본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Korea's First Museum and the Categorization of “Buddhist Statues”

Seunghye Lee
동아시아학술원 (The Academy of East Asian Studies)|2021.05|Sungkyun Journal of East Asian Studies|제21권 제1호|pp. 51-81|DOI 10.1215/15982661-8873892

0

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Buddhist statuessculpturecollecting practicesKorean art historiographyPrince Yi Household Museum
주제분류학제간연구

초록

The establishment of a museum in the precinct of Ch'anggyŏnggung Palace in 1909 marked an important moment in the historiography of Korean art. Although recent studies have examined the founding, organization, and financing of the first Korean museum, the formation of its Buddhist art collection and its historical implications remain unexamined. Given that not a single Buddhist temple was allowed to exist within the capital city, the entry of these objects into the palace demonstrates a radical paradigm shift in the royal court's relation to Buddhist icons. The museum's Buddhist art collection reveals what was available in the art market of the time and what was considered worthy of being collected in a royal museum. Through close examination of Korea's first museum and its collection, this study traces the recontextualization of religious icons into art objects and the historical implications behind the category of “Buddhist statues.”

Abstract

The establishment of a museum in the precinct of Ch'anggyŏnggung Palace in 1909 marked an important moment in the historiography of Korean art. Although recent studies have examined the founding, organization, and financing of the first Korean museum, the formation of its Buddhist art collection and its historical implications remain unexamined. Given that not a single Buddhist temple was allowed to exist within the capital city, the entry of these objects into the palace demonstrates a radical paradigm shift in the royal court's relation to Buddhist icons. The museum's Buddhist art collection reveals what was available in the art market of the time and what was considered worthy of being collected in a royal museum. Through close examination of Korea's first museum and its collection, this study traces the recontextualization of religious icons into art objects and the historical implications behind the category of “Buddhist statues.”

참고문헌 (80)

