Effect of scanning strategies on the accuracy of digital intraoral scanners: a meta-analysis of in vitro studies
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose. This study aimed to investigate whether the accuracy of intraoral scanners is influenced by different scanning strategies in an in vitro setting, through a systematic review and meta-analysis. Materials and methods. This review was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA 2020 standard. The following PICOS approach was used: population, tooth impressions; intervention, the use of intraoral scanners with scanning strategies different from the manufacturer’s instructions; control, the use of intraoral scanners following the manufacturers’ requirements; outcome, accuracy of intraoral scanners; type of studies, in vitro. A comprehensive literature search was conducted across various databases including Embase, SciELO, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. The inclusion criteria were based on in vitro studies that reported the accuracy of digital impressions using intraoral scanners. Analysis was performed using Review Manager software (version 5.3.5; Cochrane Collaboration, Copenhagen, Denmark). Global comparisons were made using a standardized mean difference based on random-effect models, with a significance level of α = 0.05. Results. The meta-analysis included 15 articles. Digital impression accuracy significantly improved under dry conditions (P < 0.001). Moreover, trueness and precision were enhanced when artificial landmarks were used (P ≤ 0.02) and when an S-shaped pattern was followed (P ≤ 0.01). However, the type of light used did not have a significant impact on the accuracy of the digital intraoral scanners (P ≥ 0.16). Conclusion. The accuracy of digital intraoral scanners can be enhanced by employing scanning processes using artificial landmarks and digital impressions under dry conditions.
Abstract
Purpose. This study aimed to investigate whether the accuracy of intraoral scanners is influenced by different scanning strategies in an in vitro setting, through a systematic review and meta-analysis. Materials and methods. This review was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA 2020 standard. The following PICOS approach was used: population, tooth impressions; intervention, the use of intraoral scanners with scanning strategies different from the manufacturer’s instructions; control, the use of intraoral scanners following the manufacturers’ requirements; outcome, accuracy of intraoral scanners; type of studies, in vitro. A comprehensive literature search was conducted across various databases including Embase, SciELO, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. The inclusion criteria were based on in vitro studies that reported the accuracy of digital impressions using intraoral scanners. Analysis was performed using Review Manager software (version 5.3.5; Cochrane Collaboration, Copenhagen, Denmark). Global comparisons were made using a standardized mean difference based on random-effect models, with a significance level of α = 0.05. Results. The meta-analysis included 15 articles. Digital impression accuracy significantly improved under dry conditions (P < 0.001). Moreover, trueness and precision were enhanced when artificial landmarks were used (P ≤ 0.02) and when an S-shaped pattern was followed (P ≤ 0.01). However, the type of light used did not have a significant impact on the accuracy of the digital intraoral scanners (P ≥ 0.16). Conclusion. The accuracy of digital intraoral scanners can be enhanced by employing scanning processes using artificial landmarks and digital impressions under dry conditions.
참고문헌 (127)
- Chen, LC, "Innovative 3D dental measurement for tooth model restoration", Key Eng Mater, 295, pp.145~150 (2005)
- Park HS, "Development of high speed and high accuracy 3D dental intra oral scanner", Proced Eng, 100, pp.1174~1181 (2015)
- Ali A, "Accuracy of digital impressions achieved from five different digital impression systems", Dentistry, 5, pp.1~6 (2015)
- Duret F, "Toward a new symbolism in the fabrication of prosthetic design", Cah Prothese, 13, pp.65~71 (1985)
