도시 정책 이동의 이상과 현실: 인도네시아와 한국의 행정 수도 이전 정책 이동 과정에서 나타난 도시와 정책 상품화에 대한 비판적 고찰
Ideal and Reality of Urban Policy Mobilities: A Critical Analysis on the Urban and Policy Commercialization in the Process of Policy Mobilities between the Processes of Capital Relocation of Indonesia and Korea
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
이 연구에서는 한국의 행정수도 이전 기술과 경험이 인도네시아 수도 이전에 정책 이동되는 과정을 비판적으로 고찰한다. 정책 이동의 기획은 양측의 정책 행위자들이 서로의 의도와 기대를 표현하고 충족시키며 빠른 시간안에 성사되었지만, 이후 진행 과정에서 정책 이동은 여러 어려움에 직면하며 ‘지지부진하게 진행’된다. 본 연구는이 사례에서 나타난 정책 이동 과정을 전문가 인터뷰와 언론 보도를 참고하여 내러티브 분석을 통해 구체적으로 드러내고 현재까지의 진행 과정을 성과와 한계의 두 측면으로 나누어 분석한다. 이 사례에서 나타난 정책 이동이 어려움을 겪는 원인을 도시와 정책 상품화의 측면에서 밝히고 이에 근거하여 도시 정책 이동의 연구와 실행이 보다신중하고 복잡한 과정을 통해 이루어져야 할 필요성을 제기한다.
Abstract
Indonesia announced plans to relocate its capital city in August 2019. The announcement drew worldwide attention as well as from within Indonesia. The relocation of the Indonesian capital has two main goals. The first is to alleviate the urban problems of Jakarta, the current capital city, and the second is Indonesia’s balanced regional development. The implementation of the plan based on these goals is generally receiving positive responses in Indonesia. Indonesia is utilizing the cases of administrative capital relocation in other countries in order to spread social imagination and share practical experiences about capital relocation. Among them, the relocation of the administrative capital to Sejong City in Korea is a representative case that led to actual cooperation in policy mobilities. Major actors of policy mobilities from both sides planned policy mobilities cooperation through narratives, expressing each other’s intentions and expectations, but faced with various difficulties, working-level policy actors ‘muddle through’ subsequent process. In this study, the achievements and limitations of policy mobilities found in this case are critically analyzed in terms of urban and policy commercialization.
참고문헌 (50)
- 강현수, "모빌리티 (Mobilities)" (2014), 아카넷
- 윤혜준, "내러티브" (2013), 서울대학교출판문화원
- 이용숙, "정책이동과 창조도시 정책 - 서울과 싱가포르 창조도시 프로그램 비교 -", 한국정책학회보, 23(1), pp.33~66 (2014), 한국정책학회
- 이지혁, "인도네시아 2019: 오른쪽으로의 선회?", 동남아시아연구, 30(2), pp.39~87 (2020), 한국동남아학회[DOI]
- 장환영, "해외 스마트시티 구축동향과 시장 유형화", 한국도시지리학회지, 18(2), pp.55~66 (2015), 한국도시지리학회
- 인도네시아 조코 위도도대통령 2기 정부 정책 전망, "최경희", 외교부, ~ (2019)
- 최원회, "기존 신행정수도 예정지역의 주변부 관리방안 및 주민이주대책 연구", 한국도시지리학회지, 7(2), pp.15~30 (2004), 한국도시지리학회
- Alan, W., "IBM’s smart city as techno-utopian policy mobility", City, 19(2-3), pp.258~273 (2015)
- Azhar, H., "Preliminary study of indonesia capital city relocation based on disaster mitigation principle with mental model approach", E3SWeb of Conferences, 148, pp.1~7 (2020)
- Bilal, M., "The concept of Capital city in Kakawin Nagarakertagama : Cultural perspective towards the Indonesia Capital city relocation master plan", International Review ofHumanities Studies, 5(1), pp.184~191 (2020)
- Cresswell, T., "Towards a politics of mobility", Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 28, pp.17~31 (2009)
- Crivello, S., "Urban policy mobilities : The case of Turin as a smart city", European Planning Studies, 23(5), pp.909~921 (2015)
- Dwyer, P., "‘WeNicked Stuff fromAll Over the Place’ : Policy Transfer or Muddling Through?", Policy& Politics, 37, pp.389~407 (2009)
- Hanif, N. A., "Preliminary study of indonesia capital city relocation based on disaster mitigation principle withmentalmodel approach", The 6thEnvironmental Technology andManagement Conference(ETMC)Web Conf, pp.148~ (2020)
- Healey, P., "The universal and the contingent : Some reflections on the transnational flow of planning ideas and practices", Planning Theory, 11(2), pp.188~207 (2012)