  1. 閔種默, "見聞事件", ~ (1881)
  2. 朴定陽., "日本國農商務省各局規則", ~ (1881)
  6. Abe, Stanley K, "Treasures Rediscovered: Chinese Stone Sculpture from the Sackler Collections at Columbia University, 7–16", pp.7~16 (2008), Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Art Gallery, Columbia University
  7. 스탠리 아베, "중국 조각의 근대적 순간", 미술자료, (82), pp.63~92 (2012), 국립중앙박물관
  8. Abe, Stanley K, "Comparativism in Art History", pp.94~108 (2017), Routledge
  9. 浅川伯教, "朝鮮の美術工 藝に就て回顧", pp.262~280 (1945), Chikazawa Shoten
  10. Aso, Noriko, "Public Properties : Museums in Imperial Japan" (2014), Duke University Press
  11. Bowie, Theodore, "Langdon Warner through His Letters" (1966), Indiana University Press
  12. Brandt, Kim., "Kingdom of Beauty : Mingei and the Politics of Folk Art in Imperial Japan" (2007), Duke University Press
  13. 全炅穆, "近代建築圖面集" (2009), Han’gukhak Chungang Yŏn’guwŏn Changsŏgak
  14. 全東園, "「韓国文化財」形成過程に関する史的考察-植民地期「朝鮮文化財」研究の成立と 言説空間の形成", PhD, pp.2017
  15. 藤田亮策, "朝鮮學論考", pp.67~88 (1963), Fujita Sensei Kinen Jigyōkai
  16. 權藤四郞介, "李王宮秘史" (1926), Chōsen Shinbunsha
  17. 한국박물관 100년사 편찬위원회, "한국박물관 100년사: 1909–2009" (2009), Kungnip Chungang Pangmulgwan and Han’guk Pangmulgwan Hyŏphoe.
  18. Henry, Todd A, "Sitings: Critical Approaches to Korean Geography", pp.15~38 (2008), University of Hawai’i Press
  19. ヒマラヤ山人, "小宮宮内次官及び宮内府中の人物", Chōsen, 3(1), pp.68~73 (1909)
  20. Horlyck, Charlotte, "Desirable Commodities—Unearthing and Collecting Koryŏ Celadon Ceramics in the Late Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries", Bulletin of SOAS, 76(30), pp.467~491 (2013)
  21. 황정연, "高宗年間(1863~1907) 宮中 書畵收藏의 전개와 변모양상", 미술사학연구, 259(259), pp.79~116 (2008), 한국미술사학회[DOI]
  22. 황정연, "조선시대 서화수장 연구" (2012), Sin’gu Munhwasa
  23. 황정연, "대한제국의 미술: 빛의 길을 꿈꾸다", pp.337~339 (2018), Kungnip Hyŏndae Misulgwan
  24. 井上正治, "博物館及動植物園の設立について", Chōsen, 1(4), pp.68~69 (1908)
  25. 石原留吉, "京城案内" (1915), Keijō Kyōsankai
  26. Jang, Sang Hoon, "A Representation of Nationhood: The National Museum of Korea", PhD, pp.2015
  27. 金子淳, "博物館の政治学" (2001), Seikyūsha
  28. 강희정, "『眞美大觀』과 일본 고대 불교조각", 美術史論壇, (28), pp.89~110 (2009), 한국미술연구소
  29. 강희정, "일제강점기 한국미술사의 구축과 석굴암의 ‘再맥락화", 선사와 고대, (33), pp.59~82 (2010), 한국고대학회[DOI]
  30. 강희정, "나라의 精華, 조선의 表象: 일제강점기 석굴암론" (2012), Sŏgang Taehakkyo Ch’ulp’anbu
  31. 京城府, "京城府史" (1934), Keijō-fu
  32. 김찬송, "창경궁박물관昌慶宮博物館의 설립과 변천과정 연구", 고궁문화, (11), pp.87~129 (2018), 국립고궁박물관[DOI]
  33. Kim, Christine, "Colonial Plunder and the Failure of Restitution in Postwar Korea", Journal of Contemporary History, 52(3), pp.607~624 (2017)
  34. Kim, Hwansoo Ilmee., "Empire of the Dharma : Korean and Japanese Buddhism 1877–1912" (2012), Harvard University Asia Center
  35. Kim, Sunglim., "Flowering Plums and Curio Cabinets : The Culture of Objects in Late Chosŏn Korean Art" (2018), University of Washington Press
  36. 김영나, "‘박람회’라는 전시공간 : 1893년 시카고 만국박 람회와 조선관 전시", Sŏyang misulsahakhoe nonmunjip, 13, pp.86~96 (2000)
  37. 木下直之, "美術という 見世物: 油絵茶屋の時代" (1993), Heibonsha
  38. 高裕燮, "朝鮮美術史 下: 各論篇", pp.164~170 (2007), Yŏrhwadang
  39. 小宮三保松, "朝鮮の美術", Chōsen, 3(5), pp.30~31 (1909)
  40. 小宮三保松, "李王家博物館所藏品寫眞帖" (1912), Riōshoku
  41. 小宮三保松, "李朝五百年の歴史を語る興味深き昌德宮の建築物", Chōsen kōron, 1(5), pp.45~50 (1913)
  42. 小宮三保松, "昌德宮と殿下の御 平生", Chōsen oyobi Manshū, 81, pp.119~121 (1914)
  43. Lee, Seunghye., "Toward the Future: Museums and Art History in East Asia", pp.151~159 (2020), apanese Committee for CIHA, Comité International de l’Histoire de l’Art, and the Otsuka Museum of Art.
  44. 睦秀炫, "일제하 박물 관의 형성과 그 의미", MA, pp.2000
  45. 睦秀炫, "일제 하 李王家博物館의 식민지적 성격", Misulsahak yŏn’gu, 227, pp.81~104 (2000)
  46. Moon, Virginia Han, "The Grafting of a Canon: The Politics of Korea’s National Treasures and the Formation of an Art History", PhD, pp.2010
  47. 국립중앙박물관, "한국박물관 개관 100주년기념특별전: 與民偕樂, 즐거움 을 나누다" (2009), Kungnip Chungang Pangmulgwan
  48. 국립중앙박물관, "국립중앙박 물관소장 불교조각 조사보고 I" (2014), Kungnip Chungang Pangmulgwan
  49. 국립중앙박물관, "東洋을 수집하다: 일제강점기 아시아 문화재의 수집과 전시" (2014), Kungnip Chungang Pangmulgwan
  50. 국립중앙박물관, "국립중앙박물 관소장 불교조각 조사보고 II" (2016), Kungnip Chungang Pangmulgwan
  51. 국립중앙박물관, "립중앙박 물관소장 불교조각 조사보고 III" (2018), Kungnip Chungang Pangmulgwan
  52. Okakura Kakuzō, "vol. 2 of Okakura Kakuzo, Collected English Writings", pp.30~48 (1984), Heibonsha
  53. Pai, Hyung Il, "Heritage Management in Korea and Japan : The Politics of Antiquity and Identity" (2013), University of Washington Press
  54. 박계리, "他者로서의 李王家博物館과 傳統觀-書畵觀을 중심으로", 미술사학연구, 240 (2003), 한국미술사학회
  55. 박계리, "帝室博物館과 御苑", Han’guk Pangmulgwan 100nyŏnsa P’yŏnch’an Wiwŏnhoe 2009, 34~81 (2009)
  56. 박소현, "帝國의 취미: 李王家博物館과 일본의 박물관 정책에 대해", Misulsa nondan, 18, pp.143~169 (2004)
  57. 박소현, "‘고려자기’는 어떻게 ‘미술’이 되었나- 식민지시대 ‘고려자기열광’과 이왕가박물관의 정치학", 사회연구, 7(1), pp.9~45 (2006), 한국사회조사연구소
  58. Racel, Masako N, "Okakura Kakuzō’s Art History : Cross-Cultural Encounters, Hegelian Dialectics and Darwinian Evolution", Asian Review of World Histories, 2(1), pp.17~45 (2014)
  59. 李王職, "李王家博物館所藏品寫 眞帖" (1912), Riōshoku
  60. 李王職, "李王家博物館所藏品寫 眞帖" (1918), Riōshoku
  61. 李王職, "李王家美術館の沿革", pp.1~6 (1938), Riōshoku
  62. 佐佐木兆治, "京城美術倶楽部創業二十年記念誌:朝鮮古美術業界二十年の回顧" (1942), Keijō Bijutsu Kurabu
  63. 關野貞, "韓國建築調査報告" (1904), Tōkyō Teikoku Daigaku Kōka Daigaku
  64. 關野貞, "朝鮮芸術之研究" (1910), Chōsen Sōtokufu Takushibu Kenchikusho
  65. 椎木宇之助, "朝鮮風景人俗寫眞帖", pp.Kaichi Shōkai, Nikkan Shobō
  66. "昌德宮昌慶苑寫眞帖", ~
  67. 신승모, "조선의 일본인경영 서점에 관한 시론— 日韓書房의 사례를 중심으로—", Irŏ ilmunhak yŏn’gu, 79(2), pp.321~338 (2011)
  68. 손영옥, "이왕가박물관 도자기 수집 목록에 대한 고찰", 한국근현대미술사학(구 한국근대미술사학), (35), pp.263~290 (2018), 한국근현대미술사학회(구 한국근대미술사학회)[DOI]
  69. 宋起炯, "‘창경궁박물관’ 또는 ‘李王家박물관’의 연대기", Yŏksa kyoyuk, 72, pp.169~198 (1999)
  70. 末松熊彦, "朝鮮の古美術保護と昌慶宮博物館", Chōsen oyobi Manshū, 69, pp.124~127 (1913)
  71. 杉原定吉, "朝鮮國寶大觀" (1911), Dōbunkan
  72. Suzuki, Sadami, "Pacific Rim Modernisms", pp.70~99 (2009), University of Toronto Press
  73. 高木博志, "近代天皇制の文化史的研究: 天皇就任儀礼・年中行事・文化財" (1997), Azekura Shobō
  74. 東京國立博物館, "東京國立博物館百年史" (1973), Tōkyō Kokuritsu Hakubutsukan
  75. 우동선, "궁궐의눈물, 백년의 침묵", pp.202~237 (2009), Hyohyŏng Ch’ulp’an
  76. Warner, Langdon., "Japanese Sculpture of the Suiko Period" (1923), Yale University Press
  77. 이인범, "韓國博物館制 度의 起源과 性格", Misulsa nondan, 14, pp.35~63 (2002)
  78. 李成市, "국사의 신화를 넘어서", pp.265~295 (2004), Hyumŏnisŭt’ŭ
  79. 이순자, "일제강점기 고적조사 연구" (2009), Kyŏngin Munhwasa
  80. 吉倉凡農, "企業案内実利の朝鮮", pp.1904, Bunkōdō

