본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

과학 관련 사회적 문제 (SSI) 교육 맥락에서 초등학생의 위치짓기 양상 -실천 지향 기후변화 동아리 활동을 중심으로-

Exploring Elementary Students’ Positioning in a Context of Socio-scientific Issues (SSI) Education: Focus on an Action-oriented Climate Change Club Activit

김종욱|김찬종
한국과학교육학회 (The Korean Association for Science Education)|2021.12|한국과학교육학회지 (Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education)|제41권 제6호|pp. 501-517

0

조회

0

다운로드

9

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초등학생기후변화climate change위치elementary studentsposition사회적 실천social actionpositioning theory과학과 관련된 사회적 논쟁(SSI)위치짓기 이론socio-scientific issues(SSI)
주제분류교육학

초록

과학⋅기술의 발전이 시대의 변화를 주도하는 현시대에, 본 연구는 학생들이 과학과 관련된 사회적 논쟁(SSI)에 대해 민주적이며 비판적으로 참여할 수 있는 소양을 지녀야 하며, 주체적이고 참여적인 시민 으로서 위치되어야 할 것이라는 입장을 지지한다. 그에 따라 초등학 생을 대상으로 사회적인 실천을 강조하는 동아리 활동을 진행하였으며, 학생들이 기후변화에 대해 어떠한 행위를 수행할 수 있는 사람으로 위치짓는지/되는지, 또한 상충되는 위치짓기 양상은 무엇인지 탐색하였다. 이 연구에서 위치는 기후변화에 대해 어떠한 행위를 수행할 수 있는 사람인지에 대한 권리와 의무의 집합으로 정의한다. 서울소재 A초등학교 6학년 학생 11명을 대상으로 2019년 3-7월까지 46차시에 걸쳐 활동이 수행되었으며, 비디오 및 오디오 자료, 인터뷰 자료 등이 지속적비교방법에 의해 분석되었다. 크게 세 스텝의 수업 과정 에서 학생들은 다음과 같이 서로 다른 위치짓기를 나타냈다. 스텝 1의 지구온난화 모델링 활동에서 학생들은 ‘적극적인 학습자’로 위치 되었으나 동시에 ‘견습생’으로서 제한적으로 위치되는 모순을 나타내 기도 했다. 스텝 2의 학생주도연구 활동에서는 ‘연구를 설계하고 수행 하는 과학자’이자 SSI 관련 지식의 논쟁적인 본성에 대해서는 결정을 ‘기피하는 자’로 위치되는 한계도 드러냈다. 스텝 3의 사회적인 실천 과정에서는 ‘변화를 만들기 어려운 초등학생’이라는 위치에서 ‘변화를 만들어내는 참여적인 시민’으로 새롭게 위치짓는 모습을 보였다. 본 연구는 과학 교육을 통해 학생들이 참여적이고 민주적인 시민으로 성장할 수 있는 가능성을 보여주었다는 점에 의의가 있다. 아울러학생들이 드러냈던 위치짓기의 상충점과 한계를 해결하기 위한 교육 학적인 방법을 논의했다.

Abstract

In the present age, when the development of science and technology is leading the changes, this study supports the view that students should possess the literacy to participate democratically and critically in socio-scientific issues, and should be positioned as agentic and participatory citizens. Accordingly, we implemented a club activity that emphasize climate social action for elementary students, and explored how students were positioned in relation to climate change. In this study, position is defined as a complex cluster of rights and duties that students have in relation to climate change. The club activity was implemented throughout 46 sessions from March to July, 2019 for 11 sixth graders of ‘H elementary School’ in Seoul, and transcripts of video and interviews were analyzed by means of a constant comparison method. In the course of the activity consisting of three steps, the students exhibited different positioning and they are as follows: In the global warming modeling activity for Step 1, students were positioned as ‘active learners’, but at the same time, they showed a contradiction in being positioned as ‘apprentice’. In the student-led research activities inherent to Step 2, they were positioned as ‘scientists who design and conduct research’ and ‘bystanders’ due to the controversial nature of SSI knowledge. As students participate in the social actions involved in Step 3, the position changed from ‘elementary school students facing difficulty in making a change’ to ‘participatory citizens creating changes.’ This study is significant because it shows students’ potential to promote participatory and democratic citizenship through action-oriented SSI activities. In addition, pedagogical approaches were discussed dealing with the contradictions and limitations of positioning.

