Time to Balance Deterrence, Offense, and Defense? Rethinking South Korea’s Strategy against the North Korean Nuclear Threat
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
South Korea, the United States, and the international community should recognize that the diplomatic approach, including the Six-Party Talks, has not been effective in either delaying or rolling back North Korea’s nuclear ambitions. North Korea conducted two nuclear tests and is believed to have several nuclear bombs,deliverable by either missiles or aircraft. South Korea, the primary target of North Korean nuclear development and strategy,should extend its deterrent, offensive, and defensive capabilities, which are three general types of preparedness for ordinary nations. Seoul should specifically strengthen its capabilities to retaliate against the North Korean leadership. It should also develop a plan to neutralize North Korean nuclear weapons in case of either an imminent or actual North Korean nuclear offense. It is about time for South Korea to build missile defense in order to strike and destroy the North Korean nuclear missiles in the air. Seoul thus needs to acquire PAC-3 missile defense systems before it discusses its comprehensive missile defense options.
Abstract
South Korea, the United States, and the international community should recognize that the diplomatic approach, including the Six-Party Talks, has not been effective in either delaying or rolling back North Korea’s nuclear ambitions. North Korea conducted two nuclear tests and is believed to have several nuclear bombs,deliverable by either missiles or aircraft. South Korea, the primary target of North Korean nuclear development and strategy,should extend its deterrent, offensive, and defensive capabilities, which are three general types of preparedness for ordinary nations. Seoul should specifically strengthen its capabilities to retaliate against the North Korean leadership. It should also develop a plan to neutralize North Korean nuclear weapons in case of either an imminent or actual North Korean nuclear offense. It is about time for South Korea to build missile defense in order to strike and destroy the North Korean nuclear missiles in the air. Seoul thus needs to acquire PAC-3 missile defense systems before it discusses its comprehensive missile defense options.
참고문헌 (51)
- Robert Art, "The Four Functions of Force, In The Use of Force", pp.3~11 (1993), University Press of America
- Thomas Schelling, "Arms and Influence" (1962), Yale University Press
- Lawrence Freedman, "Evolution of Nuclear Strategy" (1975), Oxford University Press
- Paul Nitze, "Deterring Our Deterrent", Foreign Policy, 25, pp.195~210 (1977)
- Colin Grey, "Nuclear Strategy: A Case for a Theory of Victory", International Security, 4(1), pp.54~87 (1979)
- Dan Reiter, "Exploding the Powder-keg Myth: Pre-emptive Wars Almost Never Happen", International Security, 20(2) (1995)
- James E. Dougherty, "Contending Theories of International Relations", pp.387~ (1990), Harper & Row
- Gordon A. Craig, "Force and Statecraft: Diplomatic Problems of Our Time" (1983), Oxford University Press
- Robert Jervis, "Deterrence and Perception", International Security, 7(3) (1993)
- Janice Gross Stein, "Deterrence and Reassurance, In Behaviour, Society and Nuclear War 2" (1991), Oxford University Press
- Glen H. Snyder, "Deterrence and Defense: Toward a Theory of National Security", pp.14~16 (1961), Princeton Univ. Press
- Tom Sauer, "Eliminating Nuclear Weapons: The Role of Missile Defense", pp.9~ (2011), Hurst & Co
- Lawrence Freedman, "Evolution of Nuclear Strategy", ~
- Kim Tae-woo, "The North Korean Nuclear Test and the Necessity to Reinforce Extended Deterrence", pp.319~ (2010), Korea Institute of Defense Analysis Press
- Marc Trachtenberg, "The Influence of Nuclear Weapons in the Cuban Missile Crisis", International Security, 10(1), pp.136~163 (1985)