- Honeck, T., "A touch of post-truth : The roles of narratives in urban policy mobilities", Geographica Helvetica, 73, pp.133~145 (2018)
- Huston, S., "‘Smart’ sustainable urban regeneration: Institutions, quality and financial innovation", Cities, 48, pp.66~75 (2015)
- Kementerian PPN, "Bappenas", Buku Saku Pemindahan Ibu Kota Negara, 2020
- McCann, E., "Assembling Urbanism : Following Policies and ‘Studying Through’ the Sites and Situations of Policy Making", Environment and Planning A : Economy and Space, 44(1), pp.42~51 (2012)
- McCann, E., "Urban policy mobilities and global circuits of knowledge : Toward a research agenda", Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 101(1), pp.107~130 (2011)
- McCann, E., "Policy boosterism, policy mobilities, and the extrospective city", Urban Geography, 34(1), pp.5~29 (2013)
- Padawangi, R., "Urban Areas and Global Climate Change", pp.321~339 (2012), Emerald Group Publishing Limited
- Peck, J., "Fast policy : experimental statecraft at the thresholds of neoliberalism, Minneapolis" (2015), University of Minnesota Press
- Picon, A., "Urban infrastructure, imagination and politics : from the networked metropolis to the smart city", International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 42(2), pp.263~275 (2018)
- Simone, A., "The Urban Poor and Their Ambivalent Exceptionalities : SomeNotes fromJakarta", Current Anthropology, 56, pp.15~23 (2015)
- Steinberg, F., "Jakarta: Environmental problems and sustainability", Habitat International, 31(3-4), pp.354~365 (2007)
- Sutoyo, E., "Twitter sentiment analysis of the relocation of Indonesia’s capital city", Bulletin of Electrical Engineering and Informatics, 9(4), pp.1620~1630 (2020)
- Van de Vuurst, V., "Perspective : Climate Change and the Relocation of Indonesia’s Capital to Borneo", Frontiers in Earth Science, 8, pp.1~6 (2020)
- Ward, K., "Policy mobilities, politics and place : The making of financial urban futures", European Urban and Regional Studies, 25(3), pp.266~283 (2018)
- Ward, K., "Mobile urbanism: cities and policymaking in the global age, Minneapolis", pp.71~96 (2011), University ofMinnesota Press
- "조코위 대통령 ‘인니 수도이전, 韓기업 참여 가능’" (2019), 연합뉴스[URL]
- "인도네시아 수도 이전주춤…”인프라 예산, 코로나 대응에 전용" (2020), 연합뉴스[URL]
- "인도네시아,투자 유치 확대를 위한 옴니버스 법 마련한다" (2020), 코트라해외시장뉴스[URL]
- "Pak Jokowi, Ingat Ada Negara yang Gagal Pindahkan Ibu Kota" (2019)[URL]
- "Jokowi looks at canberra as model capital" (2020)[URL]
- "Population growth of Greater Jakarta and its impact" (2011)[URL]
- "Discourse: New capital should be self-sufficient, attractive: South Korean envoy" (2019)[URL]
- "Pemindahan Ibu Kota Negara di Mata Anies dan Para Mantan Gubernur DKI" (2019)[URL]
- "IbuKotaDipindah, Anies Harapkan Pembangunan Jakarta Tetap Jalan" (2019)[URL]
- "Pemindahkan ibu kota presiden jokowi tiru korea selatan" (2020)[URL]
- "Sigi IndoBarometer: Mayoritas Publik Setuju Pemindahan Ibu Kota" (2020)[URL]
- "Indonesia strives to set example as home of ASEAN secretariat" (2019)[URL]
- "Indonesia puts capital relocation project on hold, shifts budget to fight coronavirus pandemic" (2020)[URL]
- Jasmine Puteri, "Senior Forest Political and Market Campaigner, Greenpeace Indonesia" (2020)
- "Galuh Syahbana Indraprahasta, Urban Geography Researcher, Indonesia Institute of Science, 2020년 2월 26일 인터뷰", ~ (2020)
- "Reni Chandriachsja Suwarso, Professor, Department of Political Science of the University of Indonesia, 2020년 2월 27일 인터뷰", ~ (2020)
- "A, 국토교통관, 주인도네시아 대한민국 대사관, 2020년 2월 27일 인터뷰", ~ (2020)
- "B, 글로벌사업처 인도네시아사업단 차장, 한국토지주택공사, 2020년 2월 25일 인터뷰", ~ (2020)
- "Umar Hadi, 대사, 주한인도네시아 대사관, 2020년 2월 14일 인터뷰", ~ (2020)
- "김창범, 대사, 주인도네시아 대한민국 대사관, 2020년 2월 27일 인터뷰", ~ (2020)
