Performance evaluation of non-invasive cardiac output monitoring device (HemoVista) based on multi-channel thoracic impedance plethysmography technology
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Background: A non-invasive method of measuring cardiac output (CO) can be beneficial in the care of critically ill patients. HemoVista (BiLab Co., Ltd.) is a medical device that measures CO non-invasively using multi-channel impedance plethysmography technology. The purpose of this study was to exploratively evaluate the performance of HemoVista in critically ill patients undergoing CO monitoring with the FloTrac (Edwards Lifesciences).Methods: After non-invasively installing the HemoVista sensor in critically ill patients whose CO was monitored with the FloTrac, CO values measured by both devices were collected for 30 minutes. Cardiac output measured by both devices was selected every 10 seconds, creating approximately 360 data pairs per patient. Linear correlation analysis with Pearson correlation coefficients, Bland-Altman analysis, and four-quadrant plot analysis were performed to evaluate the performance of HemoVista.Results: A total of 7,138 pairs of CO data from the 20 patients were included in the analysis. A significant correlation was observed between the two methods of measuring CO (Pearson's r=0.489, P<0.001). The mean bias was 1.03 L/min, the 95% CI for the limit of agreement was –1.83 L/min to 3.93 L/min and the percentage error was 55.8%. The concordance rate of time-dependent CO between the two devices was 14.6%.Conclusions: It was observed that the current version of HemoVista has unsuitable performance for use in intensive care units. To be used for critically ill patients, the algorithm must be improved and reevaluated with an enhanced version.
Abstract
Background: A non-invasive method of measuring cardiac output (CO) can be beneficial in the care of critically ill patients. HemoVista (BiLab Co., Ltd.) is a medical device that measures CO non-invasively using multi-channel impedance plethysmography technology. The purpose of this study was to exploratively evaluate the performance of HemoVista in critically ill patients undergoing CO monitoring with the FloTrac (Edwards Lifesciences).Methods: After non-invasively installing the HemoVista sensor in critically ill patients whose CO was monitored with the FloTrac, CO values measured by both devices were collected for 30 minutes. Cardiac output measured by both devices was selected every 10 seconds, creating approximately 360 data pairs per patient. Linear correlation analysis with Pearson correlation coefficients, Bland-Altman analysis, and four-quadrant plot analysis were performed to evaluate the performance of HemoVista.Results: A total of 7,138 pairs of CO data from the 20 patients were included in the analysis. A significant correlation was observed between the two methods of measuring CO (Pearson's r=0.489, P<0.001). The mean bias was 1.03 L/min, the 95% CI for the limit of agreement was –1.83 L/min to 3.93 L/min and the percentage error was 55.8%. The concordance rate of time-dependent CO between the two devices was 14.6%.Conclusions: It was observed that the current version of HemoVista has unsuitable performance for use in intensive care units. To be used for critically ill patients, the algorithm must be improved and reevaluated with an enhanced version.
참고문헌 (21)
- Huygh J, "Hemodynamic monitoring in the critically ill : an overview of current cardiac output monitoring methods", F1000Res, 5, pp.F1000 Faculty Rev-2855~ (2016)
- Youssef N, "The routine use of the pulmonary artery catheter should be abandoned", Can J Cardiol, 33, pp.135~141 (2017)
- Arya VK, "Cardiac output monitoring-invasive and noninvasive", Curr Opin Crit Care, 28, pp.340~347 (2022)
- Argueta E, "FloTrac® monitoring system : what are its uses in critically ill medical patients?", Am J Med Sci, 349, pp.352~356 (2015)
- McLean AS, "Comparison of cardiac output measurements in critically ill patients : FloTrac", Vigileo vs transthoracic Doppler echocardiography, 2011, pp.39, 590~598
- Nuttall G, "Surgical and patient risk factors for severe arterial line complications in adults", Anesthesiology, 124, pp.590~597 (2016)
- Sangkum L, "Minimally invasive or noninvasive cardiac output measurement : an update", J Anesth, 30, pp.461~480 (2016)
- Ko RE, "Noninvasive beat-to-beat stroke volume measurements to determine preload responsiveness during mini-fluid challenge in a swine model : a preliminary study", Shock, 56, pp.850~856 (2021)
- Bland JM, "Measuring agreement in method comparison studies", Stat Methods Med Res, 8, pp.135~160 (1999)
- Kanazawa H, "Accuracy and trending ability of blood pressure and cardiac index measured by ClearSight system in patients with reduced ejection fraction", J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth, 34, pp.3293~3299 (2020)
- Critchley LA, "A meta-analysis of studies using bias and precision statistics to compare cardiac output measurement techniques", J Clin Monit Comput, 15, pp.85~91 (1999)
- Saugel B, "Tracking changes in cardiac output : statistical considerations on the 4-quadrant plot and the polar plot methodology", Anesth Analg, 121, pp.514~524 (2015)
- Mehta Y, "Newer methods of cardiac output monitoring", World J Cardiol, 6, pp.1022~1029 (2014)
- Nguyen LS, "Non-invasive monitoring of cardiac output in critical care medicine", Front Med(Lausanne), 4, pp.200~ (2017)
- Putensen C, "Electrical impedance tomography for cardio-pulmonary monitoring", J Clin Med, 8, pp.1176~ (2019)
- Ulbrich M, "Influence of physiological sources on the impedance cardiogram analyzed using 4D FEM simulations", Physiol Meas, 35, pp.1451~1468 (2014)
- Anand G, "Bioimpedance analysis as a tool for hemodynamic monitoring : overview, methods and challenges", Physiol Meas, 42, pp.03TR01~ (2021)
- Sanders M, "Accuracy and precision of non-invasive cardiac output monitoring by electrical cardiometry : a systematic review and meta-analysis", J Clin Monit Comput, 34, pp.433~460 (2020)
- Van Wyk L, "Accuracy and trending ability of electrical biosensing technology for non-invasive cardiac output monitoring in neonates : a systematic qualitative review", Front Pediatr, 10, pp.851850~ (2022)
- Chung CR, "Comparison of noninvasive cardiac output and stroke volume measurements using electrical impedance tomography with invasive methods in a swine model", Sci Rep, 14, pp.2962~ (2024)
- Braun F, "Limitations and challenges of EIT-based monitoring of stroke volume and pulmonary artery pressure", Physiol Meas, 39, pp.014003~ (2018)