Association of flap tension with flap design and graft volume in soft tissue augmentation: a cadaveric study in pigs

Abstract

Purpose: This study was performed to evaluate the effects of flap design, grafting material, and graft dimension on flap tension and the initial volume increase achieved in soft tissue augmentation. Methods: Six fresh porcine jaw cadavers were used in this study. Each side of the jaw was randomly assigned to receive either a standard split-thickness flap or a split-thickness f lap with a palatal island. Following flap preparation, random allocation was employed to determine the order of 4 treatment modalities: 3 mm of a volume-stable collagen matrix (VCMX), 6 mm VCMX, 3 mm of a subepithelial connective tissue graft (SCTG), and 6 mm SCTG. Flap tension was measured and the wound was closed after the insertion of each specimen. Intraoral scans were taken before flap preparation and after closure to facilitate profilometric analysis. Results: The palatal island flap exhibited significantly greater overall (P=0.010) and crestal (P=0.007) volume gains compared to the split-thickness flap, regardless of the use of VCMX or SCTG. The palatal island flap was associated with significantly lower flap tension force values (0.6 N; P=0.035) than the split-thickness flap. Both materials (VCMX and SCTG) demonstrated comparable volume gains. Conclusions: The findings of this cadaveric study indicate that the use of a palatal island f lap effectively reduces flap tension. While both materials (VCMX and SCTG) yielded similar increases in volume, the palatal island flap demonstrated greater volume gains than the splitthickness flap for each grafting material.