본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

일본의 의사학 교육 150년: 역사와 과제

150 Years of Medical History Education in Japan: History and Challenges

이규원
대한의사학회 (The Korean Society For The History Of Medicine)|2023.08|의사학 (Korean Journal of Medical History)|제32권 제2호|pp. 661-696

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

일본Japanmedical education의학교육medical humanities의학사의료인문학medical historyhistory of medicine의사학의사학 교육이마무라 료medical history educationImamura Ryō
주제분류역사학

초록

This paper is the first attempt to get a broad view of the history of modern medical history education in Japan, from the origin of medical history education in the Meiji era to its current state in medical schools. By correcting errors related to the first university lectures on medical history in Japan and historically contextualizing the challenges of medical history education and the academic community’s responses, this paper aims to examine both the historical significance and practical implications. The history of medical history education in Japan is relatively long. Medical history lectures in a medical school were first planned in 1876, and contrary to popular belief, the actual lecture started in December 1882 under Imamura Ryō’s charge and continues to this day. However, despite its relatively long history, the substance of medical history education in Japan is lacking in both quality and quantity. The absence of full-time professors of medical history education and related departments has led to a vicious cycle of failure in producing experts and a decline in medical education. Medical history education in Japan failed to take advantage of the fact that it began early despite the absence of tradition. The status of medical history education greatly increased in the 1930s, but the opportunity to expand its base was not utilized during the postwar reorganization of medical education and the student movement in the late 1960s. Falling into amateurism, evasion of real issues, and a lack of collective academic responses have hindered the understanding of these phenomena and problem-solving. The history of medical history education in Japan provides significant implications for the current reality of medical history education in Korea. The Korean medical history community must also confront and adapt proactively and organizationally within the evolving landscape of medical education. If the community settles for the present, Japan’s past will become Korea’s future.

Abstract

This paper is the first attempt to get a broad view of the history of modern medical history education in Japan, from the origin of medical history education in the Meiji era to its current state in medical schools. By correcting errors related to the first university lectures on medical history in Japan and historically contextualizing the challenges of medical history education and the academic community’s responses, this paper aims to examine both the historical significance and practical implications. The history of medical history education in Japan is relatively long. Medical history lectures in a medical school were first planned in 1876, and contrary to popular belief, the actual lecture started in December 1882 under Imamura Ryō’s charge and continues to this day. However, despite its relatively long history, the substance of medical history education in Japan is lacking in both quality and quantity. The absence of full-time professors of medical history education and related departments has led to a vicious cycle of failure in producing experts and a decline in medical education. Medical history education in Japan failed to take advantage of the fact that it began early despite the absence of tradition. The status of medical history education greatly increased in the 1930s, but the opportunity to expand its base was not utilized during the postwar reorganization of medical education and the student movement in the late 1960s. Falling into amateurism, evasion of real issues, and a lack of collective academic responses have hindered the understanding of these phenomena and problem-solving. The history of medical history education in Japan provides significant implications for the current reality of medical history education in Korea. The Korean medical history community must also confront and adapt proactively and organizationally within the evolving landscape of medical education. If the community settles for the present, Japan’s past will become Korea’s future.

참고문헌 (98)