- Richert R, "Intraoral scanner technologies : a review to make a successful impression", J Healthc Eng, 2017, pp.8427595~ (2017)
- Hayama H, "Trueness and precision of digital impressions obtained using an intraoral scanner with different head size in the partially edentulous mandible", J Prosthodont Res, 62, pp.347~352 (2018)
- "ISO 5725-1. Accuracy (trueness and precision) of measurement methods and results - Part 1: General principles and definitions", International Standards Organization (ISO), ~ (1994)
- Miyazaki T, "A review of dental CAD", CAM : current status and future perspectives from 20 years of experience, 2009, pp.28, 44~56
- Atieh MA, "Accuracy evaluation of intraoral optical impressions : a clinical study using a reference appliance", J Prosthet Dent, 118, pp.400~405 (2017)
- Gan N, "Accuracy of intraoral digital impressions for whole upper jaws, including full dentitions and palatal soft tissues", PLoS One, 11, pp.e0158800~ (2016)
- Mehl A, "Full arch scans : conventional versus digital impressions-an in vitro study", Int J Comput Dent, 12, pp.11~28 (2009)
- Ender A, "Accuracy of complete-arch dental impressions : a new method of measuring trueness and precision", J Prosthet Dent, 109, pp.121~128 (2013)
- Kihara H, "Accuracy and practicality of intraoral scanner in dentistry : A literature review", J Prosthodont Res, 64, pp.109~113 (2020)
- Chiu A, "Accuracy of CAD", CAM digital impressions with different intraoral scanner parameters, 2020, pp.20, 1157~1166
- Haddadi Y, "Effect of software version on the accuracy of an intraoral scanning device", Int J Prosthodont, 31, pp.375~376 (2018)
- Revilla-León M, "Intraoral digital scans : Part 2-influence of ambient scanning light conditions on the mesh quality of different intraoral scanners", J Prosthet Dent, 124, pp.575~580 (2020)
- Carneiro Pereira AL, "Factors that influence the accuracy of intraoral scanning of total edentulous arches rehabilitated with multiple implants : A systematic review", J Prosthet Dent, 129, pp.855~862 (2023)
- Jivanescu A, "Can dental office lighting intensity conditions influence the accuracy of intraoral scanning?", Scanning, 2021, pp.9980590~ (2021)
- Son K, "Effect of finish line locations of tooth preparation on the accuracy of intraoral scanners", Int J Comput Dent, 24, pp.29~40 (2021)
- Page MJ, "The PRISMA 2020 statement : an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews", Int Surg J, 88, pp.105906~105915 (2021)
- Ouzzani M, "Rayyan-a web and mobile app for systematic reviews", Syst rev, 5, pp.1~10 (2016)
- Çakmak G, "Effect of measurement techniques and operators on measured deviations in digital implant scans", J Dent, 130, pp.104388~104394 (2023)
- González de Villaumbrosia P, "In vitro comparison of the accuracy(trueness and precision)of six extraoral dental scanners with different scanning technologies", J Prosthet Dent, 116, pp.543~50.e1 (2016)
- Donmez MB, "Congruence between the meshes of a combined healing abutment-scan body system acquired with four different intraoral scanners and the corresponding library file : An in vitro analysis", J Dent, 118, pp.103938~103945 (2022)
- Elter B, "The trueness of an intraoral scanner in scanning different post space depths", J Dent, 127, pp.104352~104357 (2022)
- Gómez-Polo M, "Influence of rescanning mesh holes and stitching procedures on the complete-arch scanning accuracy of an intraoral scanner : An in vitro study", J Dent, 110, pp.103690~103698 (2021)
- Hategan SI, "Powder and powder-free intra-oral scanners : digital impression accuracy", Prim Dent J, 7, pp.40~43 (2018)
- Ioshida M, "Accuracy and reliability of mandibular digital model registration with use of the mucogingival junction as the reference", Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol, 127, pp.351~360 (2019)
- Jeon JH, "Three-dimensional evaluation of the repeatability of scanned conventional impressions of prepared teeth generated with white-and blue-light scanners", J Prosthet Dent, 114, pp.549~553 (2015)
- Kim YH, "Linear accuracy of full-arch digital models using four different scanning methods : an in vitro study using a coordinate measuring machine", Appl Sci, 10, pp.2741~2752 (2020)
