요한복음 13-17장의 요한식 문체-구조 연구
The Johannine Structures and Styles in John 13-17
4
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Although John is allegedly written with simpler expressions and easiervocabulary than other books in the New Testament, it is John that is characterized as one of the most complex books in the Bible regarding its structuresor riddles of the text, causing the readers to struggle in grasping itsways of writing and confusing many scholars with its complexity ofduplications, repetitions, stylistic variations, and seemingly illogical sequencesand complicated structures. Thus, John has long been treated as a primary materialused for historical criticism, which presupposes that John was written andredacted by multiple authors or redactors through a period of times. But, is it right that we see in our ways of reading John? Can the way of seeing that modern scholars who have been trained in the modern andwestern way of education be applied to the ancient writing in ancient ways? How much, and to what degree? This article suggests that we have tounderstand John's way of writing as we read it. Styles are made with phrasalrelations of interaction and structures are created with combination of bigger,larger units in consecutiveness. Most of the scholars who do not pay proper attention to the literaryconstruction of John 13-17 and do not recognize its value present the lineroutline as Beasley-Murray does. But most of the scholars considering theliterary structure in unity consider a chiastic structure due to its repetitions between John 14 and 16. Among them, there are C. Keener, Peter Ellis, and W. Brouwer. The structures and styles presented here are different from the ones which have been suggested earlier. The related data have shown certain coherences of units in groups designed with parallel or chiastic ways of composition, eventually creating the chiastic structures of chs. 13-17 according to a unique, Johannine way of structuring-text. This is the chiastic structure: A (13:-35), B (13:36-38), C (14:1-31), X (15:1-17), C' (15:18-16:31), B'(16:32-33), A' (17:1-26).
Abstract
Although John is allegedly written with simpler expressions and easiervocabulary than other books in the New Testament, it is John that is characterized as one of the most complex books in the Bible regarding its structuresor riddles of the text, causing the readers to struggle in grasping itsways of writing and confusing many scholars with its complexity ofduplications, repetitions, stylistic variations, and seemingly illogical sequencesand complicated structures. Thus, John has long been treated as a primary materialused for historical criticism, which presupposes that John was written andredacted by multiple authors or redactors through a period of times. But, is it right that we see in our ways of reading John? Can the way of seeing that modern scholars who have been trained in the modern andwestern way of education be applied to the ancient writing in ancient ways? How much, and to what degree? This article suggests that we have tounderstand John's way of writing as we read it. Styles are made with phrasalrelations of interaction and structures are created with combination of bigger,larger units in consecutiveness. Most of the scholars who do not pay proper attention to the literaryconstruction of John 13-17 and do not recognize its value present the lineroutline as Beasley-Murray does. But most of the scholars considering theliterary structure in unity consider a chiastic structure due to its repetitions between John 14 and 16. Among them, there are C. Keener, Peter Ellis, and W. Brouwer. The structures and styles presented here are different from the ones which have been suggested earlier. The related data have shown certain coherences of units in groups designed with parallel or chiastic ways of composition, eventually creating the chiastic structures of chs. 13-17 according to a unique, Johannine way of structuring-text. This is the chiastic structure: A (13:-35), B (13:36-38), C (14:1-31), X (15:1-17), C' (15:18-16:31), B'(16:32-33), A' (17:1-26).
