본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

A Composite Look into South Korea and Japan’s Missile Defense and Intelligence, Surveillance, and Re-connaissance Capabilities

조비연
통일학연구원 (Ewha Institute of Unification Studies)|2021.08|Journal of Peace and Unification|제11권 제3호|pp. 81-111|DOI 10.31780/jpu.2021.11.3.81

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

JapanIntelligenceSouth KoreaSurveillanceBallistic Missile Defense (BMD)and Recon-naissance (ISR)Deterrence and Defense

초록

While North Korea’s increasing asymmetric capabilities have impelled both South Korea and Japan to seek arms build-up in their conventional means to detect, defend, and/or ‘hit-to-kill’ incoming targets, South Korea and Japan have shown intriguing level of divergence in their armaments and enthusiasm in joining the US-led BMD in the region. Yet, as this study finds, existing studies on South Korea and Japan’s BMD have been, what this study calls, ‘interceptor-oriented.’ Although the literatures on the BMD address the role of sensors and radars in tandem, the analysis has been often limited to equipment that come in ‘set’ of interceptor missiles. Building upon the technical anatomy of the BMD and ISR and literatures on deterrence and defense, this study posits the BMD and ISR as composite means of active deterrence and defense.

Abstract

While North Korea’s increasing asymmetric capabilities have impelled both South Korea and Japan to seek arms build-up in their conventional means to detect, defend, and/or ‘hit-to-kill’ incoming targets, South Korea and Japan have shown intriguing level of divergence in their armaments and enthusiasm in joining the US-led BMD in the region. Yet, as this study finds, existing studies on South Korea and Japan’s BMD have been, what this study calls, ‘interceptor-oriented.’ Although the literatures on the BMD address the role of sensors and radars in tandem, the analysis has been often limited to equipment that come in ‘set’ of interceptor missiles. Building upon the technical anatomy of the BMD and ISR and literatures on deterrence and defense, this study posits the BMD and ISR as composite means of active deterrence and defense.

참고문헌 (79)

