본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Comparison of Constrained Acetabular Components and Dual Mobility Cups in Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty: A Literature Review

Eduard Van Eecke|Jens Vanbiervliet|Jan Dauwe|Michiel Mulier
대한고관절학회 (The Korean Hip Society)|2020.06|Hip and Pelvis|제32권 제2호|pp. 59-69

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

RevisionDislocationTotal hip arthroplastyDual mobilityConstrained

초록

Recurrent instability remains a common cause of failure after revision total hip arthroplasty (THA). Dual mobility (DM) cups and designs with constrained acetabular liners (CAL) have both been developed to help overcome this challenge. The aim of this report is to compare safety and efficacy outcomes of both designs based on the literature. A comprehensive literature review including published evidence on the results of DM and CAL in revision THA was performed and summarized. Available literature focusing on overall survival, dislocation, loosening, intra-prosthetic dislocation (IPD), and functional outcomes were analysed. Forty-six reports including an evaluation of 5,617 total hips were evaluated were included in the review. The included studies were divided into two distinct groups based on implantation approach: i) CAL (n=15) and ii) DM (n=31). The DM group had higher overall survival rates (94.7% vs. 81.0%), lower dislocation rates (2.6% vs. 11.0%), and lower acetabular loosening rates (1.0% vs. 2.0%) compared to the CAL group. IPDs were reported in 6 studies (mean rate, 0.6%). No differences in functional outcomes were identified due to incomplete reports. Our observations reveal that designs with CAL have poorer outcomes as compared to DM cups in revision THA. Currently, the use of DM seems more appropriate since they offer lower rates of dislocations, loosening and re-revisions in the short- and mid-term. Concerns regarding the potential of increased wear in a younger, high-demand population require additional data and evaluation by long-term studies for the DM design.

Abstract

Recurrent instability remains a common cause of failure after revision total hip arthroplasty (THA). Dual mobility (DM) cups and designs with constrained acetabular liners (CAL) have both been developed to help overcome this challenge. The aim of this report is to compare safety and efficacy outcomes of both designs based on the literature. A comprehensive literature review including published evidence on the results of DM and CAL in revision THA was performed and summarized. Available literature focusing on overall survival, dislocation, loosening, intra-prosthetic dislocation (IPD), and functional outcomes were analysed. Forty-six reports including an evaluation of 5,617 total hips were evaluated were included in the review. The included studies were divided into two distinct groups based on implantation approach: i) CAL (n=15) and ii) DM (n=31). The DM group had higher overall survival rates (94.7% vs. 81.0%), lower dislocation rates (2.6% vs. 11.0%), and lower acetabular loosening rates (1.0% vs. 2.0%) compared to the CAL group. IPDs were reported in 6 studies (mean rate, 0.6%). No differences in functional outcomes were identified due to incomplete reports. Our observations reveal that designs with CAL have poorer outcomes as compared to DM cups in revision THA. Currently, the use of DM seems more appropriate since they offer lower rates of dislocations, loosening and re-revisions in the short- and mid-term. Concerns regarding the potential of increased wear in a younger, high-demand population require additional data and evaluation by long-term studies for the DM design.

참고문헌 (78)