- Lee B, "Evaluation of the trueness of digital implant impressions according to the implant scan body orientation and scanning method", Appl Sci, 11, pp.3027~3038 (2021)
- Marques VR, "Effect of scanned area and operator on the accuracy of dentate arch scans with a single implant", J Clin Med, 11, pp.4125~4137 (2022)
- Nedelcu RG, "Scanning accuracy and precision in 4 intraoral scanners : an in vitro comparison based on 3-dimensional analysis", J Prosthet Dent, 112, pp.1461~1471 (2014)
- 박지만, "Comparative analysis on reproducibility among 5 intraoral scanners: sectional analysis according to restoration type and preparation outline form", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 8(5), pp.354~362 (2016), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Park JH, "Registration of digital dental models and cone-beam computed tomography images using 3-dimensional planning software : Comparison of the accuracy according to scanning methods and software", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 157, pp.843~851 (2020)
- Passos L, "Digital impressions’ accuracy through"cut-out-rescan"and"data exchange by over scanning"techniques in complete arches of two intraoral scanners and CAD", CAM software, 2022, pp.66, 509~513
- Pedroche LO, "Marginal and internal fit of zirconia copings obtained using different digital scanning methods", Braz Oral Res, 30, pp.e113~20 (2016)
- Pereira ALC, "Accuracy between intraoral and extraoral scanning : Three-dimensional deviation and effect of distance between implants from two scanning methods", J Indian Prosthodont Soc, 22, pp.279~287 (2022)
- Pozzi A, "Accuracy of complete-arch digital implant impression with or without scanbody splinting : an in vitro study", J Dent, 119, pp.104072~104079 (2022)
- Ren X, "Accuracy of proximal and occlusal contacts of single implant crowns fabricated using different digital scan methods : an in vitro study", Materials(Basel), 14, pp.2843~ (2021)
- Revilla-León M, "Accuracy of the 3-dimensional virtual patient representation obtained by using 4 different techniques : An in vitro study", J Prosthet Dent, S0022-3913(22), pp.00342~00340 (2022)
- Virard F, "Improving digital scans by using a peripheral custom tray : a dental technique", J Prosthet Dent, 126, pp.173~177 (2021)
- Ye J, "Comparison of the dimensional and morphological accuracy of three-dimensional digital dental casts digitized using different methods", Odontology, 111, pp.165~171 (2023)
- Zhang YJ, "Influence of different factors on the accuracy of digital impressions of multiple implants : an in vitro study", Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants, 36, pp.442~449 (2021)
- Camcı H, "Effect of saliva isolation and intraoral light levels on performance of intraoral scanners", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 158, pp.759~766 (2020)
- Gajbhiye V, "Comparative evaluation of three gingival displacement materials for efficacy in tissue management and dimensional accuracy", J Indian Prosthodont Soc, 19, pp.173~179 (2019)
- Imburgia M, "Continuous scan strategy(CSS) : a novel technique to improve the accuracy of intraoral digital impressions", Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent, 28, pp.128~141 (2020)
- Koseoglu M, "Evaluating the effect of ambient and scanning lights on the trueness of the intraoral scanner", J Prosthodont, 30, pp.811~816 (2021)
- Lim SW, "Registration accuracy between intraoral-scanned and cone-beam computed tomography-scanned crowns in various registration methods", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 157, pp.348~356 (2020)
- Moon YG, "Comparison of the accuracy of intraoral scans between complete-arch scan and quadrant scan", Prog Orthod, 21, pp.36~ (2020)
- Nedelcu R, "In vivo trueness and precision of full-arch implant scans using intraoral scanners with three different acquisition protocols", J Dent, 128, pp.104308~104319 (2023)
- Althubaitiy R, "The accuracy of digital implant impressions when using and varying the material and diameter of the dental implant scan bodies", Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent, 30, pp.305~313 (2022)