  1. 홍규덕, "사드(THAAD) 배치에 관한 주요쟁점과 미사일방어(MD) 전략", 신아세아, 22(4), pp.110~134 (2015), 신아시아연구소
  2. Hong, S. P., "Air Weapons System Capable of Intercepting North Ko-rea’s Ballistic Missiles", pp.150~155 (2008), North Korea
  3. 김흥규, "4차 북한 핵실험과 사드의 국제정치", 통일정책연구, 25(1), pp.25~58 (2016), 통일연구원
  4. Kim, S. T., "Military Transformation of the US and Bilateral Alliance in Northeast Asia: A Comparative Study on Alliance Policies of South Korea and Japan", PhD, pp.2008
  5. Kim, W. S., "TMD System and East Asia Security Structure", National Strategy, 23, pp.6~39 (2001)
  6. Kim, Y. W, "Analysis on Technical Components and Direction for Development on the Multifunctional Air Defense Radars", Air Defense Journal, 133, pp.84~113 (2020)
  7. Defense Postures of the ROK and Japan against North Ko-rea’s Ballistic Missile Threats: Similarities and Differences, "Ko, B. J.", Jeju Peace Institute, 213~225 (2008)
  8. Lee, S. H., "US’s Strategic Intention behind THAAD Deployment on the Korean Peninsula", Catholic Review, 10, pp.45~52 (2017)
  9. Park, C. K., "Two Perspectives on the US’s Missile Defense Review 2019", KIMS Periscope, 153, pp.1~3 (2019)
  10. Park, C. H., "Power Shift in East Asia and Changes in Japan’s Ex-ternal Strategy" (2014), East Asia Foundation
  11. 박영준, "일본 방위산업 성장과 비군사화 규범들의 변화 - ‘무기수출금지 3원칙’의 형성과 폐지 과정을 중심으로 -", 한일군사문화연구, 18, pp.43~76 (2014), 한일군사문화학회
  12. 박휘락, "한국 국방정책에 있어서 오인식(誤認識)에 관한 분석과 함의: 전시 작전통제권과 미사일방어의 사례를 중심으로", 의정논총, 9(1), pp.301~332 (2014), 한국의정연구회
  13. 박휘락, "The Ballistic Missile Defense Construction Strategies of South Korea and Japan: Self-reliance versus Cooperation with the US", Journal of International and Area Studies, 25(2), pp.87~105 (2018), 국제학연구소[DOI]
  14. Park, H. R., "The South Korea’s Long-term and Stable Penetration against the North Korean Nuclear Missile Threat: Establishing Mis-sile Defense Shields", Military Forum, 73, pp.35~52 (2013)
  15. 박휘락, "일본의 탄도미사일 방어체제 추진사례 분석과 한국에 대한 교훈", 국가전략, 19(4), pp.83~111 (2013), 세종연구소[DOI]
  16. 2020 Defense White Paper, "ROK Ministry of Defense", Minis-try of Defense, ~ (2020)
  17. ROK National Assembly Secretariat, "Proceedings of National Defense Committee. The Fifteenth National Assembly, the Fifth Session of the 198th Regular Session of National Assembly", ~ (1998)
  18. Yoon, D. M., "A Comparative Study on Adjustment of ROK-US and US-Japan Alliances" (2007), Korea Research Institute for Strategy
  19. Arase, D., "Japan, the Active State?: Security Policy after 9", 11, 2007, pp.47(4), 560~583
  20. Armed Control Today, "Pentagon Wants to Test THAAD Despite Un-resolved Treaty Issues", Armed Control Today, ~ (1994)
  21. Bennett, B. W., "Why THAAD Is Needed in Korea", The Ko-rea Times, ~ (2017)
  22. Daugherty, W., "The Consequences of ‘Lim-ited’ Nuclear Attacks on the United States", International Security, 10(4), pp.3~45 (1986)
  23. Davenport, K., "Nuclear Weapons: Who Has What at a Glance" (2018), Arms Control Association
  24. Davis, J. W. Jr, "Taking Offense at Offense-Defense Theory", Inter-national Security, 23(3), pp.179~182 (1999)
  25. Finel, B. I, "Taking Offense at Offense-Defense Theory", Interna-tional Security, 23(3), pp.182~189 (1999)
  26. Gady, F. S, "Japan Launches Second Maya-class Guided Mis-sile Destroyer", The Diplomat, ~ (2019)
  27. Galtung, J., "Trans armament : From Offensive to Defensive Defense", Journal of Peace Research, 2(2), pp.127~139 (1984)
  28. Gholz, E., "Defensive Defense : A Better Way to Protect US Allies in Asia", The Washington Quarterly, 42(4), pp.171~189 (2020)
  29. Glaser, C. L., "What Is the Offense-Defense Balance and How Can We Measure It", International Security, 22(4), pp.44~82 (1998)
  30. Graham, W, "Japanese H-IIA launches IGS Optical 6 Satellite", NASA Spaceflight, ~ (2018)
  31. Hoff, R, "US-Japan Missile Defense Cooperation Increasing Security and Cutting Costs", American Action Forum (2015)
  32. Statement of the Chief Cabinet Secretary, Ja-pan-US Joint Technological Research on Ballistic Missile Defense, "Japan Defense Agency", ~ (1998)
  33. Annual White Paper 1991, "Japan Defense Agency", Japan De-fense Agency, ~ (1991)
  34. Defense Programs and Budget of Japan: Overview of FY2004 Budget, "Japan Ministry of Defense", ~ (2004)
  35. Japan Ministry of Defense, "Japan’s BMD", ~ (2008)
  36. Defense of Japan 2016, "Japan Ministry of Defense", Japan Ministry of Defense, ~ (2016)
  37. Defense of Japan 2017, "Japan Ministry of Defense", Japan Ministry of Defense, ~ (2017)
  38. Defense of Japan 2020 (Digest), "Japan Ministry of Defense", ~ (2020)
  39. Jervis, R, "Cooperation under the Security Dilemma", World Politics, 30(2), pp.167~214 (1978)
  40. Jo, B. Y, "Arming South Korea: Restrained Arms Acquisition in Bal-listic Missile Defense and Intelligence, Surveillance, Reconnais-sance Capabilities", Ph.D, pp.2020
  41. 조비연, "Revisiting Neoclassical Realism in Understanding Variations in States’ Armaments: A Case of South Korea and Taiwan's Ballistic Missile Defense", Korean Social Science Journal, 47(2), pp.83~100 (2020), 한국사회과학협의회
  42. Kallender-Umezu, P, "Japan Begins National Security Space Buildup", Defense News, ~ (2015)
  43. Kim, T. H., "South Korea’s Missile Defense: Dilemma and Opportunity for a Medium State", Asian Politics and Policy, 1(3), pp.371~389 (2009)
  44. Problems of Strategy in China’s Revolutionary War, "Mao, Z.", The Maoist Documentation Project, ~ (1936)
  45. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, "Deployment of US PAC-3 to Kadena", ~ (2006)
  46. Missile Defense Advocacy Alliance, "Missile Defense of the US Part-ners", ~ (2018)
  47. Mizokami, K, "Everything You Need to Know: Japan’s Missile De-fense" (2017), The National Interest
  48. Morton, T., "Manned Airborne Intelligence, Surveillance, and Recon-naissance", Air & Space Power Journal, pp.34~52 (2012)
  49. Nitze, P. H, "Deterring Our Deterrent", Foreign Policy, 25, pp.195~210 (1977)
  50. Odgaard, L., "Maritime Security in East Asia : Peaceful Coexistence and Active Defense in China’s Diaoyu", Senkaku Policy, 2017, pp.26(103), 118~133
  51. Oros, A. L., "Explaining Japan’s Tortured Course to Surveillance Sat-ellites", Review of Policy Research, 24(1), pp.29~48 (2007)
  52. Paek, C. H., "A Grand Strategy for Korea’s Defense", Korean Journal of Defense Analysis, 1(2), pp.167~197 (1989)
  53. Paul, T. V., "The Tradition of Non-Use of Nuclear Weapons" (2009), Stanford University Press
  54. Peters, R., "Deterrence in the 21st Cen-tury: Integrating Nuclear and Conventional Force", Strategic Studies Quarterly, 12(4), pp.15~43 (2018)
  55. US-ROK Alliance Management: OPCON Transition and ISR, "Pinkston, D.", International Crisis Group, ~ (2014)
  56. Quester, G. H., "Offense and Defense in the International System" (1977), John Wiley and Sons
  57. The 3 Major Phases of Effective Missile Defense Systems, "Reed, T", Microwaves & RF, ~ (2017)
  58. Reif, K, "Missile Defense System at a Glance" (2019), Arms Control Associa-tion
  59. Japan PM’s ‘Stealth’ Constitution Plan Raises Civil Rights Fears, "Reuters", ~ (2013)
  60. Roehrig, T., "Japan, South Korea, and the United States Nuclear Um-brella: Deterrence after the Cold War" (2017), Columbia Uni-versity Press
  61. Sagan, S. D., "The Limits of Safety: Organizations, Accidents, and Nu-clear Weapons" (1993), Princeton University Press
  62. Sankaran, J., "Missile Defense and Strategic Stability: Terminal High Altitude Area Defense(THAAD) in South Korea", Contemporary Security Policy, 38(3), pp.321~344 (2017)
  63. Shiping, T., "Offence-defense Theory: Towards a Definitive Under-standing", The Chinese Journal of International Politics, 3, pp.213~260 (2010)
  64. Simpson, J, "Japan’s Radar Network" (2011), Japan Security Watch New Pa-cific Institute
  65. Smith, S. A., "Japan Rearmed: The Politics of Military Powe" (2019), Harvard University Press
  66. Snyder, G. H., "Deterrence and Defense: Toward a Theory of National Security" (1961), Princeton University Press
  67. Snyder, J., "Civil-Military Relations and the Cult of the Offensive, 1914 and 1984", International Security, 9(1), pp.108~146 (1984)
  68. Spacetech, "Japan Launches Reconnaissance Satellite IGS-Radar 6", ~ (2018)
  69. The Associated Press, "Missile Defense 101: N. Korea Could Hit with Little Warning", ~ (2017)
  70. The State Council Information of the People’s Republic of China, "China’s Military Strategy", ~ (2015)
  71. 2002 Nuclear Posture Review, "US Department of Defense", ~ (2002)
  72. The Ballistic Missile Defense System, "US Department of Defense, Missile Defense Agency", MDA Fact Sheet, ~ (2018)
  73. US Joint Chiefs of Staff, "Joint Publication 3-12: Doctrine for Joint Nuclear Operations (Final Coordination)", ~ (2003)
  74. US Navy, "Aegis Weapon System", Fact File, ~ (2019)
  75. Annual Report to Congress: Military and Security Developments Involving the Democratic Peo-ple’s Republic of Korea, "US Office of the Secretary of Defense", US Department of De-fense, ~ (2014)
  76. Van Evera, S., "Offense, Defense, and the Causes of War", International Security, 22(4), pp.5~43 (1998)
  77. Van Evera, S., "Causes of War: Power and the Roots of Conflict" (1999), Cornell University Press
  78. Yonhap News, "Korea’s Military Seeks Five Indigenous Spy Satellites by 2023", ~ (2017)
  79. Yoo, H. J., "Domestic Hurdles for System-driven Behavior: Neoclassi-cal Realism and Missile Defense Policies in Japan and South Korea", International Relations of the Asia-Pacific, 12(2), pp.317~348 (2012)

