Alliance Burden-Sharing in System Polarities
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
As we move into the third decade after the end of the Cold War, scholars and commentators continue to ask how newly defined roles of various U.S. allies will correspond to their levels of burden sharing. In order to answer this question, we draw on neorealist and economic models to develop theoretical expectations about the relationship between system polarity and alliance burden sharing. Using the Alliance Treaty and Obligations (ATOP) data to measure alliances, and military expenditures and GDP data to fashion a burden sharing index, we examine the effects of major power and minor power alliances with a system leader under multipolarity, bipolarity, and unipolarity from 1885 to 2001. Consistent with the expectations, allies’ burden sharing demonstrates no clear pattern under multipolarity; decreases for U.S. allies and major powers allied with the USSR, but increases for minor powers allied with the USSR during bipolarity; and decreases for minor powers allied with the U.S. while having no effect on major powers allied with the U.S. under the current unipolar system.
Abstract
As we move into the third decade after the end of the Cold War, scholars and commentators continue to ask how newly defined roles of various U.S. allies will correspond to their levels of burden sharing. In order to answer this question, we draw on neorealist and economic models to develop theoretical expectations about the relationship between system polarity and alliance burden sharing. Using the Alliance Treaty and Obligations (ATOP) data to measure alliances, and military expenditures and GDP data to fashion a burden sharing index, we examine the effects of major power and minor power alliances with a system leader under multipolarity, bipolarity, and unipolarity from 1885 to 2001. Consistent with the expectations, allies’ burden sharing demonstrates no clear pattern under multipolarity; decreases for U.S. allies and major powers allied with the USSR, but increases for minor powers allied with the USSR during bipolarity; and decreases for minor powers allied with the U.S. while having no effect on major powers allied with the U.S. under the current unipolar system.
참고문헌 (48)
- Malcolm Chalmers, "The Atlantic Burden-Sharing Debate—Widening or Fragmenting?", International Affairs, 77, pp.569~585 (2002)
- Andrew Bennett, "Burden–Sharing in the Persian Gulf War", International Organization, 48, pp.39~75 (1994)
- Glenn H. Snyder, "Alliance Politics" (1997), Cornell University Press
- Glenn H. Snyder, "Alliance Theory : A Neorealist First Cut", Journal of International Affairs, 44, pp.103~123 (1990)
- Kenneth N. Waltz, "Theory of International Politics", pp.164~ (1979), Addison–Wesley
- Glenn H. Snyder, "The Security Dilemma in Alliance Politics", World Politics, 36, pp.466~ (1984)
- John J. Mearsheimer, "The Tragedy of Great Power Politics" (2001), W. W. Norton &Company, Inc
- Mancur Olson, "An Economic Theory of Alliances", The Review of Economics and Statistics, 27, pp.266~279 (1966)
- Stephen M. Walt, "The Origins of Alliances" (1987), Cornell University Press
- Randall L. Schweller, "Bandwagoning for Profit : Bringing the Revisionist State Back in", International Security, 19, pp.72~107 (1994)
- Stephen M. Walt, "Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power", International Security, 9, pp.3~43 (1985)
- William M. Reisinger, "East European Military Expenditures in the 1970s: Collective Good or Bargaining Offer?", International Organization, 37, pp.143~155 (1983)
- Nuno P. Monteiro, "Unrest Assured : Why Unipolarity Is Not Peaceful", International Security, 36, pp.9~40 (2012)
- Todd Sandler, "On Sharing NATO Defense Burdens in the 1990s and Beyond", Fiscal Studies, 21(3), pp.297~327 (2000)
- Todd Sandler, "Economics of Alliances : The Lessons for Collective Action", Journal of Economic Literature, 39, pp.869~896 (2001)
- William C. Wohlforth, "The Stability of a Unipolar World", International Security, 24, pp.5~41 (1999)
- 정하용, "단극 체계와 한미동맹의 변화", 한국정치연구, 21(1), pp.231~254 (2012), 한국정치연구소