참고문헌 (75)
- Sang-Hoon Kim, "Sourcebook of the Structures and Styles in John 1-10: The Johannine Parallelisms and Chiasms" (2014), Wipf & Stock
- C.H. Dodd, "The Interpretation of the Fourth Gospel" (1992), Cambridge Univ
- Gunnar stenstad, "Patterns of Redemption in the Fourth Gospel: An Experiment in Structural Analysis" (1998), Edwin Mellen
- 김상훈, "요한복음 프롤로그와 요한일서 서문의 비교 연구", 신약연구, 9(3), pp.369~408 (2010), 한국복음주의신약학회
- 김상훈, "요한복음 5:19-30 예수 담화의 요한식 역교차 구조와 문체 연구", 신약연구, 10(3), pp.479~511 (2011), 한국복음주의신약학회
- R.A. Culpepper, "Anatomy of the Fourth Gospel" (1983), Fortress
- J.L. Staley, "The Print s First Kiss: A Rhetorical Investigation of the Implied Reader in Fourth Gospel" (1988), Scholars
- Mark W.G. Stibbe, "John as Storyteller: Narrative Criticism and the Fourth Gospel" (1992), Cambridge Univ
- Stibbe, "The Gospel of John as Literature: An Anthology of Twentieth-Century Perspectives" (1993), Brill
- Margaret Davies, "Rhetoric and Reference in the Fourth Gospel" (1992), Sheffield Academic
- D.F. Tolmie, "Jesus Farewell to the Disciples: John 13:1-17:26 in Narratological Perspective" (1995), Brill
- Derek Tovey, "Narrative Art and Act in the Fourth Gospel" (1997), Sheffield Academic
- Warren Carter, "John: Storyteller, Interpreter, Evangelist" (2006), Hendrickson
- Raymond Brown, "An Introduction to the Gospel of John", pp.259~265 (2003), Doubleday
- Andreas J. Köstenberger, "A Theology of John s Gospel and Letters" (2009), Zondervan
- G. van Belle, "Repetitions and Variations in the Fourth Gospel: Style, Text, Interpretation" (2009), Peeters
- Craig Keener, "The Gospel of John: A Commentary, 2 Vols" (2003), Hendrickson
- Andreas J. Kösterberger, "John (BECNT)" (2004), Baker
- A.J. Kösterberger, "Encountering John: The Gospel in Historical, Literary, and Theological Perspective" (2002), Baker
- Raymond Brown, "The Gospel According to John XIII-XXI: Introduction, Translation, and Notes" (1970), The Anchor Bible
- Daniel B. Stevick, "Jesus and His Own: A Commentary on John 13-17" (2011), Eerdmans
- Fernando Segovia, "Love Relationships in the Johannine Tradition", pp.82~ (1982), Scholars Press
- Segovia, "The Farewell of the Word: The Johannine Call to Abide", pp.284~ (1991), Fortress
- Frank Stagg, "The Farewell Discourses: John 13-17", RE, 62(4), pp.459~460 (1965)
- Francis J. Moloney, "The Gospel of John: Text and Context", pp.260~262 (2005), Brill
- John Painter, "The Quest for the Messiah: The History, Literature and Theology of the Johannine Community", pp.417~434 (1993), Abingdon
- Urban C. von Wahlde, "A Commentary on the Gospel and Letters of John" (2010), Eerdmans
- James M. Reese, "Literary Structures of Jn 13:31-14:31; 16:5-6, 16-33", CBQ, 34, pp.321~331 (1972)
- Rudulf Bultmann, "The Gospel of John: A Commentary" (1971), Westminster Press
- George R. Beasley-Murray, "John" (1987), Word
- John W. Pryor, "John: Evangelist of the Covenant People: The Narrative & Themes of the Fourth Gospel" (1992), InterVarsity
- R. Alan Culpepper, "Anatomy of the Fourth Gospel: A Study in Literary Design", pp.77~98 (1987), Fortress
- Warren Carter, "John and Empire: Initial Explorations", pp.144~175 (2008), T&T Clark
- Fernando F. Segovia, "The Fourth Gospel from a Literary Perspective", pp.23~54 (1991), Scholars Press
- H. Windisch, "The Gospel of John as Literature: An Anthology of Twentieth-Century Perspectives", pp.25~64 (1993), E.J. Brill
- G. Mlakuzhyil, "The Christocentric Literary Structure of the Fourth Gospel" (1987), Editrice Pontificio Istituto Biblico
- Steven Richard Scott, "Chapter Six as the Centre of John" (2011), International SBL
- John Gerhard, "The Literary Unity and Compositional Methods of the Gospel of John", PhD, pp.1975