- Denneulin T, "Accuracy of complete-arch implant digital scans: effect of scanning protocol, number of implants, and scan body splinting", Int J Prosthodont, 36, pp.219~227 (2023)
- Fang Y, "A Technique for digital impression and bite registration for a single edentulous arch", J Prosthodont, 28, pp.e519~23 (2019)
- Osman RB, "Influence of scan technology on the accuracy and speed of intraoral scanning systems for the edentulous maxilla : An in vitro study", J Prosthodont (2022)[DOI]
- Reich S, "Do"cut out-rescan"procedures have an impact on the accuracy of intraoral digital scans?", J Prosthet Dent, 125, pp.89~94 (2021)
- Garikano X, "Evaluation of repeatability of different alignment methods to obtain digital interocclusal records : An in vitro study", J Prosthet Dent (2022)[DOI]
- Bratos M, "Effect of simulated intraoral variables on the accuracy of a photogrammetric imaging technique for complete-arch implant prostheses", J Prosthet Dent, 120, pp.232~241 (2018)
- Diker B, "Accuracy of six intraoral scanners for scanning complete-arch and 4-unit fixed partial dentures : an in vitro study", J Prosthet Dent, 128, pp.187~194 (2022)
- Burcu Diker, "Comparing the accuracy of six intraoral scanners on prepared teeth and effect of scanning sequence", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 12(5), pp.299~306 (2020), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Diker B, "Accuracy of digital impressions obtained using six intraoral scanners in partially edentulous dentitions and the effect of scanning sequence", Int J Prosthodont, 34, pp.101~108 (2021)
- Kim MK, "The effect of scanning distance on the accuracy of intra-oral scanners used in dentistry", Clin Anat, 32, pp.430~438 (2019)
- Kim EY, "Effect of scanning origin location on data accuracy of abutment teeth region in digital impression acquired using intraoral scanner for removable partial denture : a preliminary in vitro study", J Clin Med, 11, pp.7392~ (2022)
- Lopes D, "Impact of different scan strategies and implant angulation on impression accuracy of full arch multiple implant : an in vitro study", Braz Dent Sci, 25, pp.e3006~ (2022)
- Mandelli F, "Full-arch intraoral scanning : comparison of two different strategies and their accuracy outcomes", J Osseointegr, 10, pp.65~74 (2018)
- Medina-Sotomayor P, "Accuracy of four digital scanners according to scanning strategy in complete-arch impressions", PloS one, 13, pp.e0202916~ (2018)
- Mizumoto RM, "The effect of scanning the palate and scan body position on the accuracy of complete-arch implant scans", Clin Implant Dent Relat Res, 21, pp.987~994 (2019)
- Müller P, "Impact of digital intraoral scan strategies on the impression accuracy using the TRIOS Pod scanner", Quintessence Int, 47, pp.343~349 (2016)
- Ochoa-López G, "Influence of ambient light conditions on the accuracy and scanning time of seven intraoral scanners in complete-arch implant scans", J Dent, 121, pp.104138~104146 (2022)
- Oh KC, "Effects of scanning strategy and scanner type on the accuracy of intraoral scans : A new approach for assessing the accuracy of scanned data", J Prosthodont, 29, pp.518~523 (2020)
- Pattamavilai S, "Accuracy of intraoral scanners in different complete arch scan patterns", J Prosthet Dent, S0022-3913(22), pp.00046~00044 (2022)[DOI]
- Rotar RN, "Scanning distance influence on the intraoral scanning accuracy-an in vitro study", Materials(Basel), 15, pp.3061~3068 (2022)
- Stefanelli LV, "Use of intraoral scanners for full dental arches : could different strategies or overlapping software affect accuracy?", Int J Environ Res Public Health, 18, pp.9946~9959 (2021)
- Arcuri L, "Influence of implant scanbody material, position and operator on the accuracy of digital impression for complete-arch: A randomized in vitro trial", J Prosthodont Res, 64, pp.128~136 (2020)
- Ender A, "Influence of scanning strategies on the accuracy of digital intraoral scanning systems", Int J Comput Dent, 16, pp.11~21 (2013)
- Latham J, "Effect of scan pattern on complete-arch scans with 4 digital scanners", J Prosthet Dent, 123, pp.85~95 (2020)
- Mizumoto RM, "Accuracy of different digital scanning techniques and scan bodies for complete-arch implant-supported prostheses", J Prosthet Dent, 123, pp.96~104 (2020)