  1. De Martino I, "Dislocation following total hip arthroplasty using dual mobility acetabular components : a systematic review", Bone Joint J, 99(ASuppl1), pp.18~24 (2017)
  2. Plummer DR, "Dual mobility in total hip arthroplasty", Orthop Clin North Am, 45, pp.1~8 (2014)
  3. De Martino I, "Dual mobility cups in total hip arthroplasty", World J Orthop, 5, pp.180~187 (2014)
  4. Viste A, "Dual mobility cups in revision total hip arthroplasty", Int Orthop, 41, pp.535~542 (2017)
  5. Abdel MP, "Constrained liners in revision total hip replacement", Bone Joint J, 95(Suppl A) (2013)[DOI]
  6. Dargel J, "Dislocation following total hip replacement", Dtsch Arztebl Int, 111, pp.884~890 (2014)
  7. Wera GD, "Classification and management of the unstable total hip arthroplasty", J Arthroplasty, 27, pp.710~715 (2012)
  8. Jones SA, "Constrained acetabular liners", J Arthroplasty, 33, pp.1331~1336 (2018)
  9. Andersen AV, "Trilogy-constrained acetabular component for recurrent dislocation", ISRN Orthop, 2013, pp.629201~ (2013)
  10. Jauregui JJ, "Dual mobility cups : an effective prosthesis in revision total hip arthroplasties for preventing dislocations", Hip Int, 26, pp.57~61 (2016)
  11. Philippot R, "Prevention of dislocation in total hip revision surgery using a dual mobility design", Orthop Traumatol Surg Res, 95, pp.407~413 (2009)
  12. Chalmers BP, "High failure rate of modular exchange with a specific design of a constrained liner in high-risk patients undergoing revision total hip arthroplasty", J Arthroplasty, 31, pp.1963~1969 (2016)
  13. Su EP, "The role of constrained liners in total hip arthroplasty", Clin Orthop Relat Res, (420), pp.122~129 (2004)
  14. Mohammed R, "Outcomes of dual-mobility acetabular cup for instability in primary and revision total hip arthroplasty", J Orthop Traumatol, 16, pp.9~13 (2015)
  15. Batailler C, "The evolution of outcomes and indications for the dualmobility cup : a systematic review", Int Orthop, 41, pp.645~659 (2017)
  16. Clavé A, "Midterm survivorship of the Lefèvre constrained liner : a consecutive multisurgeon series of 166 cases", J Arthroplasty, 31, pp.1970~1978 (2016)
  17. Zagra L, "Total hip arthroplasty instability treatment without dual mobility cups : brief overview and experience of other options", Int Orthop, 41, pp.661~668 (2017)
  18. Williams JT Jr, "Constrained components for the unstable hip following total hip arthroplasty : a literature review", Int Orthop, 31, pp.273~277 (2007)
  19. Della Valle CJ, "High failure rate of a constrained acetabular liner in revision total hip arthroplasty", J Arthroplasty, 20(7 Suppl 3), pp.103~107 (2005)
  20. Khan RJ, "The constrained acetabular component for hip instability", J Arthroplasty, 22, pp.377~382 (2007)
  21. Pattyn C, "Complications encountered with the use of constrained acetabular prostheses in total hip arthroplasty", J Arthroplasty, 25, pp.287~294 (2010)
  22. Rady AE, "The use of a constrained cementless acetabular component for instability in total hip replacement", Hip Int, 20, pp.434~439 (2010)
  23. Mäkinen TJ, "The focally constrained liner is a reasonable option for revision of unstable total hip arthroplasty", Int Orthop, 40, pp.2239~2245 (2016)
  24. Munro JT, "Acetabular liner with focal constraint to prevent dislocation after THA", Clin Orthop Relat Res, 471, pp.3883~3890 (2013)
  25. Guyen O, "Modes of failure of Osteonics constrained tripolar implants : a retrospective analysis of forty-three failed implants", J Bone Joint Surg Am, 90, pp.1553~1560 (2008)
  26. Abdel MP, "Dual-mobility constructs in revision total hip arthroplasties", J Arthroplasty, 33, pp.1328~1330 (2018)
  27. Moore C, "The dual mobility concept in total hip arthroplasty", Bone Joint Sci, 3, pp.1~8 (2012)
  28. van Heumen M, "Dual mobility acetabular component in revision total hip arthroplasty for persistent dislocation : no dislocations in 50 hips after 1-5 years", J Orthop Traumatol, 16, pp.15~20 (2015)
  29. Guyen O, "Constrained liners, dual mobility or large diameter heads to avoid dislocation in THA", EFORT Open Rev, 1, pp.197~204 (2017)
  30. Lange JK, "Utilizing dual mobility components for first-time revision total hip arthroplasty for instability", J Arthroplasty, 33, pp.505~509 (2018)