- Peter F. Ellis, "The Genius of John: A Composition-critical Commentary on the Fourth Gospel", pp.14~15 (1984), Liturgical Press
- Wes Howard-Brook, "Becoming Children of God: John s Gospel and Radical Discipleship", pp.289~290 (1994), Orbis
- Wayne Brouwer, "The Literary Development of John 13-17" (2000), SBL
- Ian H. Thompson, "Chiasmus in the Pauline Letters" (1995), Sheffield Academic
- Craig Blomberg, "The Structure of 2 Corinthians 1-7", Criswell Theological Review, 4, pp.3~20 (1989)
- 김문현, "요한복음에 등장하는 유다, 그는 누구인가?", 신약연구, 11(4), pp.828~853 (2012), 한국복음주의신약학회
- D.A. Carson, "The Gospel According to John" (1991), Eerdmans
- 이승문, "요한복음서의 세족에 대한 주요 연구 동향과 사회학적 재해석", 신약논단, 20(4), pp.923~958 (2013), 한국신약학회
- Segovia, "The Structure, Tendenz, and Sitz im Leben of John 13:31-14:31", JBL, 104, pp.491~492
- John Ferreira, "Johannine Ecclesiology" (1998), Sheffield Academic
- Robert Kysar, "Voyages with John: Charting the Fourth Gospel", pp.54~55 (2005), Baylor Univ
- Brown, "Gospel According to John I-XII", 26~28
- 현경식, "요한의 고별담론과 사랑의 수사학", 신약논단, 20(2), pp.371~408 (2013), 한국신약학회
- Talbert, "Reading John: A Literary and Theological Commentary on the Fourth Gospel and the Johannine Epistles", pp.189~190 (1992), SPCK
- John R. Yarid, Jr., "Reflections of the Upper Room Discourse in 1 John", Bibliotheca Sacra, 160, pp.65~76 (2003)
- Michael Cannon Jr., "The Prayer of Jesus: An Expository and Analytical Commentary on John 17", pp.6~ (2011), Resource Publications
- Jerome H. Neyrey, "The Gospel of John", pp.276~288 (2007), Cambridge Univ. Press
- H. Becker, "Die Reden des Johannesevangeliums und der Stil der gnostischen Offenbarungsreden", pp.56~61 (1956), Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht
- 김문현, "요한복음 17장 어떻게 읽을 것인가? ― 교회를 향한 예수의 비전 ―", 신약연구, 10(4), pp.825~858 (2011), 한국복음주의신약학회
- Y. Simoens, "La gloire d aimer: Structures stylistiques et interprétatives dans le Discours de la Cène (Jn 13-17)", pp.52~80 (1981), Biblical Institute Press
- Rekha M. Chennattu, "Johannine Discipleship as a Covenant Relationship" (2006), Hendrickson
- F.F. Segovia, "The Farewell of the Word: The Johannine Call to Abide", pp.49~51 (1991), Fortress
- Ben Witherington, III, "John s Wisdom: A Commentary on the Fourth Gospel", pp.244~276 (1995), WJK
- Herman C. Waetjen, "The Gospel of the Beloved Disciple: A Work in Two Editions", pp.327~377 (2005), T&T Clark
- John Carlson Stube, "A Graeco-Roman Rhetorical Reading of the Farewell Discourse", pp.79~82 (2006), T&T Clark
- Gary M. Burge, "Interpreting the Gospel of John" (1992), Baker Book
- Robert Tomson Fortna, "The Fourth Gospel and its Predecessor: From Narrative Source to Present Gospel", pp.1~10 (2004), T&T
- Paul N. Anderson, "The Riddles of the Fourth Gospel: An Introduction to John" (2011), Fortress
- Tom Thatcher, "The Riddles of Jesus in John: A Study in Tradition and Folklore" (2000), SBL
- Francis J. Moloney, "Belief in the Word", pp.52~ (1993), Fortress
- George L. Parsenios, "Departure and Consolation: The Johannine Farewell Discourse in Light of Greco-Roman Literature", pp.49~76 (2005), Brill
- H.B.H. Bevan, "Does Arise, Let Us Go Hence (John 14:31d) Make Sense Where It Stands?", JTS, 54(2), pp.576~578 (2003)
- Gail R. O' Day, "John(WBC)", pp.142~144 (2006), WJK
- W.J. Peter Boyd, "Ascension According to St John: Chapters 14-17 not Pre-passion but Postresurrection", Theology, 70(563), pp.208~ (1967)
- Quintilian, "Rhetorica ad Herennium 1.2.3", 7~
- David Dorsey, "The Literary Structure of the Old Testament", pp.17~ (2004), Baker
- Yehuda T. Radday, "Chiasmus in Antiquity: Structures, Analyses, Exegesis", pp.51~ (1999), Research Press