관련 논문AI추천

The Ballistic Missile Defense Construction Strategies of South Korea and Japan: Self-reliance versus Cooperation with the US박휘락국제학연구소 · Journal of International and Area Studies2018 · 제25권 제2호Toward Functioning Alignment: Future Developments of Defense Cooperation between South Korea and Japan유기현, Hirohito Ogi, Kohtaro Ito한국국방연구원 · The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis2025 · 제37권 제2호한국과 일본의 탄도미사일 방어(BMD) 추진 비교박휘락세종연구소 · 국가전략2015 · 제21권 제2호The Acquisition of Regional Ballistic Missile Defenses in the Shadow of Great Powers김형민, 유진석, David L. Rousseau한국국방연구원 · The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis2024 · 제36권 제3호한국과 일본의 대탄도미사일방어(BMD) 비교 : 대미협력 수준 차이를 중심으로박휘락한국세계지역학회 · 세계지역연구논총2020 · 제38권 제2호Prospects for Regional Cooperation on Missile Non-Proliferation in Northeast Asia전성훈통일연구원 · International Journal of Korean Unification Studies2004 · 제13권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (3건)

When Dogs Wag their Tails: How Great Powers Patrons Manage their Belligerent Client Allies under Uncertainty박동준pp. 5-26Politico-economic Implications of North Korea's "Quasi-market Economy” in the Kim Jung-un Era오승렬pp. 27-51Pursuing Peace and Prosperity with Unified Values of South and North Korea guided in IR Theories and PD Practices황미애pp. 53-79
원문 보기