저작인격권의 일신 전속성에 관한 소고
A Study on Inalienability of Moral Rights
4
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The copyright law of Korea is ruling that the moral rights are inalienable in article 14, clause 1. That rule is common among many countries' law, and the courts and scholars of Korea take it as granted. That rule, however, has conflicts with article 9, which rules about employed authors. Unless we think the moral rights are alienable, we can't explain the exact meaning of article 9. Each rights which belong to the moral rights are the similar conflicts with article 14, clause 1. For example, the right of making public in article 11 of legal entity can't exist unless moral rights are alienable. To explain the copyright law of Korea in harmonious way, we need to doubt the inalienability of moral rights. If needed, we should make some exceptions to the inalienability of moral rights. There already have been some questioning of whether the moral rights are inalienable, and some countries made some exceptions to the inalienability of moral rights. From now, we need to study the inalienability of moral rights with open mind to keep the copyright law pace with real world and to accomplish the goal of copyright law.
Abstract
The copyright law of Korea is ruling that the moral rights are inalienable in article 14, clause 1. That rule is common among many countries' law, and the courts and scholars of Korea take it as granted. That rule, however, has conflicts with article 9, which rules about employed authors. Unless we think the moral rights are alienable, we can't explain the exact meaning of article 9. Each rights which belong to the moral rights are the similar conflicts with article 14, clause 1. For example, the right of making public in article 11 of legal entity can't exist unless moral rights are alienable. To explain the copyright law of Korea in harmonious way, we need to doubt the inalienability of moral rights. If needed, we should make some exceptions to the inalienability of moral rights. There already have been some questioning of whether the moral rights are inalienable, and some countries made some exceptions to the inalienability of moral rights. From now, we need to study the inalienability of moral rights with open mind to keep the copyright law pace with real world and to accomplish the goal of copyright law.
참고문헌 (45)
- 박성호, "저작권법의 이론과 현실", pp.180~ (2006)
- 정상조, "저작권법 주해", pp.322~ (2007)
- "서울민사지방법원 1989.4.19선고, 88나29391판결", ~ (1989)
- H. Hubmann, "Das Persönlichkeitsrecht, 3. Aufl.", pp.178~ (1967)
- 윤춘섭, "建築 관련 著作人格權 중 同一性維持權에 관한 硏究", 대한건축학회논문집 계획계, 20(10), pp.157~164 (2004), 대한건축학회
- 정상조, "저작권법 주해", pp.326~ (2007)
- 오승종, "저작권법", pp.352~ (2008)
- 배대헌, "현행 저작권법상 저작인격권의 법리에 관한 검토", 산업재산권, (21), pp.147~192 (2006), 한국산업재산권법학회
- Dan Rosen, "Artists' Moral Rights: A European Evolution, an American Revolution", Cardozo Art & Ent. L.J, 155, pp.157~158 (1983)
- "베른협약 Article 6bis (1)", ~
- Ralph S. Brown, "Copyright, 8th Ed", pp.745~ (2002), Foundation Press
- Michael A. Epstein, "Epstein on Intellectual Property, 4th Ed", pp.4~51 (2004), Aspen Publishers
- 강남진, "인격권에 관한 연구", 민사법연구, pp.225~ (1994), 호남민사법연구회
- , 1995
- , 1992
- 정상조, "지적재산권법", pp.311~ (2004)
- 최상필, "우리 저작권법 체계상 저작자와 저작권의 귀속문제", 재산법연구, 24(1), pp.347~375 (2007), 한국재산법학회
- Stephen Fraser, "BERNE, CFTA, NAFTA & GATT: The Implications Of Copyright Droit Moral And Cultural Exemptions In International Trade Law", 18 Hastings Comm, 1996, pp.292~
- 저작권심의조정위원회, "북유럽 저작권법", 저작권관계자료집, 22 (1997)
- 최현호, "단체명의저작물의 문제점, In 지적재산권법의 제문제 (매산송영식선생 화갑기념 논문집)"
- 구대환, "현행 저작권법에 의한 데이터베이스 보호의 문제점", 창작과 권리, (31), pp.111~ (2003)
- 박도희, "인격권의 보호법리와 그 적용의 한계", 박사, pp.2005
- 사법연수원, "저작권법", pp.147~ (2005)
- , 2000
- 문화관광부, "개정저작권법 해설", 21~
- "저작권법 제12조 제1항", ~
- Ralph S. Brown, "Copyright, 8th Ed", pp.748~ (2002), Foundation Press
- , 1989
- , 1989
- Merges, "Intellectual Property in the New Technological Age, 3rd edition", pp.443~ (2003), Aspen Publishers
- "저작권법 제13조 제1항", ~
- 김문환, "동일성유지권의 침해 여부, 한국 저작권 판례평석집(1)", 저작권관계자료집, 23, pp.60~ (1998), 저작권심의조정위원회
- , 1989
- 송영식, "저작권침해와 위자료", 민사판례연구, 13, pp.157~ (1991)
- , 1990
- , 1991
- 허희성, "제호의 사용과 동일성 유지권 침해", 계간 저작권, (14) (1991)
- , 1994
- , 1995
- , 2001
- , 2003
- 저작권심의조정위원회, "중국·대만 저작권법", 저작권관계자료집, 37, pp.50~ (2002)
- , 1990
- , 1993
- 이상정, "판례평석-롯티사건", 창작과 권리, (6) (1997)