  31. Sutter EG, "Outcomes of modular dual mobility acetabular components in revision total hip arthroplasty", J Arthroplasty, 32, pp.S220~4 (2017)
  32. De Martino I, "Early intraprosthetic dislocation in dual-mobility implants : a systematic review", Arthroplast Today, 3, pp.197~202 (2017)
  33. Oral E, "Wear resistance and mechanical properties of highly cross-linked, ultrahigh-molecular weight polyethylene doped with vitamin E", J Arthroplasty, 21, pp.580~591 (2006)
  34. Rastogi S, "Aseptic loosening of the acetabular component in relation to the positioning of prosthesis", Indian J Orthop, 36, pp.3~ (2002)
  35. Picado CHF, "Pain as symptom of threaded acetabular cup loosening", Acta Ortop Bras, 13, pp.2004~2006 (2005)
  36. Leiber-Wackenheim F, "Treatment of recurrent THR dislocation using of a cementless dual-mobility cup : a 59 cases series with a mean 8 years’ follow-up", Orthop Traumatol Surg Res, 97, pp.8~13 (2011)
  37. Williams J, "Radiographic evaluation of hip replacements", Spectrum, 19, pp.8~12 (2012)
  38. Chalmers BP, "Cementation of a dual mobility construct in recurrently dislocating and high risk patients undergoing revision total arthroplasty", J Arthroplasty, 33, pp.1501~1506 (2018)
  39. Anderson MJ, "Constrained acetabular components", J Arthroplasty, 9, pp.17~23 (1994)
  40. "Hip-arthroplasty" (2006)[URL]
  41. Nilsdotter A, "Measures of hip function and symptoms : Harris Hip Score(HHS), Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score(HOOS), Oxford Hip Score(OHS), Lequesne Index of Severity for Osteoarthritis of the Hip(LISOH), and American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons(AAOS)hip and knee questionnaire", Arthritis Care Res(Hoboken), 63(Suppl 11), pp.S200~7 (2011)
  42. Harris WH, "Traumatic arthritis of the hip after dislocation and acetabular fractures: treatment by mold arthroplasty. An end-result study using a new method of result evaluation", J Bone Joint Surg Am, 51, pp.737~755 (1969)
  43. Hailer NP, "Dual-mobility cups for revision due to instability are associated with a low rate of re-revisions due to dislocation : 228 patients from the Swedish Hip Arthroplasty Register", Acta Orthop, 83, pp.566~571 (2012)
  44. Lewis PL, "Constrained acetabular components used in revision total hip arthroplasty : a registry analysis", J Arthroplasty, 32, pp.3102~3107 (2017)
  45. Wegrzyn J, "Can dual mobility cups prevent dislocation in all situations after revision total hip arthroplasty?", J Arthroplasty, 30, pp.631~640 (2015)
  46. Hernandez-Vaquero D, "Constrained acetabular liners in hip revision surgery. A low-cost solution for senile patients", Acta Orthop Belg, 82, pp.563~569 (2016)
  47. Berend KR, "The long-term outcome of 755 consecutive constrained acetabular components in total hip arthroplasty examining the successes and failures", J Arthroplasty, 20(7 Suppl 3), pp.93~102 (2005)
  48. Stanton DA, "Salvaging unstable or recurrent dislocating total hip arthroplasty with the constrained acetabular component", J Orthop Surg(Hong Kong), 10, pp.165~169 (2002)
  49. Knudsen R, "Constrained liners for recurrent dislocations in total hip arthroplasty", Hip Int, 17, pp.78~81 (2007)
  50. Karvonen M, "Freedom constrained liner for the treatment and prevention of dislocation in total hip arthroplasty", Scand J Surg, 106, pp.165~172 (2017)
  51. Jo S, "The cumulative risk of re-dislocation after revision THA performed for instability increases close to 35% at 15years", J Arthroplasty, 30, pp.1177~1182 (2015)
  52. Fricka KB, "Constrained liners in revision total hip arthroplasty : an overuse syndrome : in the affirmative", J Arthroplasty, 21(4 Suppl 1), pp.121~125 (2006)
  53. Guyen O, "Use of a dual mobility socket to manage total hip arthroplasty instability", Clin Orthop Relat Res, 467, pp.465~472 (2009)
  54. Massin P, "Acetabular revision using a press-fit dual mobility cup", Orthop Traumatol Surg Res, 96, pp.9~13 (2010)
  55. Schneider L, "Revision total hip arthroplasty using a reconstruction cage device and a cemented dual mobility cup", Orthop Traumatol Surg Res, 97, pp.807~813 (2011)