  1. 권복규, "의학교육에서 의료인문학의 가치: 의사학을 중심으로", 의사학, 31(3), pp.495~517 (2022), 대한의사학회[DOI]
  2. 김택중, "미국 의료시스템과학 교육의 한국 도입과 그 비판", 의사학, 31(3), pp.519~546 (2022), 대한의사학회[DOI]
  3. 서울대학교 의과대학 의사학·인문의학교실 및 동문회, "서울대학교 의과대학 의사학·인문의학교실 70년", 서울대학교 의과대학 의사학·인문의학교실 및 동문회, ~ (2018)
  4. 여인석, "국외 의사학 교육의 역사적 고찰 - 유럽과 미국을 중심으로 -", 의사학, 32(1), pp.175~201 (2023), 대한의사학회[DOI]
  5. 이상미, "의사학 교육 80년, 역사와 현황", 의사학, 32(1), pp.147~174 (2023), 대한의사학회[DOI]
  6. ウィリアム, "幕末維新を駈け抜けた英国人医師: 甦るウィリアム・ウィリス文書" (2003), 創泉堂出版
  7. モデル・コア・カリキュラム改訂に関する連絡調整委員会, "医学教育モデル・コア・カリキュラム", モデル・コア・カリキュラム改訂に関する連絡調整委員会, ~ (2022)
  8. 京都帝国大学, "京都帝国大学一覧 自大正十一年至大正十二年" (1923), 京都帝国大学
  9. 慶応義塾, "慶応義塾七十五年史" (1932), 慶応義塾
  10. 慶応義塾大学医学部, "慶応義塾大学医学部一覧" (1934), 慶応義塾大学医学部
  11. 慶応義塾大学医学部六十周年記念誌編集委員会, "応義塾大学医学部六十周年記念誌" (1983), 慶応義塾大学医学部
  12. 今村亮, "洋方醫傳" (1884), 今村亮
  13. 大原孫三郎伝刊行会, "大原孫三郎伝" (1983), 大原孫三郎伝刊行会
  14. 大鳥蘭三郎, "ポンぺの外科学説について", 日本医史学雑誌, 7(4), pp.214~ (1957)
  15. 大村敏郎, "医史学教育の役割と問題点", 医学のあゆみ, 151(9), pp.555~557 (1989)
  16. 大村敏郎, "医史学教育の現状アンケートから", 日本医史学雑誌, 43(3), pp.296~297 (1997)
  17. 刀圭新報發行所, "富士川游氏醫學博士の學位を享く", 刀圭新報, 6(8), pp.253~255 (1915)
  18. 東京大学, "東京大学年報 第三" (1884), 東京大学
  19. 東京大学医学部, "東京大学医学部一覧 従明治十五年至明治十六年" (1883), 丸家善七
  20. 東京大学医学部, "東京大学医学部一覧 従明治十六年至明治十七年" (1884), 丸家善七
  21. 東京大学医学部創立百年記念会, "東京大学医学部百年史" (1967), 東京大学出版会
  22. 東京慈恵会医科大学, "東京慈恵会医科大学一覧 昭和六年七月" (1931), 東京慈恵会医科大学
  23. 東京帝国大学, "東京帝国大学五十年史 上册" (1932), 東京帝国大学
  24. 東北大学五十年史編集委員会, "東北大学五十年史 上" (1960), 東北大学
  25. 東北帝国大学, "東北帝国大学一覧 自昭和六年至昭和七年" (1931), 東北帝国大学
  26. 藤岡巌, "醫學史的硏究出デヨ", 藝備醫事, 333, pp.165~171 (1924)
  27. 藤浪鑑, "某生ニ與ヘテ醫史學ヲ論ズルノ書", 中外醫事新報, 922, pp.936~941 (1918)
  28. 鹿子木敏範, "ヨーロッパ特にドイツの医史学教育と研究の現況", 日本医事新報, 3012, pp.138~139 (1982)
  29. 龍野一雄, "医史学教育の諸間題(二)", 総合医学, 6(24), pp.1284~ (1949)
  30. 李楑源, "日韓の医学に及ぼした藤浪鑑の影響―基礎医学と医史学を中心に―", 日本医史学雑誌, 67(2), pp.209~ (2021)
  31. 尾暗耕司, "明治維新期西洋医学導入過程の再検討", 大手前大学論集, 13, pp.43~64 (2012)
  32. 福島統, "8. 公開シンポジウム 「医学教育：過去，現在，そして未来へ」 1．医学教育の歴史", 医学教育, 49(5), pp.421~428 (2018)[DOI]
  33. 福田雅代, "桔梗 : 三宅秀とその周辺" (1985), 福田雅代
  34. 富士川游, "日本医学史" (1904), 裳華房
  35. 富士川游, "日本医学史 : 決定版" (1941), 日新書院
  36. 富士川游, "医史叢談 : 科学随筆" (1942), 書物展望社
  37. 「富士川游先生」編纂委員会, "富士川游先生" (1954), ｢富士川先生｣刊行会
  38. 北里文太郞, "慶應義塾醫學所(下)", 日本医史学雑誌, 1310, pp.507~531 (1942)
  39. 寺畑喜朔, "ヒポクラテスの木と体験学習", 日本医史学雑誌, 33(1), pp.58~60 (1987)
  40. 山崎震一, "ウイリアム・ウイリス伝 : 薩摩に英国医学をもたらした男" (2019), 書籍工房早山
  41. 山内孝一, "復刊の辭", 日本医史学雑誌, 5(1), pp.1~ (1954)
  42. 杉田暉道, "医史料の保存", 日本医史学雑誌, 45, pp.51~52 (1999)
  43. 森忠三, "日本の医学部·医科大学における医学概論の実施状況―1988年度と1994年度のアンケート調査―", 医学教育, 27(3), pp.155~159 (1996)
  44. 石田純郎, "ウトレヒト陸軍軍医学校の我国への影響", 日本医史学雑誌, 31(2), pp.193~195 (1985)
  45. 石田純郎, "江戸のオランダ医" (1988), 三省堂
  46. 小高健, "長与又郎日記 : 近代化を推進した医学者の記録 上" (2001), 学会出版センター
  47. 小関恒雄, "三宅秀日記(1888~1938)", 日本医史学雑誌, 28(1), pp.34~47 (1981)
  48. 小関恒雄, "明治六, 七年度東京大学医学部学科表(資料)", 日本医史学雑誌, 29(4), pp.462~476 (1983)