참고문헌 (82)

  1. 안주호, "-ㄹ 수 있-' 구성의 특성과 문법화", 한국언어문학, (53), pp.207~232 (2004), 한국언어문학회
  2. Aikenhead, G. S., "Science education : Border crossing into the subculture of science", Studies in Science Education, 27(1), pp.1~52 (1996)
  3. Alsop, S., "Activist Science and Technology Education", pp.1~19 (2014), Springer
  4. Arnold, J., "Science students’ classroom discourse : Tasha’s umwelt", Research in Science Education, 42(2), pp.233~259 (2012)
  5. Austin, J. L., "How to do things with words" (1975), Oxford University Press
  6. Basu, S. J., "Developing a framework for critical science agency through case study in a conceptual physics context", Cultural Studies of Science Education, 4, pp.345~371 (2009)
  7. Bencze, L., "Science and Technology Education Promoting Wellbeing for Individuals, Societies and Environments", pp.19~45 (2017), Springer
  8. Bencze, L., "13 Questions: Reframing Education’s Conversation: Science", pp.69~87 (2018), Peter Lang
  9. Bencze, L., "Students’ research-informed socio-scientific activism : Re", visions for a sustainable future, 2012, pp.42(1), 129~148
  10. Berge, M., "Storylines in the physics teaching content of an upper secondary school classroom", Research in Science & Technological Education, 38(1), pp.63~83 (2020)
  11. Birmingham, D., "Putting on a green carnival : Youth taking educated action on socioscientific issues", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 51(3), pp.286~314 (2014)
  12. Blackley, S., "A STEM narrative: 15 years in the making", Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 40(7) (2015)
  13. Bossér, U., "Students’ positioning in the classroom : A study of teacher-student interactions in a socioscientific issue context", Research in Science Education, 49(2), pp.371~390 (2019)
  14. Bourdieu, P., "The logic of practice" (1990), Stanford University Press
  15. Calabrese-Barton, A., "Science education in urban settings : Seeking new ways of praxis through critical ethnography", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 38(8), pp.899~917 (2001)
  16. Calabrese-Barton, A., "We be burnin’! Agency, identity, and science learning", The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 19(2), pp.187~229 (2010)
  17. Calabrese-Barton, A., "Beyond equity as inclusion : A framework of"Rightful Presence"for guiding justice-oriented studies in teaching and learning", Educational Researcher, 49(6), pp.433~440 (2020)
  18. Creswell, J. W., "Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches" (2013), Sage
  19. Fairclough, N., "Analysing discourse: Textual analysis for social research" (2003), Routledge
  20. Funtowicz, S. O., "Science for the post-normal age", Futures, 25(7), pp.739~755 (1993)
  21. Goffman, E., "Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience" (1974), Harvard University Press
  22. Halliday, M. A. K., "An introduction to functional grammar" (2004), Hodder Arnold
  23. Harré, R., "Positioning and the discursive construction of categories", Psychopathology, 38(4), pp.185~188 (2005)
  24. Harrė, R., "The person as the nexus of patterns of discursive practices", Culture & Psychology, 21(4), pp.492~504 (2015)
  25. Harré, R., "The self and others: Positioning individuals and groups in personal, political, and cultural contexts" (2003), Greenwood Publishing Group
  26. Harré, R., "Recent advances in positioning theory", Theory &Psychology, 19(1), pp.5~31 (2009)
  27. Harré, R., "Positioning theory: Moral contexts of intentional action" (1999), Malden
  28. Havinghurst, R., "Development tasks and education" (1972), David McKay
  29. Herman, B. C., "Students’ emotive reasoning through place-based environmental socioscientific issues", Research in Science Education, 50(5), pp.2081~2109 (2020)
  30. Hodson, D., "Science education as a call to action", Canadian Journal of Science, Mathematics and Technology Education, 10(3), pp.197~206 (2010)
  31. Hodson, D., "Activist science and technology education", pp.67~98 (2014), Springer
  32. Hong, E. -M., "Biomass and bioenergy: Potential estimation and current status and outlook", KCID Journal, 14(2), pp.255~260 (2007)
  33. 황철형, "비판문화기술지의 방법적 탐색: 탐구영역과 그 절차에 대한 이해", 교육문화연구, 19(3), pp.31~68 (2013), 교육연구소[DOI]
  34. 현재환, "시민참여를 통한 과학기술 거버넌스: STS의 ‘참여적 전환’ 내의 다양한 입장에 대한 역사적 인식론", 과학기술학연구, 12(2), pp.33~79 (2012), 한국과학기술학회
  35. Climate change 2014: Synthesis report. contribution of working groups I, II and III to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change, "IPCC", IPCC, ~ (2014)
  36. IPCC, "Global warming of 1.5℃, An IPCC special reprot on the impacts of global warming of 1.5℃ above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission pathways, in the context of strengthening the global response to the threat of climate change, sustainable development, and efforts to eradicate poverty: Summary for Policymakers", World Meteorological Organization, ~ (2018)
  37. Kahn, S., "A conceptual analysis of perspective taking : Positioning a tangled construct within science education and beyond", Science & Education, 28, pp.605~638 (2019)
  38. Kempton, W., "Identity and the natural environment: The psychological significance of nature", pp.317~341 (2003), MIT Press
  39. Kim, M., "Understanding children’s science identity through classroom interactions", International Journal of Science Education, 40(1), pp.24~45 (2018)
  40. 김종욱, "신문기사 읽기를 활용한 소집단 의사결정 과정 양상 -기후변화 관련 사회적 논쟁 활동을 중심으로-", 한국과학교육학회지, 38(2), pp.203~217 (2018), 한국과학교육학회[DOI]
  41. 김종욱, "실행 과정에서의 정체성 이론의 이해와 적용 방안", 한국과학교육학회지, 41(3), pp.267~281 (2021), 한국과학교육학회
  42. Kolstø, S. D., "‘To trust or not to trust,...’-pupils’ ways of judging information encountered in a socio-scientificissue", International journal of science education, 23(9), pp.877~901 (2001)