  56. Pattyn C, "Early complications after revision total hip arthroplasty with cemented dual-mobility socket and reinforcement ring", Acta Orthop Belg, 78, pp.357~361 (2012)
  57. Mertl P, "Recurrence of dislocation following total hip arthroplasty revision using dual mobility cups was rare in 180 hips followed over 7 years", HSS J, 8, pp.251~256 (2012)
  58. Civinini R, "A dual-mobility cup reduces risk of dislocation in isolated acetabular revisions", Clin Orthop Relat Res, 470, pp.3542~3548 (2012)
  59. Saragaglia D, "Relevance of a press-fit dual mobility cup to deal with recurrent dislocation of conventional total hip arthroplasty : a 29-case series", Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol, 23, pp.431~436 (2013)
  60. Mukka SS, "Dual mobility cups for preventing early hip arthroplasty dislocation in patients at risk : experience in a county hospital", Orthop Rev(Pavia), 5, pp.48~51 (2013)
  61. Prudhon JL, "Cementless dual-mobility cup in total hip arthroplasty revision", Int Orthop, 38, pp.2463~2468 (2014)
  62. Jakobsen T, "The dislocating hip replacement-revision with a dual mobility cup in 56consecutive patients", Open Orthop J, 8, pp.268~271 (2014)
  63. Snir N, "Revision of failed hip resurfacing and large metal-on-metal total hip arthroplasty using dual-mobility components", Orthopedics, 38, pp.369~374 (2015)
  64. Haen TX, "Can cemented dualmobility cups be used without a reinforcement device in cases of mild acetabular bone stock alteration in total hip arthroplasty?", Orthop Traumatol Surg Res, 101, pp.923~927 (2015)
  65. Plummer DR, "Dual-mobility articulations for patients at high risk for dislocation", J Arthroplasty, 31(9 Suppl), pp.131~135 (2016)
  66. Gonzalez AI, "Comparison of dual-mobility cup and unipolar cup for prevention of dislocation after revision total hip arthroplasty", Acta Orthop, 88, pp.18~23 (2017)
  67. Plummer DR, "Salvage of monoblock metal-on-metal acetabular components using a dual-mobility bearing", J Arthroplasty, 31, pp.846~849 (2016)
  68. Lebeau N, "Total hip arthroplasty revision by dual-mobility acetabular cup cemented in a metal reinforcement : a 62 case series at a minimum 5 years’follow-up", Orthop Traumatol Surg Res, 103, pp.679~684 (2017)
  69. Mohaddes M, "Use of dual-mobility cup in revision hip arthroplasty reduces the risk for further dislocation : analysis of seven hundred and ninety one first-time revisions performed due to dislocation, reported to the Swedish Hip Arthroplasty Register", Int Orthop, 41, pp.583~588 (2017)
  70. Simian E, "Dual mobility cup in revision total hip arthroplasty : dislocation rate and survival after 5 years", Orthop Traumatol Surg Res, 101, pp.577~581 (2015)
  71. Dangin A, "Prevention of dislocation risk during hip revision surgery with the dual mobility concept; study of a new generation of dual mobility cups", Surg Technol Int, 29, pp.314~319 (2016)
  72. Carulli C, "The use of a dual mobility cup in the management of recurrent dislocations of hip hemiarthroplasty", J Orthop Traumatol, 17, pp.131~136 (2016)
  73. Brüggemann A, "Do dual-mobility cups cemented into porous tantalum shells reduce the risk of dislocation after revision surgery?", Acta Orthop, 89, pp.156~162 (2018)
  74. Noble PC, "Constrained cups appear incapable of meeting the demands of revision THA", Clin Orthop Relat Res, 470, pp.1907~1916 (2012)
  75. Wirth T, "Evolution of late presenting developmental dysplasia of the hip and associated surgical procedures after 14 years of neonatal ultrasound screening", J Bone Joint Surg Br, 86, pp.585~589 (2004)
  76. Rosenlund S, "The effect of posterior and lateral approach on patient-reported outcome measures and physical function in patients with osteoarthritis, undergoing total hip replacement : a randomised controlled trial protocol", BMC Musculoskelet Disord, 15, pp.354~ (2014)
  77. Berry DJ, "Effect of femoral head diameter and operative approach on risk of dislocation after primary total hip arthroplasty", J Bone Joint Surg Am, 87, pp.2456~2463 (2005)
  78. Berend KR, "Achieving stability and lower-limb length in total hip arthroplasty", J Bone Joint Surg Am, 92, pp.2737~2752 (2010)