- Motel C, "Impact of different scan bodies and scan strategies on the accuracy of digital implant impressions assessed with an intraoral scanner : an in vitro study", J Prosthodont, 29, pp.309~314 (2020)
- Peroz S, "Measured accuracy of intraoral scanners is highly dependent on methodical factors", J Prosthodont Res, 66, pp.318~325 (2022)
- Revilla-León M, "Analysis of different illuminance of the room lighting condition on the accuracy(trueness and precision)of an intraoral scanner", J Prosthodont, 30, pp.157~162 (2021)
- Wesemann C, "Does ambient light affect the accuracy and scanning time of intraoral scans?", J Prosthet Dent, 125, pp.924~931 (2021)
- Zarone F, "Comparison of different intraoral scanning techniques on the completely edentulous maxilla : an in vitro 3-dimensional comparative analysis", J Prosthet Dent, 124, pp.762.e1~8 (2020)
- Al-Ibrahim I, "The effect of operator scanning speed on the trueness and precision of full-arch digital impressions captured in vitro using an intraoral scanner", J Osseoint, 13(4 Supplement), pp.S265~70 (2021)
- Baek YW, "Effect of custom abutment data superimposition on the accuracy of implant abutment level scanning : an in vitro study", J Prosthet Dent, S0022-3913(22), pp.00176~00177 (2022)
- Cakmak G, "Comparison of measured deviations in digital implant scans depending on software and operator", J Dent, 122, pp.104154~ (2022)
- Feng CW, "Accuracy of different head movements of intraoral scanner in full arch of both maxilla and mandible", Appl Sci, 11, pp.8140~8152 (2021)
- Kurz M, "Influence of material surface on the scanning error of a powder-free 3D measuring system", Clin Oral Investig, 19, pp.2035~2043 (2015)
- Revilla-León M, "Influence of ambient temperature changes on intraoral scanning accuracy", J Prosthet Dent, S0022-3913(22), pp.00061~00060 (2022)
- Oh HS, "Effect of scanning-aid agents on the scanning accuracy in specially designed metallic models : a laboratory study", PLoS One, 17, pp.e0267742~51 (2022)
- Song J, "Accuracy on scanned images of full arch models with orthodontic brackets by various intraoral scanners in the presence of artificial saliva", Biomed Res Int, 2020, pp.2920804~ (2020)
- You R, "Evaluation of intraoral optical scanning accuracy for fine structure reconstruction and occlusal records of inlay", onlay preparations, 2022, pp.25, 257~265
- Alenezi A, "Effect of full arch two scanning techniques on the accuracy of overdenture conventional and CAD", CAM Co-Cr bars, 2022, pp.34, 553~564
- Hai Yen Mai, "Impact of scanning strategy on the accuracy of complete-arch intraoral scans: a preliminary study on segmental scans and merge methods", The Journal of Advanced of Prosthodontics, 14(2), pp.88~95 (2022), 대한치과보철학회[DOI]
- Arakida T, "Evaluating the influence of ambient light on scanning trueness, precision, and time of intra oral scanner", J Prosthodont Res, 62, pp.324~329 (2018)
- An H, "Effect of scanning speed, scanning pattern, and tip size on the accuracy of intraoral digital scans", J Prosthet Dent, S0022-3913(22), pp.00326~00322 (2022)
- Chen Y, "Influence of liquid on the tooth surface on the accuracy of intraoral scanners : an in vitro study", J Prosthodont, 31, pp.59~64 (2022)
- Donmez MB, "Trueness and precision of combined healing abutment-scan body system depending on the scan pattern and implant location : an in-vitro study", J Dent, 124, pp.104169~104179 (2022)
- Gavounelis NA, "The effect of scanning strategy on intraoral scanner’s accuracy", Dent J(Basel), 10, pp.123~133 (2022)
- Gómez-Polo M, "Influence of the surface humidity, implant angulation, and interimplant distance on the accuracy and scanning time of complete-arch implant scans", J Dent, 127, pp.104307~104316 (2022)
- Kanjanasavitree P, "Comparison of different artificial landmarks and scanning patterns on the complete-arch implant intraoral digital scans", J Dent, 125, pp.104266~104273 (2022)
- Kim JE, "Accuracy of intraoral digital impressions using an artificial landmark", J Prosthet Dent, 117, pp.755~761 (2017)
- Li Z, "Effect of scan pattern on the accuracy of complete-arch digital implant impressions with two intraoral scanners", Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants, 37, pp.731~739 (2022)
