, pp.293~299 (1998)
- Gaggero, S., "RANS and PANEL method for unsteady flow propeller analysis", J. Hydrodyn, 22(5), pp.564~569 (2010)
- Germano, M., "Properties of the hybrid RANS", LES filter, 2004, pp.17, 225~231
- Germano, M., "A dynamic subgrid-scale eddy viscosity model", Phys. Fluid. Fluid Dynam, 3(7), pp.1760~1765 (1991)
- Gong, J. F., "Research on propeller lowfrequency flow noise simulation method", China Ship Res, 7(5), pp.14~21 (2012)
- He, P., "Prediction of cavitation dynamics and cavitation erosion around a three-dimensional twisted hydrofoil with an LES method", Int. J. Nav. Archit. Ocean Eng, pp.100536~ (2023)
- Hong, F., "Analysis of the applicability of different subgrid models in the numerical calculation of hydrofoil cloud cavitation", J. Drain. Irrigat. Mach. Eng, 40(9), pp.915~920 (2022)
- Hsiao, C. T., "Numerical study of cavitation inception due to vortex", vortex interaction in a ducted propulsor, 2008, pp.52(2), 114~123
- Jiang, H., "Numerical Analysis of Excitation Force Characteristics of Pump Jet Thruster", pp.2017
- Jiang, J. W., "Propeller low-frequency broadband noise influence parameters research and flow-acoustic multi-objective optimization design", Ship Mec, 20(Z1), pp.184~197 (2016)
- Krasilnikov, V., "Analysis of Unsteady Propeller Blade Forces by RANS", First International Symposium on Marine Propulsors Smp, 9 (2009)
- Kusano, K., "Detached eddy simulation of unsteady flow field and prediction of aerodynamic sound in a half-ducted propeller fan", Fluids Eng. Div. Sum. Meet, 44403, pp.713~722 (2011)
- Lee, S., "Wake dynamics of a 3D curved cylinder in oblique flows", Int. J. Nav. Archit. Ocean Eng, 12, pp.501~517 (2020)
- Lee, S. B., "Computational simulations of transitional flows around turbulence stimulators at low speeds", Int. J. Nav. Archit. Ocean Eng, 13, pp.236~245 (2021)
- Lenormand, E., "Large eddy simulation of subsonic and supersonic channel flow at moderate Reynolds number", Int. J. Numer. Methods Fluid, 32(4), pp.369~406 (2000)
- Lilly, D. K., "A proposed modification of the Germano subgrid-scale closure method", Phys. Fluid. Fluid Dynam, 4(3), pp.633~635 (1992)
- Liu, D. C., "Numerical methods for propeller non-constant force viscosity in companion currents", Proceedings of the Twenty-Third National Symposium on Hydrodynamics and the Tenth National Hydrodynamics Conference, pp.2011, 8[DOI]
- Lu, L., "CFD prediction and simulation of a pumpjet propulsor", Int. J. Nav. Archit. Ocean Eng, 8(1), pp.110~116 (2016)
- Lu, L., "Numerical investigations of tip clearance flow characteristics of a pumpjet propulsor", Int. J. Nav. Archit. Ocean Eng, 10(3), pp.307~317 (2018)
- Nicoud, F., "Subgrid-scale stress modelling based on the square of the velocity gradient tensor", Flow turb. Com, 62(3), pp.183~200 (1999)
- Qiu, C., "Numerical simulation of hydrodynamic and cavitation performance of pumpjet propulsor with different tip clearances in oblique flow", Ocean Eng, 209, pp.107285~ (2020)
- Smagorinsky, J., "General circulation experiments with the primitive equations: I. The basic experiment", Mon. Weather Rev, 91(3), pp.99~164 (1963)
- Sun, D. P., "Characterization of pump jet propeller tip gap flow field based on large vortex simulation", Ship Sci. Tec, 44(6), pp.95~101 (2022)
- Sun, D. P., "Characterization of pumpjet thruster tip flow field based on large eddy simulation", Ship Sci. Technol, 44(6), pp.95~101 (2022)
- Takahashi, K., "Experimental and numerical studies on the unsteady propeller thrust of underwater vehicles", Ships Offshore Struct, pp.1~10 (2022)
- Wang, L., "Computational analysis of non-constant force characteristics of catenary propeller with front stator", Ship Mec, 25(2), pp.175~182 (2021)
- Wu, H., "Analysis of Turbulence in the Tip Region of a Waterjet Pump Rotor", American Society of Mechanical Eng (2010)
- Xie, J.L, "Study on noise characteristics of impact jets based on different subgrid models", J. Eng. Thermophys, 40(2), pp.314~318
- Xiong, Z. Y., "Research on low-frequency broadband noise prediction of incident turbulence and propeller interaction", China Shipbuild, 55(3), pp.1~11 (2014)
- Yang, Z. J., "Research on Three-Dimensional Flow Large Vortex Simulation Method of Centrifugal Pump", pp.2011
- Yao, H. Y., "Propeller broadband nonconstant force characteristics under grid turbulence excitation", J. Harbin Eng. Univ, 43(7), pp.936~943 (2022)
- Yao, H. Y., "Study on the effect of sublattice model on the prediction of broadband non-constant force of pump-jet thruster", Propuls. Tec, 43(6), pp.410~420 (2022)
- Yu, F. N., "Computational analysis of excitation force of pump jet thruster in open water and after boat", Ship Sea Eng, 48(4), pp.96~101 (2019)
- Zhang, K. Q., "Numerical simulation of propeller non-constant force under inhomogeneous inlet field", Naval Sci. Tec, 40(3), pp.33~38 (2018)
- Zhou, J. W., "Numerical simulation of non-constant forces on propeller blades due to cavitation of large-size propellers", Ship Sea Eng, 45(6), pp.15~19 (2016)
- Zhou, M. S., "A review of sublattice models for equation of state simulation of trans", supercritical fluids with large eddies, 2023, pp.63(4), 473~486
- Zhu, X. Q., "Research on low frequency noise of ship propellers", Ship Mec, (1), pp.50~55 (2000)
- Zhu, X. L., "Study of hydrodynamic and air bubble performance of a seven-bladed side-slanting propeller in oblique flow", Propuls. Tech, 43(8), pp.9~ (2022)