해외로 반출된 중국문화재 반환에 관한 국제법률문제 고찰 －한국에의 시사점을 중심으로－
A Documentary Study for Recovering Chinese Cultural Objects removed illegally Abroad - An International Law Perspective - (关于返换流失海外中国文物的国际法律问题考察)
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The current international legal situation presents great difficulties for China to recover its enormous amount of cultural Relics lost to foreign countries for various reasons in history. Pragmatic means to recover those relics make effective use of present international conventions and actively lead the establishment of new international rules. As an important source nation, China lost innumerable and valuable cultural treasures in history. More troubling is the fact that illicit movement of China cultural property is increasing rapidly nowadays. Therefore, it is necessary to explore how to recover illegally removed cultural property in history and nowadays in order to make lost cultural and national treasures back home as soon as possible. For China to recovery lost cultural property,measures to be taken mainly include international litigation, multilateral cooperation, bilateral agreement, buying-back or gift. Though each strategy has its own advantages, disadvantages inevitably exist.
Abstract
The current international legal situation presents great difficulties for China to recover its enormous amount of cultural Relics lost to foreign countries for various reasons in history. Pragmatic means to recover those relics make effective use of present international conventions and actively lead the establishment of new international rules. As an important source nation, China lost innumerable and valuable cultural treasures in history. More troubling is the fact that illicit movement of China cultural property is increasing rapidly nowadays. Therefore, it is necessary to explore how to recover illegally removed cultural property in history and nowadays in order to make lost cultural and national treasures back home as soon as possible. For China to recovery lost cultural property,measures to be taken mainly include international litigation, multilateral cooperation, bilateral agreement, buying-back or gift. Though each strategy has its own advantages, disadvantages inevitably exist.
참고문헌 (44)
- 杨晓涡, "文物归还的"原罪"难题", 风凰周刊, 219(14) (2006)
- 高升, "文物返换国际争议解决的合作与交流原则", 河南科技大学学报(社会科学版) (2008)
- 李玉雪, "文物返还问题的法律思考", 中国法学, (6) (2005)
- 戴雄, "抗战时期中国文物损失概况", 民国档案, (2) (2003)
- 孟国祥, "日本侵华对中国文化的破坏" (2005), 中国社会科学出版社
- 王云霞, "二战被掠文物返换的法律基础及相关问题", 辽宁大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 35(4) (2007)
- Ronald. D. Duboeuf, "艺术法概要" (1995), 中国社会科学出版社
- 陈筱红, "2亿3千万年前古化石回家", 北京青年报 (2002)
- 龚柏华, "我国追索非法流转境外文物的国际法律问题研究", 法学评论, (3) (2003)
- 程晓霞, "国际法" (2005), 中国人民大学出版社
- 吴映京, "从国际法视野看中国对海外流失文物的追索", 玉溪师范学院学报, (9) (2008)
- 国家文物局致函香港两拍卖行提出严正要求, "停止拍卖被掠圆明园文物", 中国文物報 (2000)
- 黄世席, "非法文物国际流通的国际法管制", 中国矿业大学学报 (2001)
- 阮振宇, "流失文物追索国际公约与中国追索海外流失文物困境评析", 文物世界 (2001)
- 이동기, "문화재환수협약의 성립경위와 현황－유네스코 협약과의 관계를 포함하여’", 1995년 도난 또는 불법반출 문화재에 대한 UNIDROIT 협약 학술대회 (2009), 국제문화재법연구회
- 김천수, "도난문화재의 회복", 1995년 도난 또는 불법반출 문화재에 대한 UNIDROIT 협약 학술대회
- 이재경, "불법반출문화재의 반환청구. in: 국제사법", 1995년 도난 또는 불법반출 문화재에 대한 UNIDROIT 협약 학술대회 (2009)
- わが国が未批准の国际条约一览, "国立国会圖書館調查及び立法考察局" (2009)
- Shapiro, D., "Repatriation: A Modest Proposal", New York University Journal of International Law and Politics, 31(1) (1998)
- "International Law Association Report of the Seventy Second Conference, 2008.04.20", ~ (2008)
- "ICOM Recommendations concerning the Return of Works of Art Belonging to Jewish Owners", ~ (2006)
- Jane A. Levine, "Returning Stolen Cultural Property", Cultural Resource Management
- "US Returns Smuggled Terracotta Figures to China, 2004.03.20", ~ (2004)
- Case studies, "Unlawful import of cultural heritage objects into Australia, 2005.03.15", ~ (2005)
- "Diplomatic Conference for the Adoption of the Draft UNIDROIT Convention on the International Return of Stolen or Illegally Exported cultural Objects, Rome, 7 to 24 June 1995-Acts and Proceedings", ~
- Nahlik. S. E., "International Law and the Protection of Cultural Property in Armed Conflicts", The Hastings Law Journal, 27(5) (1976)
- John Alan Cohan, "An Examination of Archaeological Ethics and the Repatriation Movement Respecting Cultural Property (Part Ⅱ)", Environmental Law & Politics Journal, 28 (2004)
- Japan Society, "Cultural Property Forum" (2003), The Export Policies of China
- 조선일보, "｢첫 문화재 약탈 피해국 회의, 우리 문화재 반환의 새 계기로｣, 『조선일보』 4월 9일자 기사", ~ (2010)
- "중국 외교부"[URL]