- Kim Hyun-soo, "A Study Regarding the Execution of Preventive Self-Defense Based in International Law", Maritime Strategy, (123), pp.258~ (2004)
- Choi Tae-hyun, "A Study Regarding the Possibility of Preventive Self-defense in International Law", The Korean Journal of International Law, (69), pp.2~ (1993)
- Kim Chan-gyu, "Re-interpretation of the Right to Self-Defense", The Journal of Law of Human Rights, (29), pp.7~ (2009)
- Robert Art, "The Four Functions of Force", 3~11
- Albert Carnesale, "Living with Nuclear Weapons" (1983), Harvard University Press
- Robert Scheer, "With Enough Shovels: Reagan, Bush and Nuclear War" (1983), Random House
- George P. Schultz, "Turmoil and Triumph: My Years as Secretary of State" (1993), Charles Scribner’'s Sons
- Kim Jin-moo, "An Analysis and Assessment of North Korean Nuclear Strategy", pp.335~ (2010), Korea Institute of Defense Analysis Press
- The International Institute for Strategic Studies, "North Korean Security Challenges: A Net Assessment", pp.112~113 (2011), IISS
- North Korea’'s Nuclear Weapons: Technical Issues, "Mary Beth Nikitin", CRS Report for Congress, 15~, pp.RL34256 (2012)
- Bruce Klingner, "The Case for Comprehensive Missile Defense in Asia", The Heritage Foundation Backgrounder, 2506, pp.3~ (2011)
- Mary Beth Nikitin, "North Korea’'s Nuclear Weapons: Technical Issues", 15~
- Siegfried Hecker, "Proceedings of The Sixth ROK-U.S. West Coast Strategic Forum organized", The Walter H. Shorenstein Asia-Pacific Research Center of Stanford University at Bechtel Conference Center (2011), Stanford University
- David Albright, "North Korea’'s Estimated Stocks of Plutonium and Weapon-Grade Uranium", Institute for Science and International Security, pp.30~ (2012)
- Nikitin, "North Korea’'s Nuclear Weapons: Technical Issues", 10~
- Albright, "North Korea’'s Estimated Stocks of Plutonium and Weapon- Grade Uranium", 30~
- Jonathan D. Pollack, "North Korea’'s Nuclear Weapons Development: Implications for Future Policy", Proliferation Papers, pp.38~ (2010)
- "Korea Times", ~
- "Asashi Shimbun", ~
- The Republic of Korea Ministry of Nation Defense, "2010 Defense White Paper", MND, 271~ (2010)
- "Chosun Ilbo", ~
- See Jung Uk-sik, "Missile Defense System" (2003), Salim Publishers
- "Donga Ilbo", ~
- Eum Ho-gun, "North Korean Nuclear Weapons Development", pp.17~ (2009), Baeksan Publishers
- Buk-han-hack-gwa, "The North Korean Nuclear Weapon and DIME", Samsung Economic Research Institute, pp.71~ (2010)
- 문순보, "북핵문제와 국제사회의 대북제재: 한계와 대안", 국가전략, 16(2), pp.95~120 (2010), 세종연구소
- Kim Jin-moo, "An Analysis and Assessment on the North Korean Nuclear Strategy", pp.345~
- U.S. Strategy against It, "North Korea’'s Nuclear Threat and the ROK", pp.2010, Hong Sungpyo
- Hong, Bennett, "North Korea’'s Nuclear Threat", 20~
- IISS, "North Korean Security Challenges: A Net Assessment", 120~
- Tom Sauer, "Eliminating Nuclear Weapons: The Role of Missile Defense", 105~
- Walter B. Slocombe, "Missile Defense in Asia, policy paper", The Atlantic Council, 18~ (2003)
- Kim Gyu, "South Korea Should Construct Its Own Style of Missile Defense Shields", Chosun Ilbo, April 12, 2012, ~ (2012)
- "Proceedings of The Closed 5th Anniversary Conference of the International Luxembourg Forum on Preventing Nuclear Catastrophe", Contemporary Problems of Nuclear Non-Proliferation (2012), Luxembourg Forum on Preventing Nuclear Catastrophe
- "Challenging Deterrence: Strategic Stability in the New Century", Oxford University and the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) at All Souls College, pp.14~16 (2006), Oxford University
- Byungki Kim, "North Korea: The Forgotten Proliferator", The Program on Science, Technology and International Security of Council on Foreign Relation (2006), Council on Foreign Relations