- Barry R. Posen, "The Sources of Military Doctrine: France, Britain, and Germany between the World Wars" (1984), Cornell University Press
- Robert J. Art, "A Grand Strategy for America" (2003), Cornell University Press
- Barry R. Posen, "Competing Visions for Grand Strategy", International Security, 20, pp.5~53 (1996)
- Robert E. Looney, "The Effect of Declining Military Influence on Defense Budgets in Latin America", Armed Forces and Society, 26, pp.437~449 (2000)
- Nathaniel Beck, "Time-Series-Cross-Section Data", Statistica Neerlandica, 55, pp.111~133 (2001)
- David Singer, "Correlates of War Project: International and Civil War Data, 1816–1992" (1993), Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research
- B. Russett, "Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organization" (2001), W. W. Norton & Company
- B. Ashley Leeds, "Reevaluating Alliance Reliability : Specific Threats, Specific Promises", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 44, pp.686~699 (2000)
- Stuart Bremer, "The Correlates of War II: Testing Some Realpolitik Models", pp.57~82 (1980), Free Press
- Nathaniel Beck, "What to Do(and Not to Do)with Time-Series-Cross-Section Data", American Political Science Review, 89, pp.634~647 (1995)
- Glenn Palmer, "Alliance Politics and Issue Areas : Determinants of Defense Spending", American Journal of Political Science, 34, pp.190~211 (1990)
- Glenn Palmer, "Security, Autonomy, and Defense Burdens : The Effects of Alliance Membership in the 19th and 20th Centuries", Defence and Peace Economics, 5, pp.189~204 (1994)
- John R O’neal, "NATO Burden Sharing and the Forces of Change", International Studies Quarterly, 33, pp.423~456 (1989)
- Gary Goertz, "Measuring Military Allocations : A Comparison of Different Approaches", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 30, pp.553~581 (1986)
- John A. C. Conybeare, "A Portfolio Diversification Model of Alliances : The Triple Alliance and Triple Entente, 1879–1914", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 36, pp.53~85 (1992)
- Benjamin E. Goldsmith, "Bearing the Defense Burden, 1886–1989: Why Spend More?", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 47, pp.551~573 (2003)
- James D. Morrow, "Alliance and Asymmetry : An Alternative to the Capability Aggregation Model of Alliances", American Journal of Political Science, 35, pp.904~933 (1991)
- S. Chan, "The Political Economu of Defense: Issues and Perspectives" (1991), Greenwood
- Alex Mintz, "The Political Economy of Military Spending in Israel", American Political Science Review, 83(2), pp.521~533 (1989)
- Ron P. Smith, "Military Expenditures and Captalism", Cambridge Journal of International Affairs, 1, pp.61~76 (1977)
- Ronald Inglehart, "Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society" (1990), Princeton University Press
- Karen A. Rasler, "Defense, Welfare, and Growth", pp.36~60 (1992), Routledge
- Bruce M. Russett, "Controlling the Sword : The Democratic Governance of National Security" (1990), Harvard University Press
- Karl DeRouen Jr, "The Guns–Growth Relationship in Israel", Journal of Oeace Research, 37, pp.71~83 (2000)
- Richard C. Eisenberg, "Representing Defense : Democratic Control of the Defense Budget in the U. S. and Western Europe", Journal of Conflict Resolution, 47, pp.399~422 (2003)
- Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transition, 1880–2002, "Monty G. Marshall", Center For Interantional Development and Conflict Management, University of Maryland, ~ (2002)
- The Effects of the Security Environment on Military Expecditures: Pooled Analyses of 165 Countries, 1950–2000, "William Noraus", the Cowles Foundation, ~ (2009)
- Emile Benoit, "Defense and Economic Growth in Developing Countries", pp.22~ (1973), Lexington Book
- Thomas J. Christensen, "Chain Gangs and Passed Bucks : Predicting Alliance Partners in Multipolarity", International Organization, 44, pp.137~168 (1990)
- Todd Sandler, "Economics of Alliances : The Lessons for Collective Action", Journal of Economic Literature, 39, pp.839~896 (2001)
- Stephen M. Walt, "Alliances in a Unipolar World", World Politics, 61, pp.86~120 (2009)