디지털통상규범의 발전과 WTO 전자상거래 협상의 의미
Implication of WTO E-Commerce Negotiations in the Development of Digital Trade Agreements
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study aims to analyze the significance of ongoing e-commerce negotiations within the World Trade Organization (WTO) in the field of digital trade. To achieve this purpose, the study examines the formal aspects of WTO e-commerce negotiations in Chapter 2. Additionally, in Chapter 3, it reviews the substantive aspects observed during the WTO e-commerce negotiation process. The conclusion then presents the limitations and implications of these WTO negotiations. However, it is important to note that this study is constrained by the fact that the text or outcomes of the WTO e-commerce negotiations have not been publicly disclosed, relying instead on leaked information. Furthermore, this study focuses on analyzing the “nature” itself of the negotiation process rather than the specific outcomes of WTO negotiations. Through this analysis, the study evaluates that, while WTO e-commerce negotiations are somewhat limited in scope and contents, they still yield meaningful results. Particularly noteworthy is the plurilateral trade agreement (PTA) approach pursued by the WTO in digital trade agreements. This approach demonstrates the potential for expanding a legal community and provides an appropriate formal framework for negotiating countries with shared understanding. Moreover, the negotiation process itself can serve as a platform for shaping new digital trade agreement. On the substantive side, the WTO e-commerce negotiations highlight the contrasting positions of countries in the current digital trade landscape. Although reaching immediate and clear conclusions based on these divergent national stances is challenging, the negotiations could contribute to establishing “soft law” in areas that remain insufficiently discussed. However, given the inherent limitations, achieving swift conclusions in WTO e-commerce negotiations remains difficult. Consequently, the study proposes methods to address the challenges and facilitate successful negotiation outcomes.
Abstract
This study aims to analyze the significance of ongoing e-commerce negotiations within the World Trade Organization (WTO) in the field of digital trade. To achieve this purpose, the study examines the formal aspects of WTO e-commerce negotiations in Chapter 2. Additionally, in Chapter 3, it reviews the substantive aspects observed during the WTO e-commerce negotiation process. The conclusion then presents the limitations and implications of these WTO negotiations. However, it is important to note that this study is constrained by the fact that the text or outcomes of the WTO e-commerce negotiations have not been publicly disclosed, relying instead on leaked information. Furthermore, this study focuses on analyzing the “nature” itself of the negotiation process rather than the specific outcomes of WTO negotiations. Through this analysis, the study evaluates that, while WTO e-commerce negotiations are somewhat limited in scope and contents, they still yield meaningful results. Particularly noteworthy is the plurilateral trade agreement (PTA) approach pursued by the WTO in digital trade agreements. This approach demonstrates the potential for expanding a legal community and provides an appropriate formal framework for negotiating countries with shared understanding. Moreover, the negotiation process itself can serve as a platform for shaping new digital trade agreement. On the substantive side, the WTO e-commerce negotiations highlight the contrasting positions of countries in the current digital trade landscape. Although reaching immediate and clear conclusions based on these divergent national stances is challenging, the negotiations could contribute to establishing “soft law” in areas that remain insufficiently discussed. However, given the inherent limitations, achieving swift conclusions in WTO e-commerce negotiations remains difficult. Consequently, the study proposes methods to address the challenges and facilitate successful negotiation outcomes.
참고문헌 (46)
- 고준성, "미국의 신보호주의 부상에 대한 대응 연구" (2017), 경제인문사회연구회
- 권현호, "디지털무역과 국제통상규범", 명지법학, 20(2) (2022)
- 디지털통상협정의 한국형 표준모델 설정 연구, "권현호", 대외경제정책연구원, ~, pp.연구보고서 22-29 (2023)
- 김호철, "WTO 정보기술협정(ITA) 현황과 쟁점", 통상법률, 통권 : 124 (2015)
- 디지털통상연구회, "디지털통상론" (2024), 박영사
- 미-중 전략경쟁하 WTO 다자체제의 전망과 정책 시사점, "송유철", 대외경제정책연구원, ~ (2021)
- 이규엽, "WTO 전자상거래 협상 전망과 한국의 과제", KIEP 오늘의 세계경제, 21(3) (2021)
- 이재민, "디지털 교역과 통상규범", 국제경제법연구, 16(2) (2018)
- 이종석, "디지털 통상규범 정립 지연 이유와 우리나라 디지털 통상정책에 시사점", 물류학회지, 29(1) (2019)
- 이주형, "사례로 이해하는 디지털통상의 기초" (2021), 산업자원부
- 정경수, "국제법상 연성법의 재인식", 안암법학, 통권 : 34 (2011)
- 정인섭, "신국제법강의 : 이론과 사례" (2022), 박영사
- Daniel Thürer, "Encyclopedia of Public International Law, vol. Ⅳ" (2000)
- Malcolm Shaw, "International Law" (2008), Cambridge University Press
- Raj Bhala, "International Trade Law: Theory and Practice" (2001), LexisNexis
- The WTO’s Discussions on Electronic Commerce, "South Centre", ~, pp.Analytical Note, SC (2017), AN[DOI]
- Provisions on Electronic Commerce in Regional Trade Agreement, "WTO", World Trade Organization Economic Research and Statistics Divisions, ~ (2017)
- "Declaration on Global Electronic Commerce", WT, DEC, pp.2, 1998[DOI]
- "INF", ECOM, Rev.2 (restricted ), 2021[DOI]
- "INF", ECOM, pp.2024, ~
- "Joint Statement on Electronic Commerce, WT", MIN(17), pp.2017, ~
- "Work Programme on Electronic Commerce, WT", L, pp.1998, ~
- Work Programme on Electronic Commerce, "Ministerial Decision of 13December 2017, WT", MIN(17), L, pp.1032[DOI]
- Work Programme on Electronic Commerce, "Ministerial Decision, WT", MIN(24), L, pp.1193[DOI]
- "WT", COMTD, 264, pp.Rev.1[DOI]
- "디지털경제동반자협정(Digital Economy Partnership Agreement: DEPA)", ~
- "미-일 디지털무역협정(US-Japan Digital Trade Agreement: USJDTA)", ~
- "역내포괄적경제동반자협정(Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership:RCEP)", ~
- "인도-태평양 경제 프레임워크(Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity: IPEF)", ~
- "포괄적·점진적 환태평양 경제동반자협정(Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership: CPTPP)", ~
- "한국-싱가포르 자유무역협정(Korea-Singapore Free Trade Agreement)", ~
- "한국-싱가포르 디지털동반자협정(Korea-Singapore Digital Partnership Agreement: KSDPA)", ~
- "호주-싱가포르 자유무역협정(Australia-Singapore Free Trade Agreement)", ~
- "EU-일본 경제동반자협정(EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement)", ~
- "1969년 조약법에 관한 비엔나협약(Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969)", ~
- 무역협회, "WTO 정보기술협정(ITA) 확대협상 품목리스트", ~ (2015)
- 한국무역협회, "인도 및 남아공, “WTO 전자전송물 무관세 조치 연장 반대”", 통상뉴스, ~ (2022)