관련 논문AI추천

Dislocation after Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty: A Comparison between Dual Mobility and Conventional Total Hip Arthroplasty김이석, 신현식, Dong-Hong Kim, Hyung Seob Ahn, Hyung Seok Kim대한고관절학회 · Hip and Pelvis2023 · 제35권 제4호Cementless Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty with Ceramic Articulation강준순, 문경호, 양성조, 양종혁대한고관절학회 · Hip and Pelvis2015 · 제27권 제4호Dual-mobility versus Fixed-bearing in Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty: Outcome ComparisonJeremy Loloi, Matthew S. Hepinstall, Ran Schwarzkopf, Vinay K. Aggarwal, Vivek Singh, William Macaulay대한고관절학회 · Hip and Pelvis2022 · 제34권 제2호Dissociation of Polyethylene Liner of the Dual Mobility Acetabular Component after Closed Reduction of Dislocation: A Case Report남주현, 배중권, 배찬일, 유기형, 전영수, 조윤제대한고관절학회 · Hip and Pelvis2017 · 제29권 제2호Acetabular Reconstruction in Total Hip Arthroplasty손원용, 최정우, Siva Swaminathan Santhanam대한고관절학회 · Hip and Pelvis2016 · 제28권 제1호Comparative Study of Peripheral Rim Fixation Using Jumbo Cup in Revisional Hip Arthroplasty권순용, 김승찬, 김용식, 임영욱, 임진형, 조우람대한고관절학회 · Hip and Pelvis2017 · 제29권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (7건)

Does Platelet-rich Plasma Augmentation Following Hip Arthroscopy Improve Outcomes: A Systematic ReviewNimesh Jain, Mohammed Ali, Biju Benjamin, Ajay Malviyapp. 70-77Early Experience of Direct Anterior Approach Total Hip Arthroplasty: Analysis of the First 53 CasesChungyoung Kim, Sung-Nyun Baek, Seung-Woo Shim, Young-Yool Chung, 김철환pp. 78-87An Analysis of the Potential Relationship between Crowe Type and Lower Extremity Morphology in Patients with Developmental Dysplasia of the HipFikret Berkan Anarat, Lezgin Mert, Mehmet Ekinci, Serkan Bayram, Ömer Naci Ergin, Emre Özmen, I˙rfan Öztürkpp. 85-92Sleep Disturbance Strongly Related to the Development of Postoperative Delirium in Proximal Femoral Fracture Patients Aged 60 or Older조명래, 송석균, Cheol-Hwan Ryupp. 93-98Sequential Bilateral Hip Fractures in Elderly Patients박경순, 윤택림, 최익선, Seong-Hwan Woo, Young-Sub Ahn, Dong-Min Jeongpp. 99-104
원문 보기