  43. Kolstø, S. D., "Scientific literacy for citizenship: Tools for dealing with the science dimension of controversial socio-scientific issues", Science Education, 85, pp.291~310 (2001)
  44. Kolstø, S. D., "Science students’ examination of scientific information related to socioscientific issues", Science Education, 90(4), pp.632~655 (2006)
  45. Krstovic, M., "Science and Technology Education Promoting Wellbeing for Individuals, Societies and Environments", pp.93~114 (2017), Springer
  46. "Science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) education: Background, federal policy and legislative action" (2008)[URL]
  47. Lee, H., "Socioscientific issues as a vehicle for promoting character and values for global citizens", International Journal of Science Education, 35(12), pp.2079~2113 (2013)
  48. 이현주, "이공계 대학생의 사회적 책임감 함양을 위한 ENACT 모형의 개발과 교육적 함의", 공학교육연구, 23(6), pp.3~16 (2020), 한국공학교육학회[DOI]
  49. Lee, J. -A, "Teaching and learning science in authoritative classrooms: Teachers’ power and students’ approval in Korean elementary classrooms", Research in Science Education, 49(5), pp.1367~1393 (2019)
  50. Lemke, J. L., "Talking science: Language learning and values" (1990), Ablex Publishing
  51. Levinson, R., "Introducing socio-scientific inquiry-based learning(SSIBL)", School Science Review, 100(371), pp.31~35 (2018)
  52. Lincoln, Y. S., "Naturalistic inquiry" (1985), sage
  54. Martin, J., "Researching teacher agency in elementary school science using positioning theory and grammar of agency", Journal of Science Teacher Education, 31(1), pp.94~113 (2020)
  55. Maeng, S., "Variations in science teaching modalities and students’ pedagogic subject positioning through the discourse register and language code", Science Education, 95(3), pp.431~457 (2011)
  56. Murcia, K., "Science in the news : An evaluation of students’ scientific literacy", Teaching Science, 55(3), pp.40~45 (2009)
  57. 문지영, "대학생의 과학 정보에 대한 신뢰도 판단 특성", 학습자중심교과교육연구, 17(1), pp.143~165 (2017), 학습자중심교과교육학회[DOI]
  58. National Research Council, "Successful K-12 STEM education:Identifying effective approaches in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics" (2011), The National Academies Press
  59. Park, E. J., "Hyeondae gugeo insik yangtae busaui yuui gwangye yeongu", Master, pp.2015
  60. Pierce, C., "Science and Technology Education Promoting Wellbeing for Individuals, Societies and Environments", pp.449~466 (2017), Springer
  61. Phillips-MacNeil, C., "Science and Technology Education Promoting Wellbeing for Individuals, Societies and Environments", pp.295~314 (2017), Springer
  62. Roth, W. M., "Scientific literacy as collective praxis", Public Understanding of Science, 11, pp.33~56 (2002)
  63. Roth, W. M., "Science education as", for participation in the community, 2004, pp.88(2), 263~291
  64. Rymes, B., "Classroom discourse analysis: A tool for critical reflection" (2015), Routledge
  65. Sadler, T. D., "Informal reasoning regarding socioscientific issues: A critical review of research", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 41(5), pp.513~536 (2004)
  66. Sadler, T. D., "Promoting discourse and argumentation in science teacher education", Journal of Science Teacher Education, 17(4), pp.323~346 (2006)
  67. Sadler, T. D., "What do students gain by engaging in socio-scientific inquiry?", Research in Science Education, 37, pp.371~391 (2007)
  68. Sadler, T. D., "A threshold model of content knowledge transfer for socioscientific argumentation", Science Education, 90(6), pp.986~1004 (2006)
  69. Sadler, T. D., "Socio-scientific Issues in the Classroom", pp.45~77 (2011), Springer
  70. Sadler, T. D., "Learning science content through socio-scientific issues-based instruction : A multi-level assessment study", International Journal of Science Education, 38(10), pp.1622~1635 (2016)
  71. Sadler, T. D., "Patterns of informal reasoning in the context of socio-scientific decision-making", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 42(1), pp.112~138 (2005)
  72. Seo, S., "Environmental identity of students participated in a social action-oriented climate change SSI club", Master, pp.2021
  73. Simonneaux, L., "Questions socialement vives and socioscientific issues: New trends of research to meet the training needs of post-modern society", 9th ESERA Conference Selected Contributions. Topics and trends in current science education, pp.37~54 (2013), Springer
  74. Sjöström, J., "Cognition, Metacognition, and Culture in STEM Eucation", pp.65~88 (2018), Springer
  75. L. Bencze, "Societies and Environments", pp.449~466, Springer
  76. STEPI, "The fourth industrial revolution: Things that haven't been said yet" (2008), E-SAE
  77. Strauss, A., "Basics of qualitative research techniques" (1998), Sage publications
  78. Tseng, A. S., "Students and evaluation of web-based misinformation about vaccination: Critical reading or passive acceptance of claims?", International Journal of Science Education, Part B, 8(3), pp.250~265 (2018)
  79. Williams, J., "STEM Education : Proceed with caution", Design and Technology Education, 16(1), pp.26~35 (2011)
  80. Zeidler, D. L., "Beyond STS : A research‐based framework for socioscientific issues education", Science education, 89(3), pp.357~377 (2005)
  81. Zeidler, D. L., "Tangled up in views : Beliefs in the nature of science and responses to socioscientific dilemmas", Science Education, 86, pp.343~367 (2002)
  82. Zohar, A., "Fostering students’ knowledge and argumentation skills through dilemmas in human genetics", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 39(1), pp.35~62 (2002)

