Sodium Citrate가 효과적으로 비전도성 후각장애에 치료효과를 보일 수 있을지에 대한 문헌 고찰
Can Sodium Citrate Effectively Improve Olfactory Function in Non-Conductive Olfactory Dysfunction?
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
초록
The objective of this study was to perform a systematic review of the literature for application of intranasal sodium citrate in the patients with olfactory dysfunction to help determine the sodium citrate treatments for this condition. Two authors independently searched the data base (Medline, Scopus, and the Cochrane database) for relevant studies from inception to January 2018. Included studies were randomized controlled studies published in English comparing topical sodium citrate application (treatment group) with saline (control group) in patients who had olfactory dysfunction. Outcomes of interest included the change of olfactory identification and threshold during 2 hours post-treatment. Three studies were enrolled in the meta-analysis. Compared with control group, treatment group did not increase posttreatment score of olfactory identification [standardized mean difference (SMD)=-0.03; 95% confidence interval (CI)= -0.29-0.24; I2=0%] and olfactory threshold (SMD=0.18; 95% CI=-0.09-0.45; I2=0%) significantly. In the degree of pre-post improvement of two outcomes, although treatment group statistically showed the significant improvement in olfactory threshold (SMD=0.30; 95% CI=0.05- 0.55; I2=17%), the clinical significance of this outcome was meaningless. Similarly, there was no significant difference in olfactory identification between two groups (SMD=0.17; 95% CI=-0.11-0.45; I2=22%). Unlike the recent favorable results, our summated results presented the uselessness for the local application of sodium citrate in improving patient’s olfactory function. However, we also had some limitation such as small sample size and inconsistent application methods. Therefore, larger trials and standardized methodology are needed to reach more stronger and exact results.
Abstract
The objective of this study was to perform a systematic review of the literature for application of intranasal sodium citrate in the patients with olfactory dysfunction to help determine the sodium citrate treatments for this condition. Two authors independently searched the data base (Medline, Scopus, and the Cochrane database) for relevant studies from inception to January 2018. Included studies were randomized controlled studies published in English comparing topical sodium citrate application (treatment group) with saline (control group) in patients who had olfactory dysfunction. Outcomes of interest included the change of olfactory identification and threshold during 2 hours post-treatment. Three studies were enrolled in the meta-analysis. Compared with control group, treatment group did not increase posttreatment score of olfactory identification [standardized mean difference (SMD)=-0.03; 95% confidence interval (CI)= -0.29-0.24; I2=0%] and olfactory threshold (SMD=0.18; 95% CI=-0.09-0.45; I2=0%) significantly. In the degree of pre-post improvement of two outcomes, although treatment group statistically showed the significant improvement in olfactory threshold (SMD=0.30; 95% CI=0.05- 0.55; I2=17%), the clinical significance of this outcome was meaningless. Similarly, there was no significant difference in olfactory identification between two groups (SMD=0.17; 95% CI=-0.11-0.45; I2=22%). Unlike the recent favorable results, our summated results presented the uselessness for the local application of sodium citrate in improving patient’s olfactory function. However, we also had some limitation such as small sample size and inconsistent application methods. Therefore, larger trials and standardized methodology are needed to reach more stronger and exact results.
참고문헌 (25)
- Alt JA, "Predictors of olfactory dysfunction in rhinosinusitis using the brief smell identification test", Laryngoscope, 124(7), pp.E259~66 (2014)
- Litvack JR, "Predictors of olfactory dysfunction in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis", Laryngoscope, 118(12), pp.2225~2230 (2008)
- Wang X, "Intranasal application of glucocorticoid alleviates olfactory dysfunction in mice with allergic rhinitis", Exp Ther Med, 14(5), pp.3971~3978 (2017)
- Katotomichelakis M, "Improvement of olfactory function for quality of life recovery", Laryngoscope, 123(11), pp.E10~6 (2013)
- Holbrook EH, "An updated review of clinical olfaction", Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 14(1), pp.23~28 (2006)
- 박석원, "후각장애 치료의 최근 경향", 대한이비인후-두경부외과학회지, 55(5), pp.272~277 (2012), 대한이비인후과학회[DOI]
- Panagiotopoulos G, "Decreasing nasal mucus Ca++ improves hyposmia", Rhinology, 43(2), pp.130~134 (2005)
- Philpott CM, "A randomised controlled trial of sodium citrate spray for nonconductive olfactory disorders", Clin Otolaryngol, 42(6), pp.1295~1302 (2017)
- Whitcroft KL, "The effect of intranasal sodium citrate on olfaction in post-infectious loss : Results from a prospective, placebo-controlled trial in 49 patients", Clin Otolaryngol, 42(3), pp.557~563 (2017)
- Whitcroft KL, "Intranasal sodium citrate solution improves olfaction in post-viral hyposmia", Rhinology, 54(4), pp.368~374 (2016)
- Menini A, "Calcium signalling and regulation in olfactory neurons", Curr Opin Neurobiol, 9(4), pp.419~426 (1999)
- Leinders-Zufall T, "Imaging odor-induced calcium transients in single olfactory cilia : Specificity of activation and role in transduction", J Neurosci, 18(15), pp.5630~5639 (1998)
- Zufall F, "Amplification of odorinduced Ca(2+)transients by store-operated Ca(2+)release and its role in olfactory signal transduction", J Neurophysiol, 83(1), pp.501~512 (2000)
- Leinders-Zufall T, "Impaired odor adaptation in olfactory receptor neurons after inhibition of Ca2+", calmodulin kinase II, 1999, pp.19(14), Rc19~
- Kelliher KR, "Importance of the CNGA4 channel gene for odor discrimination and adaptation in behaving mice", Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 100(7), pp.4299~4304 (2003)
- Lötsch J, "Different odor tests contribute differently to the evaluation of olfactory loss", Chem Senses, 33(1), pp.17~21 (2008)
- Kobal G, "Multicenter investigation of 1, 036 subjects using a standardized method for the assessment of olfactory function combining tests of odor identification, odor discrimination, and olfactory thresholds", Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol, 257(4), pp.205~211 (2000)
- Doty RL, "A study of the test-retest reliability of ten olfactory tests", Chem Senses, 20(6), pp.645~656 (1995)
- Acion L, "Probabilistic index : An intuitive non-parametric approach to measuring the size of treatment effects", Stat Med, 25(4), pp.591~602 (2006)
- Saito S, "Development of a smell identification test using a novel stick-type odor presentation kit", Chem Senses, 31(4), pp.379~391 (2006)
- Klimmeck D, "Calcium-signaling networks in olfactory receptor neurons", Neuroscience, 151(3), pp.901~912 (2008)
- Choi R, "Olfactory epithelium : Cells, clinical disorders, and insights from an adult stem cell niche", Laryngoscope Investig Otolaryngol, 3(1), pp.35~42 (2018)
- Chang H, "Clinical implication of the olfactory cleft in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis and olfactory loss", Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 135(10), pp.988~992 (2009)
- Soler ZM, "The olfactory cleft endoscopy scale correlates with olfactory metrics in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis", Int Forum Allergy Rhinol, 6(3), pp.293~298 (2016)
- Pekala K, "Efficacy of olfactory training in patients with olfactory loss : A systematic review and meta-analysis", Int Forum Allergy Rhinol, 6(3), pp.299~307 (2016)