NAMDANG’S THEORY ON THE NATURES OF HUMANS AND NON-HUMAN LIVING BEINGS AND HIS DEVELOPMENT OF ZHU XI’S THEORIES
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article examines a thesis by Namdang, a Confucian scholar in Chosŏn Korea, on the natures of humans and non-human living beings, using Zhu Xi’s li (理) - qi (氣) theory. Regarding the sameness or difference between li and qi, Zhu Xi formulated different opinions in his early and later life and was also at times inconsistent in his works of a certain period. To a certain extent, Zhu Xi’s thoughts lacked coherence, which led to subsequent debates. In seeking to develop Zhu Xi’s li-qi theory, Namdang put forward his original thesis of Trichotomous Nature, which significantly enriched Zhu Xi’s ideas. The “nature transcending the appearance of things” (K. ch’ohyŏnggi 超形氣) refers to a pure xing (K. sŏng 性; nature), concerned with only li without considering the influence of qi from the perspective of a unitary source (K. irwŏn 一原; one source). At this stage, everything shares the same li and xing. The “nature originated from temperament” (K. in’gijil 因氣質) demonstrates the shared nature for the same species as well as the difference in nature across species, thus being an endowment-dependent li. At this stage, for the same species, they share the same li, qi, and xing, while for varying species, there is a difference in li, qi, and xing. The “nature mixed with temperament” (K. chapkijil 雜氣質) considers the xing of pure qizhi (K. kijil氣質; physical temperament) in which all creatures differ. It is thus a concept that demonstrates the particularity in all things, with varying differences in li, qi, and xing.
Abstract
This article examines a thesis by Namdang, a Confucian scholar in Chosŏn Korea, on the natures of humans and non-human living beings, using Zhu Xi’s li (理) - qi (氣) theory. Regarding the sameness or difference between li and qi, Zhu Xi formulated different opinions in his early and later life and was also at times inconsistent in his works of a certain period. To a certain extent, Zhu Xi’s thoughts lacked coherence, which led to subsequent debates. In seeking to develop Zhu Xi’s li-qi theory, Namdang put forward his original thesis of Trichotomous Nature, which significantly enriched Zhu Xi’s ideas. The “nature transcending the appearance of things” (K. ch’ohyŏnggi 超形氣) refers to a pure xing (K. sŏng 性; nature), concerned with only li without considering the influence of qi from the perspective of a unitary source (K. irwŏn 一原; one source). At this stage, everything shares the same li and xing. The “nature originated from temperament” (K. in’gijil 因氣質) demonstrates the shared nature for the same species as well as the difference in nature across species, thus being an endowment-dependent li. At this stage, for the same species, they share the same li, qi, and xing, while for varying species, there is a difference in li, qi, and xing. The “nature mixed with temperament” (K. chapkijil 雜氣質) considers the xing of pure qizhi (K. kijil氣質; physical temperament) in which all creatures differ. It is thus a concept that demonstrates the particularity in all things, with varying differences in li, qi, and xing.
참고문헌 (19)
- Han Wŏnjin, "Chuja ŏllon tong’igo (An examination of the theory of sameness and differences in the dialogues of Master Zhu)" (2002), Somyŏng
- Han Wŏnjin, "Namdang chip (Collected works of Namdang)" (1986), Kyŏng’in munhwa sa
- Han Wŏnjin, "Kyŏng’i kimunnok (Record of interpretations of Confucian classics)" (2005), Sŏnggyun’gwan taehakkyo munhwa yŏn’guso
- Yi Kan, "Oeam yugo (The posthumous works of Yi Kan)" (1982), Kyŏng’in munhwasa
- Yi I., "Yulgok chŏnsŏ (Complete works of Yulgok Yi I)" (1971), Sŏnggyun’gwan taehakkyo munhwa yŏn’guso
- Zhu Xi, "Sishu jizhu (Annotations of the Four Books)" (2016), Commercial Press
- Zhu Xi, "Zhuzi wenji (Literary collection of Master Zhu)" (2002), Defu wenjiao jijinhui
- Zhu Xi, "Zhuzi yulei (The selected dialogues of Master Zhu)" (1986), Zhonghua shuju
- 최영진, "南塘", 巍巖 未發論辨의 再檢討 ― 退溪, 동양철학, pp.2008, (29)[DOI]
- 홍정근, "호락논쟁에 관한 임성주의 비판적 지양 연구", 박사, 한국철학, pp.2002
- Hong Chŏnggŭn, "Chaoxian xuezhe han yuanzhen de xing sanceng shuo yiji ren shengzhou dui ci de guandian (The theory of trichotomous nature of a Chosŏn scholar, Han Wŏnjin and the comments of Im Sŏngju)", Qilu wenhua yanjiu, 6, pp.172~181 (2008)
- Hong Chŏnggŭn, "Ruxue simeng xuepai lunji (An anthology of essays on Confucian Zi Si and Mengzi Schools)", pp.287~297 (2008), qilu shushe
- 홍정근, "Is the Morality of Human Beings Superior to the Morality of Non-Human Beings? : Debate over Human versus Animal Nature in the Joseon Period", Korea Journal, 51(1), pp.72~96 (2011), 유네스코한국위원회
- Legge, James, "The Chinese Classics, Vols. 1–2" (1991), SMC Publishing Inc.
- Li Cunshan, "Cong xingshan lun dao fan xingshan lun (From a theory of good human nature to that of universal good nature)", Kukchep’an yugo munhwa yŏn’gu, 7, pp.177~206 (2002)
- Minteer, Ben A., "An Appraisal of the Critique of Anthropocentrism and Three Lesser Known Themes in Lynn White’s ‘The Historical Roots of our Ecologic Crisis.’", Organisation & Environment, 18(2), pp.163~176 (2005)
- Xing Liju, "Chaoxian shiqi renwu xing tongyi lunzheng de lilun laiyuan jiqi chayi (The theoretical sources and differences among the debates on the sameness and difference of the nature between human and things during the Chosŏn era)", Zhexue yanjiu, 11, pp.62~69 (2008)
- 형려국, "南塘 韓元震의 人物性異論에 대한 硏究", 동양철학연구, (56), pp.97~128 (2008), 동양철학연구회
- 邢丽菊, "朱熹的“理气同异论”与韩国儒学史上的人物性同异论争", 國際版<儒敎文化硏究>, (14), pp.97~116 (2010), 유교문화연구소