관련 논문AI추천

시민으로서의 참여와 실천을 위한 과학교육의 전환 가능성 탐색: 기후-선거 프로그램김진아, 유금복, 유은정한국과학교육학회 · 한국과학교육학회지2025 · 제45권 제5호기후변화와 생물다양성 감소에 대한 지역 기반 SSI 프로그램 운영 및 교육효과 탐색김재덕, 문지영, 이현주교과교육연구소 · 교과교육학연구2023 · 제27권 제6호사회적 실천지향 SSI 수업을 시행하면서 직면하는 초등 교사의 어려움 탐색 -구조와 행위주체성 관점에서-김종욱, 김찬종, 임성은한국과학교육학회 · 한국과학교육학회지2021 · 제41권 제2호과학관련 사회적 쟁점 기반 과학 수업 연구의 특징 분석이윤정, 장신호한국초등과학교육학회 · 초등과학교육2023 · 제42권 제1호탄소중립 STEAM 프로그램이 초등학생의 기후변화에 대한 태도와 기후변화에 대한 탐구 능력 인식에 미치는 영향김소정, 신동훈에너지기후변화교육학회 · 에너지기후변화교육2025 · 제15권 제2호기후변화 STS 수업이 초등학생의 과학 흥미와 과학 호기심에 미치는 영향강지훈, 유병길에너지기후변화교육학회 · 에너지기후변화교육2023 · 제13권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (6건)

2022 개정 교육과정 고등학교 지구과학 내용 구성 방안 탐색 -천문 영역을 중심으로-김현종pp. 441-454텍스트 마이닝을 활용한 융합인재교육정책 동향 분석 -2009년∼2020년 교육부보도, 언론보도, 학술지 초록 비교분석-김성원, 유정민pp. 455-470한국의 과학교육 종합 지표 개발 연구고수영, 강다연, 홍옥수, 김도경pp. 471-481과학과 교육과정 지역화 정책에 대한 전문가 인식 탐색 -교육과정 편성⋅운영 지침 및 성취기준 개정을 중심으로-홍훈기, 이경건, 천주영pp. 483-499예비교사들의 과학 교사 정체성 형성 -생명과학 탐구 수업 시연 및 반성 과정을 중심으로-김희백, 안지은pp. 519-531
원문 보기