본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

日韓説得型談話の対照研究 -構造的特徴及びストラテジーを中心に-

A Contrastive Study on Persuasive Discourses between Korea and Japan -Focusing on the Structural Characteristics and Strategies-

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류일본어와문학

초록

This study analyzes the structural characteristics of persuasive behavior and the use aspect of persuasive strategies of Korean native speakers and Japanese native speakers. As analysis data, 8 cases of actual telephone conversation in each Korea and Japan were collected, which was transcribed through a method suitable for this study. 1)In the low burden situation of a preceding paragraph, Korean native speakers preferred the type of checking the opponent’s environment or asking for information to understand the current situation of the opponent. Under the high burden situation, Japanese native speakers preferred the method of provides information about persuasion situations in advance. 2)Regarding the persuasive paragraph, the use aspect of persuasive strategies was examined. As the biggest characteristic, Japanese native speakers showed the highest use aspect of「Strategy to Induce Listeners’ Psychology」regardless of types of persuasive situation. Through this, Japanese native speakers tended to save the listener’s(opponent’s) face rather than him/herself as a speaker regarding the linguistic behavior inducing the opponent’s behavior. 3)In the re-persuasive paragraph, both Korean/Japanese native speakers commonly showed the highest use aspect of「Strategy to Induce Listeners’ Psychology」under the low burden/high burden situation. With the matter of the opponent’s response in persuasive discourses, and the suggestion of proper reward and the reduction of listeners’ burden in re-persuasive discourses, the linguistic behavior to save listener’s face was more preferred.

Abstract

This study analyzes the structural characteristics of persuasive behavior and the use aspect of persuasive strategies of Korean native speakers and Japanese native speakers. As analysis data, 8 cases of actual telephone conversation in each Korea and Japan were collected, which was transcribed through a method suitable for this study. 1)In the low burden situation of a preceding paragraph, Korean native speakers preferred the type of checking the opponent’s environment or asking for information to understand the current situation of the opponent. Under the high burden situation, Japanese native speakers preferred the method of provides information about persuasion situations in advance. 2)Regarding the persuasive paragraph, the use aspect of persuasive strategies was examined. As the biggest characteristic, Japanese native speakers showed the highest use aspect of「Strategy to Induce Listeners’ Psychology」regardless of types of persuasive situation. Through this, Japanese native speakers tended to save the listener’s(opponent’s) face rather than him/herself as a speaker regarding the linguistic behavior inducing the opponent’s behavior. 3)In the re-persuasive paragraph, both Korean/Japanese native speakers commonly showed the highest use aspect of「Strategy to Induce Listeners’ Psychology」under the low burden/high burden situation. With the matter of the opponent’s response in persuasive discourses, and the suggestion of proper reward and the reduction of listeners’ burden in re-persuasive discourses, the linguistic behavior to save listener’s face was more preferred.

참고문헌 (11)

  1. 蒲谷 宏, "依頼表現方略の分析と記述 : 待遇表現教育への応用に向けて", 早稲田大学日本語研究教育センター紀要, 5, pp.52~69 (1994)
  2. 池田裕他, "中国人日本語学習者の言語行動─日本語と中国語における依頼─", 多摩留学生センター教育研究論集, 2, pp.27~37 (2000), 電気通信大学国際交流推進センター
  3. 猪崎保子, "「依頼」会話に見られる『優先体系』の文化的相違と期待のずれ─日本人フランス人日本語学習者の接触場面の研究─」『", 日本語教育, 1(4), pp.79~88 (2000), 日本語教育学会
  4. 宇佐美まゆみ, "基本的な文字化の原則(Basic Transcription System for Japanese:BTSJ)の開発について, 日本人の談話行動のスクリプト・ストラテジーの研究とマルチメディア教材の試作", 平成7年度~平成8年度文部省科学研究費-基盤研究(C)(2)-研究成果報告書(課題番号07680312)研究代表者西郡仁朗, 12~26 (1997)
  5. 吳恵卿, "説得場面におけるコミュニケーション‧スタイルの日韓比較-セールス談話の分析から-", 大阪大学言語文化 学, 17, pp.97~113 (2008), 大阪大学言語文化学硏究科
  6. 柳慧政, "依頼談話の日韓対照研究-談話の構造・ストラテジーの観点から", 博士, pp.2006
  7. ザトラウスキー・ポリー, "日本語の談話の構造分析―勧誘のストラテジーの考察―", pp.72~73 (1993), くろしお出版
  8. Brown, P., "Politeness: Some Universals in language usage", pp.65~68 (1987), Cambridge University Press
  9. 이하영, "한·일 설득전략에 관한 대조연구-「권유」와 「의뢰」상황에서의 설득장면을 중심으로-", 일본언어문화, (30), pp.229~251 (2015), 한국일본언어문화학회[DOI]
  10. 전정미, "설득 화법의 원리와 방법", 화법연구, 8, pp.281~303 (2005), 한국화법학회
  11. 조영남, "일본어교육 연구의전선2013", pp.87~98 (2013), 도서출판 책사랑

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (12건)