- Oh HS, "Influence of scanning-aid materials on the accuracy and time efficiency of intraoral scanners for full-arch digital scanning : an in vitro study", Materials(Basel), 14, pp.2340~2351 (2021)
- Oh HS, "Influence of applied liquid-type scanning-aid material on the accuracy of the scanned image : an in vitro experiment", Materials(Basel), 13, pp.2034~2045 (2020)
- Passos L, "Impact of different scanning strategies on the accuracy of two current intraoral scanning systems in complete-arch impressions : an in vitro study", Int J Comput Dent, 22, pp.307~319 (2019)
- Rapone B, "The accuracy of three intraoral scanners in the oral environment with and without saliva : a comparative study", Appl Sci, 10, pp.7762~7781 (2020)
- Revilla-León M, "Intraoral digital scans-Part 1 : Influence of ambient scanning light conditions on the accuracy(trueness and precision)of different intraoral scanners", J Prosthet Dent, 124, pp.372~378 (2020)
- Tao C, "Accuracy of intraoral scanning of edentulous jaws with and without resin markers", Chin J Dent Res, 23, pp.265~271 (2020)
- Lee KM, "Comparison of two intraoral scanners based on three-dimensional surface analysis", Prog Orthod, 19, pp.1~7 (2018)
- Grassi FR, "Effectiveness of computer-assisted anesthetic delivery system(sta™)in dental implant surgery : a prospective study", Oral Implantol(Rome), 10, pp.381~389 (2017)
- Tsirogiannis P, "Evaluation of the marginal fit of single-unit, complete-coverage ceramic restorations fabricated after digital and conventional impressions : A systematic review and meta-analysis", J Prosthet Dent, 116, pp.328~35.e2 (2016)
- Ahlholm P, "Digital versus conventional impressions in fixed prosthodontics : a review", J Prosthodont, 27, pp.35~41 (2018)
- Ferrari M, "The ability of marginal detection using different intraoral scanning systems : A pilot randomized controlled trial", Am J Dent, 31, pp.272~276 (2018)
- "European Lightening Standard. EN 12464-1. Light and lighting - Lighting of work places - Part 1: Indoor work places", ~ (2011)
- Blanco D, "Influence of ambient light on the quality of laser digitized surfaces", Proceedings of the world congress on engineering, 1, pp.32~37 (2008)
- Fang JH, "Digital intraoral scanning technique for edentulous jaws", J Prosthet Dent, 119, pp.733~735 (2018)
- Chebib N, "Edentulous jaw impression techniques : An in vivo comparison of trueness", J Prosthet Dent, 121, pp.623~630 (2019)
- Patzelt SB, "Assessing the feasibility and accuracy of digitizing edentulous jaws", J Am Dent Assoc, 144, pp.914~920 (2013)
- Andriessen FS, "Applicability and accuracy of an intraoral scanner for scanning multiple implants in edentulous mandibles : a pilot study", J Prosthet Dent, 111, pp.186~194 (2014)
- Flügge TV, "Precision of intraoral digital dental impressions with iTero and extraoral digitization with the iTero and a model scanner", Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop, 144, pp.471~478 (2013)
- Deferm JT, "Validation of 3D documentation of palatal soft tissue shape, color, and irregularity with intraoral scanning", Clin Oral Investig, 22, pp.1303~1309 (2018)
- Ji-won Anh, "A comparison of the precision of three-dimensional images acquired by 2 digital intraoral scanners: effects of tooth irregularity and scanning direction", 대한치과교정학회지, 46(1), pp.3~12 (2016), 대한치과교정학회
- Khraishi H, "Evidence for use of intraoral scanners under clinical conditions for obtaining fullarch digital impressions is insufficient", Evid Based Dent, 18, pp.24~25 (2017)
- Huang MY, "Effect of distance between the abutment and the adjacent teeth on intraoral scanning : an in vitro study", J Prosthet Dent, 125, pp.911~917 (2021)
- Burde AV, "Three-dimensional evaluations of the coating thickness of two optical conditioning scanning sprays", Mater Plast, 53, pp.65~67 (2016)
- Quaas S, "Direct mechanical data acquisition of dental impressions for the manufacturing of CAD", CAM restorations, 2007, pp.35, 903~908
- Dehurtevent M, "Influence of dentist experience with scan spray systems used in direct CAD", CAM impressions, 2015, pp.113, 17~21