관련 논문AI추천

CREATING REGIMES OF VALUE THROUGH CURATION AT THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF KOREACEDARBOUGH T. SAEJI한국학연구원 · Acta Koreana2014 · 제17권 제2호From Colonial Dilettantism to the Korean Wave: The Formation and Ever-changing Roles of Korean Art Collections in the United States김수진한국학중앙연구원 · The Review of Korean Studies2024 · 제27권 제2호Aspirations for the Pure Land Embodied in a Modern Korean Temple, Anyang’am이승혜한국학연구원 · Acta Koreana2019 · 제22권 제1호일제강점기의 조선 불교미술 조사와 복원- 한국 불교미술 연구의 출발점 -강희정미술사와 시각문화학회 · 미술사와 시각문화2010 · 제9호한국 불교조각 연구의 현주소와 미래최선아인문과학연구소 · 인문과학연구논총2015 · 제36권 제3호Rethinking the Picture Title: The Issue of Appellations of the GamnodoPAKTAYLOR미술사와 시각문화학회 · 미술사와 시각문화2021 · 제27호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (5건)

Meritorious Heroes: Allegorical Hawk Paintings in Yuan China and Early Chosŏn KoreaYouenhee Khopp. 1-25Useless Tribute, Desirable Exotics: Japanese Folding Fans in China, 1000–1500Yiwen Lipp. 27-49The Translating Subject beyond Borders: Relay Translations of Biographies of George Washington in East Asia in the Early Twentieth CenturySung-jun Sonpp. 83-103Where Is North?: Directionality in Precolonial and Colonial Land Surveys in Korea, 1897–1918Sora Kimpp. 105-122Buddhist Apologetics in East Asia: Countering the Neo-Confucian Critiques in the Hufa lun and the Yusŏk chirŭi nonThomas Jülchpp. 123-125
원문 보기