  49. 小川鼎三, "医史学教授として出立する", 医学史研究, 6, pp.306~ (1962)
  50. 小川鼎三, "医史学と私", 日本医史学雑誌, 19(4), pp.365~376 (1973)[DOI]
  51. 松木明知, "医学教育の中の医史学―全国アンケート調査の結果から―", 日本医史学雑誌, 28(1), pp.72~75 (1982)
  52. 順天堂, "順天堂史 下巻" (1996), 順天堂
  53. 神谷昭典, "名古屋大学医学部における医学概論·医学史講義の試み", 医学教育, 4(4), pp.269~272 (1973)
  54. 神津忠彦, "医学史教育のワーキンググループ報告", 医学教育, 28(5), pp.356~ (1997)
  55. 深川晨堂, "漢洋医学闘争史 上巻" (1934), 旧藩と医学社
  56. 安田健次郎, "慶應義塾大学医学所と大学医学部の創設 : 自然科学教育の重視", 義塾医学, 85(2), pp.79~109 (2009)
  57. 岩熊哲, "杏仁医館随筆(その十六)", 九大医報, 11(3), pp.209~220 (1937)
  58. 五洋生, "京都醫學會第四次總會誌ノ後ニ記ルス", 京都医学雑誌, 4, pp.79~89 (1907)
  59. 外山尚吾, ""医学とは何か"を問う教育の実態調査 : 中川米造の医学概論の観点から", 医学教育, 51(4), pp.379~388 (2020)
  60. 医学公論社, "日本医籍録 昭和29年版 北海道·東北·関東·東海·信越·北陸" (1954), 医学公論社
  61. 医学史研究編集部, "世界医学史教育・略年表", 医学史研究, 6, pp.307~308 (1962)
  62. 醫海時報社, "大正三年中の重要事件", 醫海時報, 1071, pp.41~42 (1915)
  63. 二至村菁, "8年制医師養成教育―GHQサムス准将の提案", 医学教育, 44(6), pp.421~428 (2013)
  64. 日本医史学会, "千葉醫科大學に醫史學講座新設", 日本医史学雑誌, 1304, pp.265~ (1942)
  65. 日本医史学会, "名古屋國帝大學醫學部に醫史學講座開設", 日本医史学雑誌, 1304, pp.265~ (1942)
  66. 日本医史学会, "醫史學講座設置校一覽", 日本医史学雑誌, 5(1), pp.84~ (1954)
  67. 日本医史学会, "東大に醫史學講座開講", 日本医史学雑誌, 5(2), pp.98~ (1954)
  68. 日本医史学会, "第五十六回日本醫史學會總會講演要旨", 日本医史学雑誌, 5(2), pp.105~ (1954)
  69. 日本医史学会, "医史学講座開設要望についての建議", 日本医史学雑誌, 5(4), pp.203~204 (1955)
  70. 日本医史学会総会百回記念誌編纂委員会, "日本医史学会総会百回記念誌" (2000), 日本医史学会
  71. 日本医史学会関西支部, "会員消息", 医譚, 51 (1966)
  72. 日本医学会, "第9回日本医学会会誌" (1934), 日本医学会
  73. 日本医学会創立120周年記念事業記念誌委員会, "日本医学会創立120周年記念誌" (2022), 日本医学会
  74. 日本臨床医学社, "名帝大に醫史學科 : 我國帝大で最初", 臨床医報, 14(16), pp.47~ (1942)
  75. 日新醫學社, "學界消息", 日新醫學, 31(1), pp.95~ (1942)
  76. 入澤達吉, "東京大学医学部 : 沿革略史", 日本之醫界, 14(12), pp.25~ (1924)
  77. 長門谷洋治, "関西医史学界のリーダー・中野操先生", 医譚, 52, pp.2424~2425 (1967)
  78. 長門谷洋治, "科学史に関する支部, 分科会, 関連諸学会の最近の動向(II)", 科学史研究, 123, pp.187~190 (1977)
  79. 長門谷洋治, "医史学の方向", 医学史研究, pp.101~102 (1995)
  80. 蔵方宏昌, "医学史教育を模索して", 日本医史学雑誌, 39(1), pp.14~15 (1993)
  81. 赤松金芳, "医史学と私", 日本医史学雑誌, 34(2), pp.323~333 (1988)
  82. 帝国学士院, "帝国学士院一覧 大正四年" (1915), 帝国学士院
  83. 酒井シヅ, "日本医史学会の沿革", 医学図書館, 19(3), pp.249~252 (1972)
  84. 酒井シヅ, "桔梗 : 三宅秀とその周辺" (1985), 福田雅代
  85. 中外醫事新報社, "醫史學講座", 中外醫事新報, 620, pp.142~143 (1906)
  86. 中外醫事新報社, "慈惠醫大に醫史學講座新設", 中外醫事新報, 1161, pp.367~ (1930)
  87. 中外醫事新報社, "慶應醫史學硏究會", 中外醫事新報, 1196, pp.277~ (1933)
  88. 中外醫事新報社, "慶應醫史學硏究會", 中外醫事新報, 1201, pp.488~ (1933)
  89. 中外醫事新報社, "慶應醫史學硏究會", 中外醫事新報, 1280, pp.246~ (1940)
  90. 中川米造, "医史学の盛衰", 医学史研究, 6, pp.309~314 (1962)
  91. 中川米造, "カリキュラム", 医学教育, 3(1), pp.45~52 (1972)
  92. 中川米造, "医学教育における医学史", 医学史研究, 50, pp.252~257 (1978)
  93. 千葉医科大学, "千葉医科大学一覧 昭和十七至十八年" (1943), 千葉医科大学
  94. 沢瀉久敬, "医学の進歩と医学概論", 医学史研究, 2, pp.52~ (1961)
  95. 坂井建雄, "図説 医学の歴史" (2019), 医学書院
  96. 和漢醫學講究所, "温知醫談 第四十五号" (1883), 温知社
  97. OECD, "Doctors (indicator)", ~ (2023)
  98. Siddall, J. B., "Surgical experiences in military hospitals in Japan", St. Thomas’s Hospital Reports V, 85~112 (1876)

관련 논문AI추천

의사학 교육 80년, 역사와 현황예병일, 이상미대한의사학회 · 의사학2023 · 제32권 제1호의과대학에서 의학사를 어떻게 가르칠 것인가?: 시기, 구성, 교수법박승만, 박지영대한의사학회 · 의사학2023 · 제32권 제2호일본 의학사의 연구동향과 전망: 연구 주제와 방법론의 확대김영수대한의사학회 · 의사학2020 · 제29권 제2호의과대학 의학사교육의 현황과 과제여인석의학사연구소 · 연세의사학2010 · 제13권 제2호국외 의사학 교육의 역사적 고찰 - 유럽과 미국을 중심으로 -여인석대한의사학회 · 의사학2023 · 제32권 제1호의학교육에서 의료인문학의 가치: 의사학을 중심으로권복규대한의사학회 · 의사학2022 · 제31권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

Medicine in the Korean WarMark Harrison, 김정란pp. 453-462Unstable Expansion: The Development of the Military Medical Evacuation Chain in Korea, 1948–1953박윤재, 강재구pp. 463-501Casualty Evacuation in Korea, 1950-53: The British ExperienceMark Harrisonpp. 503-552A Foundation for a “Cheerful Society”: The Korean War and the Rise of Psychiatry신지혜, 임성빈pp. 553-591의학교육에서 의사학의 자리를 찾아 (3) - 의과대학 의사학 교육 방법을 중심으로최은경pp. 593-594
원문 보기